Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in the US

Gumbo and key lime pie

You expect a menu that pairs a hearty bowl of gumbo with a slice of key lime pie. You want the savory depth of a stew followed by a sharp, citrus finish.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
The Blue Crab Crabhouse image 1
The Blue Crab Crabhouse image 2
The Blue Crab Crabhouse image 3
View all
Seafood restaurant

Nautical-themed seafood restaurant nestled under live oaks with string lights and Spanish moss creating a cozy, charming atmosphere. The vibe stays chill and comfortable, attracting a social crowd around over 20 tables. Known for fresh, local seafood and a relaxed, homey feel away from commercial joints.

Shrimp features heavily in the gumbo, giving it a rich seafood flavor. Portions come on the smaller side compared to the price, but it serves well as a starter or part of a larger meal.

Creamy texture and puckering tartness define the key lime pie here. It stands out as homemade and highly praised for its flavor, even winning over those not usually fond of key lime pie.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly, especially when serving the Crab Cakes."

"I'd order the Key Lime Pie again; it's the best I've ever had."

"The Gumbo staff was really nice and attentive."

Good to know

1

Bloody Mary and mimosa specials are available on Sundays until 5 pm.

2

Margarita specials are offered on Tuesdays.

3

Oyster specials are available on Wednesdays for $1 each.

02
Crustees image 1
Restaurant

Tiny restaurant offers outdoor dining with a clean, cheerful space and neo-soul/house music creating a super chill vibe. The atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxed, attracting a community-focused crowd. Pot pies and desserts stand out as signature features.

Generous portions of seafood and sausage fill the gumbo, delivering a rich flavor that stands out. The gumbo pairs well with rice and satisfies those who enjoy a hearty, well-made dish.

Tart and creamy with an authentic Key West flavor, the Key Lime Pie stands out among a variety of desserts like peach cobbler and banana nut pie.

People are saying

"The pot pie crust is perfect, flaky, and savory."

"I enjoyed the gumbo; it was super good and flavorful."

"I swear this Key Lime Pie is flown in straight from Key West."

Good to know

1

The pies cost approximately $10 each with tax.

2

The cost is about $20 per person for a pot pie and dessert.

3

They offer a buy one get one free coupon on any item.

03
The Wharf Restaurant image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant on the water offers waterfront views and an Old Florida vibe with outdoor seating and heaters. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, featuring a dock for boats and a dedicated dog-friendly space. Multiple TVs show sports, creating a lively yet comfortable setting.

Seafood and sausage fill a large bowl of gumbo with a great sauce and some heat. The portion costs about $8.95 and serves as a full meal.

An incredible graham cracker crust stands out in the key lime pie. The portion is perfectly sized for dessert and consistently satisfies.

People are saying

"The peel and eat shrimp and blackened grouper were rated 10/10."

"I had to get their Key Lime Pie; it hit the spot."

"The gumbo here is packed with seafood and sausage."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is from 3:30 to 6:00 PM, but only at the bar.

2

Parking at the restaurant is limited and can be challenging to find.

3

The restaurant closes at 10 PM tonight.

04
The Conch Republic Grill image 1

Restaurant offers cozy outdoor seating with beautiful sunset views and unique conch shell decor. Atmosphere feels fun and family friendly, with live music and sports screens adding to the vibe. Happy hour features strong tropical cocktails and a variety of seafood dishes stand out.

Seafood Gumbo stands out with scallops and a rich mix of flavors. It pairs well with conch fritters and complements dishes like Jalapeรฑo crusted grouper.

Authentic key lime flavor stands out in their homemade pie. The texture is smooth and the taste is consistently praised as highly recommended.

People are saying

"The seafood here is fantastic, especially the grouper."

"The dinner spots here have amazing, delicious food with beautiful presentation."

"I had the best seafood gumbo I have ever encountered."

Good to know

1

A dinner reservation is a must, especially during busy seasons.

2

Happy hour runs from 1 PM to 7 PM every day with 2-for-1 drinks.

3

Parking is ample and convenient for visitors.

05
Catfish Deweys image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant with family-style dining and old Florida decor creates a nostalgic atmosphere. Music features southern tunes that add to the vibe. Large, busy space offers a full bar and casual, friendly energy.

Shrimp gumbo has few shrimp, sometimes disintegrated, which can be off-putting. Other gumbo versions come with fried catfish and shrimp, offering a classic Southern flavor.

Key lime pie stands out as consistently delicious and very good. Staff sometimes bring it out to celebrate birthdays, adding a nice touch.

People are saying

"The seafood here is amazing, especially the fried shrimp and catfish."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was really good."

"I tell you, the gumbo was so good."

Good to know

1

All-you-can-eat shrimp is available on Mondays.

2

Tuesdays feature all-you-can-eat shrimp and catfish.

3

Thursdays offer all-you-can-eat crab legs.

06
Flying Fish image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant with an authentic fisherman theme and 1950s fish shack vibe filled with unique wall decor and a nostalgic atmosphere. The mood is chill and peaceful, attracting families and friends who enjoy blues music in the background. Frozen margaritas and a variety of sauces complement the well-loved fried fish and lobster rolls.

Seafood gumbo stands out with its rich flavor and is often ordered more than once. It pairs well with grilled vegetables and beans, though rice is sometimes served mixed in rather than on the side.

Key lime pie stands out as a very good and yummy dessert option. It pairs well with seafood dishes like catfish and shrimp.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"I thought the gumbo was the best I've had outside of New Orleans."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers easy parking for visitors.

2

Expect reasonable prices for seafood dishes.

3

The dining area is generally clean and well-maintained.

07
Charlie's Creole Kitchen image 1

Restaurant offers N'awlins style decor and a Louisiana theme with live music enhancing the atmosphere. Space feels cozy and clean with a mom & pop vibe and many screens showing sports. Energy is relaxed and welcoming, attracting those who appreciate authentic Creole and Cajun cuisine.

Seafood gumbo stands out with a roux spot on and packed with shrimp and crab. The gumbo offers a tangy flavor that differs from typical versions and pairs well with dishes like red beans and rice.

House-prepared Key Lime pie offers a fresh, tangy finish. It stands out as a dessert highlight with a balanced tartness and smooth texture.

People are saying

"The seafood fondue here is delicious and a must-try."

"The seafood gumbo here is full of shrimp and crab with a spot-on roux."

"The Key Lime Pie was more like cheesecake with a strawberry swirl."

Good to know

1

Charlieโ€™s Creole Kitchen charges a 3% fee for credit card payments.

2

There is a 20% extra charge for parties of five or more.

3

Expect to deal with gnats flying around your food during your visit.

08
High Tide - Goodyear image 1
Food and drink

Elevated coastal vibe blends with warm hospitality and a huge bar in a beautiful, sophisticated setting. Atmosphere stays pleasant and lively, suitable for dates or business dinners. Fresh seafood and creative cocktails shape the experience.

Gumbo features plentiful seafood like shrimp and crawfish in a warm, cozy broth. The dish is fresh and flavorful, making it a standout choice.

A generous slice of Key Lime Pie closes the meal with a delightful balance of tart and sweet. It serves as a satisfying and refreshing dessert option.

People are saying

"The seafood here is impeccably fresh, especially the oysters."

"Leena offered us samples of the gumbo before we ordered."

"The Key Lime Pie was a delightful end to dinner."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 3 to 6 PM with special menu selections.

2

Reservations are not required but can be beneficial during busy times.

3

Oyster Tuesday and Wine Wednesday offer additional deals throughout the week.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...