Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Italian food and ice cream sandwiches in the US

An Italian dinner transitions perfectly into the simple joy of an ice cream sandwich.

Based on 776 Opinions
+773
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
The Gourmet Way image 1
The Gourmet Way image 2
The Gourmet Way image 3
View all

Small, eclectic bakery offers a homely and fun atmosphere with unique flavors in breads, oils, and macarons. Gelato station adds a fresh twist, while the vibe feels like visiting a friend. The space is cute and quaint, inviting relaxed enjoyment.

Fresh focaccia bread arrives warm and fragrant daily, with a soft texture that stands out. The pesto chicken sandwich offers a rich, flavorful Italian taste that complements the bakery items well.

Macaron ice cream sandwiches stand out with their PHAT Mac variety offering a rich, creamy treat. These sandwiches come at a great price and deliver a ridiculously yummy flavor that appeals to all ages.

People are saying

"Their focaccia bread and sandwiches are to die for."

"The macaron ice cream sandwiches here are amazing and yummy."

"The Italian focaccia bread here is amazing and warm."

Good to know

1

The store offers a variety of unique flavored olive oils and balsamic vinegars.

2

Tasting sessions are available for customers to sample products before purchasing.

3

The store has a bakery section with a selection of treats.

02
Super Nice Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Smallish pizza restaurant offers a cozy, sexy, lively atmosphere with soft lighting and tasteful decor in a beautifully restored classic NYC building. Full bar serves terrific wine and balanced cocktails while music selection enhances the cool, effortless vibe. Neighborhood crowd gathers here for phenomenal pizza and easygoing ambiance.

Eggplant parmesan appears in multiple dishes, including a sandwich stuffed with eggplant and rich tomato sauce. Desserts feature authentic tiramisu, cannolis with cherries, and layered cakes like chocolate and coconut. Pizza has a firm crust and house-made mozzarella.

Unique take on the ice cream sandwich offers a divine finish to the meal. This dessert stands out with its distinctive flavor and texture.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was truly amazing."

"The pizza crust here is exceptional, with a perfect chew."

"I thought the ice cream sandwich was divine."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended during peak hours to avoid long waits.

2

The restaurant is open late, making it a good option for night owls.

3

Expect personal-sized pizzas, perfect for individual dining.

03
Pasta|Bar image 1
Californian restaurant

Intimate kitchen counter seating surrounds chefs preparing innovative dishes, creating an immersive dining experience. Moody lighting and lively music set a vibrant, speakeasy-like atmosphere. Unique fusion cuisine and personalized touches like customized menus and Polaroid photos distinguish the setting.

Technically flawless pasta dishes like gnocchi and garganelli ruvida offer deeply comforting and memorable flavors. The menu progresses beautifully from sourdough bread to seafood, salads, pasta, mains, and desserts, with options like hand-rolled cavatelli featuring prawns, kimchi, and leeks. Pescatarian requests are fully embraced without compromise.

Banana ice cream sandwiches come topped with caviar, blending playful and refined flavors. Desserts balance textures and tastes with a beautifully balanced presentation.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is technically flawless and deeply comforting."

"It's an intimate experience with a moody bar and personal touches."

"The intimate counter seating and chef explanations made the Ice Cream Sandwich special."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for special events like Valentine's Day.

2

The restaurant is located on the second floor, accessible via escalators.

3

Expect to pay around $300 per person for a full dining experience.

04
Shadow Wagyu image 1
Butcher shop

Butcher shop combines premium Wagyu cuts with a casual, intimate vibe that feels both inviting and eclectic. Small space features a fast-moving kitchen and high top tables, creating a lively yet cozy atmosphere. Crowd enjoys quick meals or fresh meat for home cooking in a setting that balances relaxed comfort with refined quality.

Rich dishes like the A5 Milanese and Wagyu Parm stand out, often paired with pasta such as rigatoni. Portions tend to be heavy and prices can be high, with some meals costing over $200.

Vanilla ice cream made with beef tallow sits between the cookies in the Sweet Licks ice cream sandwich. The Wagyu tallow ice cream sandwich cookie offers a rich dessert finished in just a few bites.

People are saying

"The Wagyu fillets I cooked were bloody amazing."

"The Italian food, especially the Wagyu Parm, is rich and decadent."

"You have to try the ice cream sandwich with vanilla ice cream."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted, which may be tricky for large parties.

2

Expect a 45-minute wait during busy times, especially on weekends.

3

Prices are high, with meals averaging around $90 for two.

05
American Bar - New York image 1

Upscale restaurant with chic, lounge-style interior and indoor and outdoor patio seating creates a buzzy, trendy atmosphere. Crowd tends to be well-heeled and fashionable, enjoying highly recommended martinis and generous portions. Seating includes beautiful booths but some tables and wicker chairs feel less comfortable.

Creamy cacio e pepe balances pepper and cheese well without being too buttery. Lobster pasta features perfectly cooked lobster and a flavorful sauce with cherry tomatoes.

Warm, gooey chocolate chip cookie holds melting cold ice cream with Oreo bits for texture. The sandwich blends soft cookie and crunchy crumble in a special dessert experience.

People are saying

"The service at these dinner spots is spectacular and attentive."

"The Italian food, especially the lobster pasta, was a big hit."

"The ice cream sandwich was warm, gooey, with melting ice cream."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to avoid being turned away from restaurants in the area.

2

Expect longer wait times for drinks and food on busy nights.

3

Martinis cost $10 on Sundays and Mondays.

06
The Ivy Room image 1
Restaurant

Intimate rooftop piano lounge offers a cozy, romantic atmosphere with live jazz music enhancing the elegant vibe. Seating includes a patio area and space suited for private events. Signature craft cocktails complement the refined setting.

Cacio e Pepe stands out as a culinary delight that impresses with its flavor and execution. The vegetarian gnocchi also earns positive remarks for its taste.

Chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches offer a delicately decadent treat with a rich, sweet flavor. Cream puffs also serve as a popular dessert choice for those craving something sweet.

People are saying

"The brunch staff sang happy birthday and surprised me."

"The live music and ambiance here are fantastic."

"The chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich is delicately decadent."

Good to know

1

On Wednesdays, selected bottles of wine are offered at reduced prices.

2

The Sunday jazz brunch features live music and unlimited mimosas for 60 minutes.

3

A reservation is required for the Wednesday wine discount.

07
Kitchen 57 image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers outdoor seating with a friendly, chill atmosphere that can get loud during large parties. The bar area is lively with well-crafted cocktails like lychee martinis and Old Fashioneds. The menu includes diverse options catering to gluten-free and vegetarian preferences.

Chicken Parmigiana stands out as a main dish alongside a Mozzarella & Tomato starter with Parma ham. The pasta pomodoro with shrimp offers a solid red sauce option.

Mint chip chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich stands out with its mint chocolate chip flavor and chewy cookie texture. Bread pudding and other desserts complement the ice cream sandwich well.

People are saying

"The pasta pomodoro and Philly cheesesteak were some of the best I've had."

"The Italian food here is served with such friendly and quick service."

"You have to try the ice cream sandwich, especially mint chocolate chip."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs on Saturdays until 7 pm, featuring food and drink specials.

2

Any cocktail priced at $13 or less is half price during happy hour.

3

Thursdays offer free champagne for women during happy hour.

08
Bar Bludorn image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers a masculine, sleek interior with mid-century modern decor and warm wood accents. Atmosphere ranges from calm and relaxing to loud and lively, with most tables facing an open kitchen. The space feels secluded from the street despite corner location, creating a unique neighborhood vibe.

Carbonara comes out perfect and the gnocchi feels as light as a pillow. Dishes like steak, duck gumbo, and artichoke ravioli are well-cooked and enjoyable, often served in courses for a paced meal.

Takes the form of a freshly made churro dipped in warm hot chocolate but served as ice cream. Stands out as a recommended dessert alongside chocolate cake.

People are saying

"The food here is absolutely excellent and delicious."

"The Italian food, like the gnocchi, was as light as a pillow."

"The ice cream sandwich is like a churro dipped in hot chocolate."

Good to know

1

Valet parking is available, but street parking can be challenging.

2

Happy hour is only available at the bar and patio.

3

Expect a packed bar during happy hour, so arrive early.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...