Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Interesting milkshake spots

You are looking for a milkshake that defies the standard menu and offers something genuinely unexpected.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Juice Time - عصير تايم image 1
Juice Time - عصير تايم image 2
Juice Time - عصير تايم image 3
View all

Modern decor creates inviting atmosphere with comfortable seating suited for quick visits. The place offers unique desserts and exotic drinks, including Arab specialties with high-quality ingredients. Energy is calm and welcoming, attracting those seeking pleasant vibes and flavorful treats.

Chocolate milkshakes balance sweetness well. The Lotus milkshake stands out as a unique flavor. Options also include the Einstein milkshake and treats like minipancakes with pistachio syrup.

Dessert options stand out with unique flavors and combinations. The menu offers an interesting variety that catches attention.

People are saying

"I found the desserts here to be so yummy and unique."

"I loved the mini pancakes with chocolate drizzle."

"I thought the Lotus Milkshake was amazing."

Good to know

1

The dessert shop is halal and has options for everyone.

2

The Dubai chocolate ice cream costs $14.

3

Make sure to ask for prices before ordering.

02
Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop showcases Caribbean-inspired flavors in a colorful, spacious setting with indoor seating and sampling options. Bright and welcoming atmosphere reflects a family-run passion for homemade treats. The vibe blends cultural heritage with a modern twist on classic ice cream.

Cookies and cream and a unique half mauby half cherry coconut flavor stand out among the milkshake options. Milkshakes come alongside ice creams and hefty slices of cake.

Many interesting ice cream flavors appear here, including activated charcoal, sea moss, soursop, and mauby. Tropical options like coconut ginger, beet ginger, and sorrel also feature on the menu.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly, they really take care of you."

"You can try unique flavors like soursop and grape nut in their milkshakes."

"I love their interesting Caribbean ice cream flavors like soursop."

Good to know

1

Mr. P's celebrates Labor Day weekend with special flavors like lemon ginger and mango.

2

The establishment offers a $3 portion size for ice cream.

3

You can choose 3 flavors on arrival for a tasting experience.

03
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers a wide variety of unique flavors, including vegan and oat milk-based options. Atmosphere feels fun and fresh with a chill vibe for relaxing while enjoying a snack. Music plays loudly, and seating is limited, focusing on quick visits rather than long stays.

Milkshakes come in cookies and cream and affogato flavors, both rich and creamy. Vanilla milkshake tastes smooth, and the menu also offers ice cream sandwiches and pints.

Interesting flavors stand out here, with a variety that is hard to find elsewhere. Samples are allowed, and novel toppings add to the variety and unique taste experience.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is amazing, creamy, and delicious."

"I found so many unique flavors I couldn't find anywhere else."

"I found the milkshake to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

They only accept contactless payment; no cash is accepted.

2

The price for 1 scoop is around $9.

3

Customers can sample up to two flavors before purchasing.

04
Evil Twin Brewing NYC - DUMBO image 1

Spacious taproom blends mid-century modern style with an industrial meets prewar building vibe, offering both indoor and outdoor seating near the river. Atmosphere stays relaxed and inviting with great hiphop music and a bright, airy feel. Known for unique sour and stout beers, it draws those seeking standout craft brews in a chill setting.

An electronic menu screen catches the eye and makes options clear. The tap list features lots of interesting beers to explore.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the unique and delicious beer here."

"The atmosphere here is beautiful with cool decor."

"They have so many interesting beers, with classic and new tones."

Good to know

1

Monday is all day happy hour with several types of beer for $5.

2

Customers should sit at the bar to get the five beer tasting option.

3

The tap room does not serve food, so it is best to eat before visiting.

05
Cafe 50's Diner - West LA image 1

Retro-themed diner with 50's decor, neon lights, and a jukebox creates a nostalgic atmosphere. Cozy and kitschy vibe welcomes families, offering toys and balloons for kids. Open 24 hours, it blends classic diner energy with playful vintage touches.

Milkshakes come in a large selection with options like Nutella and classic vanilla. They are creamy and served in generous portions, making them a highlight here.

50s-related knick-knacks and posters fill the space, creating a super interesting decor. The diner has a cool atmosphere with a unique, different vibe from typical Route 66 spots.

People are saying

"The staff made me feel like I was coming home for a home-cooked meal."

"The retro decor here feels truly nostalgic, like stepping back into the 50s."

"The 50s-related knick-knacks and posters here are really interesting."

Good to know

1

Cafe 50's Diner is open 24 hours for late-night cravings.

2

Reservations are available to avoid waiting during busy hours.

3

The diner accepts cash only for payment, no credit cards.

06
Mom's Kitchen and Bar image 1

Restaurant offers a retro diner interior filled with '90s nostalgia and Nickelodeon cartoons on TVs. Loud house music and live DJ create a lively, energetic atmosphere that can make conversation difficult. Outdoor seating includes heated options, while indoor space feels small and cozy.

Milkshakes here stand out for their amazing flavor and rich texture. They deliver a satisfying, classic taste that draws people back.

Unconventional American breakfast dishes offer interesting renditions of staple orders. Cocktails stand out with unique twists, like a mimosa served in a glass full of ice.

People are saying

"The food portions here are really large and delicious."

"The brunch service was kind, attentive, and excellent."

"The chicken and waffles here are worth the trip."

Good to know

1

Brunch is served all day at the restaurant.

2

Happy hour specials are available from 3-5pm on weekdays.

3

Y2K specials are available on Fridays starting at 8pm.

07
Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - 35th St image 1

Hamburger restaurant with nostalgic 90’s wall art and a roof terrace bar overlooking a city landmark. Loud music and multiple TVs create a busy, energetic atmosphere that can make conversation difficult. Offers heated outdoor seating and a lively bar area popular for cocktails.

Huge milkshakes come beautifully presented and taste indulgent. The cookie vanilla flavor stands out as amazing and offers a perfect sweet treat.

Burgers come with tasty, interesting flavors that stand out. The spot features fun shakes and interesting decor that add to the vibe.

People are saying

"You have to try the milkshakes; they're the biggest and best I've ever had."

"I tasted the best burger I have ever had."

"The shakes here are interesting and look like artwork."

Good to know

1

Happy hour menu features discounted items, perfect for budget-friendly dining.

2

Customers must seat themselves and order via their phone from the table.

3

Reservations are not accepted; expect a wait during peak hours.

08
burger joint image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Entrance through a red curtain inside a luxury hotel leads to a hidden, intimate space with a dive bar vibe. The atmosphere feels claustrophobic yet cool, enhanced by local music and live sports. Walls invite personal expression, creating a unique, immersive experience.

Oreo milkshakes stand out as a great choice here. Pairing them with a burger and crispy fries creates a classic combo.

Hidden inside a hotel, the spot features guest artwork and signatures with photos on the walls. This unique setting makes eating a hamburger feel different and interesting.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be very good and delicious."

"I found the milkshake to be delicious and exceptional."

"I found the place interesting, hidden inside a hotel."

Good to know

1

Expect a long queue (between 30 minutes and 1 hour) during peak hours.

2

You will have to queue if you go before 3 PM.

3

You can order online to pick up if the line is too long.

09
Hershey's Chocolate World image 1

Chocolate shop offers an immersive sensory experience with an overwhelming smell of sugar and chocolate. Colorful, fun decor and interactive displays create a lively, crowded atmosphere. Unique features include custom candy bar wrappers and a stuff your own cup-Reese's bar.

Chocolate and s'mores milkshakes stand out for their rich, delicious flavors. Milkshakes come with a small Hershey's chocolate as a courtesy, adding a nice touch.

Variety of rare candies and unique chocolates creates an interesting experience. Colorful, fun decor adds to the appeal, while free chocolate samples catch attention.

People are saying

"I found a really varied selection of Hershey's Chocolate here."

"I thought the milkshake I had was so good."

"I found the variety of chocolates and unique flavors really interesting."

Good to know

1

Hershey's central location in Times Square makes it easily accessible.

2

The establishment only accepts plastic payments.

3

There are no restrooms available for anyone, including paying customers.

10
Sugar Factory New York - Time Square image 1

Restaurant offers upstairs and downstairs bars with loud music and a fun atmosphere suited for celebrations. Maximalist desserts and cocktail variety stand out amid a space with worn decor and mixed cleanliness impressions.

Maximalist desserts stand out here, especially the Nutella and banana milkshake and the brownie volcano milkshake. Milkshakes are very sweet and popular, often paired with candy or burgers for a rich treat.

A menu packed with novelty-filled drinks and unique desserts creates an interesting experience. Photos from the place also catch attention with their distinctiveness.

People are saying

"It's a fun spot with a high-energy, exciting atmosphere."

"You should get one of the insane milkshakes because they are so good."

"The drinks and desserts here are really interesting."

Good to know

1

Lunch is served after 3:30 PM.

2

A mandatory 20% service fee is added to every bill.

3

The restaurant has no parking available.

11
Gelato Factory image 1
Ice cream shop

Bright space with large windows and plenty of seating creates a fresh, clean vibe. Music plays softly, setting a pleasant atmosphere for casual hangouts. Offers creamy gelato with a wide variety of flavors, including sugar-free options.

Milkshakes come in flavors like tiramisu and are served alongside crepes and coffee. Quality varies, with some milkshakes tasting okay but not great.

An assortment of unique flavors like tiramisu and creme brulee stands out. Some interesting mix-ins appear, though listing their components could help with allergen info and flavor choices.

People are saying

"The gelato here is so rich and creamy, a real dessert dream."

"The mango and passionfruit sorbets are refreshingly vibrant."

"Kim provided amazing customer service with the milkshake."

Good to know

1

The establishment claims to close at 11pm but locks the doors at 10:45pm.

2

You can choose to take away a box with 3 flavors for $18 (small) or 4 flavors for $36 (large).

3

The gelato sizes are larger than they appear, as the staff fills the cups generously.

12
GOSHT | Restaurant | Halal Steakhouse & Burgers image 1

Charcoal grills define the cooking style, creating a halal steakhouse with modern, cozy design and a family-friendly atmosphere. A children's play area keeps kids entertained, contributing to a lively and sometimes noisy environment. The setting suits both intimate dinners and group gatherings.

Milkshakes come in classic flavors like Oreo and Snickers, plus tropical options like pina colada. They match the same recipe on both adult and children's menus, with a price difference favoring the kids' menu.

Very interesting design with a comfortable outside sitting area. The salad dressings add a special touch, and some dishes stand out as interesting.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be juicy, fresh, and unforgettable."

"The service here is amazing, with waiters like George making it feel special."

"I found the milkshakes to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at least a day in advance for special events.

2

The kids' play area costs $15 per child, which is not disclosed upfront.

3

Expect a long wait of about 1 hour for food during busy times.

13
Mom's Kitchen & Bar image 1
American restaurant

Nostalgic 90s decor and Cartoon Network TVs create a cozy, kitsch atmosphere with a throwback music vibe. Outdoor seating offers a spacious, decorated area that complements the indoor theme. The energy is relaxed and inviting, appealing to those who enjoy retro aesthetics.

Milkshakes come in extravagant and unique flavors like Nutella with tequila and a massive cookie version. Strawberry and classic options taste delicious and often exceed expectations.

Menu offers interesting takes on American classics and unique dishes like mac and cheese pancakes. Drinks and brunch options show creative twists, while staff engage in interesting conversations.

People are saying

"The brunch here is delicious and the portions are ample."

"You have to try their milkshakes; they're delicious and scrumptious."

"The menu's comfort food with a cool accent is really interesting."

Good to know

1

They offer all day brunch specialties.

2

MOM's hosts Mean Girls trivia events on certain nights.

3

They have happy hour all day.

14
Milk Bar image 1
Dessert shop

Industrial interior with pink theme and cute merchandise creates a bright, friendly atmosphere. Music is often loud and energizing, contributing to a lively vibe. Seating is limited and uncomfortable, with bar stools and picnic tables that don't suit groups well.

Chocolate milkshakes come rich and creamy with a unique dessert twist. The cereal milkshake stands out for its flavor and smooth frozen consistency.

Options include creating your own cake in a jar and trying cereal milk soft serve or crunchy cereal ice cream, both with unique flavors.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be really tasty."

"The birthday cake milkshake here is incredible."

"The cereal milk soft serve flavor is interesting and unique."

Good to know

1

The location is very accessible as it is right on Broadway.

2

There is no place to sit at this location.

3

They charge for glasses without warning.

15
Ellen's Stardust Diner image 1

Classic Broadway-themed diner with singing waitstaff performing throughout, creating a lively, energetic environment. Small, crowded space with a balcony overlooking the whole place adds to the unique atmosphere. Entertainment feels like being inside a Broadway musical.

Milkshakes come with a unique twist, served during a waiter's song that feels like a musical rehearsal. This adds a lively, unexpected vibe to the experience.

A musical-themed diner offers live performances by singing waitstaff, creating a lively and entertaining atmosphere. It provides a fun way to experience American culture and musicals while dining.

People are saying

"The singing servers put on a Broadway-caliber show; it's such fun activities!"

"The singing servers make the milkshake experience feel like a Broadway show."

"The waiters singing live songs is really interesting."

Good to know

1

Expect a 50-minute wait during evening hours.

2

A 20% tip is automatically added to the bill.

3

Come during the week to avoid long lines.

16
Lexington Candy Shop image 1

Small diner with retro American atmosphere and handmade soda fountain service creates a nostalgic vibe. Crowded space filled with classic 1920s Americana details and an authentic luncheonette feel. Regulars enjoy old-fashioned cokes and traditional breakfast dishes in a compact, lively setting.

Old-fashioned milkshakes come with a retro soda fountain vibe. Flavors like strawberry and orange cream stand out for their rich, classic taste.

Historical charm stands out in this old diner. The Coca Cola with ice cream offers an interesting twist, and the overall vibe feels rushed but fun for classic diner lovers.

People are saying

"You have to try the diner's Coke, mixed the old-fashioned way."

"The milkshake here is genuinely delicious and a highlight."

"Trying the old-fashioned Coca-Cola with ice cream is interesting."

Good to know

1

Breakfast time is recommended to avoid queues at lunchtime.

2

On the weekends, there’s a line that stretches around the block.

3

Be prepared for a wait; it’s all part of the experience.

17
Black Iron Burger image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Long, narrow burger bar with Betic decoration and a hole-in-the-wall feel offers a subdued, welcoming atmosphere with three screens showing sports. The space balances tall and low tables, creating a comfortable setting even at the bar. Burgers stand out as a defining feature, praised for being juicy and delicious.

Malted milkshakes use real ice cream and come in flavors like Strawberry and vanilla Nutella. Gourmet options stand out as highlights of the meal.

Interesting tap selection includes Montauk IPA and Lagunitas. Decor and menu feature Seville references. Several dishes and appetizers stand out as interesting.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be spectacular and amazing."

"I thought their burgers and milkshakes were super good."

"The burgers here are great and have a strong American character."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from Monday to Friday from 4 PM to 7 PM with discounts on drinks and food.

2

Margaritas are less than half the price during happy hour from 4-6pm.

3

Be careful with giving double tips; an 18% gratuity is added for groups over 4.

18
Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Brooklyn image 1

Spacious movie theater combines leather reclining chairs with food service at seats and a bar area for drinks. Atmosphere mixes vintage film clips before movies with occasional talking and phone use during screenings. Seating shows wear but overall environment stays clean and cozy.

Whiskey banana and salted caramel milkshakes stand out for their rich flavors. Cold brew milkshakes also complement the food well, making the milkshake selection consistently good.

An interesting bar greets visitors with exhibits that can shock. Walls display classic movie posters and the bar offers unique drink specials with a soundtrack.

People are saying

"The seats here are so comfortable for watching movies."

"You have to try the whiskey milkshake; it's exceptionally good."

"The bar here is interesting, with exhibits that could shock visitors."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays before 5, movies are $11 total with tax.

2

The restaurant offers movie-specific specials for food and drinks.

3

You cannot be late to the movie, nor can you pull out your phone during the movie.

19
Serendipity 3 - Upper East Side image 1

Whimsical and iconic atmosphere fills a tiny, tightly packed space with nostalgic charm. Delightful photo service and outdoor terrace add unique touches. Heat can be intense, but the vibe remains adorable and fanciful.

Smooth and creamy textures define the $100 milkshake, which delivers a sublime experience. Ordering the $1000 milkshake requires planning, as it needs at least two weeks' notice.

Interesting decor and a light, fun vibe set the tone. The shop offers novelty items and the photography service adds a unique touch.

People are saying

"The frozen hot chocolate was fantastic and creamy."

"The desserts here are amazing and perfect for a sweet tooth."

"I had the $100 Milkshake twice; it was sublime."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required at Serendipity 3 to avoid long wait times.

2

There is a minimum spend of $19 per person to enter.

3

Expect a long line if you visit without a reservation.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...