Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Tartar sauce and Italian food in the US

Finding an Italian kitchen that understands the necessity of a proper tartar sauce is a headache when you are tired of settling for standard marinara.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Restaurant

Small interior hosts a warm and cozy vibe with live band and DJ creating a lively atmosphere. Beautiful artwork and a full bar add to the inviting setting. The space includes a small enclosed patio for outdoor seating.

Seasoned tartar sauce adds a little extra smile and pairs well with sliders on toasted brioche buns. The housemade sauce is on point but not always necessary, especially with well-seasoned fried catfish.

Pasta dishes stand out with lemon pepper penne and lemon chicken pasta offering rich, flavorful tastes. Chicken wings come perfectly seasoned, complementing the Italian offerings well.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and made with pride."

"The lemon pepper chicken pasta here is so good!"

"The housemade tartar sauce was on point."

Good to know

1

The spoken word event is free every 2nd and 4th Wednesday.

2

Street parking is available but can be scarce, costing about $13.

3

The restaurant has a focused menu with unique items from authentic recipes.

02
B's Shrimp & Fish image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant with warm family vibe and friendly atmosphere creates a welcoming space. Clean interior features flat-screen TVs for casual entertainment. Regulars enjoy fresh, well-seasoned seafood and a strong sense of community pride.

Pairs perfectly with fried items, the tartar sauce has a garlic-like taste and is not sweet. It stands out as a homemade style that beats many other recipes.

Spaghetti stands out with its flavorful, nostalgic taste. Mozzarella sticks come highly praised for their quality. Other dishes like catfish, rib tips, and dirty rice complement the menu well.

People are saying

"The fried seafood here is perfectly golden and crunchy."

"The Italian Food here is so crispy and perfectly fried perfectly fried."

"Their homemade Tartar Sauce has a great garlic-like taste."

Good to know

1

Soul Food Sunday features special menu items every weekend.

2

B's Shrimp & Fish offers carry out only; no dine-in service available.

3

Soul Food Monday is also available for those who miss Sunday.

03
Surfside Fish House image 1

Casual restaurant with clean, bright decor and a cool San Diego mural creates a welcoming, chill atmosphere. Seating includes outdoor patio and bar options, with a lively vibe that can get noisy when busy. Offers affordable, fresh seafood with a serious focus on quality and variety.

Small sides of tartar sauce come with some orders and taste delicious. Sometimes it appears alongside cocktail sauce, but ketchup and utensils for slaw are not always included.

Spicy shrimp linguine stands out with a side of garlic bread. Fried calamari and Barramundi with veggies and rice also appear alongside Italian dishes.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the happy hour with $2 tacos and $6 wine."

"The Italian food here is spectacular, especially the linguine."

"The tartar sauce here is delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 4 to 6 pm with $2 fish tacos and $1.5 oysters.

2

Expect generous portion sizes for the price, especially the kids' shrimp basket.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of seafood dishes at very reasonable prices.

04
Champโ€™s Seafood & Grill image 1

Seafood restaurant with ambient lighting and a welcoming atmosphere offers laid-back music and a clean, professional appearance. No indoor seating is available, but plenty of parking supports easy access. The vibe is inviting and relaxed, with staff pride evident in maintaining the space.

Homemade tartar sauce offers a fresh flavor that pairs well with seafood. Portions come with one serving for multiple pieces, balancing simplicity and taste.

Shrimp and salmon pasta dishes stand out with creamy Cajun sauce and fresh toppings like cherry tomatoes and a lemon wedge. Pasta is cooked perfectly and full of flavor.

People are saying

"The food here is always super fresh and delicious."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta with salmon, is pure perfection."

"The tartar sauce tastes homemade and fresh."

Good to know

1

There is plenty of parking available near the restaurant.

2

You can order online to have your food ready upon arrival.

3

The restaurant is consistently clean and welcoming.

05
518 Sports Pub & Grill image 1

Dark, cozy space blends live Delta blues music with a relaxed coastal vibe. Spacious layout includes a private room and pool tables, attracting groups and music lovers alike. Atmosphere shifts from quiet afternoons to lively evenings with strong, well-crafted cocktails.

Made in King's Inn style, the tartar sauce has a perfect twang that lifts the seafood dishes. It stands out as next level among homemade sauces.

Cajun pasta stands out with rich flavors and a satisfying texture. Other dishes like seafood fondue and Rockefeller pasta add variety and depth to the Italian offerings.

People are saying

"The oysters here are so fresh and delicious."

"The Cajun pasta here is amazing, with plenty of sausage."

"The homemade tartar sauce has just the right amount of twang."

Good to know

1

On Mondays, oysters are $1 each, making it a great deal.

2

Sundays feature $20 bottomless mimosas from 10am to 3pm.

3

Happy hour offers $3 drinks and half off wine on Wednesdays.

06
It Ain't Just Fish image 1

Restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with a modern artistic design and a family vibe. Music features old school R&B, creating a lively and engaging environment where people sing and talk. The space is beautifully painted and clean, often busy with a strong sense of community support.

Homemade tartar sauce stands out with a fantastic flavor. An extra charge applies for additional servings after spending over $40-$50.

Baked pasta comes with a rich, creamy sauce and succulent shrimp. Shrimp Rasta Pasta resembles Alfredo but can vary in flavor, sometimes tasting bland.

People are saying

"The food here is so good, it's worth the drive."

"The baked pasta dish was covered in a rich, creamy sauce."

"The tartar sauce here is homemade and fantastic."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is usually very busy, so calling ahead is recommended.

2

Expect longer wait times during peak hours due to popularity.

3

Portion sizes are larger than average, providing good value.

07
Latitudes Restaurant and Bar image 1

Waterfront setting with unbeatable river views and an outdoor patio creates a relaxing atmosphere. Live steel drum music adds a vibrant Caribbean vibe that fills the space. Fresh seafood and a sushi bar complement the casual yet refined dining experience.

Tangy tartar sauce comes in a small container alongside ketchup and coleslaw. It pairs well with Fish & Chips and has a consistently excellent flavor.

Pappardelle Bolognese stands out when available, offering a rich, hearty option. The menu also features shrimp pasta and steaks that pair well with Italian dishes.

People are saying

"The food here was excellent and terrific."

"Brooke makes the best drinks, especially the margaritas."

"I thought the tartar sauce was amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for groups larger than six to avoid long wait times.

2

Happy hour offers $2 oysters every day until 6 PM.

3

Music bingo takes place every Thursday night, starting at 7 PM.

08
The Conch Republic Grill image 1

Restaurant offers cozy outdoor seating with beautiful sunset views and unique conch shell decor. Atmosphere feels fun and family friendly, with live music and sports screens adding to the vibe. Happy hour features strong tropical cocktails and a variety of seafood dishes stand out.

Grilled black grouper comes with exceptional tartar sauce that stands out. The house-made sauce pairs well with french fries and offers rich, flavorful notes.

Seafood pasta stands out with perfect seasoning and cooking. Other dishes include chicken Alfredo and Rasta pasta, all delivering strong flavors that satisfy seafood lovers.

People are saying

"The seafood here is fantastic, especially the grouper."

"The Italian food here is amazing, and the servers are incredible."

"I've never tasted tartar sauce this good before."

Good to know

1

A dinner reservation is a must, especially during busy seasons.

2

Happy hour runs from 1 PM to 7 PM every day with 2-for-1 drinks.

3

Parking is ample and convenient for visitors.

09
New Berlin Fish House & Oyster Bar image 1

Seafood restaurant with an airy nautical theme and clean, well-maintained decor creates a warm, family-friendly atmosphere that can get lively due to its small size. A full bar offers creative cocktails alongside casual dining, making it a comfortable spot to enjoy seafood and watch a game.

Sauces come homemade with little bits of onion and sweet relish in the tartar sauce. The cocktail sauce balances just enough horseradish for a sharp kick.

Shrimp tortellini appears in several dishes, including tri-color and cheese versions. Lobster ravioli offers a rich, creamy option. Crab cakes also feature as a notable starter.

People are saying

"The char-broiled oysters here are fantastic."

"I tried the lobster ravioli; it was heavenly."

"The tartar sauce has little bits of onion and sweet relish."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with fantastic drink specials.

2

Wednesdays offer 60-cent oysters, a popular special that draws crowds.

3

Thursdays have Maine lobsters priced at $20, a great deal for seafood lovers.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...