Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of US

Key lime pie spots

Made for those who refuse to choose between a savory, herb-crusted lamb chop and the sharp, citrus finish of a classic key lime pie.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Daniel's Miami image 1
Daniel's Miami image 2
Daniel's Miami image 3
View all
Steak house

Upscale steakhouse with tasteful decor and spacious seating creates a cozy, elegant atmosphere that balances liveliness with easy conversation. Bar area offers a compact, beautiful space for casual drinks or full meals. Attention to detail shows in impeccable service and carefully crafted experiences throughout.

Lamb chops come perfectly cooked and full of flavor. Portions are substantial and consistently high quality.

Very tangy but balanced flavor defines the key lime pie. It often steals the show during meals.

People are saying

"The food here is exquisite, with incredible flavor and quality."

"The Lamb Chops here are phenomenal, thanks to Andrew's amazing service."

"The key lime pie totally stole the show."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

Happy hour runs from 5-7pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

They participate in Miami Spice, offering a special menu at a great value.

02
Gallagherโ€™s Steakhouse NYC image 1

Steakhouse features an enormous dry aging room and an open kitchen where chefs prepare meals in view. Atmosphere blends old-school jazz with classy, buzzing energy, creating a lively yet refined dining experience. Seating is crowded, with tables close together, enhancing a bustling vibe.

Lamb chops come in small portions, usually three pieces per serving. They are cooked perfectly and often included in special lunch courses alongside other premium cuts like fillet mignon.

Full of flavor and divine, the key lime pie stands out with its rich taste. It consistently earns a 5 out of 5 rating.

People are saying

"The porterhouse steak was flavorful and cooked to perfection."

"The Key Lime Pie here is perfection."

"The lamb chops here are so tender and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for lunch courses on weekends.

2

Lunch course is available until 4pm on weekends.

3

Expect around $130 per person for a meal with drinks, tips not included.

03
Keens Steakhouse image 1
Steak house

Exposed pipes line the ceiling, creating a historic chophouse vibe with old-school New York decor. The atmosphere feels classic and timeless, filled with vintage memorabilia and a sense of tradition. Guests enjoy a unique dining experience that blends rich history with hearty steakhouse energy.

Known for aged mutton, the lamb chops are cooked like a steak and come out tender and delicious. They stand out as an excellent choice alongside other cuts like T-bone and Chateaubriand.

A very light texture stands out in the key lime pie. It ranks among the best in the city and finishes meals with a memorable touch.

People are saying

"The atmosphere and service at this Steakhouse are professional and pleasant."

"You have to try the Key Lime Pie; it's delicious."

"The lamb chops were tender and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required as this is a popular restaurant.

2

The portions at the steakhouse are quite big, so definitely come hungry.

3

If you mention an anniversary when reserving, they celebrate with ice cream and candles.

04
Southern Chicago image 1

Elegant space features beautiful dรฉcor and a warm, comfortable atmosphere with great music enhancing the vibe. Guests enjoy thoughtfully crafted cocktails and high-quality Southern-inspired dishes in a setting that feels both inviting and refined.

Flame-grilled lamb chops come cooked to perfection with a rich, savory flavor. They stand out as a well-executed entrรฉe among other seafood options.

Key lime pie stands out as a delicious dessert option. It consistently delivers on flavor without disappointment.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and thoughtfully prepared."

"The desserts here are phenomenal, sealing the deal for me."

"I had the lamb chops; they were the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great prices on food and drinks.

2

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

3

Valet parking is available for guests.

05
14 Prime image 1
Steak house

Upscale steakhouse with elegant design and ambient lighting creates a sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere. Guests receive personalized touches like floral arrangements and complimentary champagne upon arrival. The space features a notable bar and spacious seating, fostering a lively but warm environment.

Lamb chops come out larger than expected and exquisitely prepared. They are cooked perfectly and taste very good.

Finishes with key lime pie that includes blueberries and is well-made. The pie has a strong incredible flavor that stands out.

People are saying

"The steak here is served with flawless, attentive service."

"The Key Lime Pie here is served with such personal, attentive service."

"The lamb chops were larger than expected and cooked perfectly."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for special events like 14 Prime.

2

Guests should place cocktail orders ahead of time for events.

3

The restaurant offers personalized experiences for special occasions.

06
Chicago Chop House image 1

Restored brownstone with early 1900s decor and photos of local celebrities creates a traditional steakhouse atmosphere. Live piano music plays softly, adding to the luxurious and old-fashioned vibe. Comfortable seating and personalized touches enhance a refined dining experience.

Lamb chops come out very good and are often described as top notch. They stand out as a great choice among entrees.

Tangy and perfectly balanced, the key lime pie delivers a sharp citrus punch with a smooth texture. It stands out as a delightful dessert alongside other sweet options.

People are saying

"I found the steak to be tender and flavorful."

"Derrick's recommendations for the Lamb Chops were superb."

"I ordered the Key Lime Pie for dessert; it was to die for."

Good to know

1

During the 40th anniversary, all food ordered was 40% off.

2

Valentineโ€™s Day celebrations offer special menu items.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially during holidays.

07
Peter Luger Steak House image 1

Classic steakhouse with old-fashioned decor and a brightly lit dining room creates a straightforward atmosphere. Energy feels comforting yet brisk, with staff moving efficiently around the room. Known for exceptional steak quality, it draws diners focused on the food rather than ambiance.

Lamb chops come out crispy on the outside and tender inside with a milky gamey flavor. The fat melts in your mouth without feeling oily, making them juicy and delicious.

Slices come with a flavorful and delicious filling. The pie stands out as a popular dessert option alongside pecan pie and chocolate mousse.

People are saying

"This steak is tender and delicious, even when cold."

"These lamb chops are cooked to perfection and so flavorful."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash and US debit cards.

2

Securing a reservation is crucial to avoid long wait times.

3

The restaurant gets busy on Tuesday nights.

08
Red Rooster Overtown image 1
American restaurant

Vibrant interior with lush greenery and colorful murals creates an upscale yet welcoming atmosphere. Live music featuring saxophone and DJ sets adds a lively southern vibe. Outdoor spaces include a covered patio under a large tree and a rooftop with Caribbean influences.

Lamb chops come cooked to perfection with a slight gaminess that some find flavorful. Dishes like the Sister Jones lamb chops stand out as solid choices alongside items like deviled eggs.

Custard and crust stand out for their lightness and freshness. Coconut meringue tops the pie, adding a unique twist to the classic key lime flavor.

People are saying

"The oxtail here is so tender and explodes with flavor."

"I found the lamb chops cooked to perfection."

"I loved their Key Lime Pie with coconut meringue."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs until 7 p.m. daily with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant can get very packed.

3

Parking is available but can be challenging; arrive early to secure a spot.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...