Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Lobster roll and shrimp po boy

Finding a place that masters both a lobster roll and a shrimp po boy is rare, as most kitchens struggle to balance the demands of two different coastal traditions.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 1
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 2
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 3
View all
Seafood market

Seafood market with fresh fish selection and small, cozy seating including a shaded garden patio. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, with a friendly, family-oriented vibe. Space is clean but cramped, offering a genuine, homey seafood experience.

Rolls come packed with high-quality, super tender lobster. Seafood fills the lobster roll to the brim without skimping.

The Shrimp Po Boy features crispy shrimp and comes with a side of calamari. It offers a classic sandwich experience with fresh, flavorful ingredients.

People are saying

"The seafood here is fresh, buttery, and garlicky."

"The lobster roll was buttery with a taste of garlic."

"I found the shrimp po boy sandwich to be amazing."

Good to know

1

The Bay Ridge Fishbar is BYOB, allowing guests to bring their own drinks.

2

Customers can choose the fish, which is freshly displayed and can be cooked on the spot.

3

The pricing at Bay Ridge Fishbar is incredibly fair for the quality.

02
The Fish Joint image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers a casual atmosphere with bright decor featuring custom surfboards and cool wall art. The space is clean and well lit, with a covered outdoor seating area and pleasant music. It attracts families and maintains a friendly, unpretentious vibe.

Lobster rolls come packed with full lobster meat and rich flavor. Thursdays offer a $5 discount, making it a great deal alongside tasty clam chowder and Cajun rice.

Shrimp po boys come in Jerk and Grilled styles, both served with flavorful sides like Cajun rice. The Buffalo shrimp po boy offers a spicy twist on the classic sandwich.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and delicious."

"I found the lobster roll to be delicious and full of lobster meat."

"I loved the Grilled Shrimp Po Boy, it was full of flavor."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a special on the lobster roll every Thursday.

2

Thursdays offer $5 off the menu price on lobster rolls.

3

Reservations are recommended for weekend dining to avoid long waits.

03
Lemon Crab image 1
Cajun restaurant

Small dining area with about seven to nine tables creates a cozy, intimate atmosphere. Nautical theme and 90s music add a distinctive vibe while the space feels family-like and welcoming. The place maintains a quiet, simple environment despite occasional crowding.

Stuffed full of fresh lobster, the lobster roll tastes great and comes loaded. It pairs well with fries and salad, offering a tasty, satisfying meal.

Shrimp po' boy comes with crispy shrimp and pairs well with Cajun sauce for dipping. It often appears alongside garlic fries or in a garlic shrimp version.

People are saying

"The food and service here are always incredible."

"The lobster roll here is fresh, loaded, and absolutely delicious."

"The Shrimp Po Boy's crispy shrimp and flavorful sauce are amazing."

Good to know

1

Lemon Crab now charges a 15% service fee for parties of 2.

2

There is a private parking lot available for customers.

3

Takeout options are available at Lemon Crab.

04
The Albright image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seaside restaurant on a pier offers huge outdoor deck with scenic views and patio seating where dogs are welcome. Atmosphere stays chill and cozy with Bob Marley music and heaters keeping the space warm. Counter service uses buzzers for orders, creating a casual, relaxed vibe.

Hot lobster rolls come packed with succulent lobster meat and deliver a generous portion. The Connecticut style stands out as excellent and rivals those from New England and pricier restaurants.

Shrimp po' boys feature crispy shrimp and come highly praised for their delicious flavor. They pair well with other seafood options like clam chowder and fish and chips.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and delicious."

"I found the lobster roll to be very good and amazing."

"I really enjoyed the amazing Shrimp Po Boy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is wheelchair accessible.

2

Expect long lines around noon; arrive early to secure a table.

3

Prices are effectively 10% higher due to a hidden fee.

05
New Berlin Fish House & Oyster Bar image 1

Seafood restaurant with an airy nautical theme and clean, well-maintained decor creates a warm, family-friendly atmosphere that can get lively due to its small size. A full bar offers creative cocktails alongside casual dining, making it a comfortable spot to enjoy seafood and watch a game.

Generous portions fill the lobster roll with plenty of fresh meat. It tastes very delicious and stands out as exceptional among other seafood dishes.

Shrimp po' boy comes stuffed full with a generous amount of shrimp fried to perfection. The sandwich features very soft bread that complements the crispy shrimp well.

People are saying

"The char-broiled oysters here are fantastic."

"The Shrimp Po Boy is packed with huge shrimp fried to perfection."

"The lobster roll here is exceptional and heaping with lobster."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with fantastic drink specials.

2

Wednesdays offer 60-cent oysters, a popular special that draws crowds.

3

Thursdays have Maine lobsters priced at $20, a great deal for seafood lovers.

06
Peacemaker Lobster & Crab image 1
Seafood restaurant

Rustic New England motif with seaside decor and portrait photos of fishermen creates a cozy, lively atmosphere. Lantern-lit dining and dog-friendly patio add to the welcoming vibe. Noise level rises, making conversation challenging during busy times.

Lobster roll features a buttery roll with a perfect crunch and fresh Maine lobster. It holds an award-winning reputation and stands out even compared to those from Boston and Maine.

Shrimp po' boys come with five small shrimp mostly covered in breading. They include chips by default, with fries available for an extra charge.

People are saying

"I thought the lobster roll was the best I ever tasted."

"I thought the lobster roll was the best I ever had."

"The shrimp po boy was mostly breading with just okay shrimp."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak dining hours.

3

Expect a 30-minute wait for tables on weekends.

07
Loco Lobster image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant with a modern fast food setup and clean, inviting atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant dining option despite limited access from inside. The vibe is relaxed and casual, welcoming guests with fresh decor and friendly energy.

Lobster rolls come packed with succulent lobster on a warm, buttery brioche bun. Serving sizes are generous and the lobster is perfectly cooked and seasoned.

Shrimp po boys come very large and are served with cole slaw and fresh corn. They taste well-prepared and satisfyingly good.

People are saying

"I got two lobster rolls for the price of one through the app."

"I found the lobster roll jam-packed with lobster and amazing."

"The Shrimp Po Boy here is really big and tastes good."

Good to know

1

Loco Lobster often offers a buy one get one free deal.

2

The parking lot is extremely slippery, posing a safety risk.

3

There is no easy access to the outdoor seating area from inside.

08
Angry Crab Shack image 1
Seafood restaurant

Backyard-style seafood restaurant offers bib and glove dining with live crab and lobster tanks for a hands-on experience. Atmosphere feels cozy and energetic, with paper-covered tables and a lively, welcoming vibe. Staff engage with diners, enhancing the casual, fun environment.

Twin Lobster Rolls come with generous portions of claw meat that is fresh and succulent. The fried version offers an extremely delicious twist, all priced fairly for the quality and quantity provided.

Large portion size makes the Shrimp Po Boy stretch to two meals. Opinions vary, with some finding it very tasty while others feel it is disappointing.

People are saying

"The staff here makes it a great spot for a date with their welcoming smiles."

"The lobster rolls are packed with generous, fresh, succulent claw meat."

"The shrimp po boy here is very tasty and large."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a lunch special with lots of crab and shrimp at a very reasonable price.

2

Expect loud announcements for special occasions, making it great for family gatherings.

3

Menu items directly donate profits to Seattle Childrenโ€™s Hospital.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...