Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Margherita pizza and marinara sauce in the US

You know that a margherita pizza is only as good as its marinara sauce, and you refuse to settle for anything less than a balanced pie.

Based on 764 Opinions
+761
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bruno’s Pizzeria image 1
Bruno’s Pizzeria image 2
Bruno’s Pizzeria image 3
View all

Small, clean pizzeria with a family atmosphere and traditional Italian vibe. Food is made from scratch using 100% real Italian ingredients, creating an authentic experience. The place feels like visiting Nona's kitchen, offering warm, inviting energy.

Fresh basil and tangy tomato sauce top a thin, slightly crispy crust. Mozzarella is balanced well, giving the pizza a good crunch and great taste.

Lots of great flavor stands out in the marinara sauce. It pairs well with warm, buttery garlic knots and outstanding meatballs.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was outstanding."

"The Margherita Pizza has a great taste and a good crunch."

"The marinara sauce here has lots of great flavor."

Good to know

1

Briana informed me about the lunch special of 2 slices and a soda for $5.99.

2

Everything is made fresh daily, including bread, dough, soup, and desserts.

3

The prices are very reasonable with large portion sizes.

02
IL Forno a Legna - Raritan image 1
Italian restaurant

Wood-fired oven creates smoky, crispy pizza in a cozy, inviting space with modern decor and authentic Italian music. The atmosphere balances warmth with occasional noise from hard walls, making it suitable for relaxed meals with friends or family. Semi-private corners offer separation for larger groups.

Margherita pizza stays consistent and on point. It pairs well with simple sides like spinach salad and Burrata.

Sauce stands out for its authentic flavor and homemade quality. It pairs well with dishes like fried calamari, enhancing their taste.

People are saying

"The food here is authentic and packed with fresh, rich flavors."

"Their Margherita Pizza is always good and on point."

"The marinara sauce here is delicious and has the perfect taste."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends to ensure a table.

2

The restaurant has a BYOB policy, allowing guests to bring their own alcohol.

3

Weekday lunch specials offer great value and quality for diners.

03
Villa Castrioti image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers a romantic, candlelit atmosphere with live piano and acoustic music that complements conversation. Space features modern, polished design with a secret dining room and street-side booths providing views. Guests enjoy a quiet, upscale vibe ideal for relaxed evenings away from city noise.

Margherita pizza stands out with its fresh, simple flavors. It ranks as the best pizza since Rome, making it a solid choice when dining with kids.

Fresh, delicious marinara sauce pairs well with fried zucchini and mozzarella bread. The sauce stands out as excellent and a great starter.

People are saying

"The food here is outstanding, truly a life-changing dining experience."

"The marinara sauce here is excellent and awesome."

"I thought the Margherita Pizza was the best I had since Rome."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Monday at 8pm.

2

Reservations are recommended for large parties or special events.

3

The restaurant sanitizes menus after each use for cleanliness.

04
Bleecker Street Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Classic New York slice shop with a bright, roomy interior and authentic character offers both indoor and outdoor seating. The atmosphere carries positive energy with friendly, quick service and lively music. It draws a steady crowd seeking some of the city's best casual pizza slices.

Thin, crispy crust with a perfect char and chewiness defines the Margherita pizza here. Fresh tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella top a flavorful, cheesy base that balances crispness and freshness well.

Marinara sauce here stands out with its tangy flavor and perfect balance on pizzas like the Nonna Maria Pie. It pairs well with fresh mozzarella and fresh basil, creating a rich, cheesy texture on a crispy thin crust.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was some of the best I had."

"This is a fantastic late night spot for tasty, fresh pizza."

"The Margherita pizza's crust is perfectly crisp and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Customers must order in advance using the app on Sundays.

2

You don't have to buy the whole pie; they serve per slice.

3

Paying in cash is cheaper than paying by card.

05
Brisa Do Mar image 1
Italian restaurant

Upscale Italian restaurant with riverside patio and bright, airy dining room offers a peaceful water view and live Italian soprano music. Guests arrive by boat or on foot, enjoying a contemporary style that blends classic and creative dishes. The atmosphere stays welcoming and classy, suited for relaxed dinners or special occasions.

Margherita pizza stands out as a key dish here. It pairs well with other items like calamari and chicken Alfredo pasta.

Marinara sauce comes with eggplant chips that are perfectly crisp and addictive. The sauce pairs well with Parmesan cheese but tends to be served a bit cooler than ideal.

People are saying

"The pizza here is amazing, especially the wood-fired kind."

"I kept eating the pizza even after I was full because it was so good."

"You have to try the Margherita Pizza; it's a must-have."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended during events to avoid inconvenience.

2

Fashion shows and house music events are hosted regularly.

3

Gluten-free pasta options are available, but may vary seasonally.

06
Dough Boyz Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with NYC subway decor and freestyle music creates an authentic New York pizza shop vibe. The atmosphere feels cozy and family-oriented, evoking a strong sense of Brooklyn. Seating is limited, with booths close to kitchen and bathroom doors, enhancing the intimate setting.

The Vodka Margherita pizza stands out with its rich sauce and fresh basil. The crust balances crispy yet soft textures, and adding extra pepperoni is a popular choice.

Rich marinara sauce comes with the Calzone and pairs well with a side of spaghetti. The sauce shows clear love and effort in its preparation.

People are saying

"This pizza is phenomenal, just like back in New York."

"The Margherita Pizza here is out of this world good."

"The marinara sauce here is rich and tasty."

Good to know

1

Dough Boyz Pizza charges $9.95 for a side of pasta.

2

Parking is available in the back of the building.

3

Third-party delivery services may add extra fees.

07
Giovannis pizzeria & mediterranean Grill image 1

Neighborhood pizza restaurant offers a quiet, comfortable atmosphere with Italian music enhancing the dining experience. The space is clean and well decorated, featuring high-quality dishware and a spacious lobby. The vibe recalls Mediterranean dining with a cozy, friendly feel.

Fresh ingredients define the Margherita pizza here, with flavors that melt in your mouth. A unique mint infusion adds an unexpected twist to the classic taste.

Sauce bursts with rich tomato flavor and tastes incredibly fresh. It pairs well with the crispy-yet-chewy crust but some dishes could use a bit more of it.

People are saying

"It's a family-owned place with owners who put their heart and soul into the food."

"I found the Margherita Pizza simply phenomenal and super fresh."

"The marinara sauce here is amazing and bursting with rich tomato flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but recommended during peak hours.

2

The restaurant offers a late-night menu until 11pm on weekends.

3

Parking is available on-site and is free for customers.

08
John's of Bleecker Street image 1

Nearly 100-year-old coal-burning oven creates a thin, crispy crust and historic vibe with celebrity photos and wooden booths. Atmosphere feels like a return to another era, cozy but sometimes cramped inside. Outdoor seating includes heaters, making it comfortable even in cooler weather.

Crust comes out crispy at the bottom and charred on the sides. The pizza melts in your mouth with fresh toppings.

Rich flavor defines the marinara sauce here, making it a standout on pizza and calzones. It pairs well with appetizers like fried zucchini and calamari, adding a crispy and tender contrast.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing."

"This Margherita pizza is probably the best I ever had."

"Their marinara sauce is amazing and unbelievable."

Good to know

1

Get there early to avoid waiting; a line forms 20-30 minutes before opening.

2

Expect to wait over half an hour during peak lunch and dinner times.

3

They only serve whole pies, no slices available.

09
Aria's Brick Oven Pizzeria image 1

Brick stone oven creates authentic Italian pizza with a crispy crust and rich flavors. Small, cozy space offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. Prices lean higher but reflect quality ingredients and taste.

Freshness varies, with the Margherita pizza sometimes topped with squeeze basil instead of fresh leaves. The crust is generally crispy, and the pizza can be customized with toppings like pepperoni.

Sides include marinara sauce along with ranch and garlic butter. Opinions on the sauce vary, with some finding it very good and others rating it below mid.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and truly Italian."

"The Margherita Pizza here is fresh and crispy."

"I thought their marinara sauce was very good."

Good to know

1

Expect a 15-20 minute wait for pizza after ordering.

2

A large pizza is currently $5 off during a special promotion.

3

The price for a 14-inch, 3-topping pizza is over $23.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...