Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to the US

Meatballs and muffuletta

You need a place that masters the savory depth of meatballs while also delivering a proper, stacked muffuletta.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Gigi's Italian To Go image 1
Gigi's Italian To Go image 2
Gigi's Italian To Go image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Italian eatery offers family-oriented atmosphere with homey murals and a hidden garden. The vibe is comfortable and welcoming, attracting those who appreciate authentic, old-school Italian sandwiches and Sicilian specialties. Busy and popular, it stands out for its high-quality ingredients and generous portions.

Massive-sized meatballs with authentic flavor and delicious marinara stand out in the meatball sub. The owner, known as the king of the meatballs, crafts homemade meatballs that earn many awards.

The muffuletta features light bread with sesame seeds that adds a crunchy texture. Its olive spread brings a salty, spicy, and tangy flavor that stands out. Fresh grated parmesan and oil enhance the sandwich's overall taste.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were amazing and old school."

"The meatball sub here is massive, flavorful, and delicious."

"The Muffuletta here is seriously amazing and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Orders are typically ready in under 30 minutes, even during busy times.

2

Expect a wait during lunch hours, especially on weekends.

3

The menu is primarily focused on sandwiches, with a few Italian market items.

02
Rosie's Sidekick Sandwich Shop image 1

Sandwich shop tucked inside an office building fills the lobby with the smell of fresh bread and seasoning. Cozy atmosphere with a friendly, bright vibe and seating available across the hall or outdoors. Known for high-quality Italian deli sandwiches with unique, fresh ingredients and homemade sauces.

Homemade meatballs come super hot with an amazing smell. The meatball sandwiches pair well with Italian beef and roast beef, offering a very good and incredibly delicious flavor.

A huge Sicilian muffuletta comes with a rich olive mix that stands out. It serves as a filling meal for both lunch and dinner.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, flavorful, and made with high-quality ingredients."

"I thought the meatball sandwich was one of the best I ever had."

"I think this muffuletta is the best sandwich I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Order ahead to avoid a 30-minute wait for small orders.

2

Parking is available in the back of the building.

3

Look for the pink Rosieโ€™s sign in the parking lot for easy navigation.

03
Jimmy's Food Store image 1
Italian grocery store

Small, dimly lit space with old-world Italian charm and a nostalgic atmosphere reminiscent of a New York deli. Aromas of authentic Italian goods fill the air, creating a warm, inviting vibe despite the cramped layout. Offers top-notch sandwiches and Italian wines, drawing those seeking genuine Italian provisions.

Meatball subs stand out with excellent quality and flavor. High-quality meat blends include spicy Italian sausage and onion and pepper sausage for rich taste.

Offers a muffuletta sandwich with fresh ingredients and Ghirardelli peppers added. The sandwich provides great value and stands out for its incredible flavor.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are excellent and amazing."

"I found the meatball subs to be delicious and worth the wait."

"I thought the Muffuletta sandwich was outrageously delicious."

Good to know

1

Jimmy's Food Store has imported products that are hard to find elsewhere.

2

Jimmy's Food Store starts taking sandwich orders at 10am.

3

On weekends, they offer fresh bread and have someone sampling olive oil and wine.

04
Carmine Lonardo's Italian image 1

Old school Italian deli with authentic East Coast charm and a retro market atmosphere. Space is small and busy, often loud and packed, with limited seating mostly for takeout. Rich aromas and family-owned feel create a lively, nostalgic vibe.

Large, old school Italian meatballs fill sandwiches and subs with rich, cheesy comfort. The meatball sandwich leaves you full but still craving more.

Crusty bread and fresh, flavorful cold cuts define the muffuletta here. The best olive relish adds a distinctive punch that stands out in every bite.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best I've ever had."

"I thought the meatball sub was to die for."

"I thought the Muffuletta was one of the best sandwiches I had ever eaten."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended as they often sell out.

2

Expect a wait during peak lunch hours, especially on weekends.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

05
Motorboat image 1
Restaurant

Coastal and beach-like interior blends with a historic building renovation to create a cute and cozy theme. Music stays chill but can get loud, contributing to a solid bar atmosphere that feels upscale without being bougie. Large, meat-loaded sandwiches stand out as the real highlight amid a casual, everyday bar setting.

Meatballs come out flavorful and well-seasoned. Kids enjoy them paired with pasta salad, making it a simple, satisfying combo.

Big enough to share, the muffuletta comes with a generous portion. It satisfies cravings with a delicious taste.

People are saying

"You have to try the fried fish sandwich at this bar."

"I love that this place is open late, perfect for midnight Meatballs."

"This Muffuletta is big enough to split between two people."

Good to know

1

There is no bike parking available.

2

Prices have increased by $1-2, now around $19 before tip.

3

The food comes out very quickly.

06
Angelo'z image 1
Poโ€™ boys restaurant

Po' boys restaurant with nostalgic mom and pop decor and a cozy, unpretentious atmosphere offers a drive-thru service alongside inside seating. The vibe is quiet and welcoming, reflecting simple, quality food with fresh bread and homemade touches.

Meatball sandwich stands out with solid flavor and good quality. The meatball sub earns consistent praise for its taste and satisfaction.

Toasty and hot, the Muffuletta stands out with its delicious flavor. It earns strong praise for its satisfying taste and warmth.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best I've ever had."

"I found the food here to be delicious and fantastic."

"I found the meatball sub to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Parking can be inconvenient, so plan accordingly.

2

The total cost for a sandwich, chips, drink, and tip is around $20.

3

Angelo'z has a drive-thru service for quick orders.

07
Joe's ITALIAN TAKE-OUT image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space with a few tables offers a quiet, pleasant atmosphere without background music. Staff provide friendly service, and food is ready on time for takeout. Display case features an impressive variety of homemade desserts, adding a distinctive touch.

Meatballs taste homemade and moist, like a nonna's recipe. The meatball subs come in large portions, enough to share or have leftovers.

The muffuletta features sesame seed bread that sometimes comes out very hard or burned in spots. It includes sub meat sliced fresh in house but has light ham coverage on each slice.

People are saying

"I loved their homemade pasta; the sauce was delicious."

"You have to try the meatball sub; it's outstanding and huge."

"I thought the Muffuletta was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited and can be difficult to find.

2

Expect large portion sizes for all menu items.

3

Credit cards are accepted for payment.

08
DeFalco's Italian Deli & Grocery image 1

Small deli and grocery with an authentic Italian vibe and old-school deli counter. Warm, inviting atmosphere with nostalgic family photos and a shaded outdoor patio. Offers a mini market featuring imported Italian goods alongside classic homemade dishes.

Meatballs come sweet and juicy with a cheesy glaze that stands out. The meatball sub is tight and packed, offering a rich, flavorful bite every time.

Muffuletta comes on a sub roll instead of traditional Muffuletta bread. It serves as a quick fix for those missing the original New Orleans style.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and amazing."

"The meatball sub was flavorful with a nice cheesy glaze."

"They made my Muffuletta sandwich on a sub roll."

Good to know

1

There is plenty of parking available nearby.

2

Expect busy lunch hours with longer wait times.

3

Prices are generally higher than average for deli items.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...