Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Toffee and rigatoni

A balanced palate demands the sugary finish of toffee alongside the hearty, textured bite of rigatoni.

Based on 555 Opinions
+552
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Clemmy's image 1
Clemmy's image 2
Clemmy's image 3
View all
Restaurant

Tiny restaurant with cozy decor and tasteful ambiance creates an intimate, inviting atmosphere. Candles and carefully chosen music set a relaxing mood without rushing diners. The space welcomes families with a kids menu and features outdoor fire pits for casual gatherings.

Sticky toffee pudding comes with coffee whipped cream and stays on the menu. It pairs well with other desserts like flourless chocolate cake and orange cake.

Rigatoni Bolognese stands out with a special touch that enhances its classic flavor. Main entrees also include Casio e Pepe and braised short ribs known for their tenderness and rich taste.

People are saying

"The orange cake dessert was delicious and couldn't be beat."

"The sticky toffee pudding was delicious and amazing."

"The rigatoni here has a special touch and is incredibly flavorful."

Good to know

1

Clemmy's is BYOB and does not accept reservations.

2

Clemmy's is a small restaurant, which may lead to wait times.

3

Expect a packed house on Friday evenings around 4:30pm.

02
'ino image 1
Italian restaurant

Open doors and a skylight fill the space with fresh air and natural light, creating a bright, welcoming energy. Soft lighting and comfortable seating foster a cozy, inviting atmosphere with a relaxed buzz. Well-crafted cocktails and sophisticated yet unpretentious vibe make it suitable for solo meals, dates, or dinners with friends.

Sticky toffee pudding stands out as a decadent dessert with a rich, sticky texture. The menu includes English-inspired items like scotch egg alongside the toffee dessert.

Over ordering happens often to try all the pasta types like pici, rigatoni, and cappelletti. Rigatoni stands out as a must-try dish here.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is outstanding, especially the pasta."

"You have to try the sticky toffee pudding; it's decadent."

"You have to try the Rigatoni; it's a must-try dish."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups to ensure seating.

2

Happy hour features discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

3

The menu includes seasonal ingredients, changing frequently to reflect freshness.

03
Nicco's Prime Cuts & Fresh Fish image 1

Upscale restaurant combines plush decor with an open kitchen showcasing fresh fish on ice. Atmosphere balances elegant and lively, featuring a live pianist and a large circular bar. Space suits both groups and romantic evenings, with a mix of cozy and vibrant energy.

Warm Butter Toffee Cake stands out as a rich, delicious dessert option. The menu also includes Toffee Pudding and other sizable, reasonably priced sweets like Banoffee Tart and Peanut Butter Brookie.

Rigatoni alla Vodka stands out as a popular choice with a rich, creamy sauce. Housemade pastas include a spicy Rigatoni that shows extra effort in preparation.

People are saying

"The steakhouse service here is top-notch and phenomenal."

"The toffee dessert was one of the best I ever had."

"The vodka rigatoni was the best pasta I had in a long time."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary, especially during busy dining times.

2

Expect to pay around $150 per person for a full meal.

3

The restaurant offers complimentary champagne mixed with Chambord on Valentine's Day.

04
American Way Pasta image 1

Italian-style restaurant offers a cozy, classy atmosphere with elegant decor reminiscent of old Chicago. The vibe balances lively yet relaxing, making it suitable for quiet conversations and date nights. Guests often enjoy exceptional pasta dishes paired with well-crafted cocktails and Italian wines.

Sticky Toffee Pudding stands out as a unique and delicious dessert here. It earns high praise for its amazing flavor and rich texture.

Chicken rigatoni features Italian sausage with rich flavors. The dish stands out alongside other Italian classics like cacio e pepe.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is amazing, especially the pistachio pesto."

"The rigatoni here is amazing, full of flavor and cooked perfectly."

"The sticky toffee pudding here is amazing and unique."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers most cocktails at half price.

2

Expect a quoted wait time of over 45 minutes, but actual wait is about 15 minutes.

3

Gluten-free pasta options are available on the menu.

05
The Smith image 1
American restaurant

Spacious American restaurant with close tables and a buzzy bar area creates a lively, loud atmosphere. Outdoor seating on a closed street adds an open feel. Sheet steel chairs contribute to the ambient noise, enhancing the energetic vibe.

Sticky toffee pudding stands out with its rich, sticky texture and pairs well with vanilla ice cream. Desserts here lean toward the decadent side, especially the toffee pudding and s'mores in a jar.

Rigatoni alla vodka comes in a decent portion size with an amazing vodka sauce. The dish is filling and stands out among other main courses.

People are saying

"The brunch here is impressive, with generous portions and fresh, well-seasoned food."

"The rigatoni alla vodka was very tasty and a decent portion."

"The sticky toffee pudding is delicious and a must-try."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required after 5pm on weekdays to secure a table.

2

Happy hour runs from 3pm to 6pm with great drink prices.

3

Expect a 40-minute wait between 7 and 8 pm during peak hours.

06
Quality Italian image 1
Italian restaurant

Industrial design with marble staircase and Edison bulbs creates a romantic but cool vibe. Crowds fill multiple seating areas including a downstairs bar known for quality cocktails. Private rooms offer great privacy amid a lively, sometimes noisy atmosphere.

Sticky toffee pudding stands out with its warm, rich flavor and malted vanilla accompaniment. It delivers a sweet, satisfying finish that many find memorable.

Spicy Lobster Rigatoni stands out with its rich flavor and live cooking presentation at the table. The dish offers an entertaining show as it's prepared on a rolling stove, making it a memorable choice.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pastas, is amazing."

"The spicy lobster rigatoni alla vodka was amazing."

"You have to try the sticky toffee pudding; it's divine."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for private events and are highly recommended for dining.

2

Quality Italian hosts a wine week three times a year, attracting many visitors.

3

Happy hour is available after work, offering discounted drinks and appetizers.

07
EVELYN image 1
Steak house

Steak house offers three distinct seating areas including a cozy bar, piano room, and dance space lively after 9 pm. Atmosphere blends vibrant energy with a stylish crowd dressed for nightlife, supported by live music and surprise performances. Interior design is stunning and inviting, creating a destination feel beyond typical dining.

Warm sticky toffee cake serves as a sweet ending. The dessert pairs brittle ice cream with rich toffee flavors.

Rigatoni alla vodka stands out as a favorite dish here. The pasta is rich and flavorful, making it a dish many return for.

People are saying

"The food here is excellent, especially the seafood and desserts."

"You have to try the rigatoni; it's incredible."

"The warm toffee cake is the perfect sweet ending."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends to avoid disappointment.

2

Valet parking is mandatory; plan for this when arriving.

3

The restaurant hosts live performances in the piano room on Fridays and Sundays.

08
The Bar Room at The Modern image 1

Modern dining space offers an elegant and civilized atmosphere with beautiful lighting and decor overlooking a green courtyard oasis. The vibe ranges from chill and inviting to lively and chaotic on busy nights, with excellent cocktails and a casual yet sophisticated bar area.

Chocolate marquise features toffee accents paired with marshmallow. Peanut toffee pudding comes with banana miso ice cream for a rich dessert.

Rigatoni comes perfectly cooked with a creamy burrata that adds richness without overpowering. The dish blends spring onion, pine nuts, and summer truffle for a light, comforting flavor.

People are saying

"The desserts here are thoughtful and effortlessly professional."

"The toffee here is masterfully handled, truly impeccable."

"The rigatoni with pesto, burrata, and truffle was so good."

Good to know

1

During Restaurant Week, the restaurant offers 2 courses for $45 or 3 courses for $60.

2

Reservations should be made at least 2 weeks in advance, especially during restaurant week.

3

The restaurant week menu is for lunch only, costing $45 for two courses and extra for dessert.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...