Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Colorado

Bakeries with birthday cakes

A birthday cake that tastes like it was baked for a celebration, rather than something pulled from a freezer case.

Based on 838 Opinions
+835
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
New York Bakery image 1
New York Bakery image 2
New York Bakery image 3
View all

Custom cakes stand out for their beautiful decoration and delicious flavors, often matching exact designs provided. Fresh breads appear daily, supporting a local bakery vibe with competitive pricing that serves groups well.

Cakes here look and taste amazing with consistent quality and reliability. Pricing stays competitive and staff remain friendly.

Birthday cakes come in custom flavors like Oreo chocolate and can be made quickly for last minute orders. Cakes such as the "Schmidt" 29 design are available and consistently meet specific requests.

People are saying

"I ordered a cake from this bakery and it tasted amazing."

"The cake here is so delicious and light."

"The birthday cake here is gorgeous and delicious."

Good to know

1

The cake costs $35 and serves about ten people.

2

Custom cake orders require at least a week's notice.

3

The bakery accepts credit cards and mobile payments.

02
Normaโ€™s Bakery image 1

Small bakery offers authentic Mexican pastries with a warm, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of a grandma's kitchen. Delicious smells greet visitors even before entering, creating a homey, nostalgic vibe. Complimentary coffee adds to the welcoming experience.

Offers a great variety of Mexican pastries with an old school feel. Pastries like the cannoli have the right sweetness and crunch, matching high-end Italian bakeries.

They make birthday cakes quickly, even for next-day orders. Kids enjoy the cakes, and they serve as a reliable option when searching for a birthday cake in the area.

People are saying

"The pastries here feel like a warm hug from Norma."

"The bakery's pastries and bread were delicious and fresh."

"I think this tres leches cake is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Normaโ€™s Bakery gives a free slice of chocolate flan on your birthday.

2

They always offer a free coffee with purchase.

3

Many people come to Normaโ€™s Bakery in the morning right when they open to get their pan dulce before work.

03
Piero's Bakery image 1

Bright, detailed design creates an inviting space with a focus on in-house cakes and desserts. The atmosphere highlights authentic Peruvian flavors and reasonably priced, richly flavored cakes. Empanadas and specialty items like tres leches and tiramisu stand out as signature offerings.

Cakes here are rich and full of flavor with beautiful decoration. Prices stay insanely reasonable and service handles last-minute orders smoothly.

Birthday cakes come with nice decorations and taste very delicious. Same-day orders get handled quickly and accommodatingly.

People are saying

"The cakes here are amazing and truly delicious."

"I got a custom cake on short notice from this bakery."

"The birthday cakes here are so delicious and nicely decorated."

Good to know

1

Prices at Piero's Bakery are reasonable, with cakes starting around $95.

2

The bakery confirms orders via email before starting the cake preparation.

3

Many desserts, including Tres Leches cake, are made in-house.

04
A Cake Occasion image 1

Small, simple bakery with a warm, friendly atmosphere and heavenly sweet smells. Offers beautifully decorated cakes and a grab-and-go section with tasty cupcakes. Prices are reasonable, and the space feels inviting and thoughtfully arranged.

Specialty cakes and indulgent cupcakes stand out here, making it a go-to spot for holidays and birthdays. The bakery offers a warm, friendly atmosphere with helpful staff.

Custom birthday cakes come with quick turnaround and delivery options. Designs often feel personal and special, connecting generations with familiar flavors and styles.

People are saying

"The cake here is so delicious and moist."

"I thought their cookies were the best I've ever had."

"The bakery cakes are perfect, moist, and delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers custom cakes for special occasions with advance notice.

2

Cupcakes are priced around $60 for a dozen, which is competitive.

3

They do not guarantee nut-free cakes, so check for allergies.

05
La Petite Bakery image 1

Small bakery offers Asian-style pastries with balanced sweetness and tropical fruit flavors. Atmosphere feels inviting and charming, with a clean, authentic vibe. Desserts include durian cake and other unique options rarely found elsewhere.

Offers a wide variety of Asian style shortcakes and Vietnamese desserts alongside traditional cakes and cookies. Pastries balance sweetness well, and macarons stand out for their flavor and price. Staff quickly prepare custom orders and provide helpful service.

Known for durian birthday cake, this bakery prepares cakes quickly, often within 15 minutes. It serves as a reliable spot for last minute birthday cakes and is a frequent choice for celebrations.

People are saying

"This Chinese fruit cake is airy, moist, and not overly sweet."

"These pastries are amazing and not too sweet."

"This bakery's fruit cake is light, airy, moist, and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for custom cake orders to ensure availability.

2

Pre-ordering is necessary for durian crepes as they are not always available.

3

Prices for cakes can be higher than average, so budget accordingly.

06
le' Bakery Sensual image 1

Interior bursts with creative decorations and humorous party themes, filling every space with visual interest. Atmosphere feels welcoming and lively, highlighted by displays of artistic cake designs that impress with detail and flavor. Cakes serve as customizable centerpieces, often becoming the highlight of celebrations.

Custom cakes and artistic centerpieces stand out here, with options like gender reveal cupcakes available on short notice. The bakery handles last-minute orders smoothly and makes celebrations special with amazing taste and design.

Incredible birthday cakes come through even last minute, with the owner stepping in to help when needed. Cakes show amazing quality and satisfy special occasions like birthdays.

People are saying

"The cake here is delicious."

"The cakes from this bakery are delicious and beautifully decorated."

"I was so happy with how they decorated my birthday cake!"

Good to know

1

They have a free parking lot in the city.

2

The cake cost $176 excluding tip for a relatively simple 1/4 sheet cake.

3

They will customize anything I needed, and it would be the hit of my party.

07
Sweets of Inspiration Bakery Cafe image 1

Bakery offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with cozy indoor and outdoor seating that encourages socializing and relaxation. It features custom cakes and cupcakes with detailed designs and a wide variety of unique flavors including dog treats. The environment blends small business charm with a friendly, comfortable vibe.

Offers customized cupcakes at reasonable prices and a custom carrot cake option. The bakery has a warm, inviting atmosphere ideal for sitting with friends and enjoying sweets and coffee.

Custom birthday cakes come with careful attention to wishes and themes. Bakers like Ariana and Erica handle orders with personalized care and deliver consistent results over multiple years.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and taste delicious."

"The bakery's custom cupcakes were beautiful and delicious."

"This Birthday Cake is the most amazing I've ever seen!"

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of baked goods, breakfast items, and drinks.

2

Prices for homemade pies are competitive.

3

Custom cupcakes can be ordered at a reasonable price for 24 cupcakes.

08
Das Meyer Fine Pastry Chalet image 1

Small-town charm blends with high-end quality in a beautiful, classic venue that feels quiet and ethereal. Family-owned pride shows through fresh, delicious pastries and unmatched cake designs. Cash-only policy adds a traditional touch to the experience.

Offers high-quality pastries at prices about 50% less than other bakeries. Serves as a go-to spot for celebrations like weddings and birthdays with a strong reputation in the area.

Birthday cakes here stand out for their visual beauty and custom themes like Super Mario. They taste incredibly delicious and impress with their cuteness and special designs.

People are saying

"I ordered my wedding cake here and it was perfect."

"Their wedding cakes are amazing and highly recommended."

"This birthday cake is so delicious and moist."

Good to know

1

Das Meyer Fine Pastry Chalet only accepts cash.

2

I wouldnโ€™t rely on Googleโ€™s information about their hours.

3

The hours at Das Meyer Fine Pastry Chalet can be unreliable.

09
SC Bakery image 1
Bakery

Small bakery with a friendly, cozy vibe and a pet-friendly setup featuring dog treats and photos. Pastries include chocolate croissants, cinnamon rolls, and mini quiches that draw consistent praise. Open only on Fridays and Saturdays, it offers a quiet atmosphere with few customers at a time.

Delicious pastries and excellent coffee stand out here, with a great selection of baked goods. The bakery offers top-tier customer service and maintains amazing prices.

Custom birthday cakes come together quickly, even on short notice. Dog birthday cakes get devoured by pups, showing their appeal and specialty.

People are saying

"Their pastries are so delicious, I fell in love with them."

"This bakery is the best I've been to in a while."

"You can get a birthday cake for your dog here."

Good to know

1

SC Bakery is only open on Fridays and Saturdays.

2

Parking is abundant.

3

SC Bakery offers homemade dog treats and dog birthday cakes.

10
Cakeheads Bakery image 1

Bright, clean space offers small tables for enjoying coffee and pastries in a welcoming atmosphere. Cakes and baked goods feature exceptional decoration and unique flavors like ube and pandan, drawing a crowd seeking custom and specialty treats.

Bright, clean setup highlights the bakery's inviting atmosphere. A great selection of mouth-watering treats and friendly staff accommodate special orders quickly.

Custom birthday cakes come out delicious and meet specific requests well. Options include graduation and birthday cakes made to order.

People are saying

"I was amazed at the creation of this custom cake."

"This bakery's cake was beautiful and tasted amazing."

"I was extremely happy with my custom birthday cake."

Good to know

1

Cakeheads Bakery is known for cakes, pies, and specialty cookies for events.

2

They offer discounted day-old 4-packs for budget-friendly options.

3

A wide variety of options includes cakes, cupcakes, macarons, and cookies.

11
Gateaux image 1
Bakery

Bakery with a Greek Gods theme offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels relaxed and cheerful. It draws a crowd looking for European pastry chef-level pastries and custom cakes that combine artistry with rich flavors. The space balances a sense of tradition with reasonably priced, high-quality treats.

Wedding cakes and desserts come with creativity and talent here. Staff offer a warm, inviting atmosphere and genuine smiles, making the bakery feel like family.

Custom birthday cakes feature detailed themes like anime characters and come in flavors such as chocolate strawberry. Orders require advance notice and the cakes consistently taste delicious.

People are saying

"The birthday cakes here are delicious and looked great."

"Michelle made my daughter's wedding cake unforgettable."

"I thought the birthday cake was delicious."

Good to know

1

Gateaux charges a $30 delivery fee for orders within 1.3 miles.

2

The bakery offers vegan options for wedding cakes and desserts.

3

Expect a wide selection of pastries and cakes for various occasions.

12
TOUS les JOURS image 1

Bright, modern bakery with fresh pastries and artisan breads offers a quiet, comfy atmosphere with plenty of seating. Decor includes festive touches and a children's corner, creating an inviting space for casual breaks or light work.

Offers a unique blend of French and Asian flavors in its baked goods. Focuses on high-quality ingredients with less sugar and fresh tastes.

Birthday cakes come in interesting flavors like yogurt frosting and feature kids' themes such as baby shark. Families often choose these cakes for special occasions and find them tasty and memorable.

People are saying

"Their pastries and cakes are light and not too sweet."

"This bakery's cakes are light and not too sweet."

"I loved their birthday cakes; they were the perfect amount of sweet."

Good to know

1

Get there early to avoid missing out on popular items.

2

Most items are sold a la carte; choose what you want from the trays.

3

Expect a line during peak hours, especially in the afternoon.

13
Masterpiece Cakeshop image 1

Cake shop offers charming decor and a joyous atmosphere with tables and board games for a relaxed visit. Family-run with strong values and inclusivity, it provides gluten-free and dairy-free options alongside expertly crafted cakes and brownies.

Breads and brownies stand out as unbelievably delicious. Birthday cakes serve as a reliable choice. Desserts inspire a strong desire to spend more time in the bakery.

Beautiful and delicious birthday cakes come with options for gluten-free versions. Cakes often arrive with extra treats like carrot cake and cookies.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and delicious."

"I thought the brownie was heavenly and delicious."

"The bakery's brownies and cookies are unbelievably delicious."

Good to know

1

The shop offers several dairy-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Gluten-free cupcakes are available for customers with gluten sensitivities.

3

The bakery is family-run, supporting a local business.

14
Azucar Bakery image 1

Cozy interior with artistic decor sets a warm tone. The bakery offers an exceptional variety of sweets, including custom cakes and savory empanadas. It attracts people looking for both celebrations and casual treats, known for delicious, beautifully crafted desserts.

Decorated cakes stand out with great variety and amazing designs. Cookies come nicely boxed, and the bakery offers a friendly atmosphere with a cute setup.

Specialty birthday cakes include options like Tres Leche, which stands out for its flavor. Cakes and cupcakes come with detailed decoration and satisfy last-minute orders.

People are saying

"This cake was the best I ever had, truly impressive."

"This bakery's cakes are stunning and tasted amazing."

"This birthday cake is perfectly sweet and moist."

Good to know

1

Online ordering is available for convenience.

2

The bakery offers a variety of cakes suitable for weddings and events.

3

Prices for custom cakes may seem high but are often worth it.

15
Cakes Iconic image 1
Cake shop

Custom cakes showcase imaginative design and flawless execution, often becoming the centerpiece of celebrations. The atmosphere is defined by beautiful, moist cakes with top-notch flavors that impress guests. Reliable timing and affordable prices support a smooth experience for any occasion.

Affordable prices meet great taste and appearance in their cakes. The bakery delivers exactly what is requested, making it a reliable choice for future orders.

Specializes in custom birthday cake designs with precise detail. Cakes come out beautifully crafted and can be ordered in multiples for different occasions.

People are saying

"The cake here is beautiful and tasted phenomenal."

"This bakery's custom cakes are beautiful and taste amazing."

"This Birthday Cake tastes amazing, even better than I expected."

Good to know

1

Cakes Iconic offers custom cakes for all occasions, but requires advance notice.

2

Prices start at $30 for small cakes, which may be higher than average.

3

The bakery is located on a busy street and can be hard to find.

16
Maggie & Molly's Bakery image 1

Warm aromas fill a cozy bakery with custom cake designs and vegan options. The atmosphere feels inviting and calm, with fair pricing and quality ingredients evident in every treat. Detailed decoration and delicious baked goods attract a diverse crowd seeking both classic and unique flavors.

Warm smiles and delicious aromas greet visitors. The bakery handles special occasion orders like weddings and birthdays, but ordering in person works best.

Massive German Chocolate Cake and Cherry Chip flavor appear on the birthday cake menu. Cakes suit dual celebrations and repeat orders show consistent availability.

People are saying

"The cake is so moist and delicious."

"The bakery's cakes and cookies are so delicious and moist."

"I thought the Birthday Cake was quite delicious."

Good to know

1

They offer delivery for $20 within a certain radius.

2

Add another $10 for same day delivery (rush).

3

It's prudent to plan ahead with orders, especially around the holidays.

17
Mermaids Bakery image 1

Historic building houses a bakery known for artistic cakes and unique cupcake flavors like strawberry lemonade. Atmosphere feels quaint and cute, with a focus on beautiful, detailed decoration. Early ordering is common due to limited hours and high demand.

Wedding cakes and large cupcakes come in a variety of flavors. The bakery handles orders graciously, including last-minute requests, and supports women, POC, and local ownership.

Custom shapes like a chocolate heart come out well with clear detail. Cakes taste delicious and meet expectations even when ordered remotely. Staff often go above and beyond for special occasions.

People are saying

"This cake is so delicious and moist."

"The bakery cupcakes are beautiful and delicious."

"The birthday cake here tasted delicious."

Good to know

1

It is recommended to order ahead to ensure the availability of desired flavors.

2

Delivery is available if you're downtown.

3

The bakeryโ€™s website stated they would deliver for orders over $30.

18
Pasteles Cisne #1 image 1

Pastry shop offers wide cake selection with event decoration materials available. Atmosphere feels friendly and reliable, attracting regulars who appreciate free cake promotions after multiple purchases. Cakes stand out for their consistent deliciousness, especially tres leches and walnut flavors.

Very good service stands out, with Rocio attending well. The bakery offers first communion cakes and earns strong recommendations consistently.

Quick service and helpful staff make ordering a birthday cake easy. This spot serves as a reliable choice for birthday cakes.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be delicious, especially the tres leches."

"Rocio was so helpful and patient with my birthday cake order."

"I highly recommended this bakery."

Good to know

1

You can ask for a cake sample if you're unsure which cake to choose.

2

They give you one free cake when you buy 10 cakes.

3

I had to pay an extra $15 to have them write 'happy birthday.'

19
Paris Baguette image 1

Korean bakery with an Asian Parisian style offers authentic European pastries that are light and not overly sweet. Spacious dining area includes indoor and outdoor seating with a calm, inviting atmosphere. Self-service layout features visually appealing displays and a tidy environment.

Offers a great selection of French-style bakery items and bread. Pastries and cakes consistently meet expectations with fresh, delightful flavors.

Delicious birthday cakes stand out here with their amazing appearance. This bakery is a go-to spot for holiday and birthday cakes.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be fresh, flaky, and full of flavor."

"This bakery's pastries are always delicious and fresh."

"Their strawberry cream birthday cake is light and delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking can be difficult during busy times due to the location's proximity to Costco.

2

There is a large parking lot in the back, but front spaces are often reserved.

3

Corporate policy states no refunds on food items, so choose carefully.

20
Eternal Flavors Bakery image 1

Small bakery with a dedicated team offers consistently high-quality cakes that are not overly sweet. The atmosphere feels cute and authentic, attracting those seeking special occasion cakes and unique flavors.

Cakes here are consistently amazing with standout options like the Spring Fling cake and red velvet cake. The bakery offers authentic flavors and reliable quality, with easy ordering and a generous pickup window.

Extremely high standards guide the selection of birthday cakes here. Multiple visits confirm the bakery as a go-to spot for special occasion cakes like birthdays and graduations.

People are saying

"I thought the Spring Fling cake was the best I ever had."

"I traveled for the Spring Fling cake from this bakery."

"This birthday cake is light, fluffy, and perfectly sweet."

Good to know

1

The banana cream cake costs $8.75 per slice.

2

They sell cakes by the slice, allowing you to try before committing.

3

The bakery has a policy of not allowing upfront payment, which may be inconvenient.

Discover more

Colorado

Area guide
Loading Map...