Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Colorado

Thrift store jewelry

Hunting for unique, pre-owned treasures and fine jewelry in the same trip.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
LOVE SARO - Custom Permanent Jewelry & Beyond image 1
LOVE SARO - Custom Permanent Jewelry & Beyond image 2
LOVE SARO - Custom Permanent Jewelry & Beyond image 3
View all

Space blends clean, inviting design with a vintage collection and artistic displays. Atmosphere feels warm, cozy, and magical, with a sense of sisterhood and family. Jewelry experience centers on custom, high-quality pieces made with intention and care.

Permanent jewelry here carries a soulful meaning that supports reflection and connection. Staff take time to ensure perfect fit and construction, making the experience feel special and personal.

Space fills with art, love, and vintage pieces. The handpicked vintage collection offers unique finds, including precious stones and jewelry that draw compliments.

People are saying

"The staff here helped craft one-of-a-kind jewelry with expertise."

"Creating a beautiful, meaningful bracelet was such a fun activity."

"This thrift store's vintage collection is handpicked and amazing."

Good to know

1

LOVE SARO hosts aura photography pop-up events regularly.

2

Expect a fun atmosphere during Galentines events hosted by LOVE SARO.

3

Creating custom jewelry pieces is a unique experience at LOVE SARO.

02
The Shop Outpost image 1
Western apparel store

Shop resembles a carefully curated Wild West time capsule with warm lighting and rich wood displays. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, filled with authentic vintage western clothing, jewelry, and unique handmade pieces. Presence of an adorable puppy helper adds to the welcoming vibe.

Lots of vintage jewelry and handmade pieces fill the shelves. Displays feature Western-inspired accessories alongside other unique finds.

Specializes in vintage western wear with a strong focus on boots, hats, and jewelry. Offers a curated selection of high-end and unique vintage housewares and clothing.

People are saying

"I found amazing vintage western wear and unique handcrafted items."

"I found the most amazing vintage cowboy boots here."

"I found amazing vintage western wear at this thrift store."

Good to know

1

The Shop Outpost features a curated selection of unique vintage western clothing and accessories.

2

Expect to find a great selection of cowgirl boots and hats at The Shop Outpost.

3

They have a zero waste approach to their products and packaging.

03
Fever Dream Vintage & Modern image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers a well-curated, spacious setting with a unique selection of authentic pieces. The atmosphere feels eclectic and trendy, creating a cool and sweet vibe without overcrowding. Dressing rooms add convenience to the shopping experience.

Offers a cool selection of costume jewelry and accessories for every taste. Includes vintage-inspired earrings and headpieces that pair well with vintage dresses.

Offers a super eclectic and unique assortment of vintage clothing and jewelry. Prices stay very fair while maintaining a perfectly curated collection from any era.

People are saying

"I found the women's clothing selection to be really, really cool."

"I found the vintage selection to be amazing and well curated."

"I found the vintage selection here to be amazing and well curated."

Good to know

1

Most items cost $35 or more, especially jackets and shoes.

2

The shop has a wide selection of vintage clothing and accessories.

3

They offer a great deal when selling clothes for store credit.

04
Circa Vintage by Eclectic CO image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers a curated collection of retro and handmade pieces with wide variety from the 1950s to 2000s. Spacious, colorful interior creates a charming, eclectic vibe where shoppers explore unique, well-cared-for finds across multiple local vendors.

Handmade and vintage styles stand out with resin jewelry and handcrafted delights. The selection includes earrings, pottery, and eclectic pieces that catch the eye.

A finely curated collection of true vintage pieces from the 50s to early 2000s fills the racks. Unique vintage clothing and accessories include jackets, dresses, furs, leathers, earrings, and eye-catching jewelry from local makers.

People are saying

"The staff at this thrift store are really friendly and fun to chat with."

"I found the clothing here to be clean, unique, and truly eclectic."

"I found unique vintage jewelry and handcrafted delights here."

Good to know

1

Circa Vintage offers a curated collection of on-trend, second-life clothing.

2

Prices vary by vendor, generally reasonable for curated, quality vintage from the 1950s-2000s.

3

The store features a variety of local vendors with vintage, handmade, and local products.

05
The Common Collective image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers unique and quirky items from the 80s and 90s with affordable prices and original jewelry. Atmosphere feels warm and creative with a homey vibe and cool music. Space includes a fireplace and provides sewing classes and a shirt slicer for customization.

Many unique jewelry pieces fill the store, with a strong focus on cute earrings. Sale bins offer affordable finds alongside original designs.

Offers a cute selection of vintage clothes and accessories with reasonably priced items. The store feels adorable and well managed, featuring both vintage and newer pieces.

People are saying

"This vintage shop has really cute, affordable, and unique clothes."

"I found the cutest jewelry here; it's seriously dope."

"I found this vintage thrift store to be the best I've ever visited."

Good to know

1

The store offers a unique selection of vintage items not found elsewhere.

2

Expect to find a variety of clothing sizes, including 4X options.

3

The prices are generally considered reasonable for vintage items.

06
The Vintage Label image 1
Vintage clothing store

Boutique blends vintage and modern touches in a cozy, well-organized space that invites easy browsing. The atmosphere feels welcoming and homey, attracting those seeking unique, thoughtfully curated clothing and accessories.

Unique and stunning vintage jewelry stands out here. You can find a gorgeous piece among their collection alongside other designer items.

A small, carefully curated collection of vintage and new clothes, accessories, and jewelry fills the boutique. Unique, stunning vintage items and tasteful pieces create a welcoming, local shopping vibe.

People are saying

"This thrift store's owner is so helpful and welcoming."

"The owner's amazing at helping you find the perfect vintage piece."

"Carolyn at this Jewelry Store made my experience extra special."

Good to know

1

The Vintage Label offers a personalized shopping experience with unique clothing and accessories.

2

Expect a fun atmosphere during events like Sip 'n Shop, which happens in March.

3

Discounts are available for guests of nearby hotels.

07
Atomic Salvage image 1
Vintage clothing store

Cozy vintage clothing store with a curated selection of clothes, shoes, houseware, jewelry, and art. Welcoming atmosphere with beautifully arranged items and an adorable dressing room. Offers unique handmade pieces alongside laundered, ready-to-wear vintage finds.

Handmade jewelry stands out with a gorgeous collection crafted by the owner. The store features cute homemade pieces that show clear craftsmanship.

A curated vintage store offers a beautiful selection of fine vintage goods including clothing and housewares. Prices stay reasonable, making it a great spot for those craving a vintage aesthetic.

People are saying

"Jules's vintage curation is incredibly impressive and detailed."

"I loved their collection of cute, handmade jewelry."

"This thrift store's curated vintage finds are so cool and impressive."

Good to know

1

The shop accepts cash only; credit cards are not accepted.

2

Unique handmade jewelry and customized pieces are available.

3

Sales and promotions happen regularly, so check back often.

08
Olde Town Exchange Consignment Store image 1

Bright, well organized consignment shop with boutique vibes and an upscale atmosphere. Relaxing space feels like shopping with friends, featuring unique, high-quality pieces and a stellar selection of clothing and accessories. Dressing rooms and kid-friendly amenities add to a comfortable, inviting experience.

Offers a wide selection of high-end jewelry alongside shoes and handbags. Jewelry pieces are immaculate and of great quality.

Offers designer and vintage pieces at huge discounts compared to retail prices. Focuses on sustainable shopping with a good selection of clothes and purses.

People are saying

"I found beautiful, high-quality women's clothing at amazing prices."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so sweet and helpful."

"I found designer and vintage pieces for a great price at this Thrift Store."

Good to know

1

The store offers a variety of items suitable for every occasion.

2

They have a wide selection of shoes, jewelry, handbags, and clothing.

3

Expect high-end luxury pieces like Louis Vuitton and Chanel.

09
American Classics Marketplace image 1

Massive antique mall with a maze-like layout and many distinct zones filled with vintage collectibles and antique furniture. Atmosphere feels like stepping back in time, calm and inviting with a sense of history and charm. Narrow walkways lined with fragile items create an immersive, nostalgic experience.

Quality authentic New Mexico style jewelry stands out here. Pieces come at affordable prices alongside a variety of collectibles and antiques.

Massive space filled with a huge assortment of vintage and antique items. Great selection of vintage glass colors and designs and plenty of novelty goods to explore.

People are saying

"This vintage shop is huge; I needed two days to see it all."

"This thrift store is huge, you'll need hours to see everything."

"You could spend hours looking through all the jewelry and collectibles here."

Good to know

1

The marketplace features a vast selection of antiques and vintage goods.

2

The entrance is located on Academy Avenue, accessible via a driveway.

3

Many items are reasonably priced, with some great deals available.

10
Good Eye image 1
Clothing store

Shop offers a curated vintage collection with unique clothing and accessories spanning multiple eras. Atmosphere feels fun and creative, filled with quirky, cute items that appeal to diverse tastes.

Vintage and eclectic jewelry stands out here, with options like custom bracelets and necklaces. The store offers unique pieces such as climber earrings and a variety of amazing jewelry.

Offers a curated mix of true vintage pieces from all eras alongside new clothing and accessories. Features one-of-a-kind vintage dresses, jewelry, and eclectic finds for various occasions.

People are saying

"The staff here are so helpful and kind when finding vintage pieces."

"I found the cutest, quirkiest women's clothing and unique handmade sweaters."

"The staff at this thrift store are so helpful and kind."

Good to know

1

The store has a no return or exchange policy.

2

Good Eye offers a curated selection of vintage and new clothing.

3

Expect to find unique jewelry, candles, and handmade sweaters.

11
Brass Armadillo Antique Mall - Denver image 1

Large antique mall resembles a museum with extensive glass cases and named aisles for easy navigation. Atmosphere feels like a time machine with refreshing music and a welcoming vibe. Onsite cafe and snack bar offer classic treats, providing a break amid browsing.

Case after case shows jewelry in every style. Large selection includes beautiful rings, antiques, and vintage collectibles.

Collectors find a vintage retro antique heaven here with a wide range of items like mid-century modern furniture, vintage clothing, and Pyrex. The store offers unique treasures including postcards, band posters, kids toys, and knick knacks.

People are saying

"I found rows and rows of fine antiques at this vintage shop."

"This thrift store is a wonderland of unique treasures and vintage finds."

"I found so many beautiful rings and other jewelry here."

Good to know

1

Brass Armadillo Antique Mall offers a vast selection of antiques and collectibles.

2

Some vendors provide good discounts on their items.

3

Bring cash for vendors who may not accept cards.

Discover more

Colorado

Area guide
Loading Map...