Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Florida's best

Key lime pie spots

A specific desire for a slice of key lime pie leads to those quiet, tucked-away corners that feel like a personal discovery.

Based on 555 Opinions
+552
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Luc’s Seafood & Grill image 1
Luc’s Seafood & Grill image 2
Luc’s Seafood & Grill image 3
View all
Seafood restaurant

Small bistro-style seafood restaurant offers a cozy, intimate atmosphere with a laid-back, friendly vibe. Outdoor seating with parasols provides a quiet, breezy option for small groups. The space combines high-end look with homey comfort and attention to detail.

Dessert features a perfectly tart Key Lime Pie made in-house. It stands out alongside other delicious sweets like chocolate mousse and bread pudding.

Small and no-frills, this spot stands out as a hidden gem in the neighborhood. It offers a local favorite vibe that feels authentic and under the radar.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh, I had one of the best pastas ever."

"I found this place to be a hidden gem for seafood."

"The Key Lime Pie had just the right zing and was perfectly tart."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $9 appetizers and discounted drinks on weekdays.

2

New specials are available every week during happy hour.

3

Happy hour appetizers are a good size for sharing.

02
Le Cafe In image 1

Cozy cafe with rustic charm and a serene atmosphere that balances quiet relaxation with a gentle buzz. Comfortable seating and pet-friendly policies create a welcoming space for work or casual visits. Indoor and outdoor areas offer beautiful views and a tidy, inviting environment.

Slices of Key lime pie come with a bright, tangy flavor that pairs well with drinks like matcha. It appears alongside breakfast items like croissants with bacon, egg, and cheese.

A cute little spot tucked away in downtown Hollywood offers a hidden gem vibe that feels cozy and unexpected.

People are saying

"The coffee here is amazing, and the staff makes you feel right at home."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie here was delicious."

"I found it to be a cute little hidden gem."

Good to know

1

Le Cafe In is dog-friendly, allowing pets in the outdoor seating area.

2

The cafe offers free wifi, making it a good spot for working.

3

Parking can be packed, so arrive early to secure a spot.

03
Dando La Brasa image 1
Latin American restaurant

Open-layout restaurant with modern artsy decor and an open kitchen creates a cozy, inviting space. Background music and a DJ add to a pleasant, family-friendly atmosphere. The vibe balances comfort with a lively, well-designed setting.

An excellent twist on key lime pie stands out as a dessert choice. It pairs well with dishes like grilled octopus and wood fire chicken, offering a delicious finish to the meal.

Rich, authentic flavors define this spot as a hidden gem for traditional Latin food. It stands out quietly in the area with its genuine taste and local appeal.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"You'll love this hidden gem for its authentic Latin flavor cooked over wood charcoal."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was excellent."

Good to know

1

They offer half-price drinks during happy hour.

2

The restaurant has a lunch menu from 12:00 PM to 4:00 PM.

3

Happy hour menu is available from 5:00 PM to 7:00 PM.

04
The Blue Crab Crabhouse image 1
Seafood restaurant

Nautical-themed seafood restaurant nestled under live oaks with string lights and Spanish moss creating a cozy, charming atmosphere. The vibe stays chill and comfortable, attracting a social crowd around over 20 tables. Known for fresh, local seafood and a relaxed, homey feel away from commercial joints.

Creamy texture and puckering tartness define the key lime pie here. It stands out as homemade and highly praised for its flavor, even winning over those not usually fond of key lime pie.

Locals frequent this spot, making it a true hidden gem. It feels tucked away yet offers a little known charm that stands out in the area.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly, especially when serving the Crab Cakes."

"I'd order the Key Lime Pie again; it's the best I've ever had."

"You have to try these hidden gem seafood dishes; the oysters were amazing."

Good to know

1

Bloody Mary and mimosa specials are available on Sundays until 5 pm.

2

Margarita specials are offered on Tuesdays.

3

Oyster specials are available on Wednesdays for $1 each.

05
Cafe Bernie image 1
Restaurant

Waterfront restaurant offers beautiful intercoastal views and relaxing outdoor seating with fairy lights enhancing the ambiance. Live music and eco-friendly straws add to the cozy, inviting atmosphere. The place draws a crowd seeking a quiet dinner or brunch by the water.

Homemade key lime pie stands out as a perfect, yummy dessert. It often serves as a satisfying end to meals and is considered better than Joe’s stone crab by some.

Offers beautiful sunset views that stand out. Recognized as a true hidden gem with a unique charm.

People are saying

"I loved the beautiful waterfront views."

"The key lime pie is the best I've ever had."

"It's a hidden gem with beautiful waterfront views and a relaxing ambiance."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to secure a table, especially during busy hours.

2

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers and drinks from 4-7pm on weekdays.

3

Taco Tuesday features special pricing on tacos every Tuesday.

06
Trophy Fish image 1
Seafood restaurant

Covered open-air seating with Caribbean style and beautiful masonry creates a laid-back yet upscale vibe. Live music and a curated playlist add to the cool atmosphere while big fans keep air moving. The spot draws a crowd that enjoys fresh seafood and tiki cocktails in a casual, cafe-style setting.

Excellent flavor stands out in the key lime pie here. It often ranks higher than homemade versions and is available for takeout.

Offers a quiet spot that many overlook. Known for its unique charm and unexpected appeal.

People are saying

"The seafood dishes here are super good and delicious."

"You have to order everything at the bar during Happy Hour."

"I found Trophy Fish to be one of Tampa's greatest hidden gems."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm with $1 oysters and discounted drinks.

2

Free beer is offered at the bar starting at 4:30pm.

3

Parking is available nearby for easy access.

07
Southwest Ranches Farmer's Market image 1

Outdoor market blends covered and open-air spaces with industrial fans creating a unique breeze. Atmosphere feels cozy and community-oriented with friendly vendors and a laid-back vibe. Offers a wide variety of natural and raw foods including standout dairy and pasture-raised eggs.

Organic key lime pie offers a very good flavor and texture. Slices are available for purchase, with whole pies priced around $20.

Offers a quiet, local vibe away from typical crowds. Features fresh produce and unique finds that stand out from usual markets.

People are saying

"You can find the best local organic food, like honey and grass-fed meat."

"I found the quality of products at this farmer's market to be the best."

"You have to try these farm-fresh Hidden Gems; the eggs are the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The market offers raw milk, organic eggs, and grass-fed beef.

2

Prices may change at the register without prior notice.

3

Bring cash as some vendors may not accept credit cards.

08
Boater's Grill image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers stunning harbor views and a relaxing outdoor patio with a nice breeze. Live music plays near a bar area, creating a lively yet laid-back atmosphere. The space welcomes dogs and is wheelchair accessible, adding to its inclusive vibe.

Tiny size stands out, about the width of a thumb. Offers a sweet finish that is above average but not exceptional.

Nestled along the waterfront inside a state park, this spot offers spectacular views of sailboats and the harbor. It serves a variety of fresh fish dishes and keeps a relaxed, unchanged atmosphere.

People are saying

"The seafood here has amazing views and a great location."

"You'll find hidden gems with mesmerizing waterfront views."

"The Key Lime Pie here has a beautiful view."

Good to know

1

Boater's Grill opens at 11 am.

2

You have to pay just to enter because it is part of the park.

3

Expect a long wait to dock and eat during peak hours.

Discover more

Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...