Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Ice cream and key lime pie in Florida

A slice of key lime pie topped with a scoop of ice cream is the ultimate treat.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
My Happy Place Deli image 1
My Happy Place Deli image 2
My Happy Place Deli image 3

Outdoor seating fills the space with a beachy vibe and fun decor that creates a lively, friendly atmosphere. Tables sit in the shade surrounded by plants, offering privacy and comfort enhanced by cool fans and misting systems. Dogs are welcome, adding to the casual, relaxed energy of the place.

Offers homemade ice cream sandwiches with notable flavors like Happy Happy and Miami Vice featuring an ice cream-based pina colada.

Bright and tangy with a smooth texture, the key lime pie stands out for its balanced sweetness and fresh lime flavor. It consistently delivers a great taste that many find very satisfying.

People are saying

"The outdoor seating has a cute, laid-back vibe."

"The grouper sandwich at this Lunch Spot is so fresh and delicious."

"I loved their homemade ice cream sandwich."

Good to know

1

The deli has outdoor seating only, perfect for enjoying the weather.

2

Dogs are welcome at the deli, making it pet-friendly.

3

Prices are reasonable, with a grouper sandwich costing $15.

02
Sweet Lich's image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop with Instagram chic decor and family-friendly design including a chalk wall and toy box for kids. Atmosphere feels warm and playful with seating by large windows and a cushioned sofa. Known for best cookies in town, creating a welcoming spot for families and cookie lovers alike.

Ice cream sandwiches stand out with rich flavors and creamy texture. Samples and detailed descriptions help pick treats like the triple threat with dulce de leche.

Bright, tangy key lime flavor stands out in the pie. The texture is smooth and creamy, making it a delicious dessert option.

People are saying

"These cookies are amazing, soft, and chewy."

"I thought the ice cream here was amazing and full of flavor."

"I found the Key Lime Pie flavor to be so amazing."

Good to know

1

Catering services are available for events like birthdays and corporate functions.

2

The shop maintains a clean environment for customers.

3

Sweet Lich's offers gluten-free cookie options.

03
Yellow Banks Groves image 1
Ice cream shop

Vintage Florida shop with orange soft serve ice cream and retro decor creates a nostalgic vibe. Small space offers citrus-themed gifts and locally made snacks. Quiet during the day, it draws those seeking unique, old-school treats.

Soft serve features a unique orange vanilla twist made with real orange juice and vanilla. The ice cream is light and refreshing, with flavors reminiscent of a dreamsicle but more intense. Cones and swirls add variety to the selection.

Light and fluffy with an extra crispy crust, the key lime pie offers a perfect balance of sweetness and tartness. Creamy texture and consistently praised as one of the best ever tasted.

People are saying

"This orange swirl ice cream is so delicious and refreshing."

"I thought the fresh orange juice I had here was the best I've ever tasted."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

They open at 10:00 AM.

2

Yellow Banks Groves is the only place left in the Tampa area that still serves orange soft served ice cream.

3

There were no public restrooms available at the location.

04
Bruster's Real Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop offers freshly made waffle cones and a cozy, charming atmosphere with shaded outdoor seating. The air fills with the sweet aroma of ice cream and cones, creating a friendly and inviting vibe. Variety of flavors and additional treats like sundaes and milkshakes attract a diverse crowd.

Offers a wide range of classic and exotic flavors like Graham Central Station. Ice cream is consistently delicious and creamy with friendly service enhancing the experience.

Offers a Key Lime Pie flavor alongside other fruit-inspired options like strawberry and banana pudding. The pie flavor stands out as a favorite among the fruit lovers' selection.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream was delicious and top-notch."

"The staff at this ice cream shop are so kind and attentive."

"I loved the Key Lime Pie and mango sorbet."

Good to know

1

On the day I visited, they were not accepting credit cards.

2

They offer free ice cream for kids under 40 inches.

3

Bruster's prices are higher compared to other locations.

05
Charlie's Bakery & Creamery image 1

Bright, modern bakery with old-fashioned charm and a newly renovated interior offers a family-friendly atmosphere and ample seating. Sweet bakery aromas and color-changing spoons create a lively, nostalgic vibe. The space balances clean, welcoming design with playful, memorable details.

Mint chocolate chip and Cookie Monster ice creams stand out for their rich flavors. Vegan options rate highly, and the pistachio ice cream pairs well with cannolis.

Authentic Florida style shines in the key lime pie, which stands out as a go-to dessert. Variations include a key lime pie on a stick, and the pies consistently deliver delicious baked goods quality.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was award-winning and super premium."

"I've been going to this bakery for over 30 years."

"I considered their Key Lime Pie the best."

Good to know

1

Charlieโ€™s Bakery & Creamery offers dairy-free ice cream options.

2

There is ample parking available at Charlieโ€™s Bakery & Creamery.

3

Customers can sign up for a rewards program to receive discounts.

06
Daniel's Miami image 1
Steak house

Upscale steakhouse with tasteful decor and spacious seating creates a cozy, elegant atmosphere that balances liveliness with easy conversation. Bar area offers a compact, beautiful space for casual drinks or full meals. Attention to detail shows in impeccable service and carefully crafted experiences throughout.

Soft serve ice cream appears in a nostalgic sundae and as a topping on various dishes. The vanilla bean ice cream pairs well with the COOKIE SKILLET, creating a rich dessert experience.

Very tangy but balanced flavor defines the key lime pie. It often steals the show during meals.

People are saying

"The food here is exquisite, with incredible flavor and quality."

"The ice cream here is great, thanks to the knowledgeable service."

"The key lime pie totally stole the show."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

Happy hour runs from 5-7pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

They participate in Miami Spice, offering a special menu at a great value.

07
Bright Ice Scoop Shop Water St image 1

Cozy ice cream shop with unique flavors and generous portions creates a welcoming vibe. Bright, clean space includes outdoor seating and offers reusable tasting spoons for samples. Atmosphere feels fresh and inviting, appealing to families and casual visitors alike.

High quality ice cream stands out with generous portions and flavors like strawberry brown sugar balsamic and warm vanilla. Chocolate varieties, including chocolate marshmallow cookies, offer rich, delicious options.

Key Lime Pie ice cream stands out with a bright, tangy flavor. It competes closely with other unique options like lemon caramelized ginger and oat of this world.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors here are so creative and delicious."

"I tried the Deepest Darkest Chocolate Secret, and it was amazing."

"I found the Key Lime Pie ice cream to be exceptional."

Good to know

1

The shop offers many unique flavor options not found in typical ice cream shops.

2

Generous portions of ice cream are served at reasonable prices.

3

Dairy-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

08
Gemma Fish + Oyster image 1
American restaurant

Rooftop dining offers charming, comfy atmosphere with warm sophistication and coastal charm. Music and heating lamps create a great vibe that suits both casual and special occasions. Valet parking and elevator access add convenience to the experience.

Salted Caramel Ice Cream stands out with rich flavor, paired well with desserts like apple crisp bread pudding and flourless chocolate cake. The ice cream complements other treats and shines alongside chocolate fondue and fried apple bread pudding.

Key lime pie features lime chantilly that adds a bright, creamy touch. It stands out as a delightful dessert often enjoyed immediately, showing its appeal.

People are saying

"The oysters here are large and full of succulent regional flavors."

"I found the Key Lime Pie to be delicious."

"The caramel ice cream was amazing with the bread pudding."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for rooftop seating, especially during peak hours.

2

Valet parking is available right outside the restaurant for convenience.

3

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

09
Fireman Derekโ€™s Bake Shop image 1

Bakery offers top-rated pies and cakes with distinctive flavors like Nutella and guava cookies. Atmosphere is busy and lively in a popular shopping area. Prices are notably high for small portions, reflecting a premium dessert experience.

Dulce banana and carrot cake vanilla ice creams stand out with rich flavors. The shop offers a wide variety of ice creams alongside pies and cakes.

Slices of Key Lime Pie come with a rich, tangy flavor that stands out. The pie is priced at around $10 per slice and offers a delicious balance of sweetness and citrus.

People are saying

"The red velvet cake here is the best I've ever tasted."

"I thought the pie here was the best I've ever had."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was even better than down in the Keys."

Good to know

1

The shop is open late, serving sweet treats until 11pm.

2

A slice of key lime pie costs $10, which may seem high.

3

The bakery offers a variety of cakes, pies, and ice cream.

10
Southwest Ranches Farmer's Market image 1

Outdoor market blends covered and open-air spaces with industrial fans creating a unique breeze. Atmosphere feels cozy and community-oriented with friendly vendors and a laid-back vibe. Offers a wide variety of natural and raw foods including standout dairy and pasture-raised eggs.

Homemade ice cream offers a choice of cow, buffalo, or goat milk. Strawberry flavor stands out as amazing. Calamari ice cream popsicles come in various flavors.

Organic key lime pie offers a very good flavor and texture. Slices are available for purchase, with whole pies priced around $20.

People are saying

"You can find the best local organic food, like honey and grass-fed meat."

"I found the quality of products at this farmer's market to be the best."

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The market offers raw milk, organic eggs, and grass-fed beef.

2

Prices may change at the register without prior notice.

3

Bring cash as some vendors may not accept credit cards.

11
Julia & Henry's Food Hall image 1

Rooftop food court features glass floors and rooftop terrace views with lively social energy. Crowds create a hectic, loud atmosphere while music and occasional entertainment add to the vibe. Multiple seating areas and bars offer diverse experiences across levels.

Soft waffles come with ice cream in several ways, including wrapped or served on a plate. The Puffles waffle ice cream stands out as a delicious dessert option. The ice cream itself is notably rich and satisfying.

A vending machine offers key lime pie that is delicious and super good but comes in a small size and is overpriced.

People are saying

"I found tons of food options and many choices to buy."

"I grabbed a key lime pie from the vending machine; it was super good."

"I thought the ice cream was quite tasty and smooth."

Good to know

1

Expect a 30-minute wait to get in during peak hours.

2

Happy hour runs until 7pm with various drink specials.

3

Bingo night is on Mondays, offering a fun experience.

12
Red Rooster Overtown image 1
American restaurant

Vibrant interior with lush greenery and colorful murals creates an upscale yet welcoming atmosphere. Live music featuring saxophone and DJ sets adds a lively southern vibe. Outdoor spaces include a covered patio under a large tree and a rooftop with Caribbean influences.

Oreo-rolled ice cream sandwich stands out as a large, sharable dessert. The key lime pie and cornbread ice cream also add variety to the dessert options.

Custard and crust stand out for their lightness and freshness. Coconut meringue tops the pie, adding a unique twist to the classic key lime flavor.

People are saying

"The oxtail here is so tender and explodes with flavor."

"Olivia was a fantastic ice cream server."

"I loved their Key Lime Pie with coconut meringue."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs until 7 p.m. daily with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant can get very packed.

3

Parking is available but can be challenging; arrive early to secure a spot.

Discover more

Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...