Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Florida

Ice cream and sandwich shops

Finding a sandwich shop that actually serves ice cream worth eating, rather than just a freezer case of pre-packaged tubs.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
The Baked Bear image 1
The Baked Bear image 2
The Baked Bear image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Shop offers fresh-baked cookies aroma and customizable ice cream sandwiches in a clean, modern space. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting with a fun, vibrant energy. Kids and families often enjoy the variety and friendly environment.

This spot offers an interesting twist with cookies and ice cream combined. It stands out as a favorite for those who enjoy custom ice cream sandwiches.

Ice cream sandwiches feature daily homemade bakery cookies and brownies paired with select ice cream flavors. Customers can create their own combinations, and staff know how to craft the perfect ice cream sandwich.

People are saying

"Melinda made the best ice cream cookie sandwich I've ever had."

"I loved customizing my own ice cream sandwich with warm cookies and cold ice cream."

"The ice cream here is delicious."

Good to know

1

Customers can customize their desserts with various cookies and ice cream flavors.

2

The establishment offers a unique selection of cookies and ice cream sandwiches.

3

Seating is limited inside, so plan accordingly during busy hours.

02
Mox Ice Cream & Coffee image 1

Ice cream shop offers unique vanilla soft serve and artisanal frozen treats with a Euro-style twist. Bright space features trippy artwork and maintains a clean, chill atmosphere. Locally owned spot balances sweet and salty flavors with environmentally conscious packaging.

Luv Buns ice cream sandwiches offer a tastier twist on the classic treat. They come alongside sundaes and milkshakes, making for a sweet combo.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be amazing and super tasty."

"The Love Bun ice cream sandwich is a delightful twist."

"The ice cream shop welcomed us even after closing."

Good to know

1

The menu offers a variety of coffees, teas, sundaes, shakes, and build-your-own bowls.

2

Prices for ice cream are on the higher side but considered worth it by many.

3

The shop maintains a high standard of cleanliness throughout the space.

03
Mimi's Creamery and Coffee image 1

Ice cream shop with a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere featuring board games and charging outlets for entertainment. The space is clean and nicely decorated with a comfortable seating area that invites lingering. It draws a mix of families and individuals looking for a relaxed spot to enjoy quality treats.

Offers a family friendly atmosphere with a nice selection of ice cream. Serves as a local spot for sweet treats and coffee.

Avocado sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and fresh ingredients. Egg and cheese sandwiches come out delicious and well-prepared.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I had ever tasted."

"I thought the avocado sandwich was the best I ever had."

"I found it to be the best ice cream shop I have been to."

Good to know

1

Free parking is available at Mimi's Creamery and Coffee.

2

Expect no wait times during weekday visits.

3

Prices for ice cream start at less than $5 for a large cup.

04
Cry Baby Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Small shop with a dark gothic and mid-century vibe offers original flavors and amazing chocolate chip cookies. Atmosphere feels cute and modern, with a hidden gem quality. Ice cream is fresh and delicious, made in-house with local ingredients.

Offers a super cool vibe that stands out among ice cream shops. Surprises with its unique approach and quality that makes it a favorite spot.

Pre-made ice cream sandwiches come in unique varieties like sticky fingers and box car. The ice cream sandwiches feature rich vanilla ice cream and have a distinctively amazing taste.

People are saying

"This ice cream is just unbelievably good."

"I thought the ice cream sandwiches were amazing."

"The ice cream at this shop is unique and delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking at Cry Baby Creamery can be challenging, so plan accordingly.

2

A single scoop costs $5, which is reasonable for the area.

3

They frequently change their ice cream flavors, offering unique options.

05
Mochi Cafe - Ice cream, Waffle, Coffee, Brunch image 1

Open, clean space with a family-friendly vibe and warm, inviting atmosphere. Games and dog-friendly touches add to the relaxed, neighborhood feel. Menu features creative waffles and house-made ice creams with generous portions at reasonable prices.

A cute little spot with a name tied to the owner's dog creates a community gem vibe. This ice cream shop offers a welcoming, unique experience beyond just the treats.

Croissant sandwiches stand out with their buttery, flaky texture and a light, pastry-like lift that balances savory fillings like burger patties and bacon. Sandwiches come with fresh greens and delicious dressing on the side.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream tasted amazing."

"This croissant sandwich is buttery, flaky, and perfectly warm."

"This ice cream shop has tail-wagging charm and a community gem vibe."

Good to know

1

Mochi Cafe offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors and desserts.

2

The food truck serves smash burgers and croissant sandwiches.

3

Mochi Cafe is kid and dog-friendly, making it a great family spot.

06
Sweet Life Bistro image 1
Ice cream shop

Small ice cream shop with cozy indoor and outdoor seating offers a charming theme and a gift shop. Atmosphere feels inviting and quaint with a great vibe throughout. Known for unique, premium ice cream flavors and warm mini donuts, it draws a steady crowd seeking coffee, smoothies, and desserts.

Charming spot with classic ice cream flavors and a simple menu. Offers coffee options alongside the ice cream.

Sandwiches come freshly made and great size with a lovely taste. They join a menu that includes smoothies and baked goods.

People are saying

"The coffee here is high quality and delicious."

"The owner's positive energy makes this Ice Cream Shop feel so welcoming."

"The sandwiches here are freshly made and a great size."

Good to know

1

Sweet Life Bistro is the only place on Treasure Island open in the evenings for coffee.

2

Expect a variety of dairy-free smoothie options available.

3

They offer sweets, a small assortment of baked goods, and are adding bagels and sandwiches soon.

07
Dairy Rich image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Outdoor seating with covered picnic tables and ceiling fans creates a cool, relaxed vibe. Bright murals and yard games add a family-friendly and lively atmosphere. Noise from nearby traffic contrasts with the welcoming, casual setting.

Quaint outdoor seating creates a personable vibe unlike mall ice cream shops. The shop offers fun ice cream sandwiches alongside other tasty treats at reasonable prices.

Burgers and sandwiches come with creative toppings and balanced sauces. The Nashville hot chicken sandwich offers a perfect cook and ideal oil level. Breakfast sandwiches arrive with delicious tots on the side.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were really, really good."

"I thought the buffalo chicken sandwich was the most underrated."

"The ice cream here is so rich, creamy, and flavorful."

Good to know

1

All seating is outside.

2

Parking is limited and at a premium.

3

Dairy Rich closes at 9pm and the kitchen closes by 8:30pm.

08
Larry's Ice Cream & Cafe image 1

Tropical neon colors create a fun, old-fashioned atmosphere with bright, child-friendly decor. Tables feature board games and arcades, inviting playful interaction while enjoying treats. Seating is limited but includes both indoor and outdoor options.

Fun and old-fashioned atmosphere sets the tone. Regular sugar cones come without extra charge, which is uncommon.

Grilled cheeses and other hot sandwiches feature on the menu alongside waffle fries and crepes. Sandwiches sometimes take a while to arrive and have been dropped during service.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream options to be delicious."

"I loved their sandwiches and the wide variety of ice cream options."

"I was charged extra for a sugar cone at this ice cream shop."

Good to know

1

A small serving costs $6, while a large serving is $10.

2

Parking is limited, and the plaza can get busy.

3

The cafe serves lunch items and alcoholic drinks in addition to ice cream.

09
Jaxson's Ice Cream Parlor & Restaurant image 1

Old-fashioned ice cream parlor with nostalgic decor and vintage signage creates a playful atmosphere filled with lively music and balloon art. Families gather around tables sharing laughter, while a walk-up window offers quick service and an adjacent candy shop sells classic treats. The place buzzes with community energy and a sense of timeless fun.

Homemade ice cream stands out with a nostalgic, vintage vibe. The shop pairs delicious ice cream with classic parlor food, creating a timeless, joyful experience.

Chicken sandwich comes with Cajun remoulade sauce. Hot pastrami sandwich offers a rich, shareable flavor. Sandwiches pair well with homemade sodas.

People are saying

"The homemade ice cream here is unbelievably delicious."

"The ice cream here is the best I've ever had."

"I'm still dreaming about the homemade ice cream."

Good to know

1

When someone celebrates an event, a loud horn sounds, and staff bring a king's hat and a banana float.

2

The to-go window only accepts one order at a time.

3

An extra fee is required to share ice cream.

10
Sprinkles & Scoops Ice Cream Shop and Cafe image 1

Small, freshly renovated ice cream shop with an incredible cafe area and grab-and-go sandwiches. Atmosphere is relaxed, attracting those looking for a casual bite or sweet treat near the beach. Offers variety of ice cream flavors and homemade salads, blending a cozy vibe with quality options.

Offers a hole in the wall vibe with a mix of deli and ice cream options. Experiences vary widely, with some visits described as excellent and others as the worst ice cream shop encountered.

Breakfast sandwiches on everything bagels stand out for their flavor. A grab-and-go cold case offers fresh sandwiches and homemade salads. Bagel sandwiches are consistently amazing and tasty.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is delicious with many flavors to choose from."

"The breakfast sandwiches at this cafe are amazing."

"I had a really great experience at the ice cream shop."

Good to know

1

Sprinkles & Scoops serves breakfast and lunch sandwiches alongside ice cream.

2

They have a grab-and-go cold case loaded with fresh sandwiches and homemade salads.

3

Two scoops of ice cream cost over $9, which may be considered high.

11
Orlando Milkhouse image 1
American restaurant

Rustic, modern space with wood furniture and dark tones creates a chill, relaxing vibe. Live music and a dog-friendly patio add to the welcoming atmosphere. Diverse menu includes craft coffee, full bar, and unique ice cream flavors.

Sandwiches feature juicy, flavorful meat with options like tender pastrami and spicy Korean BBQ chicken. The chicken sandwiches come with bold spices and pair well with sides like fried pickles and butter biscuits.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is rich, creamy, and the scoops are generous."

"I found the chicken sandwich amazingly flavorful and spicy."

"It's a mini food hall with a coffee shop and an ice cream shop."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from Monday to Friday from 4 PM to 7 PM with great deals.

2

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday at 8 PM with a $5 entry fee.

3

Parking is limited, and it may take time to find a spot nearby.

12
Gelato Go Winter Garden Italian House image 1

Gelato shop offers authentic Italian gelato with a wide variety of flavors in a cozy, clean environment. The space includes kid-sized tables and a stylish espresso bar, creating a family-friendly and classy atmosphere.

Offers quality ice cream that filled a gap in Central Florida's dessert scene. Stands out as a go-to spot for good ice cream in the area.

Sandwiches come in savory styles including paninis and more. They pair well with coffee and gelato, making for a tasty combo.

People are saying

"I thought the gelato was the best authentic Italian ice cream I ever had."

"I found the sandwiches and gelato always delicious."

"The ice cream here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

The location is on Plant Street, kiddie corner to 7-Eleven in the Healthy West Orange building.

2

They allow samples without pressure.

3

There is a variety of flavors available.

Discover more

Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...