Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Jacksonville

Pie spots

A slice of pie that feels like a deliberate finish to an American meal rather than a generic, mass-produced afterthought.

Based on 555 Opinions
+552
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mixed Fillings Pie Shop image 1
Mixed Fillings Pie Shop image 2
Mixed Fillings Pie Shop image 3
View all

Pie shop offers a cozy, inviting atmosphere with jazzy background music and top-notch decor. It serves varied pie flavors by the slice, allowing sampling of unique and classic options. The vibe is welcoming and relaxing, perfect for enjoying coffee and pie in a clean, friendly setting.

Key lime pie stands out with a smooth filling and a salty pretzel crust. Chicken pot pie offers a rich, comforting flavor. Apple and blueberry pies also appear as notable options.

Pies here stand out for their exceptional flavors and delicious variety. The key lime pie and peanut butter pie are especially notable for their taste and quality.

People are saying

"I thought the pie here was beyond delicious."

"My toddler ate an entire slice; it's so kid friendly!"

"I'm still dreaming about the key lime pie; it's amazing American Food."

Good to know

1

Arrive early to get the best selection of pie slices before they sell out.

2

The shop operates on a walk-up format for quick service.

3

You can buy pie by the slice to sample different flavors.

02
Southern Shores Seafood Jacksonville image 1

Seafood restaurant offers large windows with views of water and creek, creating a bright, welcoming atmosphere. Decor includes family fishing photos and local charm, with seating that balances comfort and space. The mood stays quiet and friendly, suitable for families and relaxed dining.

Creamy seafood bisque with sausage and shrimp stands out, served with fried balls of cheddar grits. Sides include collard greens, fries, hush puppies, and baked potato, all well prepared.

Saving room for dessert pays off with the key lime pie. It tastes delicious and stands out as a sweet finish.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, generous, and really good."

"The hush puppies here are excellent and fried in fresh oil."

"You have to save room for the key lime pie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Lunch ends at 4 PM.

2

Reservations are recommended for dinner to avoid long wait times.

3

The restaurant offers a special menu on the 1st and 15th of each month.

03
Culhane's Irish Pub & Restaurant image 1

Pub offers authentic Irish vibes with big screens showing sports and live music events. Atmosphere shifts from lively bingo nights to relaxed dining with ample seating and a spacious layout. Crowd enjoys classic drinks like Guinness and hearty food such as fish and chips and Reuben sandwiches.

Philly cheesesteak with beer cheese stands out as a signature dish. The menu also features shrimp and grits, Mac and cheese, and fish and chips that consistently impress.

Shepherd's Pie features a slightly sweet Guinness gravy and a savory, homemade taste. Dingle Fish Pie and Dingle Pie also stand out as highlights with rich, satisfying flavors.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be great and incredible."

"The American food, especially the Reuben, is one of the best I've ever had."

"The shepherd's pie was phenomenal and quite tasty."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Wednesday at 7pm with a $5 entry fee.

2

Karaoke takes place every Friday and Saturday night starting at 10pm.

3

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

04
The Blue Crab Crabhouse image 1
Seafood restaurant

Nautical-themed seafood restaurant nestled under live oaks with string lights and Spanish moss creating a cozy, charming atmosphere. The vibe stays chill and comfortable, attracting a social crowd around over 20 tables. Known for fresh, local seafood and a relaxed, homey feel away from commercial joints.

Crab cakes come fat and plump with a rich flavor. The Mardi Gras gumbo stands out as a highlight. The hush puppies are light and airy, offering a unique twist. Shrimp and cheese grits also get solid praise.

Key lime pie stands out for its creamy texture and puckering tartness. It has a reputation for being very flavorful and enjoyable even for those who don't usually like key lime pie.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly, especially when serving the Crab Cakes."

"The American Food here is great, and the staff is so friendly."

"I'd order the key lime pie again; it's the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Bloody Mary and mimosa specials are available on Sundays until 5 pm.

2

Margarita specials are offered on Tuesdays.

3

Oyster specials are available on Wednesdays for $1 each.

05
14 Prime image 1
Steak house

Upscale steakhouse with elegant design and ambient lighting creates a sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere. Guests receive personalized touches like floral arrangements and complimentary champagne upon arrival. The space features a notable bar and spacious seating, fostering a lively but warm environment.

Lobster mac and cheese features large chunks of lobster, lots of cheese, and a hint of Thai chili spice. Key lime pie offers a strong, memorable finish.

Key lime pie stands out with its incredible flavor and tangy sweetness. The escargot puff pastry pie offers a unique twist with rich, savory layers.

People are saying

"The steak here is served with flawless, attentive service."

"The American food here comes with complimentary prosecco and steak tostadas and muffins to go."

"The pie here is personalized and unforgettable."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for special events like 14 Prime.

2

Guests should place cocktail orders ahead of time for events.

3

The restaurant offers personalized experiences for special occasions.

06
Gemma Fish + Oyster image 1
American restaurant

Rooftop dining offers charming, comfy atmosphere with warm sophistication and coastal charm. Music and heating lamps create a great vibe that suits both casual and special occasions. Valet parking and elevator access add convenience to the experience.

Key lime pie shines with lime chantilly and stands out as a delightful dessert. Bread pudding and apple crisp also impress, often enjoyed quickly due to their incredible flavor.

People are saying

"The oysters here are large and full of succulent regional flavors."

"The American Food here, especially the oysters, is great."

"The key lime pie was the best part of the meal."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for rooftop seating, especially during peak hours.

2

Valet parking is available right outside the restaurant for convenience.

3

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

07
Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen image 1
Traditional American restaurant

Interior features retro hub caps on the ceiling and self-serve kiosks at tables for ordering and payment. Atmosphere stays comfortable and inviting, with a large bar area where sports play on screens. Seating ranges from spacious booths to smaller tables, accommodating groups and casual diners alike.

Chicken pot pie stands out with its rich, comforting flavor. The menu also features moist country fried chicken and a Buffalo Fried Chicken Sandwich that offer hearty, classic American tastes.

Chicken pot pie features flaky puff pastry on top and large pieces of chicken inside. Portions come generous and filling, with a crust that stands out as a highlight.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious and well cooked."

"I found the chicken pot pie, a classic American Food, to be delicious and satisfying."

"The chicken pot pie was flavorful and satisfying."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted for parties over 15 people, especially close to closing time.

2

Expect longer wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of food options, including vegetarian and vegan modifications.

08
Soul Food Bistro image 1

Dining room features dark, outdated interior with cafeteria-style line and inside seating. Atmosphere feels like home kitchen gatherings, laid back and welcoming with jazz music enhancing the vibe. Busy times bring a lively, family-friendly energy that balances casual chaos with professionalism.

Fried chicken comes out perfectly cooked and stands out as a highlight. The mac and cheese is creamy and highly praised. Other dishes like oxtail, smothered chops, collard greens, peas, and cabbage round out a solid American food selection.

Sweet potato pie stands out with its delicious and scrumptious flavor. Cakes and pies overall offer a tasty dessert option.

People are saying

"This food is the best I've ever had, so delicious."

"I'll be back for more of that soul-satisfying fried chicken."

"The sweet potato pie here is delicious."

Good to know

1

On Sundays, they play awesome worship and praise songs.

2

The line at Soul Food Bistro can be long, so plan accordingly.

3

Servings are large, often enough for multiple meals from one plate.

09
Sweet Mama's Southern Homestyle Cookin image 1

Small restaurant with an open kitchen and old school southern vibe feels like a cozy diner. Atmosphere is warm and family-oriented with 90s R&B slow jams playing. Space is homey and welcoming, resembling a grandma's kitchen.

Mac and cheese tastes homemade, super cheesy, and well seasoned. Shrimp comes out so tasty it needs no sauce, while cheese grits melt in your mouth and fish stays tender and flavorful.

Sweet potato pie stands out with a rich, perfect flavor that draws attention. Cornbread also pairs well, making the pie selection amazing and worth noting.

People are saying

"The soul food here is so good, it's like real comfort food."

"The American Food here, especially the oxtail and meatloaf, is excellent."

"I thought the sweet potato pie was absolutely perfect."

Good to know

1

Expect popular dishes to run out by early evening, especially cornbread and greens.

2

The restaurant has no air conditioning, which may affect comfort during hot days.

3

Call ahead to check on food availability before visiting.

10
Singletons Seafood Shack image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant with waterfront deck and live music offers views of dolphins and ferries. Atmosphere feels rustic and relaxed, blending old Florida charm with a clean, rebuilt space. Dog-friendly setting attracts groups enjoying fresh seafood and cold drinks.

Minorcan Chowder serves as a hot, plentiful take on Manhattan Clam Chowder priced at $8.00. Key lime pie stands out as an excellent dessert option.

Key lime and peanut butter pies come made in house. The peanut butter pie stands out as particularly impressive, while the key lime pie offers an excellent dessert option.

People are saying

"I thought the seafood here was delicious and cooked to perfection."

"I could have eaten three more bowls of the chowder."

"You have to try the peanut butter pie; it's impressive."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features $1 off drinks from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

Oyster night on Thursdays offers $0.75 raw oysters.

3

Live music is available every Friday evening.

11
Bob Evans image 1
Family restaurant

Family restaurant offers a down-home atmosphere with a quiet, old-fashioned environment. The space feels clean and comfortable with country-style charm reminiscent of classic diners. It serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner all day with reasonable prices and a steady flow of guests after opening.

Pot roast stands out with its extreme tenderness and rich flavor, paired well with mashed potatoes. Chicken Fried steak arrives quickly and is cooked perfectly. Biscuits and gravy, along with apple and pecan pies, offer classic American comfort.

Peanut butter pie stands out with rich flavor. Apple pie and pecan pie offer classic tastes. Pumpkin pie and strawberry pie add variety to the selection.

People are saying

"I found the breakfast food to be hot, fresh, and delicious."

"The American Food, like the pot roast, is sinfully good."

"The apple and pecan pies were so awesome."

Good to know

1

Breakfast prices range from $10-12, with early bird specials around $8-$10.

2

The restaurant gets busy quickly after opening, so arrive early.

3

Bob Evans serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner at any time of the day.

12
Metro Diner image 1

Old-fashioned diner with a retro style and homey atmosphere. Music plays softly in the background, adding to the pleasant vibe. The space feels bustling and wide open, attracting friendly people who enjoy classic diner charm.

Fried chicken and waffles stand out with a fantastic flavor and texture. The grits and cranberry sauce also deliver strong, memorable tastes.

Home-style pies stand out with Shepherd's Pie and Chicken Pot Pie offering rich, comforting flavors. The Apple Pie delivers a classic, sweet finish.

People are saying

"My server made my breakfast experience great and attentive."

"The American Food, especially the Chicken & Waffles with strawberry butter, was amazing."

"I ordered the shepherd's pie, and it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Metro Diner offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a wide variety of selections.

2

The portions are always enough for two.

3

The prices at Metro Diner are affordable.

Discover more

Jacksonville, Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...