Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Jacksonville

Diner sandwiches

A thick, stacked sandwich served in a diner setting is the definition of a straightforward meal.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Benchwarmers Cafe image 1
Benchwarmers Cafe image 2
Benchwarmers Cafe image 3
View all

Small cafe with a classic diner vibe and baseball-themed environment offers a family-friendly atmosphere that feels like a mom and pop hometown restaurant. The space is cozy and welcoming, with a single TV playing sports and a self-serve coffee and tea station. It attracts locals looking for affordable, hearty meals in a relaxed setting.

Small size and classic diner vibe define this spot. Simple yet tasty breakfast options capture the essence of a traditional diner.

Chicken Parmesan sandwich comes with French fries and tastes really good. Breakfast sandwiches always hit and make this a solid spot for sandwiches.

People are saying

"I had the best breakfast pitas I've ever eaten."

"The diner staff here are so friendly and make you feel welcomed."

"The breakfast sandwiches here always hit the spot."

Good to know

1

Benchwarmers Cafe is open Monday through Friday until 2pm.

2

There is no wait staff; you seat yourself and order at the counter.

3

The prices at Benchwarmers Cafe are affordable with large portions.

02
Bills Diner image 1

Old-fashioned diner with homey atmosphere and patriotic southern vibe offers a family-friendly setting. Regulars gather in a quaint, cozy space featuring historic photography and worn booths. The place feels like a small town mom and pop spot with down-home energy.

Quaint and quiet with a mom and pop diner feel, this spot serves custom homemade dishes cooked to order. The friendly down home atmosphere pairs well with top notch service and large, sweet pancakes.

Egg sandwiches stand out with pita bread, sausage, and cheese. Breakfast sandwiches offer a solid, satisfying start to the day.

People are saying

"The homemade sausage patty for breakfast was the best part."

"The diner staff here is so friendly and genuinely cares about you."

"I had the best egg sandwich I have ever had."

Good to know

1

Expect busy hours during breakfast, especially before 9am on weekends.

2

The diner charges extra for home fries and rye toast, so check the menu carefully.

3

Prices are reasonable and have remained unchanged for decades.

03
Fox Restaurant image 1
American restaurant

Long, narrow space shaped like an old shotgun house offers a nostalgic diner vibe with 1970s decor and personal touches. Atmosphere feels friendly and relaxed, filled with good music and a welcoming energy. Small and quaint, it fills up quickly with people seeking classic American breakfast and lunch fare.

Classic diner fare shines with traditional dishes done right. The spot offers a cute local breakfast diner vibe and consistently delivers great diner food.

Chili and chicken salad sandwiches come fresh and flavorful. The club sandwich stands out as outstanding and satisfying. Meatloaf sandwich also impresses with its taste.

People are saying

"It's got that awesome old school diner feel."

"The omelettes here are themed and delicious."

"I thought the club sandwich was the best I had in a while."

Good to know

1

Expect to wait for a table during busy brunch hours.

2

The restaurant fills up quickly, especially on weekends.

3

Parking at Fox Restaurant can be a little hard to find.

04
Goal Post Sandwich Shop image 1

Small family-owned diner with mom and pop vibes and walls decorated with school kids' art creates a peaceful atmosphere. Regulars enjoy breakfast pitas and sandwiches with spiced beef, complemented by a long history of local tradition and reasonable prices.

Small local diner with a long history offers a cute atmosphere and serves sandwiches and burgers.

Offers a large variety of fresh sandwiches including a notable tabouli sandwich and the original Steak-N-Sack sandwich. Also serves great breakfast sandwiches and hash browns in a classic mom and pop style.

People are saying

"This is a wonderful local spot with great food and friendly staff."

"This is the greatest little sandwich shop I've ever went to."

"I loved this cute little diner with great food and comfy seating."

Good to know

1

The shop has been family owned for over 50 years.

2

They serve breakfast and lunch with a variety of sandwiches.

3

Prices are very reasonable and budget-friendly.

05
Saraโ€™s of San Marco image 1

Cafe offers a homely, witchy vibe with a relaxed, old-school diner atmosphere. It stays quiet and welcoming, attracting those who appreciate simple, affordable meals under $10. The place feels like stepping back in time with kitschy decor and plenty of seating for dine-in or takeout.

Small diner with a casual, old-school atmosphere and authentic diner food. Coffee serves as classic diner coffee, straightforward and standard.

Sandwiches come with quality ingredients and are cooked to order. Options like the Reuben and egg and cheese Pita are tasty and generously sized.

People are saying

"This lunch spot has huge, delicious sandwiches with quality ingredients."

"I found the sandwich to be delicious and huge."

"The diner here has great prices and tasty food."

Good to know

1

The prices at Saraโ€™s of San Marco are surprisingly affordable for the quality.

2

I paid around $16 for two breakfasts, which I found outstanding value.

3

There was a free parking lot available.

06
Johnny Angel's Diner image 1

Diner with 50's and 60's theme features Elvis memorabilia and a working free jukebox playing era music. Atmosphere feels nostalgic and lively, with TVs showing period movies and outdoor seating available. Food includes generous portions of classic dishes like homemade corned beef hash and crispy fries.

A 1950s diner vibe fills the space with poodle skirts and lively tunes. Homemade corned beef hash comes out crispy, matching the cozy, welcoming atmosphere and great service.

Sandwiches feature smoky, meaty flavors and come with perfectly cooked eggs and crispy, thick bacon. Options like the James Dean Ruben and Route 66 stand out for their taste and quality.

People are saying

"The diner food here is awesome and cooked perfectly."

"I thought the juicy, medium-rare burger was perfect."

"This sandwich was so good, I was extremely happy with my choice."

Good to know

1

Johnny Angel's Diner charges a $4.00 fee for debit or credit card payments.

2

Breakfast is served all day, including during lunchtime.

3

Expect a wait to get into the diner during peak hours.

07
Barrs Street Eats image 1
American restaurant

Small, cozy diner with a laidback vibe and soft jazz music creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Frequented by hospital staff, it offers a family-friendly setting with reasonable prices and a charming, old-fashioned feel.

A small, family-friendly diner with great prices and quiet yet lively atmosphere. Food consistently hits the spot in a cozy setting.

Sandwiches come huge and filling, like the fish sandwich that fills the entire container and is cut in half. Rolls and biscuits get toasted on the grill, adding a nice touch to options like the club and Reuben sandwiches, both packed with flavor.

People are saying

"The American Food here has huge, perfectly flavored club sandwiches."

"This diner has great prices and solid food."

"I had the best sandwich of my life here."

Good to know

1

Parking is available at the storefront and on the street.

2

Prices are very reasonable, with burgers starting at $9 including fries.

3

The restaurant is family-friendly and suitable for a quick bite.

08
Gina's Deli image 1

Old school diner style creates a cozy, family atmosphere with gator decor adding unique character. The space feels intimate yet roomy, suitable for quiet meals or quick lunches. It stays busy and welcoming, reflecting a clean, friendly, and affordable neighborhood spot.

Family-run diner offers hearty breakfasts with an old school diner vibe. The interior has a classic diner-style feel that invites sitting down and enjoying the atmosphere.

Grilled chicken sandwich comes on a toasted bun with Swiss cheese, mayo, tomato, and lettuce. Menu includes chicken salad, pasta salad, tabouli, egg salad, burgers, pitas, cold subs, and hot sandwiches.

People are saying

"This is a great family-run lunch spot with delicious food."

"I loved the big, juicy burger at this diner."

"The grilled chicken sandwich with Swiss, mayo, tomato, and lettuce is really good."

Good to know

1

Gina's Deli offers a great variety and value in their menu.

2

The prices at Gina's Deli are very affordable.

3

The dining area at Ginaโ€™s Deli is always clean.

09
Metro Diner image 1

Old-fashioned diner with a retro style and homey atmosphere. Music plays softly in the background, adding to the pleasant vibe. The space feels bustling and wide open, attracting friendly people who enjoy classic diner charm.

Classic diner vibe shines through with an old-fashioned appearance and a clean, busy atmosphere. Food stays consistently delicious and pure, making it a solid choice for breakfast or brunch.

Sandwiches come in generous portions with options like a spicy honey chicken and a 3-cheese grilled cheese. Club sandwiches and bacon, egg, and cheese croissants offer hearty, flavorful choices.

People are saying

"My server made my breakfast experience great and attentive."

"This diner's comfort food, like the fried chicken Benedict, is incredible."

"The spicy honey chicken sandwich was amazing, and Angela was so supportive."

Good to know

1

Metro Diner offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a wide variety of selections.

2

The portions are always enough for two.

3

The prices at Metro Diner are affordable.

10
Terry's Grill Oceanway image 1
American restaurant

Small local restaurant offers a home town atmosphere with a friendly, down-to-earth vibe and cozy, intimate seating. Walls display encouraging Bible verses, adding to the welcoming, country feel. Tables often push together for large groups, reflecting a community-oriented setting.

A great little diner with a strong local vibe serves classic breakfast options. Some dishes could use better flavor and preparation to appeal more to vegetarian diners.

Triple-decker sandwiches stand out with customizable options like no jalapeรฑos or banana peppers. The club sandwich pairs well with green beans. Friendly service includes the owner personally making sandwiches to-go.

People are saying

"I thought the breakfast here was great and high quality."

"This diner has such wonderful local charm and friendly smiles."

"I had to add salt to my sandwich and fries."

Good to know

1

Terry's Grill Oceanway serves breakfast and lunch only, closing at 2:00 PM.

2

You are supposed to seat yourself upon arrival.

3

The restaurant is very kid friendly, making it suitable for families.

Discover more

Jacksonville, Florida

Area guide
Loading Map...