Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Illinois

Sugar cookie spots

Tracking down a sugar cookie that actually tastes like butter and vanilla rather than just a sugary, store-bought afterthought.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Simply Sweet Caroline's image 1
Simply Sweet Caroline's image 2
Simply Sweet Caroline's image 3
View all

Custom cookies showcase exquisite decoration and detailed designs with vibrant colors and metallic accents. The atmosphere is friendly and professional, with a smooth ordering process and reliable service. Cookies are individually sealed, making them convenient for travel and special occasions.

Cookies come beautifully decorated and individually sealed for easy transport. Custom designs match inspiration photos perfectly, making them a hit at birthdays and showers.

Sugar cookies come out delicious and perfect with a taste that stands out. They often become a family favorite and pair well with the cookie cake.

People are saying

"The cookies here are beautiful and delicious."

"These cookies are adorable and delicious, a real hit for kids."

"I thought the sugar cookies looked and tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

The ordering process is easy and smooth for custom cookies.

2

Caroline offers cookie designs that can match your event theme.

3

Cookies are individually sealed for convenient transport.

02
Envy Design Cookies INC image 1

Custom cookie shop offers highly detailed designs that match event themes precisely. Atmosphere centers on personalized service with affordable pricing and exceptional taste. Cookies consistently impress with both appearance and flavor, making them a popular choice for celebrations.

Beautifully designed cookies match complex art perfectly and taste amazing. They suit events like birthdays and bridal showers, impressing guests with both look and flavor.

Iced sugar cookies come with lemon and vanilla flavors and feature adorable, detailed designs. They appeal even to those who usually do not like sugar cookies.

People are saying

"These cookies are amazing, delicious, and beautifully designed."

"The cookies for Birthday Parties were stunning and tasted phenomenal."

"Darina's sugar cookies are stunning and perfectly decorated."

Good to know

1

Order in advance as they book up quickly, especially during summer and holidays.

2

The cookies are beautifully designed and taste great.

3

Expect meticulous craftsmanship and attention to detail in every cookie.

03
Bake It with Tina - Custom Cookies & Custom Cakes image 1

Custom cookie and cake shop operates from an in-home setup with no seating. Creations feature intricate designs and creative decorations that serve as edible art. The atmosphere centers on personalized, detailed craftsmanship with treats that are both beautiful and delicious.

Cookies come out beautifully decorated with attention to detail on small accents that make each one a piece of art. They taste absolutely delicious and stay soft for days after baking.

Custom sugar cookies come in perfect consistency and sweetness with detailed icing. They look great and suit celebrations like birthdays well.

People are saying

"These custom cookies are gorgeous and delicious!"

"The custom cookies and smash cakes are adorable and delicious for kids' parties."

"These sugar cookies are works of art and delicious."

Good to know

1

Ordering and delivery from Bake It with Tina is easy and straightforward.

2

Custom cookie orders require at least one week's notice for best results.

3

All cookies are made fresh and can be customized to fit any theme.

04
Gather Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with an open, sunlit space and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Features a small kids play area that entertains children while adults enjoy fresh pastries and coffee. The environment feels friendly and relaxed, making it easy to linger and chat.

Frosted sugar cookies come in adorable designs and taste delicious. Custom cookies for events like graduations and baby showers impress with their freshness and flavor.

Custom sugar cookies come decorated for events and gifts with a hungry caterpillar theme and other designs. Frosted sugar cookies taste just right, not too sweet, and pair well with croissants.

People are saying

"Their cookies are soft, flavorful, and absolutely to die for."

"I found the croissants to be divine and delicious."

"I ordered custom sugar cookies that were darling and delicious."

Good to know

1

Gather Bakery offers cookie decorating events for all ages.

2

The bakery makes their products fresh daily.

3

Gather Bakery has vegan bread options available.

05
Moose & Me Baking Company image 1

Spacious bakery offers a calm, sensory-friendly atmosphere with gluten-free options and innovative cupcakes. Games and books create a welcoming space for children and families. Staff includes people with different abilities, supporting a mission of meaningful employment.

Cookies come in a large variety of flavors and generous sizes. They are gluten-free, baked with a crunchy outside and chewy inside.

Sugar cookies come with detailed decoration and look beautifully decorated. They taste great and appeal even to those not usually fond of sugar cookies.

People are saying

"The cake was SO SO delicious and beautifully decorated."

"I found the cookies to be amazingly delicious."

"These sugar cookies are so yummy and pretty to look at."

Good to know

1

They offer custom cakes for special occasions with a variety of flavors.

2

Gluten-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

The bakery hosts cookie decorating events for groups and parties.

06
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Small cookie shop fills with bright lights and a sweet aroma of freshly baked treats. Atmosphere feels vibrant and welcoming, often crowded with people drawn to its preppy, pink-themed decor. Cookies come in unique weekly flavors served quickly, making it a lively spot for quick indulgence.

Cookies here stand out for their amazing flavor and consistent quality. The cornbread cookie is a notable favorite, often described as the best ever tasted.

Classic pink and original frosted sugar cookies offer a mouth-watering taste. Specialty flavors like cookies and creme and caramel pumpkin cake add variety beyond the plain options.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be soft, warm, and delicious."

"It's so kid friendly; my daughter loved picking her own flavor."

"These sugar cookies are mouth-wateringly good."

Good to know

1

The Crumbl app offers exclusive discounts and flavor updates.

2

Cookies are typically ready for pickup in about 5 minutes.

3

Special flavors like the Dubai Chocolate Brownies are only available online.

07
D's Cookie Dough Company image 1
Wholesale bakery

Bright space with a beautiful window display and cute seating area creates a welcoming atmosphere. Cookies are large and thick, often served warm and fresh, with phenomenal chocolate chip varieties standing out. The shop is part of a collective, offering a cozy spot for coffee and conversation.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their freshness and clean ingredients. Mini cookies and pastries come beautifully done and taste like homemade treats from grandma's porch.

Sugar cookies come in jumbo size and pair well with coffee. They taste plain with an aftertaste and lack sweetness.

People are saying

"I thought these cookies were probably the best I've ever had."

"These chocolate chip cookies are amazing, soft, and gooey."

"The sugar cookies paired nicely with coffee."

Good to know

1

The shop is closed on Sundays.

2

Most cookies are often out of stock until restocked.

3

The cookies are large enough for two people to share.

08
Sweet Mandy B's Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with an authentic interior and a relaxed atmosphere that feels like home. Known for famous cupcakes and a varied selection including vegan options, it draws families and casual visitors alike. The space is smaller and less trendy, focusing on simple, honest baked goods.

Softness stands out in the cookies here, with options like confetti cookies, sugar cookies, and a gluten-free cookie that impress. Cookies come in large sizes and include flavors like lemon raspberry and snickerdoodle.

Confetti and sugar cookies come out soft and sweet, with the confetti ones standing out as divine. The iced sugar cookie offers a different take, but it does not taste like a traditional sugar cookie.

People are saying

"I thought the devil's food cake was the best cake I ever had."

"I enjoyed their divine sugar cookies."

"I thought the gluten-free cookie here was the best I'd ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers vegan options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Prices for baked goods are not clearly marked, so ask before ordering.

3

The bakery is open seven days a week for your convenience.

Discover more

Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...