Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Indiana

Mediterranean sandwiches

A sandwich that brings Mediterranean flavors to the table without feeling like a watered-down version of the real thing.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Mt. Olive Mediterranean Grill image 1
Mt. Olive Mediterranean Grill image 2
Mt. Olive Mediterranean Grill image 3
View all

Small space with comfortable booths and colorful murals creates a cozy, welcoming vibe. Charcoal grill aromas and spice scents fill the air, while absence of music keeps the atmosphere calm. Staff offer generous food samples, enhancing the relaxed, friendly energy.

Falafel stands out as the best ever tasted, paired with lentil soup that ranks top in the region. Authentic, satisfying Mediterranean dishes come through clearly in every bite.

Falafel sandwich stands out with its rich flavor and satisfying texture. Chicken shawarma pita offers a burst of flavor and a nice crunch from pickled veggies, paired with labneh dip.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be authentic and delicious."

"The Mediterranean food, especially the chicken shawarma, was delicious."

"I found the falafel sandwich here to be delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

The mix grill is 100 percent zabiha halal.

2

Expect about a 10-minute wait for fresh food.

3

Lunch specials offer good options during the hours.

02
IndyMeat Wrap and Over Rice image 1
Middle Eastern restaurant

Food truck serves halal Middle Eastern dishes with generous portions and a quiet atmosphere. It attracts people looking for authentic gyro and rice plates, especially late at night. The vibe is calm and satisfying, with a focus on quality and detail.

Menu includes Halal meats and falafel with options like chicken, steak, gyro, and falafel over rice. Falafel is moist and packed with fresh veggies and sauce, making it a solid choice for vegetarians.

Steak sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and a satisfying texture. Chicken wraps also offer a full flavor experience, making sandwiches here consistently tasty and well-prepared.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"The Mediterranean food here, especially the gyro, is incredible."

"The steak sandwich was very good and juicy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but calling ahead is recommended as they may open later than 3PM.

2

The food truck serves halal and kosher options, including chicken, steak, gyro, falafel, fries, and rice.

3

Expect generous portions; one dish can often provide two meals.

03
Mr. Shawarma image 1
Middle Eastern restaurant

Middle Eastern restaurant offers a clean, inviting space with relaxed, positive vibes and moderate music volume. The atmosphere feels authentic and warm, reminiscent of urban shops in Amman or the UK. It attracts those seeking family-friendly dining with a welcoming environment.

Shawarma here stands out with authentic flavors and high-quality beef and chicken options. Staff take clear pride in delivering consistent, delicious Mediterranean food.

Juicy sandwiches pack a nice kick with beef and chicken shawarma options. Coleslaw comes with the box but can make the sandwich a bit soggy, and only two pieces of french fries are included inside the sandwich.

People are saying

"I found the Mediterranean food's shawarma to be the best I've ever had."

"I had some of the best falafel I have ever tasted."

"I thought the chicken shawarma sandwich was the best."

Good to know

1

Mr. Shawarma offers generous portions at fair prices.

2

The restaurant maintains a clean and welcoming dining area.

3

Mr. Shawarma is open on Thanksgiving for those looking for a meal.

04
Indy Gyros image 1
Restaurant

Small space with minimal decor and a quiet atmosphere creates a low-key dining experience. Affordable prices and large portions attract a family-oriented crowd seeking hearty meals. The vibe leans toward casual takeout rather than lively sit-down dining.

Falafel stands out as a flavorful highlight across dishes like gyros and salads. Lamb gyros and pita with hummus complement the menu with rich Mediterranean staples.

Gyros and pork tenderloin sandwiches come with generous portions of meat. Burgers, sandwiches, and bowls offer well-proportioned servings that are filling and satisfying.

People are saying

"The lamb gyro here is tender and delicious."

"I thought the Mediterranean food, especially the gyro, was phenomenal."

"This sandwich is so filling, it's packed with meat."

Good to know

1

Prices are affordable, making it cheaper than many fast food options.

2

Portion sizes are generous, providing excellent value for the cost.

3

Indy Gyros offers halal food options, including unique Indian dishes.

05
Reem Mediterranean Grill image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Small space with warm golden light and classic Mediterranean music creates a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Plenty of seating supports a lively dining environment filled with clinking glasses and laughter. The restaurant combines a modern, clean look with authentic charm.

Chicken shawarma comes out tender and juicy with perfect flavor. Falafel and hummus offer solid, authentic tastes. Shawarma bowls and falafel sandwich platters serve as good Mediterranean staples here.

Lamb gyro and chicken shawarma sandwiches feature tender, perfectly seasoned meat. Falafel sandwich platters come well presented and are a popular choice for gatherings.

People are saying

"I drove an hour for this fresh, rich Mediterranean food."

"The falafel here is so delicious and fresh."

"The falafel sandwich platter was delicious and perfectly presented."

Good to know

1

Reem Mediterranean Grill offers a build-your-own menu for items like pitas and wraps.

2

The restaurant is affordable with large portions.

3

The prices at Reem Mediterranean Grill are very affordable.

06
Yazsh image 1
Restaurant

Small space with original artwork and austere Balkan vibe offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Piano music adds to the comfortable, inviting setting. Local beers on tap complement the thoughtful, unique menu.

Shakshuka features a deeply flavored sauce and perfect poached eggs. Falafel sandwich and feta fries offer wholesome, healthy tastes alongside other Mediterranean dishes.

Falafel and lukanka salami sandwiches offer bold flavors without feeling heavy. Chicken sandwiches come across as wholesome and healthy. Sandwich prices run around $18, which is high for the area.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and authentic."

"This sandwich was so flavorful without being too heavy."

"The Mediterranean food here is packed with flavor and wholesome."

Good to know

1

There's plenty of free parking all around the restaurant.

2

Yazsh is only open until 3 PM, so it's limited to lunch hours.

3

The menu is currently very limited.

07
Mama saaj and gyro image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Restaurant inside an international grocery store offers freshly made Middle Eastern dishes with a warm, inviting atmosphere. Food court setting includes diverse ethnic options and generous portions at reasonable prices. Energy is casual, with a single employee often managing service.

Falafel has a perfect texture, crispy outside and soft inside. Shawarma comes in flavorful chicken and beef versions. Kebabs, including lamb and chicken, are juicy and tender with reasonable prices.

Chicken shawarma sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and a well-balanced mix of ingredients, including tomatoes that complement the taste even for those who usually avoid them.

People are saying

"The chicken shawarma here is juicy, flavorful, and perfectly grilled."

"I've never had a better gyro; it's the best Mediterranean food I ever had."

"This gyro sandwich had the best seasoned meat I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is located inside an international grocery store, functioning like a food court.

2

Expect generous portion sizes that can easily feed multiple people.

3

Prices are very reasonable compared to the portion sizes.

08
Sam's Gyros image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant offers cozy, quiet atmosphere with a friendly, inviting vibe. Interior feels old and unpolished, creating a relaxed but modest setting. Board games add a casual touch to the experience.

Falafel stands out with fresh preparation and perfect seasoning, served alongside yogurt, veggies, tahini, and hummus. The baba ganoush offers rich, flavorful depth, while the chicken shawarma remains a favorite for its taste and quality.

Falafel sandwiches stand out with their freshness and perfect frying. Spicy gyro sandwiches offer a bold flavor that pairs well with the falafel.

People are saying

"I thought the spicy gyro sandwich and falafel were crazy good."

"I thought the shawarma and falafel were the best."

"I thought the falafel sandwich was fried to perfection."

Good to know

1

There is a $1 charge to use a card.

2

They offer a 1/2 gyro, fries, and sodas for $10.99.

3

The servings at Sam's Gyros are generous.

09
bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop image 1

Quaint, family-owned sandwich shop with soft jazz and a calm, welcoming atmosphere. Tables feature painted mason jars with flowers, adding to the cute, clean interior. Staff show passion for their food heritage, creating a unique, expansive menu with affordable prices.

Homemade falafel comes out light and crispy with creamy, flavorful hummus on the side. Chicken shawarma stands out as rich and well-seasoned, paired well with fresh wraps and salads like broccoli and potato salad.

Grilled pastrami sandwiches come with a small house salad and offer a hearty, delicious experience. The sandwich features a generous variety of fillings, though some may find the pastrami portion could be larger.

People are saying

"The owner is super friendly and offers great salad suggestions."

"I loved the homemade falafel; it was light and crispy."

"The Mediterranean food's falafel is light, crispy, and creamy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open on Saturdays until 2 PM.

2

Prices are affordable with a wide variety of sandwiches and daily specials.

3

Expect quick service; food is ready in about 5 minutes.

10
New York Gyro and Indian Food ( Troy avenue ) image 1

Restaurant offers clean, brand new interior with affordable prices and large portions. Atmosphere feels cute and welcoming with limited seating. Menu features authentic halal cart-style chicken and lamb over rice alongside Indian dishes like butter chicken and naan.

Seekh kebabs and chicken over rice stand out with strong flavors. The menu also features solid falafel gyros, naan bread, and a variety of Mediterranean staples like hummus, feta cheese, and baklava.

Grilled chicken sandwiches offer an authentic NYC taste with a nod to the Bronx. Pre-made chicken patty sandwiches lack quality compared to fresh options like falafel gyros and fish sandwiches.

People are saying

"The lamb gyro was large and very good."

"The Mediterranean food, especially the chicken and rice, was fantastic."

"This grilled chicken sandwich has an authentic NYC taste."

Good to know

1

You can call ahead for takeout orders.

2

The pricing is very affordable, with gyros costing $8 when paying cash.

3

Expect wait times of more than 30 minutes during busy hours.

11
AlBasha of Fishers โ€“ Mediterranean Kitchen image 1

Small Mediterranean restaurant connects directly to a grocery store, creating a simple yet tasteful setting with homey atmosphere and welcoming vibe. Lighting tends to be somewhat dark, and noise levels can rise when busy. Known for authentic halal dishes and fresh, flavorful food, it attracts those seeking genuine Mediterranean flavors.

Smooth, creamy hummus and moist, well-made falafel stand out here. Lentil soup, chicken souvlaki pita, and tzatziki also deliver solid Mediterranean flavors.

Falafel and shawarma sandwiches stand out as the best here. The menu also features a Philly steak sandwich and a Chicken Souvlaki Pita Sandwich, all well made.

People are saying

"I found the food to be absolutely delicious."

"The Mediterranean food here has the smoothest hummus and moistest falafel."

"I found the falafel and shawarma sandwiches to be the best."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a variety of halal options for diners.

2

Expect fresh ingredients and authentic Middle Eastern flavors.

3

Prices are reasonable, but some items may have increased recently.

12
Taste of yemen Restaurant image 1
Yemeni restaurant

Arabic style seating with floor cushions and private draped booths creates an authentic and cozy environment. The atmosphere is laid-back and respectful, enhanced by Middle Eastern incense that adds warmth and familiarity. The space suits gatherings, offering privacy and a relaxed vibe without music.

Lamb dishes with Yemeni spices stand out, especially the Hummus with Meat topped with cubed lamb. Chicken mandi, tabbouleh, shawarma, and falafel offer authentic Mediterranean flavors alongside classic hummus and pitas.

Beef kafta and falafel sandwiches stand out with rich flavors. Shawarma sandwiches pair well with smoothies for a satisfying combo.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and amazing."

"The Mediterranean food here is flavorful, especially the lamb dishes."

"The falafel sandwich was delicious and fresh and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers 100% halal food.

2

Prices are affordable, with generous portions for $20.

3

The restaurant is clean and well-maintained.

13
Petra Cafe image 1
Middle Eastern restaurant

Small dining space creates a cozy atmosphere with a warm and inviting vibe despite occasional crowding. Loud music adds energy, while the place stays open very late, attracting those seeking authentic Middle Eastern flavors and late-night meals.

Chicken shawarma and kebabs stand out with rich yogurt sauce and tender meat. Falafel sandwiches come with crispy fries and fresh pita, while baba ganoush and hummus add classic Mediterranean flavors.

Falafel sandwiches come freshly prepared with hot, crispy fries and just the right amount of toppings. Chicken shawarma, lamb kabobs, and gyro sandwiches also feature bold, rich flavors but falafel stands out as a favorite.

People are saying

"You have to try the chicken shawarma; it's Lebanese style and perfectly cooked."

"I dreamed about their gyro platter; it's the best Greek food."

"The falafel sandwich was freshly prepared, hot, and great."

Good to know

1

Petra Cafe stays open until 4 am on weekends.

2

Petra Cafe offers halal food options.

3

They have vegan options available at Petra Cafe.

14
New York Gyro & Indian Kitchen image 1

Food truck offers halal dishes with affordable prices and fresh, flavorful gyros and curries. Atmosphere feels warm and well-decorated, with a clean and well-maintained setup. Location near highway exits and gas stations makes it convenient for travelers and truck drivers.

Falafel stands out with a great taste, served over rice or in a sandwich. The Veggie burger and chicken gyro also offer solid Mediterranean flavors.

Gyro and Philly cheesesteak sandwiches offer classic flavors with solid preparation. Chili chicken and fish sandwiches stand out for their bold seasoning and rich taste.

People are saying

"The lamb gyro here is flavorful and piled high on warm pita."

"I found the Mediterranean Food, especially the Falafel, delicious."

"The chili chicken and fish sandwich is so flavorful and well seasoned."

Good to know

1

The food truck is located right across the street from Road Ranger truck stop exit #99 on I65.

2

Parking is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

3

Prices are affordable, with goat curry costing $13.50.

15
Petos Greek Grill&Pasta image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant with authentic atmosphere and modern, artistic decor offers spacious interior and outdoor seating with umbrellas. The vibe is cozy and inviting, often filled with friendly, family-owned warmth. Acoustics can be challenging, but the setting feels like a real Greek tavern with local music.

Falafel stands out as a top dish here, paired well with hummus and pita that avoid heavy garlic. The Chicken Souvlaki dinner features two kebabs served on pilaf or Greek potatoes with a small Greek salad.

Gyros and Shawma sandwiches come with seasoned meat and the right accompaniments. Lamb shank and Souvlaki sandwiches deliver flavorful, well-prepared options.

People are saying

"The gyros here are traditional and amazingly delicious."

"I ordered the Lamb Gyro sandwich, and it was great."

"The Mediterranean food, especially the lamb skewers and chops, was heavenly."

Good to know

1

Call for reservations for 6 or more people is highly recommended.

2

I had difficulty finding parking in the Artsy Pedestrian-Friendly neighborhood.

3

Expect high prices for small portions.

16
Al Waha Restaurant image 1

Small dining area inside an international supermarket offers a casual atmosphere with clean tables and beautiful tablecloths. The place serves authentic Middle Eastern cuisine with large portions suitable for sharing or takeout. It feels like a hidden gem due to its tucked-away location along the side wall of the grocery store.

Falafel stands out with its freshness and noticeable herbs. Shawarma options include beef and chicken, both authentic and flavorful. Other dishes like yellow lentil soup, kofta kebab, and hummus complement the menu well.

Falafel sandwich comes wrapped in a flour tortilla instead of pita bread and lacks sauces and vegetables like lettuce and tomatoes. Chicken Shawarma and Shish Tawook sandwiches stand out for their freshness and delicious taste.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, well-cooked, and full of flavor."

"The dinner portions here are so ample, they could feed two people."

"The falafel sandwich here is very good and filling."

Good to know

1

They offer a buffet on Fridays and Saturdays.

2

During Ramadan, they had a dinner buffet with unique home cooking dishes.

3

The restaurant is located inside an international supermarket.

17
Aladdin Pita image 1
Middle Eastern restaurant

Middle Eastern restaurant with beautiful wall paintings and a quiet, pleasant atmosphere that suits reading or a relaxed meal. Space feels clean and roomy, welcoming families and couples alike. A small grocery section offers authentic Middle Eastern products alongside the dining experience.

Hummus stands out with its creamy texture and is often paired with warm pita. The falafel sandwich and lamb kebabs consistently deliver strong Mediterranean flavors.

Falafel and chicken schwarma sandwiches come with fresh, warm pitas and sides like hummus, baba ghanoush, and soup. Portions are generous and affordable, often enough to share.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and perfectly cooked."

"I found the Mediterranean food here to be delicious and fantastic."

"I get the chicken schwarma sandwich every time I go."

Good to know

1

The Sunday buffet runs from 1 PM to 9 PM, offering a variety of dishes.

2

Dinner buffet on Sundays features all-you-can-eat options for sampling many dishes.

3

Vegan and vegetarian options are available at the buffet.

18
JAWDI GRILL image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Small Mediterranean restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with lively music that can get loud due to the compact space. The place feels warm and welcoming, with clean, well-organized surroundings and a vibe like family gathering.

Beef shawarma stands out with its authentic, juicy, and perfectly seasoned flavor. Fresh falafel, gyro, and hummus complement the menu, delivering real Mediterranean tastes that feel like home.

Sandwiches feature generous amounts of meat with options like tender beef shawarma and Arabic style chicken and meat. Flavors balance well and seasoning stands out.

People are saying

"The food here is so authentic and packed with flavor."

"I found the Mediterranean food here to be out of this world."

"The chicken shawarma sandwich is delicious with a generous amount of meat."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait during lunch rush hours due to popularity.

2

Reservations are not accepted; it's a walk-in only establishment.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

19
NYC Halal Eats (Greenwood) image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food restaurant with a bright, clean interior and NYC street urban vibe creates a welcoming, positive atmosphere. The space feels modern and spacious, decorated with cool wall art that adds character. It attracts people seeking authentic halal street food with generous portions and bold flavors.

Falafel comes in different forms here, from a crumbly texture in the platter to a crispy falafel gyro served with green chutney. Combo platters mix chicken, lamb gyro, and falafels over rice with salad and fries, topped with white, chipotle, and hot sauces.

Chicken cheese steak offers a solid balance but leans toward more bread than meat. Salito chicken sandwich stands out with its unique flavor and is worth ordering again.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the tender, well-seasoned lamb."

"The falafel gyro here is a solid Mediterranean Food choice."

"I will definitely get the salito chicken sandwich again!"

Good to know

1

The portion sizes are generous, often enough to share between two people.

2

Prices are reasonable for the quality and portion sizes offered.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean and welcoming environment.

20
Pita Stop image 1
Restaurant

Family-owned restaurant offers a warm, relaxing atmosphere with limited indoor seating. Quiet setting suits those seeking a calm meal experience. Online ordering and a punch card system add convenience and value.

Gyros, chicken shawarma, and hummus stand out with bold flavors. Shish kebabs are solid, but falafel pita has a bitter hummus and less appealing taste. Tzatziki sauce varies but stays average.

The menu features the boss sandwich and a gyros sandwich. Both come with rich flavors and satisfying portions.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and flavorful."

"This Mediterranean food is fresh, flavorful, and tastes homemade."

"I thought the boss sandwich was delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is known for its cleanliness and hygiene standards.

2

Portions are generous, providing good value for the price.

3

Prices are reasonable, with meals averaging around $30 for two people.

21
Munster Gyros image 1
Gyro restaurant

Old school diner-style space with throwback decor and a mom & pop shop vibe offers a wide menu selection focused on gyros and ribs. Atmosphere feels like typical fast food, with a homey but somewhat dated interior. Known for affordable prices and generous portions, it attracts groups and locals seeking classic flavors.

Gyros come with lots of toppings and amazing tzatziki sauce. The tzatziki has just right cucumbers and stands out as a highlight.

Gyro Sandwich stands out with moist, flavorful meat and generous portions. Sautรฉed onions and fresh tomato slices add a perfect blend of flavor, making it consistently well-cooked and affordable.

People are saying

"I've never had Greek food with gyros this juicy and flavorful."

"I thought the ribs here were the best I had."

"This gyro sandwich is perfectly cooked and packed with flavorful, flavorful, juicy meat."

Good to know

1

Daily specials are available at Munster Gyros.

2

The price of the Gyro Sandwich is very affordable.

3

The portions are generous, providing good value for money.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...