# Cookie spots in Indianapolis > Made for those who treat a well-baked cookie as a serious culinary pursuit rather than a casual snack. Source: https://www.atly.com/united-states/indiana/indianapolis/best-cookie ## Places (24) ### 1. Howdy Homemade Ice Cream Bright, open space offers fresh homemade ice cream with unique flavors and a lemon butter cookie served in a cone. Cookies pair well with cold brew and inspire an ice cream flavor. Friendly staff and soft music create a comforting, wholesome environment with ample seating. - Address: 370 N New Jersey St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/HowdyHomemadeIceCream ### 2. Heartland Homemade Ice Cream Small shop offers unique homemade ice cream with dairy-free options and a family-friendly vibe. Cookies like Lemon Cream bring a tart twist. Cozy seating inside and outside invites casual visits and flavor voting. - Address: 4911 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/HeartlandHomemadeIceCream ### 3. Mr A Pizza & Wings Small pizza parlor shines with scratch-made sauces and unique fusion pizzas like Indian-style options. Cozy indoor seating creates a family atmosphere perfect for locals. Don't miss the large, warm cookie with a chewy inside and crispy outside, topped with chocolate drizzle. - Address: 9516 Haver Way, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Mr-A-Pizza-Wings ### 4. Movable FEAST Bohemian decor and quirky art create an eclectic vibe perfect for casual lunches. Outrageous cookies shine alongside great sandwiches and salads. Quick service and reasonable prices make it a fun, cool spot for diverse tastes. - Address: 5143 E 65th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/MovableFEAST ### 5. Slammyz Sandwich shop offers innovative sandwiches in a fun, rock-themed setting with lime green bags. Carryout only with some outdoor seating fits an artsy vibe. No-bake cookies shine, especially the peanut butter corn flakes one with perfect texture and taste. - Address: 2658 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Slammyz ### 6. Café Babette Pastry shop boasts sea salt chocolate chip and s'mores cookies with rich flavors. Over 15 unique baked goods fill a laid-back atmosphere with mismatched tables. High demand means waiting or preordering is common, no coffee or eat-in service offered. - Address: 2627 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Café-Babette ### 7. The Cavity Factory Small cookie shop buzzes with a trendy vibe and friendly atmosphere. Cookies are super soft with unique flavors like s'mores, offering a sweet, satisfying treat. Place fills up fast, so arriving early is key to enjoy the fresh, highly praised cookies. - Address: 1354 Shelby St B, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/TheCavityFactory ### 8. Crumbl Bright, welcoming space with a sweet aroma invites cookie lovers. Soft, gooey cookies and unique mini and waffle options offer rich, addictive flavors. Clean environment ensures fresh, high-quality treats despite minimal staff interaction. - Address: 3329 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Crumbl230 ### 9. Vanilla Bean Bakery Cupcakes and cakes show exceptional craftsmanship and can be made fast, even last minute. Cookies come with personalized decorating kits that keep kids busy and taste great. Friendly staff and sugar-free options make it a welcoming spot for all. - Address: 1510 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/VanillaBeanBakery ### 10. Transformations Salon and Spa Calm, relaxing space blends spa serenity with chic salon energy. Warm, friendly staff offer homemade cookies and coffee, creating an inviting atmosphere. Clients enjoy massage chairs in a clean, professional setting with affordable, quality services for all ages. - Address: 8083 A Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/TransformationsSalonAndSpa ### 11. Mansion On The Mile B&B Mansion blends historic architecture with world famous cookies by Geanne. Piano music fills breakfast, creating a charming atmosphere. Location offers easy walking access to downtown attractions and lively spots. - Address: 228 N East St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Mansion-On-The-Mile-BB ### 12. Old Northside Bed & Breakfast Victorian home offers quiet, spacious rooms with a vast movie collection including VHS tapes. Fresh baked homemade cookies fill the air all day, paired with cold drinks and snacks. Location is peaceful yet near downtown, creating a personal and inviting atmosphere. - Address: 1340 Alabama St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Old-Northside-Bed-Breakfast ### 13. Subway Sandwich shop offers fresh, soft bread and amazing cookies that are always soft and tasty. Interiors stay clean and well-kept, creating a calm vibe. Staff often remember orders, though prices are a bit high for portions. - Address: 11816 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46229, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Subway2626 ### 14. Heidelberg Haus Cozy German restaurant offers authentic cookies with seasonal treats like Christmas specials. Quirky gift shop features gnomes and knickknacks. Staff wear fun outfits, creating a lively atmosphere in a tight, bustling space. - Address: 7625 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46226, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/HeidelbergHaus ### 15. Please & Thank You "INDY" Small space with chewy chocolate chip cookies and gluten-free options creates a hipster vibe. Cool, welcoming atmosphere draws a laid-back crowd. Limited seating and dog-friendly touches add to cozy, casual energy. - Address: 849 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Please-Thank-You-"INDY" ### 16. The Rejoicing Vine Winery Winery offers a modern rustic design and lively atmosphere with live music. Cookie decorating classes add a fun, engaging touch, paired with tasty snacks. Sustainable, family-owned focus creates a warm community vibe perfect for gatherings. - Address: 8440 W 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46278, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/TheRejoicingVineWinery ### 17. Taylor's Bakery Bakery offers best cakes and iced sugar cookies with custom designs. Chocolate chip cookies with icing shine among seasonal treats. Fun, clean spot draws families for special occasions and daily delights. - Address: 6216 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46220, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Taylor's-Bakery1 ### 18. Magoo's Pizza Cozy spot offers homemade pizza with unique toppings and standout wings for casual meals. Warm, fresh cookies often come free, adding a sweet touch. Family-friendly vibe makes it great for relaxed evenings with friends or kids. - Address: 6925 S Franklin Rd #106, Indianapolis, IN 46259, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Magoo's-Pizza1 ### 19. Greiner's SubShop Rustic design and old car decorations create a warm, welcoming space. Strong, independent women staff add unique energy. Homemade double chocolate chip cookies shine, with extras if a batch is off. Outdoor seating is dog friendly, perfect for a relaxed visit. - Address: 2126 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Greiner's-SubShop ### 20. Fancy Fortune Cookies Custom fortune cookies arrive fresh and intact with personalized messages and amazing flavor. Packaging uses multiple ice packs to keep quality during shipping. Delivery timing varies but cookies always arrive in perfect condition. - Address: 3909 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/FancyFortuneCookies ### 21. Bovaconti Coffee Cozy indoor seating and a spacious patio with Adirondack chairs create a dog-friendly vibe. Cookies like peanut butter chocolate chip offer a dense, tasty treat that pairs well with chai latte. Peaceful ambiance suits work but can get loud when busy. - Address: 1042 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/BovacontiCoffee ### 22. Nine Lives Cafe & Cat Lounge Cat cafe offers a calm space with playful cats and cat-themed art. Chocolate chip cookies have rich flavor and pair well with drinks. Visitors enjoy a clean, safe space that supports local rescues. - Address: 1315 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Nine-Lives-Cafe-Cat-Lounge ### 23. Cookie Plug Cute space with a retro vibe offers soft, dessert-style cookies like strawberry and red velvet that melt in your mouth. Friendly energy creates an inviting spot for a unique cookie experience with well-balanced, not too sweet flavors. - Address: 646 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/CookiePlug4 ### 24. Prime 47- Indy's Steakhouse Steakhouse shines with old vault wine locker and intimate atmosphere. Enjoy fresh baked chocolate chip cookies with ice cream for dessert. Drinks include well-crafted cocktails that pair well with high-quality steaks and seafood. - Address: 47 S Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Prime-47--Indy's-Steakhouse ## Get this data directly This page comes from the Atly Places API, which scores close to 2 million places against more than 1,400 intents — "nice view", "work friendly", "gluten free", "dog friendly" — from what real reviewers say, with the statements behind every score. - **MCP server:** `https://agentic-api.atly.com/mcp` — connect it in ChatGPT or Claude. Nothing to install. - **Guide for agents:** - **OpenAPI contract:** - **No key needed to start.** `POST https://agentic-api.atly.com/v0/keys` with an email raises the quota. Coverage is densest in the United States, with pockets in Mexico, Israel and Thailand.