Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Unique hotel stays in New Jersey

Made for those who seek out unconventional architecture and design even when they are just booking a place to sleep.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Lokal Hotel - Cape May image 1
Lokal Hotel - Cape May image 2
Lokal Hotel - Cape May image 3
View all

Boutique hotel offers spacious, tastefully decorated rooms with ocean views and heated saltwater pool in a quiet, cozy atmosphere. Small size with only eight units creates a peaceful, private environment often shared with friendly families. Location is central and steps from the beach, blending convenience with a relaxing retreat feel.

Steps from the beach, this hotel offers a cozy, clean stay with many amenities. The small size adds to a comfortable, unique experience.

A unique pool stands out, adding a relaxing touch. Rooms feel modern and clean, creating a distinct stay.

People are saying

"I felt completely at home here, like my own house."

"The Hotel's location is perfect, just steps from the beach."

"The rooms here are uniquely decorated and feel like a friend's apartment."

Good to know

1

The hotel is just a 3-minute walk to the beach entrance.

2

Restaurants and the Washington Street Mall are within walking distance.

3

The hotel provides beach chairs and umbrellas for guests.

02
Coastal Chateau image 1

Hotel offers luxurious rooms with quiet, cozy atmosphere and modern amenities like keyless check-in and gourmet coffee. Spacious common areas include a rooftop deck with ocean views and a porch with rocking chairs, creating a serene and stylish environment. Family-run operation emphasizes thoughtful touches and proximity to beach and boardwalk.

Offers a luxurious boutique hotel experience with a vibe that feels like a private luxury escape. Stays here are consistently described as memorable and unique.

Interior feels like an interior design magazine with each room showing unique beachy vibes. The lobby stands out with its coastal-inspired decor.

People are saying

"This hotel was the most beautiful and cleanest place I've ever stayed."

"You should go to the rooftop to relax and enjoy the weather."

"The decor is luxurious, modern, and uniquely French-inspired."

Good to know

1

Live music on the rooftop happens from 6:30 to 8:30 PM on select nights.

2

The rooftop offers a great view for watching fireworks on July 4th.

3

The hotel is just a 3-minute walk to the boardwalk and beach.

03
Ocean City Mansion image 1

Victorian mansion offers unique, cozy rooms with historic decor and pet-friendly accommodations. Quiet location near the beach creates a peaceful atmosphere with a home-like vibe. Amenities include full kitchens, comfortable beds, and inviting porches.

Historic hotel offers a well-kept environment with friendly staff who treat guests like friends. Free street parking right in front makes arrival easy.

Each room offers a unique layout that feels both comfortable and exciting. An open porch adds to the distinct charm of the place.

People are saying

"The beds were super comfortable and the rooms were clean."

"Nancy and the staff make you feel so welcome at this hotel."

"Nancy's kindness and coolness made it a truly unique experience."

Good to know

1

The mansion is close to the beach and boardwalk, yet in a quiet area.

2

Free street parking is available for guests.

3

Dog-friendly accommodations are offered, making it a great choice for pet owners.

04
The Carriage House OG, LLC image 1

Victorian-style bed and breakfast offers cozy, intimate rooms with beautiful period decor and private patios. The atmosphere stays quiet and peaceful, attracting guests seeking a romantic, calming getaway just steps from the beach. Amenities include bikes, beach chairs, and towels, enhancing the seaside experience.

Cozy and personal with a Victorian style that blends modern updates and historic charm. Guests enjoy lovely porches, garden seating, and a gourmet breakfast within walking distance to the beach and shops.

Rooms stand out with incredible and unique designs, each different from the next. Beach chairs and towels are provided, a fantastic and unique touch in the area.

People are saying

"The breakfast here was delicious and homemade."

"The innkeeper made our stay so memorable and accommodating."

"The rooms are uniquely decorated and feel so cozy."

Good to know

1

The Carriage House is just steps away from the beach.

2

Parking can be a challenge during the summer months.

3

The location is within walking distance to shops and restaurants.

05
Summer Nites image 1
Bed & breakfast

Rooms showcase distinct 50s, 60s, and 70s themes with memorabilia and period furniture. A vintage diner serves breakfast and refreshments with authentic jukebox music. Entertainment includes pinball machines, pool tables, and hot tubs, creating a relaxed, nostalgic atmosphere.

Rooms feature a distinct Elvis theme that stands out. The hotel stays super clean and has a cute vibe throughout.

Each room features a distinct theme with impeccable execution. The overall decor creates a welcoming and unique atmosphere throughout.

People are saying

"Sheila and Rick were the nicest, most dedicated hosts for breakfast."

"The themed rooms here are a fun blast from the past for Date Spots."

"I truly enjoyed my stay at this hotel; it was memorable."

Good to know

1

Snack time occurs daily at 4 pm with milkshakes and hot pretzels.

2

Special holiday packages are available for events like Elvis.

3

Breakfast options are included and offer two filling choices each morning.

06
The Asbury Hotel image 1

Hotel offers spacious, trendy design with live music venues and a heated outdoor pool. Lobby buzzes with energy from local talent performances and lively crowds. Rooftop bar provides ocean views and a vibrant setting for socializing.

Offers a funky vibe that stands out from typical venues. The lobby features local art collections creating a unique atmosphere. Staff are personable and cool, enhancing the overall stay.

Funky atmosphere stands out from the moment you arrive. The style feels unique and well-designed, creating a fun and memorable vibe throughout.

People are saying

"It's the perfect spot for date spots, with the beach and boardwalk just steps away."

"The staff at this Hotel are so friendly and make you feel welcome."

"It's a unique hotel with a funky, surreal atmosphere."

Good to know

1

Parking costs $50 per day for valet service; street parking is limited.

2

Rooftop movie nights occur regularly; check the schedule for upcoming films.

3

The Hi-Tide summer pool parties are popular and attract many guests.

07
Tavern on the Bay Hotel, Marina & Restaurant image 1

Waterfront setting offers stunning bay views and a romantic atmosphere with outdoor seating that enhances the dining experience. The vibe mixes homey comfort with occasional lively moments, creating a unique and relaxed environment. Soft beds and great amenities support a peaceful stay.

Feels like home with a welcoming vibe and a unique style different from standard hotels. The hotel bar is quiet and sparsely populated, offering a calm spot even during storms.

Dated furniture and visible repairs create a unique atmosphere that stands out from standard hotels. The place carries a distinct charm that feels different and memorable.

People are saying

"The food here is really good and delicious."

"The Hotel's bayfront view from the second floor is unforgettable."

"The view from the second floor is unforgettable."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers discounted prices on drinks and appetizers.

2

Expect a wait time of 15-30 minutes during busy weekends.

3

Parking is available on-site, but it can fill up quickly.

08
Bungalow Hotel image 1

Rooms offer spacious layouts with modern design and fireplaces, creating a bright, welcoming atmosphere. Lobby exudes cool, West Coast vibes with ample natural light and social spaces. Noise from footsteps above is common, making the hotel better suited for lively stays than quiet retreats.

Rooms offer spacious layouts with chic, modern decor and large amenities like shower gel and shampoo. Located near the beach, the hotel suits families, business trips, and vacations with excellent service throughout.

Decor features a very unique style that invites hanging out in the lobby or playing pool. Rooms feel efficient and relaxing with a lovely design.

People are saying

"The hotel staff here is amazing and friendly."

"The fireplace in the room made it feel so cozy."

"The bungalow's unique decor makes you want to hang out."

Good to know

1

Parking is available at an additional cost.

2

Rooms include mini kitchens with a fridge, sink, and coffee maker.

3

There are no amenities at the hotel, but guests can use those at The Wave for a small resort fee.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...