Bay Shore

Explore over 700 places in Bay Shore, New York for coffee, date spots, drinks, and more, all curated by locals on Atly.

UPDATED MAY 15, 2026

Best lists

Made for those who approach every meal as an opportunity to explore the local culinary landscape.

28 curated spots

Finding a space where the only requirement is to sit back and breathe.

22 curated spots

Made for those who refuse to leave their children behind and require environments that accommodate the whole family.

20 curated spots

Spacious, clean restaurant featuring a beautiful interior with roomy tables and a modern-classic hot pot setup.

Charming American-themed restaurant with a rotating state-inspired menu and a warm, eclectic ambiance.

Cozy small takeout spot with simple Mexican decor, offering generous portions in a welcoming atmosphere.

Bright, renovated traditional deli with a cozy, authentic atmosphere showcasing its rich history and community spirit.

Spacious, gigantic interior with a nicely shaded courtyard and lively, welcoming atmosphere enhanced by exceptional service.