# Pie in New York > Made for those who appreciate a standard American menu but prioritize finding the right slice of pie to finish the meal. Source: https://www.atly.com/united-states/new-york/best-american-food-pie ## Places (27) ### 1. Gibneys NYC Irish pub with live Irish music and big screens creates a warm, calm atmosphere despite nearby hustle. Crowd enjoys top-notch Guinness and hearty dishes like chicken pot pie in a clean, inviting space. Rooftop bar adds a lively vibe for post-theater nights. - Address: 228 W 39th St, New York, NY 10018, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/GibneysNYC ### 2. Barrotta’s Supper Club Live 3-piece jazz band plays in a low-lit, intimate setting with careful attention to detail. Atmosphere blends classy, relaxed vibes with energy reminiscent of a New York City club. Guests enjoy excellent cocktails and a speakeasy-style upstairs party room. - Address: 69 Wall St, Huntington, NY 11743, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Barrotta’s-Supper-Club ### 3. Cait's Key Lime Online bakery specializes in small-batch key lime pies with gluten-free and nut-free options. Pies balance tart and creamy flavors without excessive sweetness and maintain quality for days. Strong focus on fresh, carefully sourced ingredients and dedicated craftsmanship defines the experience. - Address: Jay St/Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Cait's-Key-Lime ### 4. Langan's Cocktail bar offers Irish Coffee and espresso martinis in a lively, stylish setting. American food shines with fresh hamburgers and perfectly cooked steak and eggs. Shepherd's pie delivers a generous portion with a great potato-to-stew balance. - Address: 114 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Langan's ### 5. The Pastry Box Small bakery with cozy seating and cute decor creates a charming atmosphere filled with natural light and soft music. The space feels inviting and cheerful, attracting those who appreciate a local vibe and world-class pastries. - Address: 515 E 12th St, New York, NY 10009, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/ThePastryBox ### 6. MOTW Coffee and Pastries Coffee shop offers modern, chic decor with purposeful wall art creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Space includes board games for casual hangouts or study sessions. Energy varies from peaceful and family friendly to lively with young groups laughing and chatting. - Address: 350 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/MOTWCoffeeAndPastries2 ### 7. The Sweet Tooth & Catering Dessert spot with affirmations on walls and cool music creates a positive, welcoming vibe. Energy stays super chill with friendly people and a beautiful, cozy setting. Known for creative, less sweet cakes and hearty breakfast sandwiches. - Address: 378 Marcus Garvey Blvd, Brooklyn, NY 11221, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/The-Sweet-Tooth-Catering ### 8. Jack Dolan’s Irish Pub Irish-themed pub offers a cozy atmosphere with authentic Irish menu and excellent Guinness pours. Music volume is high, making conversation difficult, but the vibe stays lively with fun patrons. Clean space includes a nice bar and dining room, creating a welcoming neighborhood spot. - Address: 296 Maple Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Jack-Dolan’s-Irish-Pub ### 9. Kerber's Farm Bright, spacious bakery with white and light wood decor and fresh flowers on tables creates a welcoming, cozy atmosphere blending coastal grandmother style with a clean, farm feel. Seating is limited despite generous indoor space, and vintage details add charm. Early opening hours and free WiFi support a relaxed, inviting pace. - Address: 264 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Kerber's-Farm ### 10. KJUN Small space with fewer than 25 seats creates an intimate atmosphere where the chef's passion is visible. Jazz music sets a lively, soulful vibe that complements the home-cooked meal feel. The crowd enjoys a fun, communal energy in a cozy, hole-in-the-wall setting. - Address: 154 E 39th St, New York, NY 10016, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/KJUN ### 11. Gallagher’s Steakhouse NYC Steakhouse shines with prime rib cooked to perfection and an enormous dry aging room visible from the open kitchen. Rich pecan pie and tangy key lime pie offer sweet finishes. Old-school jazz and a buzzing, crowded atmosphere create a lively yet refined dining vibe. - Address: 228 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/GallaghersSteakhouse ### 12. 4 Charles Prime Rib Steak house offers an intimate, clubby interior with classical music and a snug patio that extends the dining experience outdoors with air-conditioned seating. The atmosphere feels quaint and charming, perfect for quiet conversation and special occasions. Limited seating creates a cozy vibe without feeling cramped. - Address: 4 Charles St, New York, NY 10014, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/4CharlesPrimeRib ### 13. Lundy's of Brooklyn Wood-burning fireplace and old-school sophistication create a warm, inviting atmosphere with classic elegance and subtle modern touches. Large, comfortable tables fill a space that balances historic charm with contemporary updates. Cocktails and seafood dishes reflect thoughtful quality, enhancing a timeless, vibrant dining experience. - Address: 44 Beard St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Lundy's-of-Brooklyn ### 14. Front Street Station Dining inside a converted trolley car with train-themed decor creates a unique vintage vibe. The atmosphere stays quiet and cozy, with bright, airy spaces and a friendly, unhurried pace. Outdoor seating on a deck offers a relaxed spot for people watching and enjoying cool breezes. - Address: 212 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/FrontStreetStation ### 15. Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie Pie shop sits by the water with outdoor picnic seating and views of New York Harbor. Atmosphere ranges from quiet and cozy to bustling and lively, with a few wooden tables and benches outside. Customers enjoy treats while overlooking the waterfront and nearby park. - Address: 185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Steve's-Authentic-Key-Lime-Pie ### 16. Au Cheval Graffiti-adorned alley leads into a modern, rustic space with dim lighting and upbeat ambiance. A lively atmosphere fills the restaurant, with a secret speakeasy bar downstairs offering a more intimate setting. The place draws a crowd that appreciates a cozy yet trendy vibe. - Address: 33 Cortlandt Alley, New York, NY 10013, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/AuCheval ### 17. Skinflints Traditional American restaurant with long bar and large electric trains circling the room creates a lively, cozy atmosphere. Busy during sports games, it offers outdoor seating and festive decorations year-round. The space features wood and stained glass, reflecting its past as an ice cream parlour. - Address: 482 79th St, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Skinflints ### 18. Chowder Bar Tiny shack on the waterfront with an old school clam shack vibe and nautical decor creates a cozy, quiet atmosphere. Families with kids feel welcome in this casual, no-frills setting where local seafood and chowder take center stage. - Address: 123 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/ChowderBar ### 19. Sweetwater Indoor space combines cozy decor with detailed vintage touches, creating a homey atmosphere. Two outdoor areas include a heated garden patio and a covered rooftop terrace, offering quieter dining options. The vibe is lively and fun, with supreme background music enhancing the experience. - Address: 105 N 6th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Sweetwater ### 20. Nowon Bushwick Spacious Korean restaurant with neon lights and hip-hop music videos projected on the walls creates a lively, cozy vibe. Music features hip-hop and 2000s RnB, often with a DJ, setting a chill, energetic atmosphere. Outdoor seating and tiger motif decor add unique touches to the stylish space. - Address: 436 Jefferson St, Brooklyn, NY 11237, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/NowonBushwick ### 21. Archer & Goat American restaurant offers intimate vibe with front and back patios and a cozy, trendy atmosphere. Music plays loudly with a mix of '90s retro tunes, creating a laid-back energy. Seating includes tight but comfortable indoor options and ample outdoor space, attracting an eclectic crowd. - Address: 187 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, NY 10026, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Archer-Goat ### 22. The Naked Pig Bar space combines multiple TVs with loud, energetic music and a stellar DJ to create a lively atmosphere. Crowd enjoys casual vibe with plenty of room to sit, stand, or dance. Decor shows unique charm and recent renovation, balancing fun energy with clean, inviting surroundings. - Address: 922 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/TheNakedPig ### 23. Wolfe Tone's Pub & Kitchen Irish pub with traditional decor and a full-service bar offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere that embraces Irish traditions. Live music and DJ performances create lively energy, while spacious seating accommodates groups comfortably. - Address: 37 E 29th St, New York, NY 10016, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Wolfe-Tone's-Pub-Kitchen ### 24. White Oak Tavern English-style pub blends modern elegance with classic tavern feel in a cozy yet spacious setting. Music ranges from live bluegrass bands to DJs spinning throwback hits, creating a lively and inviting atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a relaxed spot for drinks and appetizers near a park. - Address: 21 Waverly Pl, New York, NY 10003, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/WhiteOakTavern ### 25. Traif Open kitchen with frying oil aroma and smoke drifting into dining areas creates a raw, urban feel. Back patio offers a wholesome, garden-like oasis with cozy lighting and plants, contrasting the lively, sometimes loud indoor atmosphere. Space suits both group dinners and romantic nights, with a casual, Brooklyn-esque vibe. - Address: 229 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/Traif ### 26. Modern Snack Bar Classic diner with retro decor and vinyl booths creates a cozy, nostalgic vibe. Atmosphere feels like stepping back to the 1950s, with friendly, familiar staff and a homey, family-oriented energy. Dining rooms are tight but add to the old-school charm. - Address: 628 Main Rd, Aquebogue, NY 11931, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/ModernSnackBar ### 27. BETTY Small space blends chill record store vibe with modern Scandinavian design. Atmosphere stays pleasant and lively, with loud dance music sometimes playing even in the morning. Offers unique experiences like dining in the dark and cooking classes alongside a full bar and outdoor terrace. - Address: 193 Henry St, New York, NY 10002, USA - Atly: https://www.atly.com/location/BETTY ## Get this data directly This page comes from the Atly Places API, which scores close to 2 million places against more than 1,400 intents — "nice view", "work friendly", "gluten free", "dog friendly" — from what real reviewers say, with the statements behind every score. - **MCP server:** `https://agentic-api.atly.com/mcp` — connect it in ChatGPT or Claude. Nothing to install. - **Guide for agents:** - **OpenAPI contract:** - **No key needed to start.** `POST https://agentic-api.atly.com/v0/keys` with an email raises the quota. Coverage is densest in the United States, with pockets in Mexico, Israel and Thailand.