Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Lively Baked Potato Spots

A baked potato served in a lively room that feels like a social hub, not a lonely cafeteria.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
The Lions Bar & Grill image 1
The Lions Bar & Grill image 2
The Lions Bar & Grill image 3
View all

Bar and grill with cramped bar area and open windows creates a lively, vibrant atmosphere filled with old school energy. Crowds gather especially on weekends, drawn by the fun vibe and engaging banter. The space feels like an extension of home, blending indoor booths and outdoor sidewalk tables.

Plain baked potatoes come with a simple, classic taste that pairs well with sides like cucumber salad. They serve it alongside other favorites like mozzarella triangles and burgers.

Weekends bring a packed crowd and an energetic atmosphere. Staff match the vibe with their lively energy.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be juicy and delicious."

"I enjoyed the burger and fries."

"The atmosphere here is lively and the crowd is energetic."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; it's first come, first served.

2

Expect long wait times, especially on weekends; plan to wait up to two hours.

3

The burger costs $19, and fries are an additional $4.

02
Connolly's image 1
Irish restaurant

Oversized pub spans four floors with distinct dining areas and a rooftop bar offering a quintessential Irish pub experience. Atmosphere is lively and noisy, with live music and a fun vibe especially during events. Crowds gather for authentic Irish drinks and hearty traditional food in a setting that feels inviting and exotic.

Extremely large baked potatoes stand out here. They look super good and fill the plate with generous size and hearty appeal.

Energy fills the room with a lively atmosphere and many people watching multiple sports screens. The place stays busy and energetic, especially in the heart of the theater district.

People are saying

"The bar staff here are incredibly friendly and make your experience enjoyable."

"The staff here is so friendly and welcoming."

"The baked potatoes here are huge and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers discounts on select beers and runs from 4-7pm.

2

The kitchen stays open until midnight for late-night diners.

3

Expect a bonus charge of $10 added to your bill without notice.

03
Hoexter's image 1
New American restaurant

Warm, cozy rooms with unique decor and wildlife murals create a Hollywood glam vibe. The space feels narrow and intimate, with a lively atmosphere that can get loud near the bar and hostess stand. It attracts a neighborhood crowd looking for a special occasion spot with standout cocktails and rich, flavorful dishes.

The loaded baked potato gets a lot of respect here. However, the plain baked potato often falls short and isn't worth eating.

Cozy and lively ambiance fills the small space. A young crowd keeps the energy up, making it great for a late dinner date in a dark setting.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the smashburger."

"It's a small, dark, and lively spot with a young crowd."

"It's a real gem for a date night."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekend dining.

2

There is a $3.00 extra charge for olives in the Martini.

3

You need to order a full dinner to have drinks at a seated table in the bar area.

04
Empire Steak House Times Square image 1

Steakhouse blends lively ambiance with a cozy atmosphere for a warm dining experience. Giant baked potatoes loaded with cheese and Canadian bacon make a hearty side. Sharp service and table-side dessert flambรฉ add unique, memorable touches.

Giant baked potatoes come loaded with tons of cheese and fresh Canadian bacon. Portions are large enough to share across the table.

Energy buzzes with a lively ambiance that mixes with intimate charm. Service stays sharp, matching the upbeat vibe without missing a beat.

People are saying

"I've never had a steak cooked so perfectly, it just melted in my mouth."

"The baked potato here is huge, easily big enough to share."

"The atmosphere here is so lively, with an energetic vibe."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a pre-theater menu only from 4:00 - 7:00 pm.

2

You can have a pre-theatre dinner between 4-7 PM for only DKK 350.

3

The happy hour offers a perfectly crafted burger and a glass of wine.

05
Nightly's image 1
American restaurant

Restaurant combines downtown chic decor with a 60's cocktail lounge vibe and sexy dim lighting. Atmosphere is loud and lively, perfect for dates or gatherings with friends. Outdoor seating adds a relaxed option to the energetic indoor space.

Twice baked potato looks unusual but tastes perfect, surpassing traditional versions in flavor.

Energetic and lively atmosphere fills the space, staying vibrant even late at night. Unique drinks like a special dirty martini add to the upbeat vibe.

People are saying

"The food at these dinner spots is delicious and memorable."

"You have to try the sticky toffee pudding; it's the best I've ever had."

"I'm on a quest for the best Baked Potato in NYC."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended because it gets packed.

2

The bar operates on a first come, first serve basis.

3

The restaurant charges $11 for mashed potatoes.

06
Red Lobster image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant spans multiple floors with large space and elevator access. Atmosphere mixes strong seafood aroma with a family-friendly vibe, though seating can feel cramped. Drinks vary widely, from notably sweet sangrias to well-received cocktails.

Baked potatoes come with seafood like lobster and shrimp. They pair well with dishes like fried cod and garlic shrimp. The potatoes are a solid side that complements the seafood variety.

Lively atmosphere fills the space with energy and warmth. Staff stay upbeat and respectful, enhancing the exciting vibe from the heart of the city.

People are saying

"I thought the Bobby biscuits were the greatest of all time."

"Our server was so upbeat and funny, it felt like being with a friend."

"I loved the baked potato with shrimp and lobster."

Good to know

1

The unlimited shrimp offer is available on Mondays.

2

The Wednesday deal includes lobster tail and steak for $32, excluding taxes.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy days like Valentine's Day.

07
Gallagherโ€™s Steakhouse NYC image 1

Steakhouse features an enormous dry aging room and an open kitchen where chefs prepare meals in view. Atmosphere blends old-school jazz with classy, buzzing energy, creating a lively yet refined dining experience. Seating is crowded, with tables close together, enhancing a bustling vibe.

Crispy skin makes a loud crunch when cut, adding texture to the baked potato. These potatoes stand out with their pure heaven flavor and texture.

An upbeat and historic atmosphere fills the space, with guests sitting shoulder to shoulder. Conversations flow lively and the setting feels warm and comfortable for groups.

People are saying

"The porterhouse steak was flavorful and cooked to perfection."

"The atmosphere here is lively, with classic old-school charm."

"The baked potato here is hearty, fluffy, and done right."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for lunch courses on weekends.

2

Lunch course is available until 4pm on weekends.

3

Expect around $130 per person for a meal with drinks, tips not included.

08
Peter Luger Steak House image 1

Classic steakhouse with old-fashioned decor and a brightly lit dining room creates a straightforward atmosphere. Energy feels comforting yet brisk, with staff moving efficiently around the room. Known for exceptional steak quality, it draws diners focused on the food rather than ambiance.

Oversized baked potatoes come twice baked and cooked to perfection. They pair well with prime beef steak and local Brooklyn beer.

Dining room ambiance feels lively yet intimate, with conversations that bring a strong presence to the space. Waitstaff share exciting background stories, adding to the engaging atmosphere.

People are saying

"This steak is tender and delicious, even when cold."

"The steak here is so soft and juicy, it melts in your mouth."

"The baked potato here is crispy outside and juicy inside."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash and US debit cards.

2

Securing a reservation is crucial to avoid long wait times.

3

The restaurant gets busy on Tuesday nights.

09
Smith & Wollensky image 1

Quintessential high-end steakhouse with a loud, boisterous atmosphere and an exclusive club vibe. Spacious layout contrasts with some cramped booths and high air conditioning. An adjoining room offers an intimate bar with skilled mixologists.

Loaded baked potatoes come with a display of fixings including cheddar, bacon, and cream cheese. They pair well with dishes like shrimp cocktail and lamb chops.

Energy fills the indoor dining area with upbeat staff and constant conversation. The lively Grill room features no-nonsense career waiters serving classic steakhouse fare.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the excellent steaks here."

"The baked potato was excellent, just like everything else."

"The atmosphere here is lively and full of energy."

Good to know

1

The "Weekend Wine Dinner" is offered Thursday through Saturday after 8:00 PM for $95 per person.

2

The weekend wine dinner includes 3 courses and unlimited wine for $95.

3

The Prix Fixe promotion is only available on Fridays and Saturdays after 8:30 PM.

10
Dallas BBQ image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Spacious barbecue restaurant with large dining area and rustic decor creates a lively, inviting atmosphere. Tables often have BBQ sauce bottles ready, and a photographer circulates to capture moments. The setting offers a view of 42nd street, blending indoor comfort with a street-like vibe.

The baked potato comes with a choice of sour cream that stands out for its quality. It pairs well with the combo meal, making it the best part of the dish.

Big drinks and hearty portions fuel a very upbeat atmosphere. The space feels lively and spacious, making it a solid spot for energetic dining.

People are saying

"The ribs here are so tasty and tender."

"You get so much food for the price, it's unreal."

"The baked potato was the best part of the meal."

Good to know

1

Reservations are advisable as the restaurant is always very crowded.

2

Expect long wait times, especially during peak dining hours.

3

A default 15% gratuity is added to the bill for larger parties or late dining.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...