Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New York's best

Banana pudding pie

Choosing between banana pudding and a slice of pie is impossible, so having both is the only solution.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
The Brooklyn Sweet Spot image 1
The Brooklyn Sweet Spot image 2
The Brooklyn Sweet Spot image 3
View all

Bakery fills the air with freshly baked goods and features plants on shelves and windows that create a cheerful atmosphere. The energy is steady with a local favorite crowd arriving early to secure limited pastries before they sell out. The shop stands out for its exceptional banana pudding and carrot cake, known for rich flavors and soft textures.

Soft, fluffy textures define the banana pudding here, with a unique taste that stands out. It pairs well with other desserts like red velvet cupcakes and carrot cake, all fresh and delicious.

Mini pies stand out with sweet potato and caramel apple flavors. Peach cobbler, apple pie, and banana pudding also get strong mentions for their rich taste.

People are saying

"I've never had banana pudding this good."

"I was hooked on their cupcakes since the day they opened."

"I thought the Banana Pudding was amazing and perfectly sweet."

Good to know

1

Weekends are their busiest days, so arrive early to avoid sold-out items.

2

Get there early as pastries and cakes sell out quickly.

3

The bakery is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.

02
The Sweet Tooth & Catering image 1
Dessert restaurant

Dessert spot with affirmations on walls and cool music creates a positive, welcoming vibe. Energy stays super chill with friendly people and a beautiful, cozy setting. Known for creative, less sweet cakes and hearty breakfast sandwiches.

Banana pudding comes with meringue on top instead of whipped cream. It appears as both a classic pudding and a banana pudding cake.

Sweet potato pie and cheesecakes like red velvet and Oreo stand out. Apple pie impresses with its flavor, and banana pudding adds variety.

People are saying

"The shrimp po'boy sandwich here is so delicious and perfectly breaded."

"The banana pudding is light, creamy, and refreshing."

"The sweet potato cheesecake is definitely worth the money."

Good to know

1

The shop was closed despite Google showing it as open.

2

This place does not have seating available.

3

The restaurant has breakfast specials available.

03
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 1

Cozy space with warm, welcoming atmosphere and tasteful modern decor offers both indoor and outdoor seating. The air carries a distinctive baked goods aroma, enhancing the inviting vibe. Seasonal animatronic decorations add a playful touch to the experience.

Rich and creamy banana pudding pairs well with soft pound cake. The pudding stands out as delicious and consistently satisfying.

Pecan pie stands out with a rich, nutty flavor that delights first bites. The key lime pie offers a bright, tangy contrast, while the banana cream pie delivers a smooth, creamy texture.

People are saying

"I got the perfect custom cake exactly as I requested."

"I enjoyed their apple pie and pecan pie."

"I found the Banana Pudding to be really good."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers many gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Seating is limited to fewer than five people, so plan accordingly.

3

They have seasonal coffee options that change regularly.

04
Leidylicious Cakes image 1

Small bakery with a retro pink and sky blue aesthetic creates a clean, charming, and cozy atmosphere. The space feels welcoming and full of personality, with limited seating for those who want to stay. Cupcakes and macarons stand out as the most delicious and distinctive treats offered.

Sweet and creamy banana pudding stands out with its rich flavor and smooth texture. Multiple servings highlight its consistent quality and appeal.

Pumpkin pie stands out with a rich, memorable flavor. Cheesecakes and key lime pies also offer a creamy, tangy taste that draws attention.

People are saying

"They truly made my cake vision come to life."

"I found the banana pudding here to be amazing."

"I thought the pumpkin pie was the best I'd ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of cupcakes and desserts including macarons and sugar cookies.

2

Prices are comparable to other bakeries in the area.

3

People with nut allergies should be cautious when visiting.

05
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Cupcake shop

Small cupcake shop with classic, old school design and pink, cute interior creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Soft jazz music plays while two small tables offer seating for quick treats. Known for outstanding cupcakes and unique flavors like banana cream pie and red velvet cheesecake.

Creamy texture and rich flavor define the banana pudding here. Staff often recommend it alongside a wide selection of desserts, making it a standout choice.

Banana cream pie stands out with rich, creamy layers. The pecan pie offers a southern-style sweetness that feels authentic. Apple pie appears in both classic and cupcake forms, with the Apple Pie A La Mode cupcake drawing special attention.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are amazing and delicious."

"I found their banana pudding to be unreal."

"I had the best pecan pie I ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

06
Ample Hills Creamery at The Social Brooklyn image 1

Colorful space combines indoor playground, pinball machines, and board game tabletops for a lively, family-friendly atmosphere. Music plays loudly, creating an energetic vibe that suits gatherings across generations. Ample seating indoors and outdoors supports both casual hangouts and kids' parties.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream here to be amazing and delicious."

"The kids' area was very thoughtful and the ice cream is amazing."

"I loved the original tastes and the option to make any flavor a milkshake."

Good to know

1

Customers can try a small sample of the flavors before choosing.

2

Customers may have to wait in line for 10 minutes even with only 2 people in front of them.

3

Doughnuts are only available on the weekends.

07
Rose Valley Cakes image 1

Quaint bakery with clean, sleek decor and upscale, classy atmosphere offers a quiet, zen setting ideal for working or meeting friends. Light music plays softly while a few tables provide space to enjoy vegan and gluten-free pastries in a warm, inviting environment.

Banana pudding comes in a cup and a cake form here. The cake has a vanilla crumble topping, while the pudding cup has bananas that taste like Circus Peanuts.

Meat pie features impossible meat and vegan cheese. Plans often include returning for Thanksgiving pie.

People are saying

"Their vegan cakes and pastries are so delicious and beautiful."

"You will not be disappointed with their selection of pie."

"I loved their banana pudding cake with vanilla crumble."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers lots of gluten-free, vegan, and sugar-free options without sacrificing taste.

2

Their prices range from $1 to $6, which is cheaper than other vegan places.

3

There is a free parking lot in the back.

08
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1

Bakery offers cozy indoor seating and a quiet backyard garden with beautiful lighting for a relaxed atmosphere. Space feels crowded and noisy inside, with tables placed closely together. Outdoor area provides a calm spot to enjoy desserts and drinks away from the bustle.

Rich and creamy with a whipped texture, the banana pudding has a cheesecake feel. It stays moist and flavorful, making it a very good and delicious choice for banana pudding fans.

Fruit pies and sweet potato pie stand out for their freshness and flavor. Banana cream pie and carrot cake also impress with their phenomenal taste and texture.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be amazing and delicious."

"I found the sweet potato pie here to be so fire."

"I found the banana pudding to be truly amazing."

Good to know

1

Mia's is open until midnight on weekends and 10 PM on weeknights.

2

Expect a 15-minute wait for to-go desserts during peak hours.

3

Parking near the bakery is challenging, with limited metered spaces.

09
Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center image 1

Small bakery with vintage-inspired decor creates a cozy atmosphere despite a chaotic layout and long queues. The space lacks seating, leading many to eat outside. It draws crowds with its large selection of cakes and cookies and a reputation for standout desserts.

Classic Banana Pudding stands out with its rich, creamy texture and balanced sweetness. A medium size costs around $7.25, and the banana pudding cookies offer a unique twist on the classic dessert.

Banana cream pie and pumpkin pie stand out with rich, classic flavors. Other notable pies include coconut, pecan, lemon icebox, and key lime, all served alongside homemade cupcakes and banana pudding.

People are saying

"I thought the banana pudding was sweet and delicious."

"I thought the banana pudding was the best I had ever tasted."

"I found the famous banana pie to be delicious."

Good to know

1

There is a separate line to order the banana pudding versus other bakery items.

2

You must order anything that is not pudding outside the line before getting in the long line.

3

If you're short on time, you can order your treats online and pick them up at the store to avoid the wait.

10
Martha's Country Bakery image 1

Spacious bakery with plenty of seating and an appealing design creates a welcoming environment. Evenings feature a live DJ spinning an eclectic mix of music, making the atmosphere lively and energetic. Outdoor seating adds to the relaxed vibe during quieter hours.

Creamy texture and use of real bananas stand out in the banana pudding. It ranks as one of the best-tasting versions, often considered the star dessert here.

Banana cream pie stands out as fresh, light, and fluffy. Other notable options include berry napoleon and sour cream apple pie, all homemade and delicious.

People are saying

"The pastries here are amazing and generously filled for the price."

"I loved the blueberry pie, it was packed with real blueberries."

"I thought the banana pudding was very creamy and delicious."

Good to know

1

On Mondays, gourmet cupcakes are on special for only $1.95 each.

2

The shop has a daily promotion with different specials each day.

3

They have a deal of the day where a different pastry or cake slice is half off.

11
Magnolia Bakery image 1

Small bakery designed for take-out only with a cozy atmosphere and sweet aromas of freshly baked goods. The space is limited, often crowded, with no seating inside but nearby outdoor options. Known for exceptional banana pudding and a variety of desserts.

Creamy texture and moist consistency stand out in the banana pudding. It balances sweetness well, avoiding being over sweet while delivering a delicious flavor.

Strong lime flavor and silky smooth creme define the key lime pie ice box. Pies like pecan caramel cheesecake and pumpkin spice pudding offer good taste without being too sweet.

People are saying

"Their banana pudding is smooth and flavorful."

"Their banana pudding is smooth and flavorful."

"The key lime pie here has a strong lime taste."

Good to know

1

Magnolia Bakery is for takeout only; there is no seating available.

2

Expect long lines on weekends due to high demand for banana pudding.

3

Banana pudding is often sold out by the end of the day.

12
Amy Ruth's image 1
Soul food restaurant

Soul food restaurant offers a family atmosphere with phenomenal murals and live R&B music at a low volume. Seating feels comfortable despite a small, somewhat cramped layout. The vibe suits celebrations and large groups, creating a welcoming, lively energy.

Large portions of banana pudding come free or with meals. The pudding is consistently described as very good and pairs well with dishes like mac and cheese.

Sweet potato pie stands out with its rich flavor and incredible taste. Other desserts include peach cobbler, pineapple coconut cake, and double chocolate cake.

People are saying

"The home-cooked food, like the meatloaf, was really good."

"This American food's fried chicken is the best I've ever had."

"I highly recommend the banana pudding; it's deadly and sinful."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times on Sundays due to gospel mass attendance.

2

Wednesday is Grape Kool Aid day, a special event at the restaurant.

3

Get there early if you want to dine in, especially on weekends.

13
Virgil's Real BBQ - NYC image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Two floors of spacious seating with giant sports screens create a lively, welcoming vibe. A big bar area and occasional live music add to the energetic atmosphere. The place fills with groups enjoying games and conversation, blending casual dining with entertainment.

Homemade banana pudding stands out with its phenomenal and excellent taste. It ranks among the house-made desserts that get consistent praise.

Pecan pie comes with ice cream and balances sweetness well. Key Lime Pie offers a great citrus flavor.

People are saying

"The American barbecue here, especially the ribs and brisket, is to die for."

"I found the key lime pie to be heavenly and full of flavor."

"I thought the homemade Banana Pudding was fantastic."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is from 3 PM to 6 PM and after 9 PM.

2

The happy hour offers excellent frozen margaritas for only $5.

3

$5 margaritas are available during happy hour.

14
Billy's Bakery image 1

Old-fashioned bakery with nostalgic vintage decor and cozy farmhouse-style tables creates a welcoming, charming atmosphere. Small seating area supports a community-oriented vibe with inviting product displays. The place feels like a classic American bakery with a touch of movie-like charm.

Banana pudding comes in cups with smashed cupcakes and tastes stupid delicious. Some batches use an instant recipe, which affects quality.

Banana Cream Pie stands out with its consistent quality and simple ingredients. Pies come in small servings, and inscriptions are not offered on them.

People are saying

"I ordered a gorgeous, custom cake that was exactly what I wanted."

"I thought the banana cream pie was a dream."

"I thought the banana pudding was stupid delicious."

Good to know

1

A slice of cake costs $7, but the portion is small.

2

The price of a cupcake is $5.25.

3

Billy's offers vegan dessert options for those who cannot have regular desserts.

15
Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South image 1

Tiny bakery with only outdoor seating on a small patio that fits about 20-25 people. Atmosphere outside is bustling and lively, often filled with curious tourists and street activity. Indoor space is compact and clean, but lacks seating, making the outdoor area the main spot to enjoy treats.

Creamy texture with real banana pieces defines the banana pudding here. It tastes light and homemade, offering a classic, authentic flavor that many find extraordinary.

Key lime pie stands out with a strong flavor and comes in a box version. Other options include pecan pumpkin pie, cheesecake, and lemon pie. The key lime pie pairs well with iced chai.

People are saying

"I found the banana pudding to be worth the hype."

"I found the banana pudding to be super delicious."

"You have to try the key lime pie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant actually closes at 10 PM, contrary to what is stated online.

2

There is no indoor seating; customers must head outside after getting their items.

3

There is no parking available.

16
Pies 'n' Thighs image 1
Southern restaurant (US)

Southern restaurant offers cozy indoor and outdoor seating with vintage diner and Brooklyn charm. The atmosphere feels intimate and lively, with great music enhancing the vibe. Space is limited and seating can be cramped, but the environment suits casual dates and quiet gatherings.

Banana pudding appears in two forms here: a cake and a pie. The pie serves as a common dessert choice to finish a meal.

Pies here stand out for their freshness and balanced sweetness. The apple pie offers a flavorful, just-right portion, while the banana cream pie is light, creamy, and not too sweet.

People are saying

"The biscuits here are flaky, buttery, and amazing."

"The fried chicken here is so crispy and moist."

"I found the pecan pie to be extremely delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to avoid long wait times.

2

The restaurant stops seating an hour before closing at 10 PM.

3

Seating is limited, so arrive early to secure a table.

17
NY Bakery and Desserts Times Square image 1

Clean space with luxurious decor and a chocolate waterfall wall creates a striking setting. Loud music fills the air, making conversation challenging. Outdoor seating offers views of street shows and passersby, adding to the lively atmosphere.

Rich flavor and creamy texture define the banana pudding here. It consistently tastes delicious and stands out among desserts.

Pumpkin pie and chocolate muffin stand out as very yummy options. Pecan pie has a hard crust and a sticky, gooey filling that resembles old honey, which some find off-putting.

People are saying

"The desserts here are fresh and absolutely amazing."

"I found the banana pudding to be truly delicious."

"I loved the creamy cheesecake and classic apple pie."

Good to know

1

There are no seats available inside the bakery, only outside seating.

2

The price of the apple turnover is $8 plus tip.

3

The bakery is located right in the middle of Times Square.

18
Little Cupcake Bakeshop image 1

Small bakery with neon lights, pink decor, and checkered floors creates a cozy, festive vibe. Seating is limited but comfortable, especially near large windows for people watching. The space feels like a small-town shop despite city location, attracting both locals and tourists.

Rich and fresh textures define the banana pudding here. It delivers a delicious and creamy experience that stands out among desserts.

Key lime pie stands out with a delicious flavor and appealing look. A variety of pies includes classics like Oreo cheesecake and unique options such as banana and pistachio pudding.

People are saying

"I thought the chocolate cake was the best I had ever tasted."

"The banana pudding here is super rich, delicious, and fresh."

"This carrot cake cupcake's flavors were perfectly balanced."

Good to know

1

The establishment closes at 11 PM.

2

Be prepared for take out because there is tiny space inside.

3

There are no restrooms available in the establishment.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...