Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New York

Expensive birthday cakes

You believe a birthday cake should be a centerpiece of craftsmanship rather than an afterthought.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Tasty Pastry Shoppe image 1
Tasty Pastry Shoppe image 2
Tasty Pastry Shoppe image 3
View all

Bright bakery offers wide gluten-free selection and exceptional cheesecake. Birthday cakes shine with beautiful designs and consistent quality. Prices are high, reflecting costly ingredients like almond paste, but treats remain worth it.

Delicious birthday cakes come with beautiful designs that suit all ages. Cakes for first and third birthdays show consistent quality and care.

People are saying

"I thought their cakes and pastries were better than I could imagine."

"This Italian bakery is a true neighborhood staple."

"I thought the birthday cake was delicious and moist."

Good to know

1

The shop gets really busy on weekends, but the line moves fast.

2

They offer a wide variety of gluten-free, sugar-free, and vegan options.

3

Small slices of pastries cost about $3 each.

02
Ivaโ€™s Sweet Parlour image 1

Pastry shop offers cozy seating and elegant, stylish decor with a friendly vibe. Desserts feature beautiful presentation and include standout items like tres leches and brownies. The atmosphere feels welcoming and quaint with a high-end ambiance.

Chocolate and dulce de leche birthday cakes come out delicious and well designed. Pickup is straightforward and convenient.

People are saying

"The tres leches cake here is so moist and flavorful."

"The chocolate brownie was decadent and to die for."

"The birthday cake here is great."

Good to know

1

Be wary of ordering on UberEats or Seamless as items may be forgotten.

2

The shop is open late for those looking for a sweet treat.

3

There is limited seating in the shop, so plan accordingly.

03
SHAKALAKA BAKERY image 1
Chinese bakery

Chinese bakery offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with rustic decor and soft lighting. Spacious seating includes free Wi-Fi and outlets, making it suitable for chatting or studying. The environment feels clean and comfortable with a large variety of pastries and drinks.

Birthday cakes here are not too sweet and offer good value for money. Custom cakes include Chinese style designs and come at reasonable prices.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautifully decorated and not too sweet."

"I loved the fresh, delicious pastries here; one wasn't enough!"

"I always ordered my son's birthday cakes from here and loved them."

Good to know

1

You have to make a reservation to eat at the bakery.

2

The bakery closes at 8:30 PM.

3

Some popular pastries or sweets will be sold out before afternoon due to high demand.

04
Conti's Pastry Shoppe image 1

Bakery offers wide variety of Italian pastries displayed in orderly glass counters within a beautiful, vintage atmosphere with modern twist. The space feels clean and inviting, with outdoor seating and a full coffee bar adding to the experience.

Birthday cakes come in custom designs and are ordered repeatedly for family celebrations. Cakes like Boston Cream and other pastries appear regularly for birthdays and special occasions.

People are saying

"They executed the custom cake design exactly to my vision."

"The pastries here are beautiful, fresh, and delicious."

"This birthday cake is beautiful and absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

You should preorder your custom cake in advance around the holidays due to high demand.

2

The bakery has a 2-day notice for placing cake orders.

3

Expect long lines on holidays like Christmas Eve due to high customer volume.

05
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1

Bakery offers cozy indoor seating and a quiet backyard garden with beautiful lighting for a relaxed atmosphere. Space feels crowded and noisy inside, with tables placed closely together. Outdoor area provides a calm spot to enjoy desserts and drinks away from the bustle.

Custom birthday cakes come with smooth ordering and on-time delivery. Options include vegan, lemon blueberry, Nutella chocolate, and Tres Leche flavors.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be amazing and delicious."

"This bakery's custom cakes are beautiful and delicious for special occasions."

"This birthday cake is light and so delicious."

Good to know

1

Mia's is open until midnight on weekends and 10 PM on weeknights.

2

Expect a 15-minute wait for to-go desserts during peak hours.

3

Parking near the bakery is challenging, with limited metered spaces.

06
Betty Bakery image 1

Charming bakery with a cute storefront and cozy interior invites visitors to relax and enjoy authentic baked goods. The atmosphere stays quiet and welcoming, making it a neighborhood staple known for delicious pies and cakes with unique flavors like cumin and coffee-infused frosting.

A 6-layer rainbow birthday cake is available for custom orders. Plans often include returning for custom birthday cakes beyond just one occasion.

People are saying

"This bakery's carrot cake is as good as it gets."

"I thought the chocolate cake was the best I ever had."

"They worked with me every step of the way for my son's birthday cake."

Good to know

1

Betty's bakery requires a minimum purchase of $10 when using a debit card.

2

Betty only accepts cash for purchases under a certain dollar amount.

3

A slice of cake and 2 cupcakes cost $18.50.

07
Lulu's Bakery image 1

Bakery space features clean glass showcases and decorative baking-themed door handles. Atmosphere feels homey and warm with a lively team working behind the counter. Pastries and cakes stand out for their freshness and high quality.

Specialty birthday cakes come with custom designs and careful attention. Angela handles orders personally, ensuring detailed decoration and delicious flavors.

People are saying

"The pastries here are decadent, creamy, and delicious."

"The cakes and desserts here are so moist and flavorful."

"This birthday cake tasted amazing and was exactly what we wanted."

Good to know

1

They do not accept Apple Pay or American Express as payment methods.

2

Pricing for round cakes is $78 and for sheet cakes is $90.

3

In order to pick up the cake, the remaining balance must be paid.

08
Villabate Alba image 1
Dessert shop

Old school Italian bakery atmosphere with heavenly aroma and beautiful, bright setup creates a calm, inviting vibe. Fresh Sicilian pastries like cannoli and sfogliatelle stand out as specialties. Coffee bar and ice cream add to the authentic Italian corner feel.

People are saying

"I thought the pastries here were excellent, even hard to get better in Italy."

"It's the best old school Italian bakery experience in Brooklyn."

"I thought their espresso was rich, creamy, and strong."

Good to know

1

You pay at the end of the line after telling them what you want.

2

The pastries cost almost $5 each.

3

Customers cannot take pictures or videos inside the establishment.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...