Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Margherita pizza cafes in New York

A margherita pizza served in a cafe setting that feels like a real meal, not just a quick snack between errands.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Novelli Cafe and Restaurant image 1
Novelli Cafe and Restaurant image 2
Novelli Cafe and Restaurant image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Cozy and elegant space with warm, stylish decor featuring glass, mirrors, and floral accents. Atmosphere balances lively yet intimate energy with a relaxed pace. Guests often enjoy fine Italian dishes like steak and salmon alongside delicious cocktails in a visually appealing setting.

Offers a classic Margherita pizza with a well-balanced flavor. The pizza pairs well with other dishes like butter shrimp and meatballs.

Warm and welcoming vibe defines the cafe. Each visit shows clear improvement, making it a spot worth returning to.

People are saying

"The bacon egg and cheese waffle during brunch was amazing."

"The Cafe's food is amazing, fresh, and flavorful."

"The Margherita Pizza here was very good."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay an additional 18% service charge on your bill.

2

Prices are higher than average for the portion sizes offered.

3

Total bills can be unexpectedly high due to service charges.

02
AMA LA VITA image 1
Kosher restaurant

Kosher restaurant with European-inspired decor and elegant, laid-back atmosphere offers excellent coffee and pizza. Spacious, well-lit interior supports both casual meals and work or study sessions. Outdoor seating and solid air conditioning add to the comfortable experience.

Cheesiness stands out on the Margherita pizza, making it richer than usual. It pairs well with the arugula salad and holds a key spot on the menu.

Cozy atmosphere with a neighborhood coffee shop feel and a touch of luxe. Coffee quality stands out, reminiscent of Italian cafes.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"I thought the coffee at this cafe was outstanding."

"I thought their Margherita Pizza was the star."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop offers free Wi-Fi for customers.

2

There are plenty of power outlets available for laptops.

3

The menu includes a wide variety of coffee drinks and pastries.

03
Caffe Napoli image 1
Italian restaurant

Restaurant offers old world charm with rustic decor that evokes Italy. Outdoor seating provides a people-watching patio complemented by live Italian music near the entrance. Multiple seating options include a basement area that can transform into a lively party space.

Thin crust holds fresh toppings with a strong pepper taste. The pizza is well-made but can be a bit undercooked, causing toppings to slide easily.

Classic Italian dishes like Clams and Seafood Plate with Homemade Pasta stand out for their fresh, tasty flavors. Staff are personable and professional, creating a welcoming cafe atmosphere.

People are saying

"This Italian food is the best I've ever had, truly exceptional."

"The cafe's pizza is the best I've ever had."

"The Margherita pizza was fresh, thin, and well-made."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers glasses of wine for $9, but prices rise after 8 PM.

2

The Feast of San Gennaro lasts for 11 days, providing a festive atmosphere.

3

You must order $25 or more for takeout from the restaurant.

04
IT Italian Trattoria image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant combines old-world style decoration with a warm, friendly atmosphere and loud music. Seating is plentiful but space between tables is tight, reflecting a takeaway-oriented setup. Known for exceptional pizza and desserts, it offers a cozy yet lively dining experience.

Thin, crispy crust holds melted fresh mozzarella and fragrant basil. Fresh, high-quality ingredients make the pizza stand out.

Cheese and tomato sauce stand out here, giving the food a unique touch. The cafe feels cosy and serves very good Italian dishes near Time Square.

People are saying

"The pizza here is simply divine."

"The pizza and bombolones at this cafe are pretty good."

"I thought the Margherita Pizza was delicious and reasonably priced."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is every day with special Spritz drinks.

2

You can get a full breakfast for under $20.

3

All pizzas are homemade with fresh ingredients.

05
Eataly - Flatiron image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Italian market and dining space combines multiple restaurants, specialty counters, and rooftop seating under one roof. Atmosphere ranges from warm and inviting to loud and bustling, with a mix of casual shoppers and diners. Frequent demonstrations and sample bars add an interactive element to the experience.

Slices feature a classic Margherita style with fresh basil and mozzarella. The ruota di carro Margherita pizza offers a vegetarian option with a rich, simple flavor. Some versions include extra toppings like salami for added taste.

Friendly service comes from staff like Tyrese who takes care of customers. Vegan options change daily but the vegan croissant stays on the menu. The ciccio is a giant cream puff filled with chantilly cream.

People are saying

"It's an amazing Italian grocery store with high-quality, hard-to-find products."

"The cafe offers delicious pastries and coffee."

"I found the Margherita Pizza to be the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Pizza by the slice costs between $7-12.

2

You walk along to pick what you want to eat and drink.

3

The location is tucked away in the back left corner by La Pizza.

06
Caffe Venezia image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers pleasant outdoor seating with cute decorations and a fun atmosphere highlighted by live music. The vibe stays relaxed as it rarely gets too busy, creating a comfortable dining experience. House-made gnocchi stands out as a signature dish among the menu.

Fresh basil tops the pizza, distinguishing it from just cheese. The crust holds a balance of crisp and chewiness, making it a solid choice to pair with wine.

People are saying

"The Italian food here feels like coming home, it's so welcoming."

"The cafe staff were amazing and made the night so special."

"I found the Margherita Pizza extremely delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great deals on drinks and appetizers.

2

The restaurant adds an 18% service charge to all bills.

3

Prices for drinks and food can be higher than listed on the menu.

07
Eataly image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian market atmosphere blends fresh pasta stations, high-end seafood, and multiple food bars under floor-to-ceiling windows with natural light. The space offers stunning views of a memorial plaza, creating a calm yet vibrant setting. Guests find a mix of gourmet shopping and dining with a posh, inviting vibe.

The Margherita pizza features burrata and comes at a $25 price point. It pairs with pasta but feels less substantial than expected for the cost.

A local Lavazza coffee shop serves creamy cappuccinos with a beautiful coffee taste and rich foam. The cafe area offers seating by the window, perfect for watching people on the street while enjoying Italian patisserie and other gastronomic options.

People are saying

"I learned to make fresh pasta in a fun, educational Italian cooking class."

"You can get delicious pastries and gelato at this cafe."

"I thought the Margherita pizza here was the most delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for busy weekend times to secure a table.

2

Eataly offers wine tasting and cooking classes for a unique experience.

3

Summer cocktails are available for $10 during happy hour.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...