Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New York's best

Cake and pecan pie spots

There is a specific comfort in pairing a slice of cake with a piece of pecan pie.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Ample Hills Creamery at The Social Brooklyn image 1
Ample Hills Creamery at The Social Brooklyn image 2
Ample Hills Creamery at The Social Brooklyn image 3
View all

Colorful space combines indoor playground, pinball machines, and board game tabletops for a lively, family-friendly atmosphere. Music plays loudly, creating an energetic vibe that suits gatherings across generations. Ample seating indoors and outdoors supports both casual hangouts and kids' parties.

Ooey Gooey Butter Cake stands out with chunks of housemade cake and ribbons of milk caramel. Ice cream cakes and flavors like butter pecan and pound cake also feature prominently.

Butter pecan pie stands out with its rich, buttery flavor. Butter pecan pie ice cream matches that with a perfect 10 out of 10 rating.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream here to be amazing and delicious."

"The kids' area was very thoughtful and the ice cream is amazing."

"I loved the original tastes and the option to make any flavor a milkshake."

Good to know

1

Customers can try a small sample of the flavors before choosing.

2

Customers may have to wait in line for 10 minutes even with only 2 people in front of them.

3

Doughnuts are only available on the weekends.

02
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Cupcake shop

Small cupcake shop with classic, old school design and pink, cute interior creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Soft jazz music plays while two small tables offer seating for quick treats. Known for outstanding cupcakes and unique flavors like banana cream pie and red velvet cheesecake.

Moist slices of cake stand out here, especially the red velvet cheesecake and Ube cake. Custom cakes like the 3-layer yellow cake with vanilla buttercream icing come out perfect.

Butter pecan pie stands out with a rich, buttery flavor. It ranks as exceptionally good and compares well to southern versions.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are amazing and delicious."

"This cake is so delicious, it's almost too beautiful to cut."

"I thought the pecan pie was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

03
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 1

Cozy space with warm, welcoming atmosphere and tasteful modern decor offers both indoor and outdoor seating. The air carries a distinctive baked goods aroma, enhancing the inviting vibe. Seasonal animatronic decorations add a playful touch to the experience.

Apple caramel crumb cake and crumb cake stand out for their rich flavor and texture. Cakes like the birthday volcano cake and double chocolate cake show detailed decoration and variety.

Pecan pie here has a rich, sweet flavor that delights with every bite. It pairs well with other desserts like crumb cake and apple pie, making it a standout choice.

People are saying

"I got the perfect custom cake exactly as I requested."

"The pistachio latte is made with real, lightly sweetened pistachio paste."

"I tried the Pecan Pie and it was the best thing."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers many gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Seating is limited to fewer than five people, so plan accordingly.

3

They have seasonal coffee options that change regularly.

04
Little Pie Company image 1

Open kitchen reveals bakers crafting pies, filling the air with buttery pastry aroma. Small, cozy space offers outdoor shaded seating and a homey atmosphere. Constant flow of people creates a pleasant, relaxed vibe.

Cakes here feature moist chocolate layers with rich, out-of-this-world frosting. Options include multiple flavors of cupcakes and traditional cakes like carrot and strawberry shortcake.

Rich buttery caramel flavor defines the Bourbon Pecan Pie, with a perfect balance of sweetness and plenty of pecans. Both the classic and bourbon versions deliver delicious, nutty goodness that stands out.

People are saying

"I tasted the best key lime pie I have ever had."

"I found the cheesecake to be incredibly creamy and delicious."

"I thought the cake here was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Little Pie Co offers 50% off select pies at 7 PM daily.

2

Pre-order pies for holidays like Thanksgiving to ensure availability.

3

Expect high prices; pies can cost around $64 each.

05
Peter Luger Steak House image 1

Classic steakhouse with old-fashioned decor and a brightly lit dining room creates a straightforward atmosphere. Energy feels comforting yet brisk, with staff moving efficiently around the room. Known for exceptional steak quality, it draws diners focused on the food rather than ambiance.

Chocolate mousse cake stands out as a dessert here, alongside a notable apple pie. Both offer rich, classic flavors that complement the meal.

Pecan pie comes gooey and nutty with just the right sweetness. It arrives topped with house-made whipped cream that pairs well with an Old Fashioned.

People are saying

"This steak is tender and delicious, even when cold."

"The steak here is USDA Prime, dry-aged on site."

"The pecan pie is gooey, nutty, and ridiculously hot."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash and US debit cards.

2

Securing a reservation is crucial to avoid long wait times.

3

The restaurant gets busy on Tuesday nights.

06
Abu's Homestyle Bakery image 1

Fresh baked goods fill the air with a warm, inviting aroma. The bakery serves a neighborhood staple known for delicious pies and cakes, especially bean pies that are moist and flavorful. Delivery options are limited to early weekdays, and orders may require patience.

Massive slices come with every cake, often lasting multiple sittings. Cakes like red velvet, carrot, and Oreo are moist, not too sweet, and made with wholesome ingredients.

Pecan pies here have a classic, rich flavor and a satisfying texture. They come alongside other pies like bean pie, showing a variety of traditional options.

People are saying

"I've been eating bean pies for 50 years and these are the best."

"The bakery's bean pies are legendary and freshly made."

"I love their red velvet cake; it's so moist."

Good to know

1

Orders can only be placed through DoorDash, not UberEats.

2

The bakery has a limited delivery window in the evening.

3

Prices are affordable.

07
KJUN image 1
Korean restaurant

Small space with fewer than 25 seats creates an intimate atmosphere where the chef's passion is visible. Jazz music sets a lively, soulful vibe that complements the home-cooked meal feel. The crowd enjoys a fun, communal energy in a cozy, hole-in-the-wall setting.

Desserts include a strawberry cornbread cake with just the right sweetness and a banana cake. Both stand out among high-standard dishes.

Pecan pie appears as a notable dessert alongside dishes like gumbo and fried oysters. It stands out as a classic Southern sweet complementing the savory menu.

People are saying

"The food here is a delicious Korean and Cajun fusion."

"The pecan pie was a great finish to the meal."

"The banana cake was a standout dish."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is recommended because the restaurant is often fully booked.

2

The lunch special is time-sensitive and can be missed if not planned properly.

3

KJUN is BYOB (Bring Your Own Bottle), so bring your favorite drink.

08
Gallagherโ€™s Steakhouse NYC image 1

Steakhouse features an enormous dry aging room and an open kitchen where chefs prepare meals in view. Atmosphere blends old-school jazz with classy, buzzing energy, creating a lively yet refined dining experience. Seating is crowded, with tables close together, enhancing a bustling vibe.

Chocolate layer cake offers a generous size with a light and airy texture. Layers include creamy filling and an intense chocolate coating.

Rich pecan pie pairs well with creamy ice cream for a classic dessert finish.

People are saying

"The porterhouse steak was flavorful and cooked to perfection."

"They brought out a cake to celebrate our honeymoon!"

"The warm pecan pie with ice cream is sweet and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for lunch courses on weekends.

2

Lunch course is available until 4pm on weekends.

3

Expect around $130 per person for a meal with drinks, tips not included.

09
Big Booty Bread Co image 1

Bakery offers an authentic atmosphere with freshly baked aromas filling the space. Small seating area provides a cozy, inviting vibe. Known for world-class cinnamon rolls and a strong selection of sweet and savory baked goods.

Cakes come out thicc and dense, matching the vibe of the bakery. They hold up well and share the same rich texture as the bread and cookies.

Mini pecan pies come out crispy, flaky, and tender with a rich texture. The pecan pie here ranks among the most flavorful and well-crafted versions available.

People are saying

"I loved the gooey center of these cookies; they were delicious."

"I thought the cakes here were pretty damn good."

"I considered this pecan pie possibly the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Prices for items can vary significantly; expect inconsistencies.

2

Cupcakes cost $4.50 each.

3

The bakery offers a great selection of gluten-free options.

10
Caffe Reggio image 1

Cafe offers historic charm with century-old artwork and an original 1902 espresso machine on display. Atmosphere feels bustling and cozy with dark wood decor and outdoor seating featuring heaters. Crowd enjoys the European ambiance and lively energy despite noise and crowding.

Excellent cakes come with a wide variety including cannolis. Pastries like homemade croissants and biscotti pair well with coffee.

Rich pecan pie pairs well with creamy ice cream. The dessert stands out as a delightful finish to a meal.

People are saying

"You should visit for the classic atmosphere and history."

"This place has such a charming and cozy atmosphere."

"I really enjoyed the pecan pie with ice cream."

Good to know

1

The sidewalk cabin seating is available on Saturdays.

2

The restaurant automatically adds a 20% gratuity on Saturdays.

3

Check your receipt because a gratuity charge may already be added to your bill.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...