Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New York's best

Organic cookie spots

Made for those who seek out organic ingredients in both their cookies and their daily meals.

Based on 739 Opinions
+736
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mila Bakes image 1
Mila Bakes image 2
Mila Bakes image 3
View all

Family-run bakery offers organic, high-quality ingredients baked with evident care. Atmosphere feels warm and personal, reflecting a strong commitment to homemade quality. Signature items include flavorful sourdough bread and melt-in-your-mouth cinnamon rolls that stand out for freshness and taste.

Cookies come out soft and fluffy with a perfect balance of sweet and tasteful flavors. Chocolate chip and marshmallow snowflake milk cookies stand out for their divine taste.

Baked goods feature organic ingredients that are simple and natural. These organic and simple ingredients play a key role in the recipes.

People are saying

"This sourdough bread is out of this world delicious."

"I loved the organic sourdough, it's so soft and delicious."

"These brown butter chocolate chip cookies are unreal."

Good to know

1

Mila Bakes uses organic ingredients in their baked goods.

2

Everything is made from scratch with care.

3

The ingredients used are clean and fresh.

02
Fortunate Hand Coffee House image 1

Coffee shop combines in-house tattoo parlor with unique decor featuring classic vinyls and art. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting with natural lighting and comfortable indoor and outdoor seating. Music plays softly, creating a relaxed vibe for both coffee lovers and tattoo enthusiasts.

Cookies here taste unmistakably homemade with standout options like brown butter chocolate chip and cardamom sugar varieties. They pair well with coffee and have a rich, full flavor.

Everything uses organic, locally sourced ingredients made in-house from scratch. The focus stays on wholesome, old-school scratch baking and real food without chemicals.

People are saying

"I considered this coffee spot a must-visit."

"I love that they use organic ingredients and make syrups in-house."

"The staff's warmth makes every cookie visit feel special."

Good to know

1

Parking is available with dedicated spots for customers.

2

All syrups are made in-house, ensuring fresh flavors.

3

The coffee house offers vegan options on their menu.

03
Rawmantic Chocolate | Dubai Chocolate Sugar-Free Vegan Chocolatier image 1

Chocolate cafe offers handcrafted vegan chocolates with clean, plant-based ingredients and sugar-free sweeteners. Atmosphere focuses on healthy indulgence, featuring bars that serve as quick meals or snacks. Customers appreciate the organic, keto-friendly options and the evolving product quality.

Chocolate cookies combine crunchy and chewy textures with a healthy twist. Cookies and truffles stand out as must-have treats here.

Chocolates here are organic and crafted with care, featuring guilt-free bars made from quality ingredients. Prices reflect the rising cost of organic cacao and other components.

People are saying

"This Dubai Chocolate is so rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced."

"I was blown away by the variety of their cookies and healthy snacks."

"This organic treat has a perfect balance of rich chocolate and earthy matcha."

Good to know

1

Rawmantic Chocolates offers vegan and keto-friendly chocolate options.

2

Products are perfect for travel or a quick meal on the go.

3

The selection of nutrient-packed snacks is available both in-store and online.

04
Sunshine Cafe image 1
Coffee shop

Bright yellow shop offers handmade cookies that pair well with drinks like milk tea. Fresh organic ingredients shine in dishes like slow-cooked rendang and crisp sandwiches. Cozy seating and a pet-friendly vibe create a warm atmosphere loved by locals.

Small handmade cookies come with drinks like milk tea. Cookies taste delicious and are popular for taking home, even with toddlers.

Food uses fresh organic ingredients throughout. The rendang features tender organic beef slow-cooked for four hours. Organic sandwiches and produce deliver fresh, zingy flavors.

People are saying

"The homemade bread at this Cafe is exceptional."

"Everything here is made with fresh, organic ingredients and so much love."

"I ordered milk tea and homemade cookies."

Good to know

1

Maria makes couscous on Fridays.

2

The price of the couscous dish is $32.

3

The cafe uses organic products and natural juice.

05
Sensible Edibles Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with gluten-free and vegan options offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere filled with friendly cats and comfy seating. The space features organic, allergy-friendly treats alongside charming touches like origami and candles. Sweet aromas and soft music create a homey vibe that invites lingering.

Big, chewy centered cookies accommodate dietary restrictions and use organic ingredients. Gluten-free options like raspberry crinkle cookies and oatmilk cookies stand out for flavor and quality.

Baked goods use organic ingredients that are also vegan-friendly and allergy friendly. Cookies, muffins, cakes, and brownies come from sustainable sources and taste fresh and natural.

People are saying

"I loved the delicious vegan baked goods, and they were dairy free too!"

"These vegan and gluten-free cookies taste amazing."

"I loved that their baked goods are organic and allergy-friendly."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide variety of vegan and gluten-free desserts.

2

Half off on select items during the last hour on Fridays.

3

The entire kitchen is gluten-free, ensuring no cross-contamination.

06
Cafe Blessing - Mineola, NY image 1

Cozy cafe with bright natural light and minimal, cute decor creates a peaceful atmosphere. Soft jazz music and friendly staff foster a quiet, welcoming vibe popular with locals and nearby workers. Roasted coffee and unique menu items like Korean bulgogi add distinct character to the space.

Matcha macadamia cookies pair well with a hot latte for a perfect match. Cookies here taste fresh and complement the coffee nicely.

Organic options include small batch sandwiches, pastries, and drinks like the Chagacchino made with chaga mushroom. Blueberries in the matcha are also organic.

People are saying

"The cafe owner brews the coffee herself and is very sweet."

"I plan to return for more of their amazing cookie."

"The organic staff here are really sweet and informative."

Good to know

1

The cafe is conveniently located near the Mineola LIRR station.

2

They offer a stamp card system that provides a $5 discount after collecting enough stamps.

3

Parking is metered right next door for 30 minutes with one coin.

07
Sixteen Mill Bakeshop image 1

Minimalist bakery space offers a cozy, intimate atmosphere with friendly energy. Gluten-free and refined sugar-free baked goods stand out for their quality and inventiveness. Regulars appreciate the gluten-free focus, refined sugar-free products, cozy vibe, and minimalist design.

Chocolate chip cookies come with a chewy texture and a sweet rice filling inside. They cost $7 and have a dense, oily consistency.

Everything uses organic ingredients with no refined sugar. The bakery focuses on small batch and nutritious products from small businesses.

People are saying

"The gluten free baked goods here have amazing flavor and texture."

"These gluten-free pastries taste like traditional baked goods."

"These organic treats are the best I've ever had, not too sweet."

Good to know

1

All baked goods are gluten-free and refined sugar-free.

2

The bakery offers a variety of vegan options alongside gluten-free items.

3

Payment methods include credit cards and mobile payments.

08
Rexer Family Farm image 1

Small climate-controlled shop offers organic produce, fresh baked goods, and unique pottery and crafts. Atmosphere feels homey and adorable with a pleasant, not busy pace. Mix of on-farm and local products creates a diverse market experience.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out as absolutely delicious. Other options include oatmeal, pumpkin seed, and date cookies alongside homemade cakes and pies.

Offers a wide selection of organic produce, including fresh vegetables, organic chicken, and meat. Also stocks local organic snacks and prepared foods like soups, pastries, and pies at fair prices.

People are saying

"I found the chicken pot pie to be delicious."

"They offered me milk for my son, even though I offered to pay."

"The cookies here are so tasty and adorable."

Good to know

1

The farm offers a variety of organic produce, baked goods, and unique pottery.

2

Prices are fair for local organic home-grown produce.

3

The shop has a good assortment of products including snacks and prepared foods.

09
goodsugar image 1
Vegan restaurant

Bright, thoughtfully designed space offers a fresh, welcoming vibe with vibrant energy and mindful atmosphere. Music and lively crowd create a cool, fun environment that feels like a small sanctuary for healthy, conscious eating.

Chocolate chip cookies are not recommended here. The cacao cookie stands out with a unique, clean taste and disappears quickly. Peanut butter cookies are crumbly and lack enough sweetness or saltiness, with a preference for a chewier texture.

Almost every ingredient is organic and made in-house. Options include vegan and kosher choices, all fresh and pure.

People are saying

"I loved their vegan treats, they were so moist and flavorful."

"I loved that everything here is organic and made with clean, high-quality ingredients."

"I found the cacao cookie unique and clean-tasting."

Good to know

1

Everything in the store is gluten-free, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Almost every ingredient is organic, so there is no need to worry about pesticides.

3

Customers can bring their jars back and get a discount for returning them.

10
Le Botaniste image 1
Restaurant

Space blends art deco and botanical-inspired design with bright natural light creating a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Seating is ample with a secret back area adding privacy. Energy feels like visiting friends, with thoughtful details and organic, plant-based menu options.

Gluten-free desserts include a Chocolate Pecan Cookie that stands out for its rich flavor. Other notable treats are the Omega-3 Brownie and Raspberry Raw Cake, both offering unique tastes.

Offers organic, plant-based meals with a focus on home-cooked style dishes like vegetable tagine. Serves organic wine and operates as a carbon-neutral restaurant.

People are saying

"The vegetarian food here is so flavorful and healthy."

"It's a great spot for healthy, organic lunch or dinner."

"I loved the soft but crispy chocolate chip pecan cookie."

Good to know

1

The entire menu is 100% plant-based, dairy-free, and gluten-free.

2

Expect a 20% service charge automatically added to takeout orders.

3

The establishment avoids single-use plates and silverware for dine-in.

11
Pura Vida Miami image 1
Coffee shop

Bright, airy space with modern decor and plentiful outdoor seating creates a vibrant, energetic atmosphere. Loud music and a chaotic vibe make conversation difficult, while a mix of people navigate the open, unreserved seating. Dog-friendly environment adds to the casual, lively feel.

Matcha Cookie and Pistachio Cookie stand out on the menu. Cookies sometimes get handled directly by staff during bagging.

Every ingredient is fresh and organic produce is standard. They avoid seed oils and use organic quinoa, but milk is not organic, which stands out given the focus on health.

People are saying

"I found the healthy food here to be delicious and fresh."

"You have to try the coconut guava cookie; it's amazing."

"The organic food here is served by friendly, attentive staff."

Good to know

1

The restaurant requires setting up an online account to order ahead.

2

This place cross contaminates everything, making it unsafe for people with severe allergies.

3

There are no clear pick-up directions for mobile orders.

12
Abracadabra Magic Diner image 1
Turkish restaurant

Turkish diner with whimsical decor and cozy atmosphere offers live jazz and jam sessions that create a happy, healing vibe. Small indoor and outdoor seating areas provide a colorful, vibrant setting. The place stands out for its homemade pastries including gluten-free and vegan options.

Large Inca Warrior cookie offers a delicious and shareable treat. Cookies like the Power cookie bring energizing and flavorful options, pairing well with coffee or matcha.

All ingredients come from organic sources, with many grown on the owner's upstate farm. The menu offers a wide range of vegan and organic options, including organic eggs and Turkish coffee.

People are saying

"I found the healthy food here to be fresh and delicious."

"The ingredients here are organic, many grown on the owner's farm."

"You have to try the gluten-free cookie; it's nutrient-filled."

Good to know

1

Abracadabra Magic Diner hosts fun events with live music.

2

The egg and cheese on a croissant costs $15.

3

Pitanga is closed on Tuesdays.

13
Barakat Halal Market image 1

Freshly baked Afghani naan and zabiha halal meat create a vibrant and inviting atmosphere. The market maintains a neat and clean environment with reasonable prices and a strong focus on quality. Regulars find it a reliable spot for authentic halal products and fresh bread.

Baked cookies offer a heavenly indulgence with rich flavors. Some batches taste old and horrible, showing inconsistency.

Fresh organic meat and chicken appear regularly. Halal meat stays consistently fresh and organic.

People are saying

"The Afghani bread here is fresh and amazing."

"The Halal staff here are so friendly and always ready to help."

"You'll find so many new products and Afghan cookies here."

Good to know

1

You have to call ahead to have the Afghan bread ready for you.

2

Fresh baked bread is available on Saturdays.

3

The store has a lot of different halal meat options.

14
Whole Foods Market image 1
Grocery store

Grocery store offers large aisles and a hot and cold food bar with a bakery and Amazon pickup counter. Atmosphere feels chill and friendly despite occasional crowding and loud music. Space includes a lower level with elevator and a bar overlooking a nearby park.

Vegan ginger snap and plant-based cookies stand out here. The chocolate-dipped lace almond and almond horn cookies offer a rich, nutty flavor. Free cookies sometimes come with bakery purchases.

Offers a wide selection of organic products including 365 organic Greek yogurt known for its thickness and taste similar to FAGE. Provides organic, non-GMO, sugar-free, and grains-free options in a spacious and organized setting.

People are saying

"I found the healthy food options here to be really fresh."

"The organic fruits and vegetables here are always so fresh."

"I found the double chocolate and vegan ginger snap cookies delicious."

Good to know

1

There is an Amazon return counter in the back of the store.

2

The store accepts EBT stamps.

3

There is no bathroom for customers.

15
Foodtown of Noll image 1
Grocery store

Spacious supermarket with beautiful decor and a welcoming atmosphere that feels both family-owned and neighborhood-focused. Features include pet-friendly carts, a sushi bar, deli with hot buffet, and a salad bar offering diverse fresh options. The store combines a modern, clean layout with a small-town vibe and big-city selection.

Shelves hold unique cookies like Tim Tams and limited edition treats such as Butterbeer Harry Potter Keebler cookies. Some boxes contain expired items, so freshness varies.

Large produce section offers organic options for almost everything. Organic vegetables, including fresh kale, are available alongside non-organic products.

People are saying

"The staff at this grocery store are always friendly and helpful."

"I found the prices here to be surprisingly affordable."

"I found fun, limited edition cookies I hadn't seen elsewhere."

Good to know

1

Foodtown of Noll is well-stocked with a variety of products.

2

The store is always clean and organized.

3

They offer a great selection of fresh produce.

16
Spring Cafe Aspen image 1

Large windows fill the space with natural light and offer people-watching views. The atmosphere blends chic decor with a chill vibe and good music, creating a bright and modern setting. Plenty of seating inside and outside supports both work and relaxation.

Peanut butter banana cookies stand out with rich flavors and a soft texture. Gluten-free and dairy-free options exist, stored under lids to keep them fresh and clean.

Everything uses organic produce and grass-fed butter. The menu features clean, vegan, and gluten-free options with a focus on vegetarian dishes.

People are saying

"I had the best vegan burrito Iโ€™ve ever had here."

"I discovered they have a variety of gluten-free cookies."

"The organic food here is delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; customers must order at the counter.

2

The restaurant offers many vegan and gluten-free options.

3

Expect a 10-minute wait for espresso during busy hours.

17
Trader Joe's image 1
Grocery store

Grocery store offers a comfortable layout with beautiful flowers and plants enhancing the space. Atmosphere ranges from pleasant and family-friendly to hectic during busy times, with many cashiers keeping lines moving. Known for affordable, high-quality food and a strong selection of snacks and produce.

Trader's Joe oatmeal cookies come in a pack of 10 for $3.99 and taste very fresh. The store also stocks a wide range of cookies, alongside chocolate snacks and potato chips.

Offers a wide range of organic produce and specialty foods at reasonable prices. Includes affordable items like organic milk, eggs, and bagged salads, plus unique healthy products for the body.

People are saying

"I found it to be a great grocery store with quality products."

"I found organic produce and meats at very reasonable prices."

"I tried the fresh, tasty oatmeal cookies."

Good to know

1

Trader Joe's is located on 23rd street and 6th Ave in NYC.

2

This Trader Joe's is only a block away from the F train.

3

I found Trader Joe's well stocked.

18
Culture An American Yogurt Company & Juice Bar by Culture image 1

Frozen yogurt made on premises appears behind a large glass window, creating a fresh, authentic feel. Indoor seating is cozy but limited, with a few outdoor seats available. The atmosphere is chill and comfortable, attracting those who appreciate tart, healthy flavors without excessive sweetness.

Biscoff and oatmeal raisin cookie crumbs add distinctive flavors to desserts. Yogurt cookie sandwiches and frozen yogurt come with toppings like dark chocolate sauce and Oreo cookie crumbs.

Selection includes organic strawberry banana and other fresh flavors like mint and ruby peach. Ingredients often surpass typical frozen yogurt shops with many options clearly organic and priced reasonably.

People are saying

"The mochi here is really good and not too sweet."

"I loved the fresh, non-artificial taste of the organic frozen yogurt."

"The yogurt tasted authentic and not overly sweet."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 10-15 minutes during peak hours.

2

Prices for frozen yogurt start at $10 for a medium cup with toppings.

3

There is no bathroom available for paying customers.

19
Mast Market image 1
Organic food store

Organic food store combines sleek minimalism with a curated selection of artisan goods and local produce. Atmosphere varies from quiet and cozy for working to lively and noisy at times, with limited seating and a welcoming vibe for families. Offers high-quality coffee and unique ice cream flavors alongside an upscale market experience.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their great flavor and freshness. Cookies come in disposable plastic containers for single use.

Variety of local organic products fills the shelves. Coffee uses organic milk exclusively, appealing to the organic crowd.

People are saying

"The coffee here is great, and the staff is super friendly."

"I loved the organic coffee and the tasty baked goods."

"I thought the chocolate chip cookie here was great."

Good to know

1

Seating at the cafรฉ is fairly limited.

2

The prices at the cafรฉ/market are quite expensive.

3

You receive a $1 credit when you bring back the glass bottles.

20
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 1

Upscale diner with cramped seating and dim lighting creates a classic yet hectic atmosphere. Live music and a small patio add to the vibe, while bottomless mimosas and standout dishes like the burger and French toast draw attention. Crowds fill the space, making it lively but noisy.

They offer gigantic cookies that work well as a dessert. A cookie milkshake is also available and popular. Cookies are sometimes given as a parting treat.

Mostly uses organic ingredients like eggs and maple syrup, which adds freshness to dishes. The organic chicken has a noticeable plastic taste and lacks quality.

People are saying

"The food here is a peaceful escape from busy routines."

"They warmed up my cookie and refilled my coffee without asking."

"I loved that they used organic eggs for their omelette dishes."

Good to know

1

Make reservations for Easter Sunday to ensure a spot.

2

Unlimited mimosas for $20 are available every day all day.

3

Bottomless mimosas and waffles are available on Sunday morning.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...