Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New York's best

Ice cream sandwich spots

An ice cream sandwich is the only acceptable way to end a date that prioritizes playfulness over formality.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
The Ivy Room image 1
The Ivy Room image 2
The Ivy Room image 3
View all
Restaurant

Intimate rooftop piano lounge offers a cozy, romantic atmosphere with live jazz music enhancing the elegant vibe. Seating includes a patio area and space suited for private events. Signature craft cocktails complement the refined setting.

Atmosphere suits intimate dates and small groups well. It creates a fantastic vibe for a date night experience.

Chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches offer a delicately decadent treat with a rich, sweet flavor. Cream puffs also serve as a popular dessert choice for those craving something sweet.

People are saying

"The brunch staff sang happy birthday and surprised me."

"The steak and fries at these date spots were delicious."

"The chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich is delicately decadent."

Good to know

1

On Wednesdays, selected bottles of wine are offered at reduced prices.

2

The Sunday jazz brunch features live music and unlimited mimosas for 60 minutes.

3

A reservation is required for the Wednesday wine discount.

02
Mitr Thai Restaurant image 1
Thai restaurant

Large venue with beautiful artwork and dangling bamboo stick art creates a unique atmosphere. Music is loud house and club style, making conversation challenging. Tables are packed closely together, contributing to a crowded feel despite the attractive setting.

Soft, perfect lighting creates a cool, relaxing vibe ideal for a date. The setting suits cozy dinners and special occasions, making it a solid choice for a night out.

A warm pillowy milk bun splits open to hold sticky rice, jackfruit, and a generous scoop of ice cream. The coconut and jackfruit flavors stand out in this dessert.

People are saying

"The food here is incredibly delicious and flavorful."

"The Pad Thai here is truly exceptional, like eating it in Thailand."

"You have to try the Thai-style ice cream sandwich with sweet rice."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.

2

Every party has an hour and fifteen minutes to eat.

3

The wait time is 1 hour during peak hours.

03
American Bar - New York image 1

Upscale restaurant with chic, lounge-style interior and indoor and outdoor patio seating creates a buzzy, trendy atmosphere. Crowd tends to be well-heeled and fashionable, enjoying highly recommended martinis and generous portions. Seating includes beautiful booths but some tables and wicker chairs feel less comfortable.

Works well for many occasions including date night and pre-dinner drinks. Offers a chill vibe suitable for couples or groups, with dishes like a large herb salmon burger and a cheeseburger.

Warm, gooey chocolate chip cookie holds melting cold ice cream with Oreo bits for texture. The sandwich blends soft cookie and crunchy crumble in a special dessert experience.

People are saying

"The service at these dinner spots is spectacular and attentive."

"The servers here are attentive and make your night wonderful."

"The ice cream sandwich was warm, gooey, with melting ice cream."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to avoid being turned away from restaurants in the area.

2

Expect longer wait times for drinks and food on busy nights.

3

Martinis cost $10 on Sundays and Mondays.

04
Super Nice Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Smallish pizza restaurant offers a cozy, sexy, lively atmosphere with soft lighting and tasteful decor in a beautifully restored classic NYC building. Full bar serves terrific wine and balanced cocktails while music selection enhances the cool, effortless vibe. Neighborhood crowd gathers here for phenomenal pizza and easygoing ambiance.

Quiet spots and lively tables coexist, making it fit for a double date or a catch-up with a friend. The vibe suits an intimate date night with great food and drinks.

Unique take on the ice cream sandwich offers a divine finish to the meal. This dessert stands out with its distinctive flavor and texture.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was truly amazing."

"The owner is so attentive; it's a nice touch for Date Spots."

"I thought the ice cream sandwich was divine."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended during peak hours to avoid long waits.

2

The restaurant is open late, making it a good option for night owls.

3

Expect personal-sized pizzas, perfect for individual dining.

05
La Churreria image 1
Spanish restaurant

Small indoor space seats about 10 with an outdoor table, creating an intimate and cozy setting. Warm, welcoming vibe with great music and seasonal decorations adds charm. Known for authentic churros and fun atmosphere, though seating can feel cramped and busy.

Churro ice cream sandwiches stand out as a sweet treat for date nights. Parfaits and churros offer simple, enjoyable options for sharing.

Churro ice cream sandwich features salted caramel ice cream inside a crispy churro shell. It stands out as a perfect treat with a sweet and crunchy texture.

People are saying

"These churros are delicious, hot, and crispy right from the order."

"The churros here are delicious and crispy."

"The churro ice cream sandwich with salted caramel was to die for."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait for a table, especially during busy hours.

2

Get there early if you plan on dining in, as seating is limited.

3

They offer 5 churros for $4.50, a great deal for a sweet treat.

06
Eyval image 1
Persian restaurant

Warm, dark interiors blend with unique Iranian decor and LED Farsi lettering to create a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Three distinct rooms offer varied seating, some tucked away for privacy. Cocktails with saffron and black lime add a distinctive twist to the dining experience.

Warm dates start the meal with a mix of comfort food and salad vibes. The Citrus Date Cabbage Salad with spicy tahini sauce offers a spicy, sweet, and citrusy flavor blend that stands out.

Saffron ice cream sandwiches deliver a rich, aromatic flavor that matches their online reputation. They stand out as a distinctive dessert option here.

People are saying

"The Persian ice cream sandwich was the best I had."

"You have to try the lamb ribs; they're a standout dish."

"The Persian food here is made with care and creativity."

Good to know

1

Reservations at Eyval open on Resy three weeks in advance; highly recommended on weekends.

2

The average wait with no reservations is about 2 hours.

3

If you do not have a reservation, you may get turned away after traveling to Bushwick.

07
Passerine image 1
Indian restaurant

Space combines modern cozy design with lush textures and moody lighting to create an immersive, warm atmosphere. Unique cocktails and an elevated bar and drawing room add to the sophisticated vibe. Guests find the setting inviting and the energy calm yet vibrant.

Ambience feels adult and brooding, setting a romantic tone ideal for date nights. The space suits intimate dinners and chic gatherings.

Elevated cocoa notes give the ice cream sandwich a nostalgic yet refined taste. It pairs well with other desserts like pistachio cremeux and offers a sweet, satisfying finish.

People are saying

"The food here was amazing, I can't wait to return."

"The food here is amazing; every dish was exceptional."

"The ice cream sandwich dessert was perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

Prices are on the higher side, with naan costing $8 each.

3

The restaurant has limited vegetarian main courses available.

08
Elio's image 1
Ice cream shop

Enjoy doughnut ice cream sandwiches with custom toppings in a friendly atmosphere featuring a retro Pac-Man game. Perfect for a relaxed date spot, it offers a cozy space to savor treats and share fun moments.

A nice and pretty spot for a date with a relaxed vibe. It offers a fun ice cream date experience that works well for meet and greet or date night.

Doughnut ice cream sandwiches come with options to build your own doughnut flavors. Cookie ice cream sandwiches use real cookies and stay cool without melting quickly.

People are saying

"The ice cream staff here are so friendly and welcoming."

"The staff here is so sweet and makes our Date Spots special."

"The donut ice cream sandwich was delicious and amazing."

Good to know

1

The dessert spot is open until 2AM on the weekend.

2

John Depp ice cream is 21+ only.

3

The ice cream sandwich costs $15.00.

09
Museum of Ice Cream image 1

Fourteen interactive rooms offer colorful, Instagrammable spaces with free ice cream at multiple stations. Loud music and many children create a lively, energetic atmosphere. Creative exhibits include a sprinkle pool and a massive slide, making the experience playful and immersive.

Offers a fun day date with playful activities like ping pong and arcade wack-a-mole. The spot suits couples looking for a cutesy selfie experience and a different kind of date night.

Bagel ice cream sandwiches stand out with their unique texture and flavor. The sprinkle pit adds a colorful, crunchy twist to the experience.

People are saying

"It's a fun, colorful, and interactive experience that kids will love."

"It's a fun spot for date nights with lots of ice cream and photo ops."

"The bagel ice cream sandwich is the best part."

Good to know

1

You should reserve your tickets in advance.

2

The cost is $60 per person.

3

Tickets must be purchased ahead of time and online.

10
Sofreh image 1
Persian restaurant

Small space combines Persian-inspired decor with a laid-back, inviting atmosphere. Backyard patio offers quiet outdoor seating away from the street. Unique cocktails complement the setting with distinct flavors.

Small portions and a bit of a rush set the scene for a cozy date night. Dishes like the tahini and date salad and lamb shank add a special touch, making the Iranian Sofreh a unique choice for dinner.

Outstanding flavor and texture make the ice cream sandwich stand out. It offers a special, memorable taste that many find life changing.

People are saying

"The food here is refined, deeply flavorful, and beautifully executed."

"The food here is amazing, truly inspiring and delicious."

"The ice cream sandwich was particularly outstanding."

Good to know

1

Reservations must be made almost a month in advance.

2

Expect to spend some cash.

3

Reservations are recommended as they take the first five people for bar seating each night and the rest are waitlisted.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...