Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New York

Hotels

Made for those who seek out obscure, off-the-beaten-path hotels that most travelers overlook.

Based on 481 Opinions
+478
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
The Modernist Hotel image 1
The Modernist Hotel image 2
The Modernist Hotel image 3
View all

Hotel offers spacious rooms with 360-degree city views and stylish decor. Atmosphere feels cozy and homey, with quiet surroundings and comfortable furnishings. Pet-friendly environment includes luxury amenities and well-designed indoor and outdoor lounges.

Uniquely located just outside Manhattan, this hotel offers easy access to the city with a 3 to 4-minute walk to the N/W subway line. The staff provide caring, genuine service and the hotel has every function needed despite its small size.

Offers a quiet retreat away from typical spots with a unique charm that stands out in the city. Stays here reveal a pleasant surprise for those exploring beyond usual destinations.

People are saying

"The Hotel staff are so friendly and helpful."

"The room had a spacious terrace with a stunning city view."

"The spacious rooms with high ceilings are true hidden gems."

Good to know

1

The hotel is a 15-minute subway ride to Manhattan.

2

It's a 4-minute walk to the subway station.

3

Guests cannot leave bags at the hotel before check-in.

02
Merrion Row Hotel and Public House image 1

Small hotel offers a quiet sanctuary tucked away from busy streets with cozy, intimate rooms and a homely vibe. Lobby features a bar and restaurant serving excellent food and drinks with attentive staff. Rooftop provides an incredible view and modern technology enhances comfort throughout.

Boutique hotel offers a home away from home feel with architectural charm and modern technology like digital thermostats and smart lighting. Located a block from Times Square, it sits close to theaters, concerts, and great dining options.

A spot tucked away in a busy area with a Public House Restaurant offering great food. It stands out as a hidden gem worth noticing.

People are saying

"The hotel rooms were super clean and comfortable."

"The food at this Pub is delicious, especially the shepherd's pie."

"The food here is amazing, a true hidden gem."

Good to know

1

The hotel is located just off Times Square, providing a quiet retreat.

2

Expect to pay an 'Urban Fee' for amenities like free wifi and water.

3

Check-in and check-out times are strictly enforced; no flexibility allowed.

03
Untitled at 3 Freeman Alley image 1

Graffiti-covered alley leads to a hotel with a grungy 80s vibe and arts-filled interior. Rooms offer quiet comfort with floor-to-ceiling windows and skyline views. Complimentary morning coffee and pastries add a cozy, modern touch.

Modern design and a creative environment shape the hotel experience. It offers thoughtful amenities like a water heater, shared oven, and ironing facilities, plus great location in the East side's heart.

A quiet courtyard offers a peaceful spot to unwind away from the city's hustle. This hotel stands out as a true hidden gem in the area.

People are saying

"The beds were comfortable and the rooms were clean and quiet."

"This hotel's morning coffee and pastries were the best."

"The staff here are genuinely warm and welcoming, a true hidden gem."

Good to know

1

The rooftop bar is closed on Fridays for private events.

2

A $25 cover charge applies on days with special parties at the rooftop.

3

Breakfast includes 2 pastries per person, served until 11am.

04
The Penny Williamsburg image 1

Rooftop spaces offer amazing views and a vibrant atmosphere with tasty cocktails and Mexican tacos. Rooms are well designed, comfortable, and equipped with small kitchens and coffee facilities. Free bike rentals and pet-friendly policies add to the convenience and appeal.

Boutique hotel offers a personal yoga mat, block, and foam roller in rooms. Booking to check out runs smoothly with a great overall experience.

Offers a quiet retreat away from typical spots with a cozy atmosphere and unique charm that stands out in the area.

People are saying

"The hotel staff were so patient, kind, and proactive."

"The rooms felt like a friend's charming apartment, so comfortable."

"The front desk staff are so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

The location is incredible, right in the heart of Williamsburg with tons to do.

2

The Penny is within walking distance to everything including restaurants, train, and shopping.

3

You are 15 minutes away from the city with the L train.

05
One Dutch Hotel image 1

Spacious rooms combine modern cozy design with well-equipped kitchens and comfortable bedding. A rooftop terrace offers relaxing seating and city skyline views, while a well-equipped gym supports active stays. The atmosphere stays quiet despite typical city noise outside.

Rooms stay clean and comfortable with a quiet, tidy atmosphere. The hotel offers a gym and rooftop area with city views and sits near major transit and dining options.

A rooftop offers a quiet spot above the city, giving a sense of discovery. The whole place feels tucked away, making it a true hidden gem.

People are saying

"This hotel's rooms are so spacious and clean, you'll have plenty of room."

"The rooftop offers beautiful views and a relaxed atmosphere."

"The staff here are genuinely friendly and always ready to help."

Good to know

1

The hotel charges a $300 cleaning fee that is not disclosed at booking.

2

The hotel is not licensed by New York Cityโ€™s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection.

3

The location is excellent, just steps from One World Trade Center and a subway station.

06
Opera House Hotel image 1

Repurposed opera house with historic decor and high ceilings creates a unique setting. Rooms are spacious and quiet, featuring king beds and modern amenities like blackout curtains and microwaves. The atmosphere is calm despite a lively surrounding neighborhood.

Rooms are large and comfortable with free wifi included. The hotel offers an excellent free breakfast buffet and features friendly, polite staff in a clean and secure environment.

The location stands out as a hidden gem that surprises many. It offers a unique charm that often goes unnoticed during routine activities like food shopping.

People are saying

"The hotel's continental breakfast is sublime and delicious."

"The rooms and bathrooms were clean and spacious."

"I found this place to be a hidden gem, my home away from home."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served in the mezzanine during the morning hours.

2

The hotel has easy access to Manhattan via subway, just a 2-minute walk.

3

The area around the hotel is very 'popular' with an unsavory population.

07
The Rockaway Hotel image 1

Hotel offers rooftop bar with skyline and ocean views and a heated pool with lively atmosphere. Spaces feature high-quality art and a calm, chic ambiance during the day, shifting to loud music and energetic crowds at night.

Offers wedding and event hosting with memorable experiences. Features hotel rooms, multiple restaurants, a pool, and spa all within a block of the beach.

Offers a quiet escape with beautiful decor away from the usual spots. Stands out as a little secret in the area.

People are saying

"The hotel staff's warmth made my stay feel personalized and special."

"This place is an unforgettable wedding venue with amazing service."

"The staff here are such hidden gems; they're all so friendly!"

Good to know

1

The Frances Pope Memorial Foundation hosts their 3rd annual Beach Ball on July 13, 2023.

2

Reservations are required for the restaurant.

3

Cabanas have a minimum spend of $1500, which may not suit small groups.

08
CIVILIAN Hotel image 1

Rooftop spaces offer amazing city views and a lively atmosphere with live music and crafted cocktails. Rooms are small but comfortable, featuring elegant design touches reminiscent of 1920s Paris and effective sound insulation. Bars include an intimate cocktail lounge with extensive Vermouth selections and live jazz, creating a vibrant social scene.

Excellent staff provide attentive service and create a welcoming atmosphere. The hotel offers a memorable stay with a perfect location that meets expectations consistently.

Exceptional staff and a spiral staircase stand out as intriguing hidden gems. A small music and theatre museum room adds unique charm alongside a lively cocktail bar and modern classic room designs.

People are saying

"This hotel is beautiful and stylish with a unique vibe."

"Waking up to the skyline view each morning was unforgettable."

"I found this place to be a phenomenal hidden gem."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the cocktail lounge during happy hour to avoid long waits.

2

Expect wait times of over 40 minutes at the bar during busy events.

3

The New Year's party had overcapacity issues, limiting access for attendees.

09
LY New York Hotel image 1

Rooms offer spacious layouts with modern amenities like sensor lights and digital mirrors. The atmosphere stays peaceful and clean, enhanced by gentle lighting and subtle scents. Guests enjoy incredible city views and a welcoming, elegant environment.

Offers a welcoming atmosphere with excellent staff providing very good service. Stays are consistently described as amazing and memorable, with management noted for quality.

Finding this spot feels like discovering a hidden treasure. It stands out quietly among the usual places, offering a unique experience away from the crowds.

People are saying

"I found the hotel to be super clean."

"The beds here are really comfortable."

"I found this hotel to be a hidden gem, like discovering a treasure."

Good to know

1

Free parking is available, but there are only 20 spots.

2

The hotel does not have a bar, restaurant, or breakfast options.

3

The hotel has a cleanliness issue, with reports of dirty rooms.

10
33 Hotel New York City Seaport image 1

Rooms offer views of Brooklyn Bridge and cityscape from private terraces. Atmosphere blends elegant style with some urban noise from street and nearby restaurant. Small, comfortable rooms contrast with lively bar and restaurant areas.

Offers a private terrace ideal for special occasions and a quiet gem atmosphere in the financial district. Staff provide excellent service with thoughtful touches like champagne and personalized notes.

Offers a private and secure atmosphere with a clean environment. Feels like one of the city's best-kept secrets.

People are saying

"This hotel's location is excellent for exploring the city."

"I loved the stunning view of the Brooklyn Bridge from my room."

"I found this place to be a beautiful hidden gem."

Good to know

1

The hotel charges a mandatory 20% extra for food orders.

2

Expect cold water and low pressure in the shower.

3

The hotel location is great with many nearby activities.

11
LIC Manhattan View Hotel image 1

Rooms offer breathtaking Manhattan skyline views and a peaceful, quiet atmosphere despite city proximity. Spaces feel modern and spacious, with comfortable, well-appointed interiors that create a retreat from urban bustle.

Rooms offer breathtaking views of the Manhattan skyline and feel modern and well-appointed. Staff remain friendly and helpful, providing local dining recommendations and quick assistance.

Offers a quiet retreat with unexpected charm away from busy spots. Rooms provide great views that many overlook.

People are saying

"This hotel is so clean and spacious."

"The views of LIC and Manhattan from the hotel were amazing."

"The Hidden Gems here offer breathtaking views of the Manhattan skyline."

Good to know

1

The location is perfect, close to public transportation for easy access to Manhattan.

2

Parking directly at the hotel is very limited; plan accordingly.

3

The area feels safe for walking at night due to good lighting.

12
The FIDI Hotel image 1

Rooms feature floor-to-ceiling windows with amazing views and a modern, minimalist design. The atmosphere is generally quiet compared to midtown, though nearby street noise can be noticeable. Amenities include a lounge with patio, complimentary coffee and wine hours, and fast elevators.

Located in the heart of the financial district, the hotel offers convenient access to subway stations and many historical spots. It features a modern, minimalist design with a calm, darker interior and provides customer service on par with 5-star hotels.

People are saying

"The hotel staff here is so kind and welcoming."

"The rooms are modern, spotless, and thoughtfully designed."

"The staff's heartfelt hospitality and local recommendations are true hidden gems."

Good to know

1

The hotel charges a $100-per-night deposit not mentioned during booking.

2

Expect a $35 destination fee charged at check-in without prior notice.

3

The hotel is cashless and does not provide petty cash for tips.

13
The Time New York - JDV by Hyatt image 1

Rooms vary from spacious suites to small, worn spaces with some modern decor. Noise from air conditioning and hallways often disrupts quiet, creating a loud atmosphere. Onsite restaurant and bar offer convenient dining and social options.

Rooms include a king suite option for special occasions. Location sits just two blocks from Times Square and Rockefeller Center. Guests get discounted rates for the nearby park.

Tucked into an unassuming building lineup, this spot stands out as a hidden gem in a busy area. It offers a great little discovery right in the heart of everything.

People are saying

"The beds are super comfortable with good pillows and thick duvets."

"This hotel's location is great, right in Times Square."

"It's a great little hidden gem in the heart of everything."

Good to know

1

The hotel offers a complimentary wine and cheese hour from 5 to 6 PM on weekends.

2

The location is ideal for accessing Broadway shows and Times Square.

3

Check-in is not available until 3 PM, so plan accordingly.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...