Old school pizza joint with a nostalgic 80s vibe and no-frills decor feels like stepping back in time. Warm, welcoming atmosphere with authentic New York-style pizza made by hand on the spot. Cash-only setup and a family-run tradition lasting over 40 years add to the genuine, personable experience.
Offers old school New York style pizza with a classic taste. Known for authentic thin crust and a true New York pizza experience.
Offers pizza that stands out as a hidden gem on Long Island, comparable to well-known spots like Gabby's and Margarita.
"I loved their fresh, crispy, old school thin crust pizza."
"My kids loved the pizza here; it's so Kid Friendly!"
"I enjoyed the excellent, authentic New York Style Pizza here."
Good to know
The shop is cash only.
Lunch special from 11AM to 2PM includes two slices of pizza and a drink for $6.
Eddie D's has been operating for over 40 years.
Small pizzeria with vintage oven and cozy vibe offers authentic New York style pizza. Known as a hidden gem, it charms locals with classic atmosphere and live music. Tight seating inside and outdoor tables add to the inviting feel.
Offers authentic New York style pizza with a taste true to the city. Known for top-tier quality that draws people from far away.
Known as a neighborhood hidden gem, this spot surprises with its quality and local charm. It stands out quietly in the area without much fanfare.
Good to know
Mano's is closed on Mondays, making it impossible to get pizza that day.
They had a pop-up on Monday.
Call in to see if they are running out of dough before making a visit.
Renovated space combines exposed brick and clean benches with a classic New York slice vibe. Warm, homey atmosphere feels like a neighborhood pizzeria with a contemporary old-school touch. TVs often show games, adding casual energy to the setting.
Classic old school New York pizza style defines the slices here. The pizza features a traditional thin crust with simple, straightforward toppings.
A spot known for its under-the-radar charm and solid pizza offerings. It stands out as a quiet favorite away from the usual crowds.
Good to know
Garlic knots are only available on GrubHub and DoorDash.
The classic slice does not use sweet pizza sauce.
Prices start at $10 for a pizza.
Brightly lit pizzeria with counter service and garage door seating creates an open, spacious feel. Atmosphere stays friendly and welcoming, with comfortable seating and good music. Outdoor seating faces a noisy street, which can affect the vibe.
Slices show quintessential New York style with a truly authentic taste. The pizza offers a very good balance of crust and toppings that captures the classic New York pizza experience.
This spot stands out as a hidden gem with its unassuming charm and quality that surprises many. It offers a quiet vibe away from the usual crowds, making it a unique find on Second Avenue.
Good to know
The price for one plain slice is $3.50.
Ordering ahead of time is recommended for a better experience.
They have halal options available.
Classic New York–style pizza shines with thin, crispy crust and balanced sauce and cheese. Spacious, inviting atmosphere with clean, modern design creates a great vibe. Known as a hidden gem, it offers top-tier quality while staying under the radar.
Thin, crispy crust stands out as a defining feature. The pizza delivers a classic New York style with a perfect balance of sauce and cheese, making it a true masterpiece of this style.
This spot stands out as a true hidden gem with consistently strong quality. It maintains a top tier status while staying under the radar.
Good to know
Nuovo is open until 3 AM on a Monday.
The deal of 2 slices with toppings and a soda for $10 is unmatched in Manhattan pizza places.
A slice is huge and costs about $4.
Pizza restaurant offers a cozy and chill vibe with private back rooms and a sunny outdoor patio. Guests enjoy free Mrs. Pac-Man arcade game and a bar serving wine, beer, and house soda. Atmosphere suits casual hangouts and dates with friendly staff and a clean, inviting space.
Pizza serves traditional New York style with a delicious, authentic taste. The quality stands out despite an unassuming exterior.
Offers gluten-free pizza that stands out. Known as a true hidden gem in the area.
Good to know
Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.
Expect longer wait times during lunch rush hours, especially on Wednesdays.
Most pizza slices cost around $7, including tax and tip.
Pizza restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating with big windows providing a spectacular view. Atmosphere feels cozy and well decorated, with a lively vibe supported by music and a dedicated party space. Guests enjoy a notable wine and beer selection alongside highly praised pizza.
Offers reasonably priced slices with a classic New York style crust and toppings. Pizza delivers the authentic thin, foldable experience typical of New York joints.
A spot known for its Italian food tucked away on 3rd Ave offers a fantastic hidden gem experience. The pizza and restaurant stand out as a great find for those seeking something off the beaten path.
Good to know
Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.
The breakfast pizza slice is available only until 12 PM.
You can get 5 large slices of a random variety of pizza for $5-6.
Glass walls and rooftop terraces create an energetic, bright atmosphere with city views and live DJ music. Indoor and outdoor seating accommodate lively gatherings and relaxed post-work hangs. The vibe blends laid-back city charm with moments of club-like energy.
Located in a busy area, this spot stands out as a hidden gem with a surprising charm. It offers a unique experience that feels tucked away despite the surrounding hustle.
Good to know
The restaurant is adjacent to Penn Station, making it easily accessible.
Customers should take the elevator to the dining room for access.
Roberta’s has a thoughtful beer and wine list available.
Counter service pizza joint with outdoor seating only creates a lively, classic New York pizzeria atmosphere. Small space feels like an Italian kitchen with minimal English spoken, adding to its authentic vibe. Outdoor tables include covered areas with heaters, making it usable in colder weather.
Authentic New York style pizza shines here with a perfect thin crust and classic toppings that capture the true NYC flavor. The pizza tastes genuine and delicious, reflecting the city's iconic slice.
A little hidden gem with amazing pizza stands out in the area. It offers a unique spot that feels tucked away yet delivers great quality.
Good to know
Pizzas are sold by slices at 3 to 5 dollars by flavor.
The restaurant is busy, so be prepared for a 5-10 minute wait.
There is no indoor dining and limited sidewalk dining.
Second-story setting with an old-school, regal feel and tin stamped ceiling creates a cozy, authentic New York atmosphere. Small and intimate space fits about 20 people, offering a quiet retreat from city noise. Music and TV screens add casual energy while maintaining a warm, welcoming vibe.
Thin crust pizza resembles flatbread more than traditional New York style. It offers a different take on the classic New York pizza experience.
Located in the middle of Manhattan, this spot offers authentic Sicilian pizza that stands out. It feels like a true hidden gem despite its central location.
Good to know
They don’t offer pizza by the slice; only half or whole pies are available.
If there are two or more of you, you’re required to order a whole pizza.
Expect a line during peak hours, but wait times are usually 15-20 minutes.
Cozy pizza restaurant with an old 1980s diner vibe and Greek family-owned charm. Spacious, clean interior features blue chairs and round bar stools alongside a diner counter. Outdoor seating offers views of the Hudson River, creating a welcoming and warm atmosphere.
Slices offer a classic New York taste but lean toward the average side in flavor and texture.
A hidden gem in a gentrified neighborhood serves incredible pizza with a Mediterranean twist. This mom and pop shop stands out quietly in the city.
Good to know
You can choose a free dessert if you leave a review.
They charge many 'secret' fees that can add up to $15 extra on your bill.
The restaurant may autotip without mentioning it.