Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Unique hotels in New York

A hotel with a unique character makes the experience of staying somewhere new feel memorable.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Warren Street Hotel image 1
Warren Street Hotel image 2
Warren Street Hotel image 3
View all

Stylish hotel blends modern elegance with classic charm through exquisite design and fine art. Rooms offer plush comfort and quiet luxury, featuring large windows and thoughtful amenities. Common areas and rooftop provide cozy, inviting spaces with impressive views and a relaxed vibe.

The hotel offers a chic, welcoming retreat that captures the energy of its neighborhood. Every detail in the design and decor feels like a work of art, creating a stunning and special stay.

Bold, colorful design fills every corner with artistic curation. The decor stands out as unique and carefully crafted.

People are saying

"The Hotel staff were so warm and welcoming."

"The decor is unique, bold, and colorful, with every corner artistically curated."

"The breakfast here is first class and delicious."

Good to know

1

The 1/2/3 subway is right around the corner from the hotel.

2

The hotel is located in Tribeca, about two blocks from ground zero.

3

Dining at The Warren Hotel is quite expensive.

02
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows image 1

Beach bungalows and motel rooms feature mid-century style and retro decor with spacious, elegant interiors. Quiet, low-key atmosphere blends private beach access with thoughtful amenities like bicycles and luxury soaps. Views of the bay create a peaceful, dreamlike setting with detailed design throughout.

Renovated into a high-end boutique hotel, it features unique interior design that honors its original era with modern updates. The place offers impeccable service and attention to detail, creating a peaceful and beautiful stay.

A high-end boutique hotel with top-rated chefs and impeccable service. The interior design blends elements of the past with a modern aesthetic for a unique feel.

People are saying

"The staff here made my stay memorable and were so helpful."

"This hotel's design is so detailed and beautiful, I never wanted to leave."

"The rooms are uniquely comfortable with plush towels and robes."

Good to know

1

The beach bar is open only on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday.

2

Reservations are recommended for dinner at the restaurant.

3

Breakfast is not available on Mondays and Tuesdays.

03
The Manner image 1
Resort hotel

Resort hotel offers stunning design with a warm, sophisticated atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. Quiet rooms contrast with a chic, lively cocktail hour and a rooftop boasting iconic city views. Amenities include luxurious beds, thoughtful extras, and access to a nearby gym.

A lovely new boutique hotel with terrific management offers a beautiful stay in the heart of the area.

Incredible service pairs with unique experiences and interior design that stands out. Lodging here offers a stay unlike any other in recent years.

People are saying

"The hotel staff made me feel so welcome and at home."

"The rooftop bar has amazing views and a great vibe."

"I found the hotel to be uniquely designed."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available at the 'Apartment' level with special drink prices.

2

The hotel is located in the heart of SoHo, close to many restaurants.

3

Check-in is quick and friendly, making the arrival process smooth.

04
The Greenwich Hotel image 1

Boutique hotel blends rustic charm with modern luxury in a cozy yet sophisticated setting. Atmosphere feels like a peaceful sanctuary with moody common areas and a romantic vibe. Spa and pool offer an incredible retreat that enhances the tranquil experience.

Understated luxury and thoughtful service define the hotel experience here. The guest-only lounge offers a quiet spot for dinner, while the exceptional shower stands out among 5-star hotels.

Ambiance transports you away from stress with a unique blend of comfort and style in individually designed rooms. Staff create a feeling of a unique house, making the setting just stunning.

People are saying

"The Hotel staff here are so friendly and welcoming, it feels like family."

"This Day Lounge is a wonderful and beautiful place to stay."

"The staff's genuine hospitality made this hotel feel like a unique home."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the restaurant, especially on weekends.

2

The hotel features a rooftop pool that is open seasonally.

3

Check-in time is at 3 PM, and check-out is at 12 PM.

05
The Fifth Avenue Hotel image 1

Hotel showcases lavish interiors with intelligent room technology and personal butler service. Atmosphere blends clubby charm with a warm, upscale vibe. Guests find it intimate and well-designed, with attentive staff and thoughtful details throughout.

Stunning architecture and lavish interiors define this hotel, paired with world-class amenities. Its great location near the subway and a house car service make getting around easy.

Welcome drinks feature a unique blend of grapefruit juice and cinnamon, offering a refreshing start. The hotel carries a distinct charisma that sets it apart from typical fancy hotels.

People are saying

"The hotel staff made our stay feel magical and wonderfully homely."

"The downstairs bar felt intimate and cozy, with an attentive bartender."

"The staff's attention to detail is truly unique and impeccable."

Good to know

1

The wine tasting takes place on the first floor every Saturday at 5pm.

2

The hotel offers free valet parking for guests.

3

Children are welcome at the hotel at all hours.

06
Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square image 1

Rooms offer spacious, clean, and luxurious design with comfortable bedding and breathtaking city views. The hotel maintains a quiet and comfortable atmosphere despite its central location, though some areas like the breakfast room feel crowded and noisy. Efficient services include fast elevators and convenient luggage storage.

Rooms offer every comfort with attentive service throughout the hotel. Location sits less than 50 meters from Times Square, placing guests in the heart of the theatre district.

Rooms offer unique views of the city. A distinct aroma fills the hotel, adding to the experience. The location stands out as well.

People are saying

"This hotel's location is brilliant for exploring."

"The nice view from the room was amazing."

"The hotel's location is unique, just steps from Times Square."

Good to know

1

The buffet closes promptly at 10 a.m.

2

Expect a 15 to 25 minute wait for breakfast during peak hours.

3

Happy hour is from 4 to 8 p.m.

07
Aqua Beach Hotel image 1

Small hotel offers private beach access and stunning water views with a quiet, peaceful atmosphere. Guests enjoy breakfast delivered in picnic baskets and relaxing outdoor amenities like a hot tub under the stars. The setting feels intimate and carefully designed for a slow, private pace.

Offers a relaxing beachside escape with a boutique hotel vibe. Staff provide memorable, enjoyable service suited for romantic getaways, celebrations, and trips with pets.

Beautiful rooms feature unique furniture and thoughtful touches that create a peaceful atmosphere. A Wine & Prosecco Happy Hour takes place at a distinctive spot overlooking Flanders Bay.

People are saying

"I loved the complimentary breakfast basket delivered to our room."

"The hotel staff are so welcoming and accommodating."

"The staff's welcoming energy and attention to detail is truly unique."

Good to know

1

Complimentary rosรฉ hour is available daily from 5 to 6 pm, one glass per guest.

2

The Wine & Prosecco Happy Hour features a scenic view overlooking Flanders Bay.

3

A Prosecco and charcuterie event is organized on New Year's Eve in the igloo.

08
The Hotel Chelsea image 1

Building showcases beautiful restoration with original architecture and quirky touches preserved. Atmosphere blends quiet, stylish rooms with a creative, inspiring lobby bar known for exceptional cocktails. Long-term residents add an authentic, lived-in vibe to the space.

Rooms offer a unique experience with a vibe that stands out in Manhattan. Service is consistently excellent and top-notch, making stays feel truly superb.

Historic charm blends with classic elegance and modern touches throughout the rooms and decor. Multiple bars and restaurants each offer a unique style and timeless atmosphere, creating a distinct vibe that feels like slipping on a warm robe.

People are saying

"It's like staying in an art museum, full of history."

"The Hotel's art and craftsmanship are exceptional."

"The rooms are spacious, comfortable, and have a unique, quirky vibe."

Good to know

1

The hotel offers a daily free wine happy hour for guests.

2

Breakfast is not included in the stay, so plan accordingly.

3

The bar operates on a first come, first serve basis for all guests.

09
Staypineapple, An Artful Hotel, Midtown New York image 1

Compact rooms offer extremely comfortable beds and quiet surroundings despite city location. The hotel features modern design with dog-friendly amenities and a welcoming atmosphere. Guests find it cozy and peaceful, with thoughtful touches like complimentary pineapple cookies and beverages.

Perfect location near Penn Station offers easy access without city noise. Rooms stay clean and the hotel provides exceptional service that stands out.

Warmth and charm define the space with an elegant decor that gives it a distinct character. The unique layout and a long list of thoughtful features create a hassle-free and memorable stay.

People are saying

"This hotel is so cute and clean."

"The beds here are super comfortable."

"The staff here is so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

The hotel is centrally located to all main sightseeing attractions in Manhattan.

2

Expect to pay an additional $25 plus taxes per night when checking out.

3

The hotel adds a $30 per night guest amenity fee at check out.

10
The Penny Williamsburg image 1

Rooftop spaces offer amazing views and a vibrant atmosphere with tasty cocktails and Mexican tacos. Rooms are well designed, comfortable, and equipped with small kitchens and coffee facilities. Free bike rentals and pet-friendly policies add to the convenience and appeal.

Boutique hotel offers a personal yoga mat, block, and foam roller in rooms. Booking to check out runs smoothly with a great overall experience.

Rooms feature design-forward accents with unique artwork, bedding, and toiletries. The hotel offers a modern boutique feel with thoughtful touches throughout.

People are saying

"The hotel staff were so patient, kind, and proactive."

"The rooms felt like a friend's charming apartment, so comfortable."

"The service here is stellar and the team is so friendly."

Good to know

1

The location is incredible, right in the heart of Williamsburg with tons to do.

2

The Penny is within walking distance to everything including restaurants, train, and shopping.

3

You are 15 minutes away from the city with the L train.

11
Untitled at 3 Freeman Alley image 1

Graffiti-covered alley leads to a hotel with a grungy 80s vibe and arts-filled interior. Rooms offer quiet comfort with floor-to-ceiling windows and skyline views. Complimentary morning coffee and pastries add a cozy, modern touch.

Modern design and a creative environment shape the hotel experience. It offers thoughtful amenities like a water heater, shared oven, and ironing facilities, plus great location in the East side's heart.

Street artists and filming create a dynamic atmosphere around the hotel. The entrance alley features graffiti art, reflecting a creative urban aesthetic that blends modern comfort with local energy.

People are saying

"The beds were comfortable and the rooms were clean and quiet."

"This hotel's morning coffee and pastries were the best."

"It's a unique place with genuinely warm and welcoming hospitality."

Good to know

1

The rooftop bar is closed on Fridays for private events.

2

A $25 cover charge applies on days with special parties at the rooftop.

3

Breakfast includes 2 pastries per person, served until 11am.

12
Henry Norman Hotel image 1

Hotel occupies a converted mechanic garage with an old school vibe and colorful art throughout. Rooms are spacious and unique, featuring terraces with panoramic skyline views. Atmosphere is quiet and comfortable despite proximity to busy streets.

Rooms have a unique layout with a penthouse roof deck option. The hotel features a cool old school vibe with classic cars out front, reflecting its history as a mechanic garage. Staff are friendly and accommodating, and a free continental breakfast is included.

Rooms feature a unique layout and are spacious with eclectic artwork throughout. The hotel combines colorful art and charm in every corner.

People are saying

"The hotel rooms here are really spacious, like a loft."

"It's a quiet neighborhood, feeling safe and relaxed."

"The staff's helpfulness and warmth made it a truly unique stay."

Good to know

1

Avoid booking basement rooms due to noise from street traffic.

2

Easy street parking is available, but it requires frequent spot changes.

3

The hotel offers a free continental breakfast for guests.

13
Mint House at 70 Pine by Kasa image 1

Spacious apartments combine art deco style with modern interiors and feature unique record players and fully equipped kitchens. The atmosphere is generally quiet and cozy, with minimal street noise and comfortable beds. Amenities include a rooftop bar, gym, supermarket, and multiple dining options within the building.

Rooms offer spacious, apartment-like layouts with excellent amenities. The hotel combines a great location with attentive service, including on-the-spot room assistance.

Rooms feature unique record players that add a memorable touch to the stay.

People are saying

"The spacious rooms are perfect for families and feel very Kid Friendly."

"The hotel rooms here are really big and spacious."

"The front desk staff are so nice and accommodating."

Good to know

1

Rooms are spacious, making them a rare find in Manhattan.

2

The hotel is located just steps from Wall Street and near a subway station.

3

Early check-in is allowed without any issues.

14
Jedediah Hawkins Inn image 1

Historic inn offers vintage rooms with gas fireplaces and manicured gardens featuring fountains and ivy. Atmosphere blends romantic charm with intimate spaces like a speakeasy for relaxed evenings. Guests enjoy peaceful settings such as a solarium and outdoor dining under sunset light.

Beautifully restored inn offers a historic charm with a Speak Easy and stunning gardens and architecture. It serves as a perfect setting for weddings and overnight stays.

A quaint and romantic venue stands out here, with a speakeasy that adds a unique twist for after parties.

People are saying

"The food at these dinner spots was outstanding and cooked to perfection."

"The hotel staff here go above and beyond for everyone."

"The food here is spectacular, cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

The venue is perfect for intimate events with up to 60 guests.

2

Karaoke setup is available for events upon request.

3

Plenty of parking is available for guests at the Inn.

15
The Maritime Hotel image 1

Hotel offers a nautical style with metal doors and porthole windows creating a ship-like atmosphere. Rooms are small but thoughtfully designed with excellent amenities like strong water pressure and dimmable lights. Location is close to nightlife and markets, though noise from the nearby club can affect quietness on weekends.

A quiet oasis with a nautical style, featuring round windows and boat clasp details. Staff provide exemplary service, including quick responses and early check-in options.

Unique design stands out with a boutique hotel feel. The vibe stays relaxed and the space is well maintained.

People are saying

"This hotel's location is superb, right across from Chelsea Market."

"The staff here is so friendly and helpful, making it feel comfortable."

"It's got a unique vibe and a really charming nautical design."

Good to know

1

The hotel is located near museums, the High Line, and Chelsea Market with easy subway access.

2

Breakfast is complimentary for all guests.

3

The hotel has a great location with easy walkability to Hudson Yards and Union Square.

16
The Shoals Suites & Slips image 1

Hotel offers coastal chic design with spacious rooms overlooking the bay and marina. Atmosphere stays peaceful and laid-back, enhanced by vintage boats for exploring nearby waters. Outdoor spaces include fire pits and hammocks, creating a cozy, relaxed vibe by the water.

Waterfront location suits boat enthusiasts with a dock to park boats. Renovated hotel features a well-decorated breakfast area and lounge with a piano hinting at live music. Nearby oyster farm offers an automatic oyster vending machine for convenience.

Access by train, floatplane, or boat creates a distinctive arrival experience. Stunning sunsets and cozy outdoor spaces add charm, while boat docking offers extra convenience.

People are saying

"I loved waking up to the patio with water views just a few feet away."

"The hotel rooms are clean, modern, and spacious."

"It's unique how each room offers bay views and a vintage Chris-Craft boat."

Good to know

1

Rooms include a small kitchen with a stove, refrigerator, and coffee maker.

2

The property is located right on the water with stunning views.

3

The hotel is ideal for boat enthusiasts with docking facilities available.

17
CIVILIAN Hotel image 1

Rooftop spaces offer amazing city views and a lively atmosphere with live music and crafted cocktails. Rooms are small but comfortable, featuring elegant design touches reminiscent of 1920s Paris and effective sound insulation. Bars include an intimate cocktail lounge with extensive Vermouth selections and live jazz, creating a vibrant social scene.

Excellent staff provide attentive service and create a welcoming atmosphere. The hotel offers a memorable stay with a perfect location that meets expectations consistently.

Building design and architecture stand out with thoughtful decor and unique touches in every room. Rooftop and second-floor bars add to the distinctive vibe throughout the hotel.

People are saying

"This hotel is beautiful and stylish with a unique vibe."

"Waking up to the skyline view each morning was unforgettable."

"Its location is unique, letting you walk almost everywhere in Manhattan."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the cocktail lounge during happy hour to avoid long waits.

2

Expect wait times of over 40 minutes at the bar during busy events.

3

The New Year's party had overcapacity issues, limiting access for attendees.

18
Henn na Hotel New York image 1

Rooms offer spacious layouts with Japanese style design and unique LG styler closets for laundry care. The atmosphere is quiet inside, though street noise and a noisy air conditioning system affect soundproofing. A 24/7 concierge adds a sense of security, and free access to a nearby gym enhances convenience.

Rooms feature LG styler closets that refresh and sanitize laundry. Location offers easy access to Times Square and multiple subway stops. Suites on higher floors provide spacious, clean accommodations with comfortable beds.

A unique door greeter welcomes guests, setting a distinct tone. The hotel uses a technology-driven concept that stands out clearly.

People are saying

"This hotel's location is super convenient, close to subway stations and shops."

"The bathroom's Japanese toilet with a heater and bidet was a pleasure."

"The staff's helpfulness and friendliness made my stay truly unique."

Good to know

1

Happy hour at Gosuke runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

The hotel is just two blocks from Penn Station, making transport easy.

3

Expect significant noise from traffic and construction, especially at night.

19
The Historic Blue Moon Hotel image 1

Hotel combines art deco charm with historic artifacts and unique artwork throughout. Rooms offer panoramic city views from balconies and blend vintage style with modern comforts. Atmosphere feels like stepping into a living museum with quiet, spacious accommodations.

Massive rooms and a Kosher restaurant attached make this hotel stand out. Staff engage in friendly conversations, and the hotel offers easy access to major sights.

A blend of classic and modern comfort shapes the stairwells, rooms, lobby, and dining areas. Each room offers a very unique design, and the strong sense of history adds a special touch throughout.

People are saying

"The hotel staff made me feel like family."

"It's a unique, historic place filled with art and personality."

"The balcony has a nice view of the city."

Good to know

1

The hotel charges a $30 resort fee despite lacking resort features such as a pool, gym, or spa.

2

Guests must walk through a little Italian cafe with homemade delicious treats to get to the main desk.

3

The hotel is conveniently located near subway stations and popular neighborhoods.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...