Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New York's best

Paneer makhani

The craving for a bowl of creamy, tomato-based paneer makhani is impossible to ignore once it sets in.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Red Onion Indian Lunch Brunch Dinner image 1
Red Onion Indian Lunch Brunch Dinner image 2
Red Onion Indian Lunch Brunch Dinner image 3
View all

Galaxy-themed decor and cosmic lights create a warm, inviting vibe perfect for dates. Butter chicken and samosa chaat offer authentic Indian flavors while paneer makhani shines with its rich tomato sauce. Cocktails add to the lively, intimate energy.

Butter chicken stands out with rich, authentic flavors. The garlic naan and samosa chaat also deliver strong, memorable tastes true to Indian cuisine.

Rich tomato-based sauce makes the paneer makhani incredibly flavorful. It stands out as a delicious and well-prepared dish among the entrees.

People are saying

"This Indian food is insanely delicious, especially the biryani."

"The owner Varun is so hospitable, you'll want to go back just for him."

"The Paneer Makhani here is incredibly flavorful and rich."

Good to know

1

Customers should call ahead to book a table due to limited seating.

2

The restaurant serves a weekday delights special with Tandoori Chicken and Naan.

3

Enjoy a weekend bottomless brunch with various options.

02
Rudraks image 1
Indian restaurant

Small space offers intimate elegance with warm hospitality and fresh aromatics. Indian dishes like rich Chicken Tikka Masala and creamy Paneer Makhani shine alongside soft naan and dal makhani. Hot towels add a thoughtful touch to the cozy, upscale vibe.

The Indian food features rich Chicken Tikka Masala and creamy Saag Paneer that pair well with soft naan. Vegetarian options like samosas and Palak Paneer stand out for their flavor and texture.

Rich, creamy texture defines the paneer makhani here. It pairs well with garlic naan and dal makhani for a satisfying meal.

People are saying

"I found the Indian food here to be the best I've ever had."

"The Indian food here is delicious."

"I thought the Paneer Makhani was perhaps the best I've had."

Good to know

1

You need to bring your own beverage (BYOB) to the venue.

2

The lunch special is a great deal.

3

There is a $20 takeout and delivery meal deal.

03
We Desi: Indian Bistro image 1
Indian restaurant

Halal Indian restaurant with modern decor and a cozy, warm atmosphere featuring live tandoori cooking and outdoor seating. Music plays at a comfortable volume, enhancing a relaxed vibe. Colorful floral walls and a Bollywood-themed setting create a distinctive, artsy environment.

Garlic Naan and butter chicken stand out as bold flavors here. The menu balances classics like channa masala, samosa chat, and Kati rolls with options like lamb chops and biryani.

Rich, creamy gravy defines the Paneer Makhani here, standing out as genuinely flavorful. The dish pairs well with fresh Garlic Naan, making for a satisfying meal.

People are saying

"I found the Indian food, especially the butter chicken, to be very good."

"I had the best butter chicken I've ever had."

"The Paneer Makhani gravy is rich and the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

All food at this restaurant is halal.

2

The restaurant is clean and inviting.

3

Prices are very affordable for the quality of food.

04
Ahimsa image 1
Indian restaurant

Bright space opens into a dining room with a skylight and glass roof, creating an indoor-outdoor experience. Warmth and friendliness fill the air, driven by unmatched hospitality from a family-run team. The atmosphere stays calm and inviting, making it a relaxing spot for vegetarian Indian cuisine.

Masala dosa stands out with light, tasty flavors paired with perfectly spiced chutneys and sambar. Garlic naan and Kadai paneer offer rich, authentic tastes, while the kheer delivers a memorable sweet finish.

Paneer makhani stands out with its rich flavor and smooth texture. It pairs well with naan and complements other dishes like palak paneer and dal tadka.

People are saying

"I found the authentic Indian food here to be excellent."

"I found the Indian food here to be amazing and delicious."

"I recommend the Paneer Makhani because it was very tasty."

Good to know

1

There is a lack of accessibility due to two stairs when trying to go up with a stroller.

2

Ahimsa accommodates food intolerances such as gluten and dairy.

3

If you donโ€™t want spicy food, you should order mild.

05
Atithi Indian Cuisine image 1
Indian restaurant

Small, cozy spot with authentic Indian dรฉcor and a beautiful mural sets a colorful, calm mood. Samosa with mint chutney and paneer makhani's sweet-spicy sauce shine on the menu. Warm, attentive service keeps the vibe inviting despite the mix of relaxing and loud techno music.

Samosa with mint chutney stands out as a tasty starter. The saag paneer offers a rich, flavorful experience. Service remains warm and attentive even during busy times.

Generous pieces of paneer swim in a sweet-spicy sauce that leans toward dessert-level sweetness. The flavor stands out among other dishes like Malai Kabob and Chicken Korma.

People are saying

"I wish I ordered more of the delicious Garlic Naan."

"The Indian food here is delicious and very tasty."

"You can't overlook the Paneer Makhani; it has generous pieces and a sweet-spicy flavor."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB (Bring Your Own Bottle).

2

The lunch special includes a starter, main course with rice, and dessert.

3

Dinner prix fixe is under $30 for three courses.

06
Mughlai Indian cuisine image 1
Indian restaurant

Indian restaurant offers a beautiful space with a cozy, dim lighting and a quiet, warm atmosphere. The vibe is casual and peaceful, attracting those who appreciate authentic flavors and a relaxed setting. Portions and prices vary, with some dishes noted for their distinct spice and presentation.

Food features authentic flavors with dishes like goat curry, Chicken Tandoori, and vegetarian thali. Naan comes fresh and warm, especially the garlic naan which stands out.

Paneer makhani here has a very sweet flavor and contains a large amount of red food coloring. It appears alongside dishes like saag paneer and chana saag.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and flavorful."

"I found the Indian food here to be absolutely delicious."

"Their Paneer Makhani is one of my favorite dishes."

Good to know

1

The lunch menu is priced at $19.95 and includes a starter, main course, naan, and rice.

2

The lunch special offers a great price and very filling portions.

3

The restaurant accommodates large parties, providing privacy for groups.

07
Patiala Indian Grill image 1
Indian restaurant

Small dining area feels cramped and cozy with tables placed very close together. Authentic Indian music plays, creating a warm and lively atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers an open-air experience for evening meals.

Chicken biryani stands out with rich flavors. Chicken tikka masala and chicken curry offer authentic, well-balanced spices.

Paneer makhani features a mild flavor with a creamy texture but sometimes lacks authentic taste. Staff may replace dishes to ensure you get paneer makhani if requested.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and authentic tasting."

"This Indian food is amazing, just like Delhi."

"I particularly enjoyed the Paneer Makhani."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers special laddus on the day of Diwali.

2

There is a waiting period of more than 1:30 hours to eat.

3

You must give your name inside on busy days as no one is taking names outside.

08
Angel image 1
Indian restaurant

Small space with cramped seating and loud Bollywood music creates a lively but tight atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a cozy alternative with heaters for comfort. The vibe reflects authentic Indian culture, making it feel like a spot in Delhi rather than the US.

Chicken Dum Biryani stands out with rich flavors and tender meat. It sets a high standard for biryani in the city.

Tomato gravy tastes both refreshing and rich, pairing well with fluffy basmati rice and butter naan. Paneer is homemade, adding a fresh texture to the dish.

People are saying

"I thought this food was the best Indian food I had ever tasted."

"The Indian Food, especially the biryanis, is flavorful and perfectly cooked."

"The paneer makhani here is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Customers should make a reservation before visiting due to limited seating.

2

Finding parking is a big challenge in that area.

3

You need to bring your own wine opener because it is a BYOB restaurant.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...