Islip

Explore over 200 places in Islip, New York for coffee, date spots, drinks, and more, all curated by locals on Atly.

UPDATED MAY 15, 2026

Best lists

A meal that is actually worth leaving the house for instead of just settling for whatever is nearby.

13 curated spots

Festively adorned diner showcasing over-the-top holiday decorations and a strong sense of American patriotism throughout.

Charming, beautifully decorated Italian restaurant with a warm, inviting atmosphere evoking traditional family gatherings.

Cozy steakhouse with a midwestern rustic feel, featuring a spacious dining room and a casual, homey atmosphere.

Charming old-school deli with traditional NY flavors, warm atmosphere, and expertly crafted sandwiches by a seasoned owner.

Charming tropical island vibe with a serene atmosphere, featuring a cute outdoor Tiki Bar deck and stunning waterfront views.