Mastic Beach

Explore over 60 places in Mastic Beach, New York for coffee, date spots, drinks, and more, all curated by locals on Atly.

UPDATED APR 24, 2026

Best lists

Made for those who believe that discovering reliable local dining options is the most important part of exploring their immediate surroundings.

8 curated spots

Cozy, candlelit dining room with a friendly, old-school atmosphere in a quaint, small neighborhood gem.

Family-friendly spot featuring spacious indoor seating and a wide variety of flavored cream cheeses.

Affordable pizzeria offering a great variety of pizzas in a very nice atmosphere with reasonable wait times.

Family-owned spot serving authentic soul food and Caribbean flavors in a clean, welcoming atmosphere with friendly service.

Clean, local bar with a jukebox and a family rec-room vibe, offering a down-to-earth, spirited atmosphere.