Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New York

Cookie and challah

Challah is a bread that demands respect, and the cookie you choose to follow it should be just as carefully crafted. You know the difference between a mass-produced loaf and one made with care.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Michaeli Bakery image 1
Michaeli Bakery image 2
Michaeli Bakery image 3
View all

Small bakery offers a cozy Israeli vibe with fresh baked goods aroma. Cookies are thick and chewy, especially chocolate caramel and Ferrero Rocher. Challah sells out fast, with seeded, raisin, and vegan options that taste great.

Cookies here are thick and chewy with a great texture. The chocolate caramel and Ferrero Rocher cookies balance chocolate and dough perfectly without being too sweet or fudge-y.

Challah sells out fast, so arriving early is key. Multiple options include seeded, raisin, and vegan challah, all with a delicious taste.

People are saying

"I thought the croissants were flaky, buttery, and layered."

"The Rocher cookie is the best I've ever had."

"This challah bread is the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

A spicy cheese stick costs $4.50.

2

This place is not nut-friendly for those with allergies.

3

A line often forms out the door, indicating its popularity.

02
Schreiber's Homestyle Bakery image 1

Bakery fills the air with fresh bread aroma and offers a take-out food bar featuring various baked goods. It draws a crowd seeking authentic Jewish pastries, especially Hamentaschen and Challah available on select days. The space feels cozy and friendly, known for high-quality kosher treats and a loyal local following.

Cookies come fresh with the right amount of sweetness and are always available alongside Black & White cookies. Pastries and bread also appear fresh and pair well with milk, coffee, or tea.

Challah comes out fresh on Thursdays and Fridays before sunset. It stays soft and flavorful with a mouth-watering taste.

People are saying

"I found their cookies to be fresh and delicious."

"I found the challah here to be delicious and perfectly soft."

"I enjoyed the great coffee here."

Good to know

1

Go there on Friday to pick up fresh baked challah.

2

Customers should go there early in the morning for piping hot bread.

3

There is no price tag on the food, so ask for prices.

03
Park East Kosher image 1
Grocery store

Grocery store offers a tight space filled with a lively, family-oriented atmosphere. It features an amazing selection of kosher products, including premium cuts of meat and a great bakery on site. The place feels like a community hub with a strong focus on quality and tradition.

Soft and moist cookies stand out here, a quality hard to find unless homemade. Options include oatmeal raisin cookies and a black and white cookie that leans on the sweet side with less frosting than expected.

Freshly baked challahs include custom fantasy challahs, cinnamon challah, and everything pull-apart rolls. Chocolate babka and oatmeal raisin cookies also complement the selection.

People are saying

"I found the Kosher meat here to be incredibly fresh and delicious."

"This cookie is soft and moist, a rare find."

"You have to try the water challah; it's the best in Manhattan."

Good to know

1

The store has a great selection of kosher groceries, meat, and prepared foods.

2

They charge $10 a piece for stuffed cabbage during Passover.

3

The store accepts EBT.

04
La Farine Pâtisserie et Café image 1

Bright, elegant bakery offers a Parisian atmosphere with cozy seating and natural light. Chocolate chip cookies are gooey and flavorful, while smoked salmon on soft challah knots delivers a fresh, balanced bite. Perfect spot for relaxing or working with coffee.

Chocolate chip cookies come out perfectly gooey and bursting with flavor. Madeline cookies offer a light and citrusy taste that stands out.

Smoked salmon on a soft challah knot pairs with tzatziki and radish for a fresh, balanced bite. Challah breads and croissants come out rich and excellent.

People are saying

"The pastries here are phenomenal and taste so balanced."

"The chocolate chip cookie is large, flat, and chewy."

"I highly recommend the smoked salmon on challah roll."

Good to know

1

Gloves should be worn when touching food and removed before returning to the register.

2

Expect 8-10 minutes to get your order taken if there's one person ahead.

3

Prices are higher than at Starbucks and other local cafes.

05
Moishe's Kosher Bakery image 1

Old-fashioned bakery with handwritten signs and a nostalgic atmosphere that feels like stepping back to the 1930s. Friendly, familiar interactions create a warm, welcoming vibe among a mix of local regulars. Known for authentic kosher baked goods sold by weight, it offers a unique, family-run experience with reasonable prices.

Black and white cookies stand out with their freshness and balanced flavors. They come highly praised and are often paired with an assortment of sprinkled cookies and cakes.

Challah here comes in bread and rolls form with above average quality. It sits alongside other kosher baked goods like babka and hamantaschen.

People are saying

"I thought the chocolate babka was a one of a kind experience."

"I thought their black and white cookies were some of the best I've ever tasted."

"I found their challah and other baked goods to be incredibly delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery/deli is cash only.

2

They sell everything by weight, allowing customers to try small portions.

3

Sunday is a great day to visit for fresh rye bread.

06
Spirals image 1
Bakery

Tiny bakery with adorable decor and warm, inviting atmosphere. Offers unique rotating flavors of cinnamon rolls, including sweet and savory options. Friendly staff create a cozy, welcoming vibe despite the small space.

Cookies come in creative cinnamon roll forms like Cookies and Cream, Sugar Cookie, and Cookie Dough. These rolls balance rich flavors without being too sweet.

Cinnamon roll challah stands out with its moist texture and delicious flavor. The original version is often described as outstanding and worth buying.

People are saying

"I thought the cinnamon rolls were the best I'd ever had."

"The cinnamon roll challah here is outstanding, truly to die for."

"The cinnamon roll's luscious cream cheese frosting is a must-try."

Good to know

1

Expect a long line on Saturday mornings, but it clears up by noon.

2

Cinnamon rolls are priced around $10 each, which some find excessive.

3

The bakery offers both sweet and savory rolls, including unique monthly flavors.

07
Breads Bakery - Rockefeller Center image 1

French bakery offers freshly baked goods with a spacious, cozy atmosphere featuring natural lighting and table seating. The space fills up quickly, creating a lively but sometimes congested environment. Pastries like babka and croissants stand out for their quality and taste.

Chocolate cookies stand out with a crunchy perimeter and soft interior, made from quality chocolate. Rugelach and chocolate chip cookies offer a delicious variety.

Sesame challah pairs well with labne and has a perfect texture and flavor. Plain challah costs nearly $10 but has a poor dough quality and is less enjoyable compared to other bakeries.

People are saying

"The croissant here is beautifully laminated with a delicate crunch."

"I loved the cookies here, they were delicious."

"I found the challah bread here to be the best."

Good to know

1

The almond croissant costs over $6.

2

The chocolate rugalach costs $14 for 6 pieces.

3

The bakery is located in midtown Manhattan along 6th Avenue, near the subway.

08
Breads Bakery - Union Square image 1

Bakery buzzes with a lively morning crowd and fresh bread aroma. Almond croissants and babka shine alongside festive challah topped with sesame. Oatmeal cookies with raisins pair perfectly with fruit tarts, making every bite a delight.

Oatmeal cookies here feature raisins and oats with a truly delicious taste. They pair well with fruit tarts, offering a nice balance of flavors.

Challah stands out for its festive style and sesame topping. It tastes delicious and rich, often recommended alongside other baked goods.

People are saying

"I found the bread and pastries here to be delicious and fresh."

"I found the oatmeal cookie to be quite perfect."

"I found the challah here to be the best I'd ever had."

Good to know

1

Breads Bakery offers sandwiches, salads, bakery items, and coffee.

2

The caraway rye bread is only available on weekends.

3

They sometimes have items on the menu only for that particular month, like the cheesecake babka in May.

09
Elbow Bread image 1

Small bakery with rustic wooden accents and bright, airy lighting creates a cozy, friendly atmosphere. No seating inside encourages a grab-and-go experience amid a bustling vibe. Aromas of fresh bread and pastries fill the space, adding to its charm.

Cookies include a Nori Chocolate Chip Cookie that is thinner and crispier than usual with a great chew. Oatmeal cookies with raisins serve as a solid snack alongside coffee or tea.

Flaky, soft, and buttery textures define the challah croissant, which tastes unmistakably like challah. Varieties include a vanilla challah honey bun and a classic honey Challah Pullman.

People are saying

"You have to try their chocolate babka from the bakery; it sells out fast."

"I tried the nori chocolate chip cookie and it had a great chew."

"I loved their challah croissant, it wasn't too sweet."

Good to know

1

A double pretzel costs $15, while a single pretzel usually costs $7.

2

Expect no line on Friday mornings around 9:45am.

3

The bakery does not start serving pretzels until later in the day.

10
2nd Ave Deli image 1

Proper sit-down deli with old school diner feel and tooled metal ceiling creates a comfortable, classic NYC kosher atmosphere. The space is quiet and welcoming, offering a warm Jewish New Yorker experience distinct from bustling modern delis.

Complimentary cookies add a nice touch. The black and white cookies stand out as delicious.

Challah here is excellent and works well both as bread and in dishes like French toast. It holds up nicely with a thick layer of pastrami for sandwiches.

People are saying

"This pastrami sandwich is epic, with juicy, smoky meat."

"You get complimentary cookies after your meal."

"The challah bread was milky, eggy, and soft."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is kosher, so no outside food or drink is allowed.

2

The restaurant only allows 40 minutes to eat after entry.

3

The restaurant closed for sit down dinner at 7:30 PM.

11
Breads Bakery - Upper East Side image 1

Roomy bakery with varied seating options including sofas, high tops, and cushioned chairs creates a cozy atmosphere. Multiple music sources play simultaneously, contributing to a lively but sometimes noisy vibe. Pet-friendly space offers wifi and power outlets, supporting work and relaxation.

The black and white cookie stands out as a unique blend of croissant, pastry, and cookie textures. Other treats include rugelah, cinnamon rolls made with croissant dough, and classic cookies that complement the bread offerings.

Great challah knots and a festive Rosh Hashanah apple challah stand out here. Challah bread is exceptional but priced around $9 for a small loaf, and it can sell out quickly.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be fresh, fragrant, and delicious."

"This black and white cookie is amazing, like a croissant."

"I found the challah here to be exceptional and festive."

Good to know

1

Cash is not accepted at the coffee stand.

2

You need to order while you are in line even if you don’t see what they offer.

3

The prices are on the high side, with croissants costing $5 to $6 each.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...