Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Ice Cream Sandwiches and Desserts in New York

Made for those who refuse to choose between a handheld ice cream sandwich and a plated dessert.

Based on 850 Opinions
+847
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
BKLYN MACS image 1
BKLYN MACS image 2
BKLYN MACS image 3
View all
Dessert shop

Dessert shop offers largest flavor selection of macarons with unique edible photo printing on treats. Space feels cozy and creative with stylish interior and small seating area. Atmosphere stays friendly and welcoming throughout visits.

Specializes in macarons with a variety of fun flavors and desserts like cookies and ice cream sandwiches. Offers an amazing selection of desserts with great service.

Soft macarons serve as the base for ice cream sandwiches with unique flavors like Ube Toasted Coconut and Dubai chocolate. The pairing of creamy ice cream and delicate macarons creates a delicious dessert experience.

People are saying

"I considered these the best macarons I have tasted."

"The macaroon ice cream sandwich was a perfect pairing."

"You have to try their macarons; they have hundreds of unique flavors."

Good to know

1

Almost everything is gluten-free, catering to dietary restrictions.

2

The macarons are made in-house with premium ingredients.

3

Expect a constantly rotating selection of unique flavors.

02
The Good Batch Bakery image 1

Bright, cheery atmosphere offers a calm, relaxed vibe with thoughtful decor and a small shop warmth. Seating inside supports quiet moments, though WiFi issues limit productivity. The space blends familiarity and creativity for a hip, comfortable experience.

Desserts here avoid heavy sugar loads, offering adult desserts that balance sweet and salty well. Options like the vegan fudge cake and chocolate lava provide rich, satisfying flavors without being overly sweet.

Ice cream sandwiches feature soft and chewy cookies paired with rich ice cream flavors like pistachio honey butter, tahini chocolate chip, and mango sticky rice. Some include a gooey fudge drizzle and sea salt that enhances the taste.

People are saying

"The ice cream sandwiches here are pure dessert perfection."

"I thought the ice cream sandwich was the best I ever had."

"The ice cream sandwich here is pure dessert perfection."

Good to know

1

The shop closed an hour earlier than listed.

2

Good Batch has a deal where you can buy 5 cookies and get 1 free.

3

They have a great selection of non-vegan, vegan, and gluten-free pastries.

03
The Ivy Room image 1
Restaurant

Intimate rooftop piano lounge offers a cozy, romantic atmosphere with live jazz music enhancing the elegant vibe. Seating includes a patio area and space suited for private events. Signature craft cocktails complement the refined setting.

Cream-filled beignets come with a berry sauce that adds a sweet tang. Profiteroles stand out as a recommended dessert option.

Chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches offer a delicately decadent treat with a rich, sweet flavor. Cream puffs also serve as a popular dessert choice for those craving something sweet.

People are saying

"The brunch staff sang happy birthday and surprised me."

"They surprised me with a chocolate mousse and sang happy birthday."

"The chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich is delicately decadent."

Good to know

1

On Wednesdays, selected bottles of wine are offered at reduced prices.

2

The Sunday jazz brunch features live music and unlimited mimosas for 60 minutes.

3

A reservation is required for the Wednesday wine discount.

04
The Little One image 1
Dessert shop

Small dessert shop offers authentic Japanese kakigori and minimalist, cozy atmosphere with local artwork on display. Seating is limited, creating a quiet, intimate vibe suited for small groups or dates. Desserts focus on unique, traditional flavors rarely found elsewhere in the city.

Refreshing kakigori stands out with its unique Japanese style. Other desserts like matcha banana pudding and yuzu parfait offer fresh, tasty options in a modern, artistic setting.

Ice cream sandwiches stand out here, especially at The Little One, known for its shaved ice and dessert variety.

People are saying

"You have to try their shaved ice desserts; they're huge and fluffy."

"It's a small, cozy spot with a welcoming vibe."

"I found some of the best ice cream sandwiches and desserts here."

Good to know

1

Cakes at the cafe are available only by preorder.

2

Expect a wait of around 20 minutes for an available table.

3

The restroom is located in the park next door or the cafe across the street, which requires a purchase to use.

05
Seamoreโ€™s image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers an airy dining room with Northeast seaside inspiration and a decent-sized bar area. The atmosphere combines live bands and a comedy/performance space downstairs, creating a lively and fun vibe. Cocktails stand out with creative options like fig syrup old fashion and blood orange margarita.

The dessert features a churro ice cream sandwich that stands out for its rich flavor and fresh preparation. Staff recommend it often, and it arrives quickly from the kitchen, making it a delicious and memorable choice.

Churro ice cream sandwich stands out as a showstopper dessert with a unique blend of textures and flavors. It often comes highly recommended and can be a memorable treat for special occasions.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and delicious, especially the oysters."

"The churro ice cream sandwich was insane!"

"You have to get the churro ice cream sandwich dessert; it's a showstopper."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the mixology class to secure a spot.

2

Happy hour oysters are priced at $1.50 each during specific hours.

3

Brunch is available only on Saturdays, costing $60 per person.

06
Mitr Thai Restaurant image 1
Thai restaurant

Large venue with beautiful artwork and dangling bamboo stick art creates a unique atmosphere. Music is loud house and club style, making conversation challenging. Tables are packed closely together, contributing to a crowded feel despite the attractive setting.

Sticky rice called I-Tim Boran stands out on the dessert menu. Desserts match the heavenly quality found in the rest of the food.

A warm pillowy milk bun splits open to hold sticky rice, jackfruit, and a generous scoop of ice cream. The coconut and jackfruit flavors stand out in this dessert.

People are saying

"The food here is incredibly delicious and flavorful."

"They sang happy birthday with our special dessert."

"You have to try the Thai-style ice cream sandwich with sweet rice."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.

2

Every party has an hour and fifteen minutes to eat.

3

The wait time is 1 hour during peak hours.

07
Supermoon Bakehouse image 1

Minimalist bakery space resembles an empty warehouse with no indoor seating, offering only a service counter and a small outdoor seating area. Atmosphere feels sterile yet chill, contrasting with the heavenly smell of fresh baked goods. Outdoor tables provide a cozy spot to enjoy some of the best croissants and pastries available.

Desserts here offer a range of flavors with pastries that are not overly sweet. The Dubai Chocolate Cookie and banana dessert stand out as notably delicious options.

Big ice cream sandwiches feature strong ube and pandan flavors. Options include Ube Pandan and cookies with ube. The unique combinations stand out among typical ice cream treats.

People are saying

"The pastries here are amazingly creative and delicious."

"The Nutella croissant was pure bliss and generously filled."

"I thought the desserts here were top tier, especially the ube รฉclair."

Good to know

1

They only accept cards and do not accept cash.

2

Check their working days and hours before visiting as they donโ€™t open every day.

3

Get there early as a line forms before they open.

08
Penny image 1
Seafood restaurant

Long, narrow space with bar seating surrounds an open kitchen, creating a communal vibe and intimate setting. Lighting includes small lamps that highlight the food as art, while 70s punk music adds energy. Atmosphere feels cool and fun, with fresh seafood and attentive service.

Chocolate mousse stands out as a rich dessert option. The ice cream sandwich made with bread offers a unique twist not to miss.

Bread serves as the base for the ice cream sandwich, creating a unique texture. A jam pairing adds a sweet contrast that complements the dessert well.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and simply cooked."

"I found the ice cream sandwich to be fine to order."

"The ice cream sandwich dessert was amazing and complicated."

Good to know

1

Reservations are hard to get unless dining at 5pm.

2

Several dishes sell out quickly, so arrive early.

3

Expect to pay high prices for small portion sizes.

09
La Churreria image 1
Spanish restaurant

Small indoor space seats about 10 with an outdoor table, creating an intimate and cozy setting. Warm, welcoming vibe with great music and seasonal decorations adds charm. Known for authentic churros and fun atmosphere, though seating can feel cramped and busy.

Desserts here are simply exceptional and often described as mind-blowing. They offer to go options like stuffed churros, making sweets easy to enjoy anywhere.

Churro ice cream sandwich features salted caramel ice cream inside a crispy churro shell. It stands out as a perfect treat with a sweet and crunchy texture.

People are saying

"These churros are delicious, hot, and crispy right from the order."

"Their exclusive desserts, like the Dubai Chocolate Toast, were mind-blowing."

"The churro ice cream sandwich with salted caramel was to die for."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait for a table, especially during busy hours.

2

Get there early if you plan on dining in, as seating is limited.

3

They offer 5 churros for $4.50, a great deal for a sweet treat.

10
Super Nice Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Smallish pizza restaurant offers a cozy, sexy, lively atmosphere with soft lighting and tasteful decor in a beautifully restored classic NYC building. Full bar serves terrific wine and balanced cocktails while music selection enhances the cool, effortless vibe. Neighborhood crowd gathers here for phenomenal pizza and easygoing ambiance.

Tiramisu and cannolis stand out as memorable desserts. Baked goods like chocolate cake and key lime tart also feature prominently.

Unique take on the ice cream sandwich offers a divine finish to the meal. This dessert stands out with its distinctive flavor and texture.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was truly amazing."

"The chocolate cake dessert here is a celebration."

"I thought the ice cream sandwich was divine."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended during peak hours to avoid long waits.

2

The restaurant is open late, making it a good option for night owls.

3

Expect personal-sized pizzas, perfect for individual dining.

11
Eyval image 1
Persian restaurant

Warm, dark interiors blend with unique Iranian decor and LED Farsi lettering to create a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Three distinct rooms offer varied seating, some tucked away for privacy. Cocktails with saffron and black lime add a distinctive twist to the dining experience.

Saffron ice cream sandwiches deliver a rich, aromatic flavor that matches their online reputation. They stand out as a distinctive dessert option here.

People are saying

"The Persian ice cream sandwich was the best I had."

"You have to try the lamb ribs; they're a standout dish."

"I thought the Latifeh dessert was amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations at Eyval open on Resy three weeks in advance; highly recommended on weekends.

2

The average wait with no reservations is about 2 hours.

3

If you do not have a reservation, you may get turned away after traveling to Bushwick.

12
Elio's image 1
Ice cream shop

Enjoy unique donut toppings and a wide variety of ice cream flavors in a fun, retro setting with a Pac-Man game. Try ice cream donuts or build your own doughnut ice cream sandwiches with real cookies that resist melting. Friendly service and a cozy spot to relax complete the experience.

Ice cream donuts and waffles stand out as unique dessert options. The spot offers a wide variety of made-on-the-spot desserts with friendly service helping select treats.

Doughnut ice cream sandwiches come with options to build your own doughnut flavors. Cookie ice cream sandwiches use real cookies and stay cool without melting quickly.

People are saying

"The ice cream staff here are so friendly and welcoming."

"I found the desserts here to be the best I've ever had."

"The donut ice cream sandwich was delicious and amazing."

Good to know

1

The dessert spot is open until 2AM on the weekend.

2

John Depp ice cream is 21+ only.

3

The ice cream sandwich costs $15.00.

13
Schmackary's image 1

Small, clean bakery with freshly baked cookie aroma filling the air. Cozy, fun-spirited vibe with limited seating and heated outdoor tables. Offers unique cookie flavors and ice cream treats in a charming, compact space.

Desserts here serve as a reliable choice for parties and gatherings. Frequent visits highlight their consistent appeal around dessert time in the theatre district.

The ice cream sandwich combines soft and crunchy textures with a mix of sweet and salty flavors. Funfetti and cookie versions come with sprinkles and smooth ice cream, though softer cookies would help keep the ice cream from falling out.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing and delicious."

"These desserts are so good, I'd fight a raccoon for them."

"This ice cream sandwich is sweet, salty, crunchy, soft, and refreshing."

Good to know

1

The ice cream shop has a 2 for 1 cookie sale.

2

New flavors come out regularly, check for updates.

3

Cookies may be given away at a discount right before closing.

14
Passerine image 1
Indian restaurant

Space combines modern cozy design with lush textures and moody lighting to create an immersive, warm atmosphere. Unique cocktails and an elevated bar and drawing room add to the sophisticated vibe. Guests find the setting inviting and the energy calm yet vibrant.

Every meal includes an amuse bouche and a dessert, creating a welcoming finish. The pistachio dessert stands out as mind-blowing, and the ice cream sandwich is well done and worth trying.

Elevated cocoa notes give the ice cream sandwich a nostalgic yet refined taste. It pairs well with other desserts like pistachio cremeux and offers a sweet, satisfying finish.

People are saying

"The food here was amazing, I can't wait to return."

"The desserts here are thoughtfully prepared and full of flavor."

"The ice cream sandwich dessert was perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

Prices are on the higher side, with naan costing $8 each.

3

The restaurant has limited vegetarian main courses available.

15
American Bar - New York image 1

Upscale restaurant with chic, lounge-style interior and indoor and outdoor patio seating creates a buzzy, trendy atmosphere. Crowd tends to be well-heeled and fashionable, enjoying highly recommended martinis and generous portions. Seating includes beautiful booths but some tables and wicker chairs feel less comfortable.

Warm, gooey chocolate chip ice cream sandwich with melting cold ice cream and Oreo bits stands out. The key lime torte also offers a notable dessert option. Desserts are rich enough to make finishing them a challenge.

Warm, gooey chocolate chip cookie holds melting cold ice cream with Oreo bits for texture. The sandwich blends soft cookie and crunchy crumble in a special dessert experience.

People are saying

"The service at these dinner spots is spectacular and attentive."

"I loved the key lime pie for dessert."

"The ice cream sandwich was warm, gooey, with melting ice cream."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to avoid being turned away from restaurants in the area.

2

Expect longer wait times for drinks and food on busy nights.

3

Martinis cost $10 on Sundays and Mondays.

16
Sofreh image 1
Persian restaurant

Small space combines Persian-inspired decor with a laid-back, inviting atmosphere. Backyard patio offers quiet outdoor seating away from the street. Unique cocktails complement the setting with distinct flavors.

Outstanding flavor and texture make the ice cream sandwich stand out. It offers a special, memorable taste that many find life changing.

People are saying

"The food here is refined, deeply flavorful, and beautifully executed."

"The eggplant and rice combination was heavenly."

"The ice cream sandwich was particularly outstanding."

Good to know

1

Reservations must be made almost a month in advance.

2

Expect to spend some cash.

3

Reservations are recommended as they take the first five people for bar seating each night and the rest are waitlisted.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...