Tiny seafood spot shines with fresh lobster salads and smoked whitefish croquettes that crunch perfectly. Cozy bar seating offers a ringside kitchen view, while the outdoor patio adds a charming al fresco vibe.
Salads feature fresh seafood like lobster and crab, paired with unique ingredients such as grilled cabbage and corn. Light options include cucumber and snap pea salads, often served alongside grilled skewers or squid.
Smoked whitefish appears in several dishes like croquettes with chili oil sauce and brandade, offering a crispy outside and soft inside. The whitefish croquettes stand out with a juicy, flavorful bite and a satisfying crunchy crust.
"The fish and chips here are a must-try, especially the chips."
"The fish and chips were so crispy and tasty."
"The whitefish in the fish and chips is tender with an excellent crisp."
Good to know
Reservations are required at least three weeks in advance to dine at reasonable times.
The restaurant has limited seating, making reservations essential.
Expect to pay over $125 per person if ordering wine.
Bar area features Jazz Age murals and dim, intimate lighting that create an elegant, old-school Manhattan vibe. The space combines classic New York decor with lively jazz music and a bustling bar scene. Patrons enjoy carefully crafted cocktails and a setting that feels like stepping into another era.
Wedge Salad stands out with boiled eggs, thick cut bacon, and Gorgonzola topped with creamy ranch. Chicken Caesar salad features fresh chicken and crisp greens, making it a solid choice.
Whitefish features prominently in a smoked Caesar salad that stands out for its flavor. It pairs well with other appetizers like steak tartare and shrimp cocktail.
Good to know
A reservation is effectively REQUIRED to be seated for dinner service.
They take reservations 14 days in advance at 9am.
Without wine, expect to spend at least $100-150 for a meal.
Smoked fish takes center stage with an incredible range and exceptional quality that draws locals. The atmosphere feels old school and family-owned, offering both indoor and outdoor seating. Bagels accompany the fish, though they lack the classic chewiness found elsewhere.
Lobster salad stands out as a signature item, often described as life-changing and among the best available. Other notable salads include tuna salad, whitefish salad, and crab salad, all praised for their quality and flavor.
Salads here feature fresh, smoky whitefish and lobster with a rich, baked texture. Smoked salmon varieties include Scottish, Canadian, and pastrami style, paired often with bagels for a classic combo.
Good to know
Breakfast is under $5 and lunch is under $15, including hot soup.
The price for a sandwich is $12.
The belly lox was $60 per pound, which is 50% more than at Zabar’s or Fairway.
Bagel shop with a retro style and modern, sleek design offers free cream cheese samples and self-serve seating. Atmosphere shifts from peaceful and pleasant during slow times to loud and crowded on busy days. Staff are knowledgeable and helpful, enhancing the friendly and energetic vibe.
Salads here feature rich flavors and good moisture, like the egg salad on an everything bagel and the chicken salad on wheat. The whitefish and salmon salads stand out for their quality and taste, making them popular choices.
Whitefish shines in the whitefish bagel and whitefish salad sandwich, both fresh and flavorful. Classic deli favorites like whitefish salad bring a nostalgic touch with rich, creamy textures.
Good to know
You need to get a ticket before ordering to join the queue.
Expect to wait at least 30 minutes during peak hours.
To avoid the wait, consider ordering online for pickup.
Interior mimics an old-school diner with retro vibe and classy servers in white lab coats. Atmosphere feels warm and homey yet somewhat sterile and quiet while ordering. Known for classic bagel and lox, it draws those seeking a historic Jewish deli experience.
Salads feature whitefish breaded and fried with lemon and remoulade, along with golden and red beet options. The menu also offers chopped liver and herring salads that stand out.
Whitefish dishes include croquettes with fresh dill and lemon, keeping them light and not greasy. The whitefish salad is breaded and fried, served with lemon and remoulade, offering a refreshing balance with house-made tartar sauce.
Good to know
Making a reservation is necessary to avoid a wait of over an hour.
Expect to wait on busy weekend mornings; arrive early to get on the list.
No reservations are accepted, so expect long waits on weekends.
Restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with cramped tables and dark lighting that creates an intimate vibe. Creative cocktails and a menu featuring familiar dishes with unique twists attract a lively, convivial crowd. Outdoor patio seating includes heaters, making it comfortable for groups despite tight spaces.
Salads feature a bright, fresh vinaigrette that lifts the flavors. The Big Leafy salad stands out for its quality, and the special corn salad offers a unique twist with its ingredients.
Whitefish croquettes stand out with strong quality and flavor. The whitefish salad tends to be overly creamy with little fish, served as a gloopy, mayonnaisey mess on a small plate.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.
Happy hour features $10 martinis and $3 oysters from 4-6pm on weekdays.
Gluten-free options are available, including bagels and burger buns.
Gourmet grocery store with old-world charm and an edgy omni-deli ambiance filled with the aroma of specialty cheeses and coffee. Crowded with serious shoppers, the atmosphere can feel tense but remains a local institution known for its unique bakery and extensive gourmet cookwear upstairs.
Salads here feature vinegar, salt, and pepper seasoning that makes them party-worthy. The whitefish salad and seafood salad stand out for their quality and flavor, while coleslaw accompanies sandwiches nicely.
Smoked whitefish and whitefish salad stand out with top-notch flavor and creamy texture. Whitefish pate and tails also appear regularly, paired often with pickles or potato latkes.
Good to know
Parking is abysmal, so plan accordingly.
There is no restroom available for customers.
The #1 subway stop is right next to Zabar's for easy access.
Bagel shop with an old school vibe and bright, inviting interior filled with crowded tight tables and loud music. The atmosphere feels comfy and vibrant, attracting a mix of regulars and newcomers. Walls display numerous photographs, adding to the authentic and classic feel.
Salads feature whitefish and tuna options that pair well with bagels. Chicken salad also stands out as a delicious choice.
The whitefish salad has too much mayonnaise, which masks the fish flavor. Classic bagels come with whitefish salad, but the fish taste is barely noticeable.
Good to know
The bagels are priced at $2, which is more expensive than other places.
The price for a bagel and cream cheese is $5.25.
Both dine-in and delivery options are available.