Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Burger and sandwich spots in Brooklyn Heights

A burger is only as good as the bread it is served on, and you refuse to accept a subpar sandwich.

Based on 751 Opinions
+748
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Grand Canyon Restaurant image 1
Grand Canyon Restaurant image 2
Grand Canyon Restaurant image 3
View all
American restaurant

Neighborhood diner with classic diner style and Mexican-inspired dishes offers a calm, family-friendly atmosphere with quiet jazz music and spaced seating. Outdoor seating adds to the relaxed vibe, making it suitable for casual meals and conversations without raising voices.

Huge, fresh ground beef burgers come cooked exactly how you like. Cheese and turkey options taste really fresh and pair well with fries.

Chicken salad sandwich stands out as flavorful. Some sandwiches like the grilled chicken and breakfast options taste good, but others such as the Mexican and club turkey sandwiches lack flavor or are served incorrectly without apology.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers were delicious and cooked perfectly."

"The diner staff were so nice and friendly."

"I thought the grilled chicken sandwich was tasty."

Good to know

1

The restaurant charges an 18% service charge fee on all bills.

2

Breakfast is served all day, making it a flexible dining option.

3

The diner can accommodate large parties, perfect for gatherings.

02
Henry Street Ale House image 1

Small bar with vintage touches and many TVs showing sports creates a lively, friendly vibe. Outdoor seating and a community area add a relaxed, social element. The atmosphere stays chill and down to earth, attracting those who enjoy good beer and casual gatherings.

Burgers here vary from tasty to burned, with some being dry and lacking taste. Prices are high since burgers do not include cheese, bacon, or fries.

The fried chicken sandwich stands out with its thin, very crispy coating and consistent preparation over the years. It tends to be a bit dry but remains a solid choice among the good pub fare options.

People are saying

"The food here is several steps above average bar fare."

"The fried chicken sandwich here is so crispy and delicious."

"I found the burgers to be tasty."

Good to know

1

The restaurant claimed to be open until 1 AM but closed at 11 PM.

2

Customers should be careful if they are heading there at 11 PM.

3

The total cost can end up being $30 per person after adding extras and a 20% tip.

03
Henry's End image 1
American restaurant

American restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with intimate vibe suited for dates or small groups. Seating is tightly packed indoors, while outdoor seating provides a classy outdoor feeling. Signature cocktails and a unique personality add to the relaxed environment.

Burgers here stand out for their unique flavor and tasty chicken option. The menu also includes an egg torta and chicken sandwich, offering variety beyond the classic burger.

Fried chicken sandwich stands out as a delicious option. The menu also includes a burger, egg torta, and chicken sandwich, offering a solid variety.

People are saying

"The steak au Poivre for dinner was fantastic, rivaling the best."

"You have to try the wild game burgers; the elk chops were worth it."

"I loved the chicken sandwich; it's the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Make sure you book a reservation at least 3-4 days in advance.

2

Single patrons are not allowed; reservations must be for two or more.

3

A service charge is automatically added to your bill.

04
O'Keefe's Bar & Grill image 1

Sports bar with lots of screens and a large bar creates a lively setting. Atmosphere ranges from festive to laid back, often filled with friendly crowds. Music and multiple TVs keep energy high, making it a solid spot for watching games.

Burgers come with moist, fresh garden options served in pita with tomato, lettuce, onion, and pickles. The O'Keefe's Burger offers a fatty, flavorful profile, paired well with waffle fries.

Steak sandwiches stand out with solid flavor and good quality. The Chicken Parmesan Sandwich offers a tasty option, but the buffalo chicken sandwich may lack real chicken and feels less satisfying.

People are saying

"It's a cool, authentic neighborhood bar with a cozy vibe."

"I thought the garden burger was awesome and delicious."

"I enjoyed the great sandwiches and fries."

Good to know

1

They have a comedy show every Wednesday.

2

Happy hour drinks are only $1 off.

3

The venue has different types of beer and lots of giant screens with all kinds of sports channels.

05
Clark's image 1
Diner

Diner with European style and cozy atmosphere offers outdoor seating where people watch the world go by. Inside feels a bit cramped but manages to seat everyone comfortably. The vibe is pleasant and relaxed, fitting a neighborhood spot with friendly energy.

Burgers come in traditional All-American style and deluxe versions like the pizza-burger with fries, tomatoes, and mesclun greens. Portions are generous, with some burgers enough to feed two people.

Crabcake and pastrami sandwiches stand out for their rich flavors. The hot Reuben features housemade sliced meat, and the roast beef sandwich is prepared perfectly.

People are saying

"This brunch was the best on the entire planet."

"The Reuben sandwich here is amazing and served with housemade meat."

"These burgers are the best I've ever eaten, truly luxurious."

Good to know

1

Brunch is very popular on weekends, expect long wait times.

2

Lunch hour is busy, plan to arrive early.

3

Dinner service starts at 10 PM.

06
Montague Diner image 1

Classic diner design blends 1940s nostalgia with modern touches like soft pink lighting and thoughtful details. Noisy atmosphere fills with an eclectic playlist and lively energy. Crowd enjoys cocktail menu alongside traditional diner fare, creating a warm, welcoming vibe.

Burgers come juicy and cooked to perfection, nestled in a soft, golden bun. They include a pickle worth the price alone and pack fresh ingredients generously.

Juicy burgers and sandwiches packed with fresh ingredients stand out here. The tuna salad sandwich and egg salad sandwich get more attention than the omelet.

People are saying

"The diner food here is solid and satisfying, especially the pancakes."

"I enjoyed the burger flavor and fries."

"The staff here are really nice and caring."

Good to know

1

The diner plans to operate 24 hours during the holiday.

2

The restaurant serves a late Sunday lunch.

3

There is a 2-hour wait even when the diner is half empty.

07
Shake Shack Dumbo image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Outdoor seating offers stunning views of Brooklyn Bridge and Manhattan skyline. The atmosphere is casual and lively, filled with a mix of tourists and locals. Inside, the space is busy and chaotic with many tables and a vibrant NYC energy.

Burgers here are made with top quality ingredients and taste very good. The truffle burger stands out as a delicious option among the tasty homemade burgers.

Sandwiches come with good fillings like chicken and fried aubergine. They taste delicious and pair well with chips, though some find them small.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be savory and flavorful."

"I loved the nice view of the Brooklyn Bridge from my table."

"I found the sandwiches here to be delicious and tasty."

Good to know

1

Expect a 15-20 minute wait to enter and order during peak hours.

2

There is only one restroom available, leading to long lines.

3

The restaurant often runs out of popular menu items like burgers.

08
Vineapple image 1
Restaurant

Outdoor seating includes a cozy backyard garden and courtyard that open when weather permits. Atmosphere feels homey and local with live music on Friday nights adding to the vibe. Cocktails stand out for their creative presentation and unique flavors.

Burgers here are super juicy and packed with full flavor. The 71 Brunch Burger includes pineapple bits that add a unique twist.

Prosciutto sandwich stands out as moist and juicy with rich flavor. Breakfast sandwich earns a perfect 10, served on a bagel and highly satisfying.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the very tasty coffee, especially the cold brew."

"The brunch staff are genuinely kind and accommodating."

"I thought the breakfast sandwich was delicious and tasty."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is highly recommended.

2

Brunch orders start at 9am.

3

After 3PM, all the pastries at Vineapple cafe are 50% off.

Discover more

Brooklyn Heights, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...