Eltingville

Explore over 300 places in Eltingville, New York for coffee, date spots, drinks, and more, all curated by locals on Atly.

UPDATED MAR 30, 2026

Best lists

You are looking for a meal that satisfies your hunger without the need for a formal dining experience.

23 curated spots

A local business that stays true to its roots instead of catering to the trends of the moment.

8 curated spots

You have a limited window to eat and refuse to waste it on a mediocre meal.

8 curated spots

Spacious Italian restaurant with a beautiful, rustic setting and a genuine, comforting atmosphere.

Beautiful Italian restaurant with a majestic exterior, cozy interior, and an amazing piazza ambiance featuring warm lighting and rustic decor.

Gorgeous, modern restaurant featuring authentic Turkish decor and light fixtures, with a warm, inviting ambiance and impeccable cleanliness.

Cozy, anime-inspired decor featuring cute cat and Pokémon portraits, paired with a peaceful, clean atmosphere and soothing music.

Bright, spacious dining area with a clean, welcoming atmosphere and beautifully minimal decor.