Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Jamaica

Dinner spots with fish

You want a dinner spot that prioritizes fresh fish on the menu.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
O Lavrador image 1
O Lavrador image 2
O Lavrador image 3
View all
Portuguese restaurant

European-style hacienda with brick arches and an elegant dining room offers two distinct spaces: a formal restaurant and a lively bar with multiple screens showing sports. Atmosphere blends authentic Portuguese vibes with a friendly, sometimes loud energy. Outdoor area features a screen for games, complementing the spacious setup with ample parking.

Dinner servings come in fabulous portions with a casual, sports bar vibe that suits both date nights and family dinners. Complimentary Portuguese sweet wine finishes the meal on certain nights.

Fresh fish dishes stand out here, especially the salty cod Bacalhau and grilled octopus. Cod fish cakes and croquettes come crispy and tasty, while seafood parrillada arrives with homemade chips.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"The food at these dinner spots was delicious and excellent."

"I enjoyed the fresh fish dishes, especially the sole."

Good to know

1

Expect a fabulous portion serving for dinner.

2

The meal for two, including an appetizer, mains, and drinks, costs $170 with tip and tax.

3

The kitchen closes earlier on Thursdays, between 9:30-10.

02
Saka Sushi and Asian Cuisine image 1
Japanese restaurant

Interior offers a beautiful, welcoming, and clean setting with a pleasant and inviting atmosphere. Sushi stands out for its freshness and high quality, complemented by reasonable prices and options like soy bean paper for allergies.

Dinner options include a Salmon Dinner Bento Box that offers a variety of items in one combo. The combo provides a balanced meal with different flavors.

Fish tastes consistently fresh here, especially in the sushi. The Alaskan roll features raw fish that stands out for its freshness.

People are saying

"The Japanese food here is delicious and so fresh."

"The fish here always tasted so fresh."

"The teriyaki at these dinner spots is top tier, just like back home."

Good to know

1

Parking is available right in front of the restaurant.

2

The prices are reasonable with a 10% discount for online orders.

3

The lunch chicken teriyaki bento box costs less than $20.

03
Cap't Loui - Cajun Seafood Boil image 1

Seafood boil restaurant with spacious, clean interior and nautical decor creates a calm, laid-back atmosphere. Music plays softly, enhancing the family-friendly vibe with thoughtful touches like crayons for toddlers. Cocktails stand out with strong, creative drinks including adult Capri Suns and Caribbean blue cocktails.

Dinner offers delicious and flavorful meals suitable for both casual and special occasions. The setting works well for family gatherings and relaxed dinners.

Fish comes with firm pieces and cooks to perfection without being salty or over-seasoned. The fish and chips feature thicc pieces and a spicy mayonnaise sauce that adds a nice touch.

People are saying

"The seafood boil here is seasoned perfectly and tastes amazing."

"The seafood dinner here is so fresh and delicious."

"The fish here is cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

Go on Tuesdays for $1 oysters all day.

2

It takes less than 20 minutes for the food to come.

3

The restaurant closes at 10:15 PM.

04
Naresh’s Essequibo Cuisine image 1

Restaurant offers warm hospitality and a cozy, neighborhood vibe with Godly music playing inside. Table arrangements feel traditional and decor is somewhat outdated. Staff maintain separate pots for vegetarian dishes to respect dietary needs.

Dinners come out well cooked and ready to eat with consistent flavoring. Meals save time and energy by being available for quick pickup.

Bake and salt fish stands out as a key dish alongside fish curry and fish cake. These items appear regularly in curries and traditional Guyanese meals like cook-up rice.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and tastes like home cooking."

"The food here is delicious and well cooked for dinner spots."

"I really enjoyed the saltfish and bake."

Good to know

1

The restaurant does not cook any meat during Navratri, making it fully vegetarian during that time.

2

Naresh does not post the prices of food items, leading to potential overcharging.

3

The seven curry set costs $26 for a small sample of each curry.

05
Soul City image 1
Soul food restaurant

Small, cramped space with loud gospel music sets a lively, welcoming vibe. Hole in the wall appearance matches the friendly family atmosphere inside. Energy feels genuine despite the dark, worn interior.

Catfish dinners come with Mac-n-Cheese and Candied Yams that taste homemade. Options include combos with shrimp and string beans for a hearty meal.

Fried fish comes out fresh and well seasoned with a great balance of flavor. Fish sandwiches and white fish dishes pair well with sides like rice and sweet potato.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing."

"The fried fish here is fresh and perfectly seasoned."

"The dinner spots here are so tasty and delicious."

Good to know

1

Come early because they tend to sell out quickly.

2

You can't dine in at this location.

3

It's a small spot and parking on the street can be difficult.

06
AL Aqsa Restaurant | Halal Food in Jamaica image 1

Halal restaurant with a clean, comfortable environment and a cozy atmosphere suited for gatherings. Offers a great variety of foods including notable biryani and kebabs. Entrance and seating areas show signs of wear and could benefit from improvements.

Halal options stand out for dinner with consistent availability. Frequent visits show regular dinner service and a reliable menu for evening meals.

Fish dishes feature tender, flavorful curry and a variety of combos including Rohu fish. The fish items consistently come with rich, tasty gravies and are a popular choice for lunch.

People are saying

"The beef tehari here is excellent and really hit the spot."

"I loved their fish combo, it was really good."

"The dinner spots here are surprisingly cheap and the food quality is great."

Good to know

1

Customers are required to pay for food before it is served at the table.

2

The price offers great value for the amount of food you get.

3

The restaurant offers all halal kababs and biryani items.

07
The Paris Café image 1
French restaurant

French restaurant inside a historic hotel with nostalgic decor and worn leather chairs creates a unique atmosphere. The space offers power outlets at counter seats and features live music that enhances the vibe. It attracts travelers looking for a distinctive dining experience before flights.

Dinner features excellent selections and perfect service with servers who are knowledgeable and polite. The atmosphere suits a quick meal or a fun family dinner before events.

Fish and chips come with three fillets and a perfect batter. Portions are generous and the dish is consistently delicious.

People are saying

"The salmon dishes here are fresh and perfectly cooked."

"The mid-century design here is a total retro blast."

"The fish and chips here have a perfect batter."

Good to know

1

Dinner at the Paris Cafe can cost around $200 for two people.

2

Expect limited menu options, with some items frequently out of stock.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially during busy travel seasons.

08
Caribbean Soul image 1
Caribbean restaurant

Lounge-style Caribbean restaurant with Caribbean-themed decor and a rooftop area featuring a live DJ and hookah. Atmosphere shifts from serene to loud as music volume increases, creating a lively energy. Crowds gather especially on the rooftop, which offers a casual vibe but can be hot and crowded.

Surprise dinners and birthday parties happen smoothly here with easy last minute reservations and accommodating staff. The setting suits intimate celebrations, enhanced by thoughtful touches like flowers and chocolates during dinner.

Freshness stands out with the snapper fish seasoned just right. Curried fish and salmon appear often, with the escovitch fish served more like a stew than the usual fried style.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and cooked to my liking."

"The service at these dinner spots is amazing and professional."

"The snapper fish was fresh and perfectly seasoned."

Good to know

1

The paint n sip event includes 1.5 hours of bottomless Rum Punch & Mimosas.

2

Sip and Paint nights are on Tuesdays, offering a creative evening.

3

Friday nights are popular for live music and a lively atmosphere.

Discover more

Jamaica, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...