Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Williamsburg

Italian sandwiches

A sandwich that respects Italian traditions without feeling like a tourist trap.

Based on 813 Opinions
+810
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
A&C Super image 1
A&C Super image 2
A&C Super image 3
View all
Bakery

Small bakery nook with thoughtful interior design and a charming outdoor seating area tucked around the corner. Atmosphere carries good neighborhood vibes with friendly people and a relaxed pace. Known for house-baked pastries and breakfast sandwiches that attract visitors from afar.

Focaccia stands out with a next-level texture and flavor. Sandwiches like the mortadella and turkey with provolone on focaccia deliver strong Italian flavors. Baked goods include banana bread and cheddar biscuits.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with cheddar biscuit bases and simple, well-done flavors. The mortadella sandwich and bacon biscuit sandwich also deliver consistently mouthwatering taste.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were delicious."

"I found the cheddar biscuits to be amazing and light."

"The focaccia here is amazing, truly the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Seating outside the bakery is limited, so pickup is recommended.

2

They cater to gluten-free diets.

3

You can conveniently order ahead through their website.

02
Ringolevio image 1
Restaurant

Large indoor/outdoor space features a huge backyard and cozy nooks with comfortable furniture. Warm lighting and great music create a welcoming, fun vibe that shifts from cafe-style coworking during the day to lively bar energy at night. Use of reusable tableware and dog-friendly policy add to the thoughtful, eclectic atmosphere.

Fresh, handmade pastas stand out here, including gnocchi with gorgonzola sauce and tagliatelle with mixed mushrooms. Ravioli ranks highly, with all pasta made in-house and consistently flavorful.

Sandwiches feature fresh ingredients and include options like a BEC sandwich and a prosciutto sandwich. The menu also offers a ham and cheese croissant and a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich.

People are saying

"I found the homemade pasta here so fresh and flavorful."

"The homemade pasta here is so good and fresh."

"I thought the sandwich was extremely good and tasted very fresh."

Good to know

1

Make sure to ask for a stamp card because the 10th drink is free.

2

The restaurant opens at 8am on Sundays for breakfast.

3

The restaurant is dog friendly.

03
Emily's Pork Store image 1
Butcher shop deli

Mom and pop butcher shop with an authentic Italian atmosphere and old school deli vibe. The space fills with an appealing aroma that reflects its high-quality Italian meats and sandwiches. Regulars come for fresh, homemade ingredients and expert recommendations, creating a strong sense of community.

Fresh mozzarella stands out, especially in sandwiches and salads. Prosciutto and homemade salami offer authentic Italian flavors. Guanciale, nduja, and fresh ravioli add to the rich Italian selection.

Sandwiches feature hot soppressata, hot peppers, and mozzarella on fresh bread with oil and balsamic vinegar. The Italian combo stands out as a phenomenal and absolutely delicious option.

People are saying

"I thought their roast pork sandwich was the best I'd ever tasted."

"I love this grocery store for its huge Italian selection."

"I thought the Italian food's cheese was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Emily's Pork Store has been family-owned for 50 years, ensuring quality and tradition.

2

The deli offers a huge selection of Italian meats, cheeses, and grocery items.

3

Prices at this deli are reasonable for the quality of products offered.

04
Maison Provence Restaurant image 1

Restaurant offers cozy indoor and outdoor seating with decor that transports guests to the South of France through thoughtful French-themed details. Atmosphere feels authentic and inviting, creating a relaxed, vacation-like vibe. Wine and cocktails reflect Provençal influences, enhancing the overall experience.

Duck breast features in several pastas, paired with velvety sauce and cooked perfectly. Options include fettuccine and mushroom fettuccine, alongside steak and seafood pasta and a Provençal style fettuccine.

Rich sandwiches feature Swiss and raclette cheese, savory prosciutto, and a runny egg yolk. Lamb sandwiches offer an extraordinary flavor with a French twist.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the onion soup."

"The Italian food here is outstanding and richly complex."

"The duck croissant sandwich was out of this world."

Good to know

1

Savory crepes cost around $18 and dessert crepes around $11.

2

The wine selection ranges from $48 to $88, with a well-curated list.

3

Everything at Maison Provence is homemade.

05
Garden Carver image 1
Vegan restaurant

Cozy vegan cafe with a calm, earthy vibe and charming decor invites slow, relaxed visits. Friendly crowd encourages easy conversation, while jazz music and comfortable seating enhance the laid-back atmosphere. Tables inside and on the sidewalk offer versatile spots for work or casual dining.

Spicy rigatoni features meatballs with bold flavor and a rich sauce. The meatball hero uses homemade ciabatta bread. Chicken parmesan and meatball parmesan are solid choices.

Meatball subs and Italian heroes stand out with rich flavors and fresh bread. Options include premium vegan sandwiches and hearty choices like BBQ chicken and steak sandwiches.

People are saying

"I loved the breakfast croissant sandwich; it's top tier."

"The steak sandwich here is incredible, especially the bread."

"You have to try the Italian food; the meatballs are fantastic."

Good to know

1

This place is 100% vegan.

2

The restaurant is dog friendly, allowing customers to bring their dogs.

3

The chickn parm sandwich costs $15.

06
Pecoraro Latteria image 1
Italian restaurant

Small Italian restaurant with European-inspired decor and a family atmosphere creates a cozy, casual vibe. Afternoon hours bring a relaxed energy perfect for enjoying aperol spritz and unique dishes. A grab-and-go section and retail corner add convenience to the experience.

Fresh pastas come out perfectly al dente with rich, flavorful sauces like the tomato cream on Paccheri. Mozzarella and ricotta are made on-site, adding to the authentic feel alongside dishes like burrata and Focaccia pizza.

Sandwiches feature fresh Italian ingredients like prosciutto and mortadella, delivering a big, shareable size. Quality is consistent, making them a solid choice for a satisfying lunch.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"Their Italian food, especially the gnocchi, is life-changing."

"I thought the sandwiches here were amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Pizza night features all pizzas priced at $15.

2

The kitchen closes at 9 PM, so arrive early.

3

Takeout sandwiches are ready within minutes.

07
Casa Cugine image 1

Cafe blends old school Italian style with classy atmosphere and Staten Island energy. Sopranos plays on loop, creating a distinctive vibe that attracts influencers and wise guys. Sandwiches and pastries focus on simple, delicious flavors with perfectly crisp bread and authentic Italian treats.

Panini and sandwiches stand out with options like mozzarella and tomato and a notably spicy salami. Large boxes of cannolis and Italian cookies like Giuggiulena sesame and cherry biscotti add sweet variety.

Pressed sandwiches stand out with crispy bread and a solid olive oil and herb dressing. Hot soppressata and provolone sandwiches offer a tasty, satisfying option.

People are saying

"These sandwiches are packed with quality ingredients and taste amazing."

"I found the coffee here to be amazing and perfect."

"I loved the authentic Italian cookies, pastries, and pantry items."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $20 for a takeaway sandwich.

2

Casa Cugine offers a limited menu with only a few paninis available.

3

The shop is currently in a soft opening phase with staff still learning the menu.

08
Sungold Restaurant Brooklyn NY (Arlo Williamsburg) image 1

Rooftop space offers amazing Manhattan views with well-spaced tables and thoughtful decor. Atmosphere stays friendly and relaxed, enhanced by an awesome DJ and comfortable seating. Crowd remains light, making it ideal for a calm brunch or dinner experience.

Focaccia bread with chive butter stands out as a signature item. Squash gnocchi and lamb meatballs offer solid veggie and meat options. Chicken Parmesan comes in a large portion with a great salad. Panna cotta and salted caramel gelato provide notable dessert choices.

Crispy chicken sandwich stands out with perfect cooking and bursting flavor. Hangover sandwich also gets strong recommendations.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and awesome."

"The Italian food here is served in a gorgeous, moody space with dim lighting."

"Carlos and Juan were so friendly and attentive with my sandwich."

Good to know

1

Sungold offers a bottomless brunch for only $28.

2

There is little to no wait at the restaurant.

3

The restaurant has limited gluten-free options.

09
L'industrie Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space fills with crowds and energy, creating a lively and chaotic vibe. Standing room dominates both inside and outside, with unique school bus seating offering sheltered outdoor dining. Guests watch pizza-making up close while enjoying heated outdoor areas and a bustling atmosphere.

Incredible flavor stands out in their sandwiches. They pair well with the heavenly pizza and are worth the wait.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be the best in town."

"I thought the Italian food here was the best pizza in all of New York."

"The sandwiches here are incredible, especially the bread."

Good to know

1

Customers may wait about 20 minutes in line on a Saturday at 4:30 pm.

2

There was already a line forming just 10 minutes after opening on a Sunday.

3

There is no inside eating area; expect to eat standing or takeout.

10
Bar Madonna image 1
Restaurant

Chic restaurant with sophisticated decor and an excellent sound system sets a vibey, relaxed atmosphere. Music leans toward hip hop, creating a boisterous, fun energy suited for lively rounds rather than quiet conversation. The space combines thoughtful design with beautiful lighting and a modern, tasteful aesthetic.

Menu stays narrow but delivers with ossobuco meatballs standing out. Dessert features cannolis that impress even those who usually skip them.

Smashed meatball and chicken sandwiches stand out here. The chicken sandwich comes with extra truffle aioli for dipping, and the meatball sandwich is known for its crispy artichokes and rich flavor.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are innovative and worth their value."

"The Italian food here is delicious, with great vibes."

"I had the smashed meatball parm sandwich, it was insane."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Happy hour offers discounted cocktails from 5-7pm on weekdays.

3

The bar serves food until closing time, making it a late-night option.

11
Tabare Williamsburg image 1
Uruguayan restaurant

Small space with rustic Parisian bistro style and intimate atmosphere. Live music plays softly while guests enjoy backyard patio and cozy heated rooms. Food and drinks focus on Uruguayan specialties with standout homemade pasta and steak.

Homemade pasta shines here, especially the truffle mushroom and butternut squash ravioli, cooked al dente and full of flavor. Traditional starters and desserts like dulce de leche flan add to the Italian food experience.

Steak and Chivito sandwiches stand out with thinly sliced meats, neatly packed vegetables, and cheese. The Chivito offers a savory, delicious flavor, often served with seasoned fries.

People are saying

"The ribeye steak here is outstanding and some of the best I've had."

"The pasta here is fresh and usually quite tasty."

"I thought the Chivito sandwich was the best item I tried."

Good to know

1

Brunch deal for $20 includes a drink, entree, and coffee.

2

Happy hour cocktails are $10 each.

3

The restaurant only accepts cash and American Express.

12
Fandi Mata image 1
Restaurant

Lush interior with exotic green decor and high ceilings creates a spacious, Instagrammable setting. Live Cuban and salsa music energizes brunch, while craft cocktails like mezcal espresso martinis stand out. Atmosphere blends vibrant jazz vibes with attentive service and natural lighting.

Gnocchi stands out as very tasty and delicious. The burrata with grilled peaches offers a creamy and sweet balance. Spaghetti rates highly, and dishes like croquetas, Brussels sprouts, half chicken, and lamb all deliver strong flavors.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with the chicken Milanese and classic chicken options drawing praise. The lamb sandwich also offers a rich, flavorful choice.

People are saying

"Our server Mario was the best, truly making our dinner special."

"The Italian food here is amazing, thanks to the attentive team."

"I loved the chicken Milanese sandwich; it was so good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for events, especially on busy weekends.

2

Happy hour specials are available at the bar; check the timing.

3

The venue can host events for 15-20 people comfortably.

13
Isla & Co. - Williamsburg image 1

Bright, airy space with plenty of natural light and a lovely outdoor garden that welcomes dogs. Atmosphere feels fresh and vibrant, with great espresso martinis and a relaxed vibe suited for casual dates or happy hour. Metal chairs inside contrast with the inviting, shaded patio seating outside.

Spicy prawn rigatoni stands out with its bold, spicy flavor and creamy vodka sauce. Lamb rigatoni offers a smoky, saucy experience, while the ragu and octopus dishes add variety to the rich Italian menu.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with their crispy texture and strong flavor. Breakfast sandwiches capture a classic Spanish Harlem vibe with a fresh twist.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are thoughtfully crafted and delicious."

"The chicken sandwich here is fire."

"The spicy prawn pasta here is so tasty."

Good to know

1

The happy hour is from 3 PM to 6 PM, Monday to Friday.

2

You need to reserve online first to make it easier for yourselves.

3

The restaurant charges a $2 fee to pay for your meal using a QR code system.

14
MISIPASTA image 1
Restaurant

Outdoor garden offers a beautiful, quiet atmosphere with mature trees and soft lighting creating an intimate setting. Indoor seating includes chefs' counter style arrangements that bring diners close to food preparation. Cocktails like Negroni and martinis stand out for their quality and size.

Fresh pasta stands out with intricate flavor profiles like butter pistachio ravioli and artichoke pasta. Desserts include a mousse-like chocolate panna cotta and a smooth affogato to finish.

Artichoke sandwich stands out as a key item, often described as very good, unpretentious, and even insane. The sandwich menu is simple and pairs well with homemade pasta dishes.

People are saying

"I thought the grilled artichoke sandwich was so good."

"The spaghetti with bottarga, lemon, and garlic crumbs was so tasty."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, was outstanding."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to dine at the restaurant.

2

The restaurant offers special holiday dishes like chocolate torta for Valentine's Day.

3

Expect limited menu options as some dishes may be sold out during dinner.

15
Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe image 1

Sandwich shop combines old-school Italian charm with a modern, basic layout featuring a long counter and a big fridge. Atmosphere varies from authentic deli vibe to a more typical, unremarkable setting inside. Outdoor seating includes benches and picnic tables, offering a casual spot to enjoy food.

Multiple cured meats like capocollo, spiced salami, and prosciutto fill the panini alongside fresh mozzarella and arugula. The homemade vodka sauce and chicken cutlet add rich flavor, while pasta and salads offer quick Italian meal options.

Offers great Italian sandwiches with fresh ingredients and creative combos. Known for standout options like the FDNY and Godmother sandwiches that fill you up and deliver bold flavors.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches here to be delicious and good."

"I found the food here to be delicious and came in big portions."

"These Italian sandwiches are the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Expect a 35+ minute wait for a sandwich during busy hours.

2

Prices for sandwiches range from $17 to $24, which is considered high.

3

You should order ahead to avoid long wait times.

16
Bacàn image 1
Italian restaurant

Bright space with tall windows and minimalist decor creates a modern Italian vibe. Cocktails and spritz selection stand out, offering a lively drink experience. Atmosphere suits leisurely brunches and casual gatherings near the park.

Tiramisu stands out with a rich, authentic flavor. Fresh pasta adds a solid, tasty base to the menu.

Sandwiches feature tuna, veggie, and egg varieties with fresh ingredients. Options include a special tuna sandwich and a breakfast egg sandwich served with Italian pastries.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, is amazing."

"I loved their expertly crafted cocktails."

"I loved the sandwiches, especially the veggie and tuna ones."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm daily with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Live jazz performances occur every Wednesday night starting at 8pm.

3

Reservations are recommended for groups larger than 10, especially on weekends.

17
The Bedford image 1
Restaurant

Rustic restaurant offers a humongous outdoor dining area with heaters and low light vibe indoors. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting but gets super loud during dinner. Seating options include a nice indoor bar and a cool pizza spot in the back.

Risotto balls stand out with great flavor, perfect crunch, and an amazing garlic aioli. The lobster ravioli offers a rich, divine taste.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with pickleback fried chicken and pickleback slaw toppings. Burgers and sandwiches like the Old Fashioned hit the spot without trying to be fancy.

People are saying

"It's a cozy place with amazing, flavorful food."

"The lobster ravioli here is divine."

"That pickleback fried chicken sandwich really hit the spot."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available, but not every day of the week.

2

Reservations are required for brunch on Sundays.

3

The restaurant charges a surcharge for credit card payments.

18
Little Ruby's Williamsburg image 1

Restaurant offers two bars and covered outdoor seating with a clean, neutral-toned interior. Atmosphere feels lively and upbeat, suitable for groups or solo visits. Cocktails stand out with strong, flavorful drinks like frozen mango margaritas and yuzu margaritas.

Shrimp pasta and spicy vodka pasta stand out with rich, creamy sauces. Gluten-free pasta offers a decent option. Fried chicken schnitzel can be added to any pasta for extra flavor.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with options like the egg sandwich and a solid breakfast sandwich. The menu also features a shrimp and avocado salad that complements the sandwich choices.

People are saying

"The pasta dishes here are delicious, especially the vodka sauce."

"The Italian food here is so satisfying, I keep coming back."

"The staff was so kind and kept offering refills."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 30-40 minutes for outdoor seating.

2

Reservations are not required, and walk-ins are welcome.

3

Prices are affordable, averaging around $50 per meal.

19
La petite joie image 1
French restaurant

Small French restaurant offers intimate, cozy atmosphere with beautiful indoor and outdoor seating. Decor features charming, floral accents that create a warm, home-like vibe. Guests enjoy a friendly, welcoming environment that captures the essence of France.

Escargot, shrimp risotto, and onion soup stand out with rich flavors. Dishes like raviolis, duck confit, and boeuf bourguignon offer classic Italian tastes with a unique twist.

Bold and flavorful Merguez Sandwich offers a great twist on brunch. Open face sandwiches come with delicious tomato preserve that spreads well. Classic options like Croque Madame and omelets are also available.

People are saying

"The brunch here is amazing, especially the Eggs Benedict."

"The gnocchi and braised beef tortellini are the best Italian food I've ever had."

"The sandwich here was spot on with every recommendation."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is from 12-6 on weekdays and 4-6 on weekends.

2

The happy hour features $2 oysters and cocktail specials.

3

The restaurant serves brunch on Sundays.

20
Good Thanks image 1
Australian restaurant

Cozy interior with gorgeous design and open kitchen archways creates a welcoming vibe. Outdoor seating with a nice patio accommodates diners with pups. Loud noise levels contrast with the relaxed atmosphere, while unique cocktails and good music enhance the experience.

Shrimp linguine features large, fresh shrimp while sausage pasta offers a bit of heat. Some pasta dishes show overcooked shrimp and bland sauces.

Shrimp sandwich features a fried shrimp patty with a springy texture and crunchy panko breading. Egg sandwiches come in varieties like kimchi and classic breakfast styles, both highly praised for their flavor.

People are saying

"The brunch food here is delicious and thoughtfully prepared."

"You have to try the breakfast sandwich; it's savory and delicious."

"The Italian food's calamari was excellent and the best I had."

Good to know

1

On Wednesdays, the restaurant offers half price natural wine bottles.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

Expect a wait during brunch hours, especially on weekends.

21
Sunday In Brooklyn image 1
American restaurant

Quintessentially Brooklyn interior with heated outdoor greenhouses and a lively corner bar create a cozy, bustling vibe. Seating feels narrow and tightly arranged, encouraging quick table turnover and limiting group gatherings. Two-level layout offers both indoor and outdoor spaces with heated lamps for comfort.

Lasagna stands out with rich layers and excellent service. The shakshuka with focaccia offers a warm, wholesome dish with a sauce that soaks well into the bread, though the feta can be skipped.

Crispy and flavorful, the hot chicken sandwich delivers a perfect amount of heat. The egg and cheese sandwich comes huge with a crispy hash brown, making it a standout breakfast option.

People are saying

"You have to try the pancakes; they're thick and fluffy."

"The egg and cheese sandwich here is a great choice."

"The Italian food here, especially the lasagna, is incredible."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for weekend dining due to high demand.

2

Sunday brunch is particularly busy; expect long wait times without a reservation.

3

The restaurant hosts a holiday pop-up with special cocktails for six weeks each year.

22
Hole In The Wall image 1

Corner space with big windows and classic old room design creates a light-filled and cozy atmosphere. Indoor and shaded outdoor seating accommodate both quiet lunches and lively gatherings with live music. Crowd includes those appreciating fabulous cocktails and a down-to-earth vibe.

Shrimp rigatoni alla vodka stands out with its spicy vodka sauce and tender shrimp. Bucatini carbonara features sweet corn that adds a bright note to the rich pasta.

Chicken sandwich comes tasty and crunchy with fries that have a lemon and spicy twist. Breakfast sandwich features fresh, light buns with eggs, bacon, hashbrowns, and cheese, served with fries.

People are saying

"The brunch here is amazing, especially the crispy pork belly."

"The rigatoni here is just like I remembered it."

"The donut holes in this sandwich were so refreshing and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak summer months.

2

Customers must scan a QR code to pay when checking out.

3

Happy hour runs from 4-6 PM Monday to Friday, with cocktails priced at $10 and beers at $5.

23
Gran Torino image 1
Restaurant

Large space includes multiple themed rooms, a gorgeous garden, and outdoor seating with natural air flow. Atmosphere varies from relaxing to lively with great music and control over sound. Dog-friendly with a private room option and amenities like a pool table.

Creamy, rich pasta cooked perfectly al dente stands out here. Prosciutto and tuna sandwiches rate highly, alongside light tiramisu and classic bruschetta.

Fresh ingredients make the tuna avocado sandwich stand out, especially on focaccia. The prosciutto and tuna sandwiches hit a perfect balance, while the breaded chicken sandwich shows a crafted touch beyond expectations.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are delicious and spectacular."

"The Italian food here feels like a mellow, luscious oasis."

"I thought the tuna sandwich was perfect and very tasty."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is advertised at 10:00 PM, but staff may enforce it starting at 11:00 PM.

2

The venue has no rental fee, only a minimum spend for food and drinks.

3

Gran Torino is dog-friendly and offers a special dog menu.

24
Leo image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious and bright restaurant with minimal and stylish interior and small seating and tables. Atmosphere is lively and cozy with good street seating that is somewhat heated. Wine selection is notably strong, featuring natural wines and draft options.

Pizza and pasta stand out with authentic Italian flavors and perfect cooking. Dishes like Cacio e Pepe, soppressata pizza, and meatballs pair well with delicious orange wine and tiramisu for dessert.

Sandwiches feature sourdough bread and include options like mozzarella and prosciutto with a sweet and mildly spicy taste. Some breakfast sandwiches, including a salmon bagel, are popular, but quality can vary, with occasional dryness or unimpressive flavors.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, is delicious."

"You have to try their soft serve ice cream; the flavors change often."

"I loved the sourdough bread for the sandwiches."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary on weekends due to potential waits of over an hour.

2

The price is 4 and 5 USD per slice, which is excellent value for money.

3

Dining in is the preferred option because you can also get soft serve and wine.

Discover more

Williamsburg, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...