Sag Harbor

Explore over 200 places in Sag Harbor, New York for coffee, date spots, drinks, and more, all curated by locals on Atly.

UPDATED MAY 15, 2026

Best lists

A hunger that only a local meal can satisfy.

8 curated spots

Elegant venue boasting fantastic harbor views and an upscale colonial ambiance with tasteful, cozy interiors.

Charming Italian eatery with substantial portions and a European bistro ambiance, blending casual takeout with relaxed dining.

Small, quaint shop with a huge, amazing donut flavor selection and a calm, cool coffee shop vibe.

Clean and authentic Mexican take-out spot featuring a small market area and well-packaged food with affordable pricing.

Charming downtown spot featuring a sizable sushi bar and outdoor patio seating with a cozy, lively atmosphere.