Shelter Island Heights

Explore over 30 places in Shelter Island Heights, New York for coffee, date spots, drinks, and more, all curated by locals on Atly.

UPDATED MAR 30, 2026

Popular in your area

Cozy, welcoming café known for excellent baked goods, sandwiches, and coffee, with a genuine community vibe.

Elegant dining space featuring a 12-foot open wood-burning hearth, cozy lighting, and a warm, intimate ambiance.

Charming Italian eatery with warm hospitality, a cozy, lively atmosphere, and complimentary bread and olives.

Effortlessly chic beachside resort featuring stunning water views, private terraces, and a laid-back Scandinavian 'beach shack' vibe.