Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Cookie spots in Utah

Made for those who view a meal as incomplete unless it concludes with a substantial, American-style cookie.

Based on 493 Opinions
+490
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Pie Party image 1
Pie Party image 2
Pie Party image 3
View all
Bakery

Bakery offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere with cute, fun decor and seating spaces. The vibe is warm and lively, attracting those who appreciate unique, high-quality pies and pastries often sold out quickly.

Pumpkin pie with sage whipped cream and a graham cracker crust stands out, and it's gluten-free. Chocolate chip cookies and pecan pie also feature on the menu.

Soft and buttery textures define the brown butter chocolate chip cookie and molasses spice cookies. Unique flavors like the peanut butter togarashi cookie add a creative twist to the cookie selection.

People are saying

"I thought the pie here was the best I ever had."

"You have to try the molasses cookies; they're dangerously good."

"You have to try the pumpkin pie; it's ridiculously delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect certain items to sell out quickly due to high demand.

2

Prices for pies range from $30-35, which may be considered pricey.

3

They offer a few gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

02
Grapefruit & Thyme image 1

Bright, cute decor creates a cheerful atmosphere with wonderful pies that range from sweet to savory. The space feels welcoming and clean, attracting those who appreciate flaky crusts and fantastic flavor in their desserts. Pies change with seasonal fruits, offering a fresh and varied experience.

Pies stand out here with brisket pie, chicken pot pie pocket pie, and Key Lime Pie all tasting rich and well-crafted. Sweet options like Dutch Apple and peanut butter pies balance fresh ingredients with flaky crusts.

Brown butter and vanilla bean cookies stand out with their perfect bake and melt-in-your-mouth texture. Chocolate chip cookies also feature as a favorite treat among the selection.

People are saying

"I thought the key lime pie was so good."

"You have to try their chicken pot pie pocket pie; it's perfect for lunch."

"I thought the cookie was the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

They offer a variety of sweet and savory pies on the menu.

2

Ordering and pickup is easy and efficient.

3

Seasonal fruit is used in their pies for fresh flavors.

03
Darn Good Coffee image 1
Coffee shop

Small house setting creates a cozy and welcoming atmosphere with natural light and plants enhancing the space. Plenty of board games and a chess set invite relaxed socializing or quiet breaks. The vibe stays comfortable and thoughtful, making it easy to spend hours chatting or working.

Grilled cheese panini stands out with fresh basil adding a unique twist. Staff offer fresh chocolate chip cookies alongside classic American comfort food.

Fresh chai cookies and chocolate cookies with salted caramel stand out here. Staff often offer fresh chocolate chip cookies, and locally made pastries and cookies are always available.

People are saying

"The coffee drinks at this cafe are delicious and high quality."

"I loved their unique grilled cheese panini with fresh basil."

"You have to try the fresh chai cookie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

The strawberry croissants sell out fast, so arrive early.

2

DGC grows their herbs right outside, ensuring freshness.

3

Expect a cozy atmosphere perfect for hanging out.

04
The Old Grist Mill image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop with warm, inviting atmosphere and freshly baked bread aroma fills a large, roomy space with small tables. The vibe is cheerful and hometown, bustling yet family-friendly. Known for healthy sandwiches and affordable, hearty meals, it offers a varied selection of baked goods and treats.

Philly Cheesesteak stands out with its spicy tang and juicy flavor. Cream cheese brownies and cinnamon rolls offer rich, addictive sweetness. Sandwiches like the club on multi-grain and grilled cheese with tomato basil soup add solid American comfort options.

Cookies come fresh and enormous, almost as big as a face. Options include oatmeal chocolate chip and pumpkin bars, all priced well for a hearty lunch combo.

People are saying

"I loved the homemade bread here; it made the sandwiches."

"I enjoyed their great tasting creamy potato soup."

"The American Food here has amazing sandwiches on fresh bread."

Good to know

1

Lunch with a sandwich, chips, drink, and cookie costs under $10.

2

Expect longer wait times for pizza orders as they take a while to prepare.

3

Every flavor of chips costs 75ยข extra, so choose wisely.

05
Leatherby's Family Creamery, Orem image 1

Old-school diner style creates a fun, family-friendly atmosphere with booths and big tables for groups or dates. The space feels cozy yet lively, often loud and crowded but clean and well-kept. Ice cream and desserts are ultra premium and massive, drawing regulars who enjoy both sweet treats and diner meals.

Grilled cheese sandwiches serve as comfort food here, with options like a grown-up version and a kids' size. Turkey club sandwiches and loaded fries add variety to the classic American menu.

A large chocolate chip cookie anchors the Cookie Concoction, paired with two ice cream flavors, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. Smaller servings like Gavin's Dish include two cookies alongside a grapefruit-size scoop of ice cream.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is out of this world delicious and refreshing."

"The ice cream and hot fudge here are pure bliss."

"The Cookie Concoction is an ice cream bliss experience."

Good to know

1

Leatherby's serves massive portions of ice cream and diner food.

2

Expect reasonable prices for large ice cream servings.

3

The creamery is family-owned and has been for decades.

06
On Broadway Deli image 1

Small deli with fresh, high-quality sandwiches offers generous portions at reasonable prices. Atmosphere feels vibrant and clean, perfect for a quick, satisfying lunch downtown. Known for carefully made sandwiches that stand out in the city.

Club sandwich stands out as very tasty and well-made. Unique options like jambalaya add variety, alongside solid choices like chicken noodle soup and spicy sandwiches.

Cookies and rice krispie treats come with drinks and chips while you wait. The cookies are very good and often described as delicious.

People are saying

"I highly recommend their sandwiches; they're the best I've ever had."

"I loved the club sandwich; it was one of the best I've had."

"I thought the cookie I got was delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $10 for custom sandwiches.

2

They use fresh ingredients in all their sandwiches.

3

A sweet treat is included with every order.

07
Old Grist Mill Bread Co image 1

Sandwich shop with a cozy, light atmosphere and a dining room that reflects a vintage style. It offers customizable sandwiches and fresh-baked goods at very reasonable prices. The place stays quiet and comfortable, with friendly staff and easy parking.

Freshly baked bread, cinnamon rolls, brownies, and scones appear daily. Soups like tomato bisque and clam chowder stand out, along with a memorable reuben sandwich and chicken noodle soup.

Cookies come in several varieties like cowpie, oatmeal with walnuts, and peanut butter. Sugar cookies stand out for their delicious flavor and are popular enough to order in advance.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were fantastic and a great price."

"I found the oatmeal raisin cookie to be delicious."

"Their fresh baked goods and sandwiches are amazing."

Good to know

1

Prices are generally below average, making it a good value.

2

The menu includes a variety of fresh-baked goods and custom sandwiches.

3

Parking is ample, including accessible spots at the front.

08
Woodbine Food Hall image 1

Food hall combines upscale food court with large outdoor patio and live music, creating a laid-back, lively atmosphere. Graffiti art and outdoor seating add to the open, inviting vibe. Variety of cuisines and an adjacent bar offer diverse options for groups and families.

Menu includes jambalaya, ramen, and pizza alongside classic American staples like cheeseburgers and fries. Prices can be high, with some combos reaching near $50 without drinks.

Chunky cookies stand out with variety of flavors and a chunky texture that offers a unique experience. The s'mores cookie impresses with rich, bold taste.

People are saying

"I loved the variety of food, from ramen to pizza to burgers."

"I thought the cookies here were amazing and super good."

"This American food is great for picky kids with lots of options."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample and convenient for visitors.

2

Expect a minimum spend of $20 at most food vendors.

3

The food hall features a rooftop bar with QR code ordering.

09
Leatherby's Family Creamery image 1

Ice cream shop with classic decor and large portions creates a lively, family-friendly atmosphere often filled with noise from kids and teens. Busy environment features beautiful ice cream displays and a confusing seating layout, making it feel like a bustling cafรฉ rather than a quiet parlor.

Hamburgers stand out as a favorite, especially among kids. Loaded fries offer a satisfying side, and every detail, from whipped cream to baked cookies and brownies, shows clear care.

Small cookies sell for 25 cents a pair, making them an affordable treat. The Celesteโ€™s Cookie Concoction and caramel cookie butter sundae stand out with large portions and detailed care in presentation.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was amazing."

"The ice cream here is so delicious, it's a total treat."

"Their ice cream is a decadent treat that melts in your mouth."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times, especially on weekends due to high traffic.

2

Reservations are not accepted, so plan to arrive early.

3

The restaurant is open until 11 pm for late-night ice cream cravings.

10
Panera Bread image 1

Bright lighting and clean, cozy decor create a welcoming space with a quiet, relaxed vibe. People come here for casual meals, studying, or chatting, often enjoying free Wi-Fi and friendly service. The atmosphere shifts smoothly from calm to lively, making it suitable for various activities.

Homestyle Chicken Noodle Soup offers a flavorful broth and perfectly cooked noodles, giving a homemade feel. The Green Goddess Cobb Salad with Chicken stays consistently fresh and flavorful. Mac and cheese stands out as very good and popular with kids.

Free cookies often come with orders or as a thank you, including for kids. The Kitchen Sink cookie and pumpkin cookie stand out as popular choices.

People are saying

"I found the food to be delicious and fresh."

"The staff here is so friendly and helpful."

"The American Food here, especially the mac and cheese, is some of the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is very clean and organized.

2

They have plenty of good vegetarian options.

3

The tablet ordering system is available but may experience outages.

11
Potbelly Sandwich Shop image 1

Cozy sandwich shop with old time charm and cute decor creates a welcoming atmosphere. Music adds to the great vibe while a variety of tables accommodate different groups. Known for top quality ingredients and a surprisingly diverse menu, it offers a satisfying experience despite being a bit pricey.

Prime rib steak sandwich stands out with rich flavor and no onions. Chicken pot pie soup offers a comforting, flavorful option. Mac and cheese delivers a creamy, satisfying side.

Oatmeal chocolate chip and chocolate brownie cookies come in solid portions and taste good. Cold brew shakes include a small cookie, and broken cookies are offered in a bowl for dogs.

People are saying

"I loved the meatball and tuna salad sandwiches here."

"The cookies here are so yummy and packed with flavor."

"I loved the prime rib steak sandwich; it's amazing American food."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay full price for each item; combos do not include drinks.

2

Some menu items may lack advertised ingredients, so check before ordering.

3

Prices are considered high for the portion sizes offered.

12
Carl's Jr. image 1
Fast food restaurant

Retro decor creates a clean, upbeat atmosphere with a chill vibe that feels welcoming. Mornings are usually slow and quiet, making it easy to enjoy a peaceful meal. Unique menu items like the Western Bacon Cheeseburger and awesome cookies set it apart from typical fast food spots.

Western Bacon Cheeseburger stands out with its rich flavor and customization options. Staff help tailor orders like the Jr. WBC without extra charges beyond bacon. Jalapeno double cheeseburgers offer a spicy twist, and burgers come carefully prepared, not just thrown together.

Cookies come with a very sweet taste and an awesome quality. Cookie P offers a kind attitude and even shares cookies and milk with kids.

People are saying

"This fast food place has the kindest, most attentive staff I've ever met."

"I thought the burgers were great and delicious."

"I had a craving for the Western Bacon Cheeseburger, it's addicting."

Good to know

1

Parking can be challenging, so arrive early to find a spot.

2

Expect to pay around $14 for a typical meal.

3

There is often no wait time during lunch hours.

Discover more

Utah

Area guide
Loading Map...