Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Salt Lake City

Cookies and sandwiches

A sandwich shop that treats the cookie at the end of the meal with as much care as the main course.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
MARCATO Kitchen image 1
MARCATO Kitchen image 2
MARCATO Kitchen image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Mini-bistro inside a warehouse-like space with kiosk ordering and no seating. Atmosphere feels family-oriented and casual, with a giant kitchen window and patio games nearby. Known for fresh bread and bold Italian sandwiches with a crunchy, chewy crust.

Cookies come out warm and are cooked to order. The big chocolate chip cookie has a good texture and flavor but leans a little sweet.

Beet Stromboli stands out as a unique and flavorful sandwich option. Meatball sandwiches rank highly, and the chef's creations offer distinct takes on stromboli and calzone styles.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the Stromboli, is amazing with fresh bread and lots of meat."

"I thought the sandwich was the best I ever had."

"I should make sure to get the chocolate chip cookie."

Good to know

1

Orders are only available online through their website and DoorDash.

2

You need to take your food to go from this restaurant.

3

There is no seating available; you have to pick up your order.

02
Eats Bakery & Coffee image 1

Spacious coffee shop with an open, airy layout and plenty of seating, including outdoor tables. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, with quiet, chill vibes suitable for studying or relaxing. Features a kids' play table and uses reusable plates and cups for dine-in.

Creative flavors like sesame chocolate chip and rosemary chocolate chip stand out among the cookies. Warming them up enhances their taste, making them even better.

Breakfast sandwiches come on the best biscuit with options like bacon, egg, and cheese. The ham and cheese sandwich is very good, and the vegan breakfast sandwich is delicious too.

People are saying

"The vegetarian donuts and cinnamon rolls are huge and delicious."

"The breakfast sandwich here is amazing."

"These cookies have really creative flavors."

Good to know

1

Eats Bakery & Coffee offers a huge selection of vegan donuts and pastries.

2

Breakfast sandwiches are available on Sundays.

3

All baked goods are vegan, catering to plant-based diets.

03
Caputo's Market & Deli 15th & 15th image 1

Italian-style deli with an artsy vibe and cute shop layout offers a shaded patio for outdoor seating. Atmosphere feels fun and lively, attracting those who appreciate unique flavors and quality foods. Known for best sandwiches and an exceptional selection of cheeses, chocolates, and high-end meats.

Chocolate chip cookie stands out as a delicious treat here. Cookies pair well with the black coffee from the airpot.

Sandwiches come in huge portions with top-notch quality ingredients. Options include making sandwiches a panini, and staff accommodate special requests like no cheese.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best in town."

"I found amazing artisan chocolate and cheese here."

"You have to try the chocolate chip cookie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Caputo's offers a fantastic selection of imported cheeses and unique food products.

2

Limited patio seating is available, so arrive early for outdoor dining.

3

Expect a great assortment of unique food items not found in other stores.

04
Beaucoup Bakery image 1

Market-style bakery space offers a warm, friendly atmosphere with plenty of room for groups. Quiet energy contrasts with a backroomesque vibe from its mall setting. Known for exceptional French pastries and fresh sourdough, it stands out for quality and variety.

Cookies stand out with raspberry and linzer varieties offering distinct flavors. They share shelf space with chocolate chip and other pastries, all crafted with care and taste.

Steak and caprese sandwiches stand out with sourdough bread and fresh ingredients. Drive-thru orders can take about 20 minutes, but the sandwiches are well made and memorable.

People are saying

"These pastries are gorgeous and taste fantastic."

"My sandwich was divine, one of the best I've had."

"Their sourdough bread has an excellent flavor and a nice crust."

Good to know

1

Get there early as popular items sell out fast.

2

The bakery often runs out of bread by mid-afternoon.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality of baked goods.

05
Babyโ€™s Bagels image 1

Bagel shop connects to a record store and coffee bar, featuring vintage vibe, funky artwork, and brick floors. Atmosphere feels cute and charming with indoor and outdoor seating, including a shady patio. Crowd enjoys a fun, relaxed energy while dining and sipping coffee.

Cookies come thin, soft, and salted, especially the Chocolate Chip variety. Cakes and other sweet treats also stand out as good options.

Sausage and bacon bagel sandwiches stand out with rich flavors and a satisfying mix. The bacon, egg, and cheese bagel sandwich pairs well with a salt bagel, creating a classic, hearty option.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be amazing and delicious."

"The bagel sandwiches here are amazing and perfect every time."

"I found the Chocolate Chip Cookie to be good, thin, soft, and salted."

Good to know

1

Babyโ€™s Bagels accepts only cashless payments.

2

Parking can be hard to find, but there's a small lot behind the building.

3

There is limited indoor seating available.

06
On Broadway Deli image 1

Small deli with fresh, high-quality sandwiches offers generous portions at reasonable prices. Atmosphere feels vibrant and clean, perfect for a quick, satisfying lunch downtown. Known for carefully made sandwiches that stand out in the city.

Cookies and rice krispie treats come with drinks and chips while you wait. The cookies are very good and often described as delicious.

Sandwiches come with careful preparation and taste homemade. Options include custom creations for picky eaters and breakfast sandwiches available weekly.

People are saying

"I highly recommend their sandwiches; they're the best I've ever had."

"The deli staff here is so friendly and remembers you by name."

"I thought the cookie I got was delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $10 for custom sandwiches.

2

They use fresh ingredients in all their sandwiches.

3

A sweet treat is included with every order.

07
Carlucci's Bakery image 1

Bakery offers a warm, peaceful atmosphere with a beautiful cafe setting. It draws a crowd with freshly baked bread and a wide variety of pastries and sandwiches that stand out for quality and flavor. The place feels cozy and inviting, suitable for casual visits or sharing desserts.

Sugar cookies taste homemade and remind of grandma's baking, especially the flower-shaped ones. Other cookies like the Black & White and lemon cookie come off as just okay.

Sandwiches feature fresh ingredients and bread that tastes like it was baked that morning. Options like the Italian Tofu and lemon chicken sandwiches stand out for their flavor and quality.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be delicious."

"I thought the coffee here was fantastic."

"I thought the fruit tart was amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a good variety of treats, including pastries and sandwiches.

2

They serve breakfast all day, making it a great spot for morning meals.

3

The sandwiches are large, so come hungry or plan to save half for later.

08
Rose Canyon Deli image 1

Throwback to old diners with a cheerful, welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. Busy and lively, it draws a crowd who enjoy customizable sandwiches made with fresh ingredients. Prices stay reasonable while offering generous portions and a friendly, personal touch.

The cookies include a white chocolate macadamia that stands out for its flavor. Meals often come with a free cookie as a nice addition.

Sandwiches feature high-quality ingredients and a wide assortment of meats, breads, and toppings for full customization. Staff offer helpful suggestions and ensure sandwiches meet exact preferences.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and fresh."

"The staff here makes every sandwich feel like a warm welcome home."

"I got a delicious cookie with my meal."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during lunch hours, especially between 11:00 and 12:00.

2

Arrive before 10am to avoid the lunch rush and ensure quick service.

3

Daily specials include a taco salad with a drink option.

09
Argentinas Cafe image 1
Coffee shop

Small cafe with Argentine style decor and classic seating offers a clean, cozy atmosphere that feels lively yet relaxed. Empanadas stand out as phenomenal and creative, often selling out on busy days. Malbec wine complements the tasteful, inviting vibe suited for quick bites or casual gatherings.

Shortbread cookies with dolce de leche filling stand out here. Two cookies cost about $4, offering a sweet treat alongside empanadas.

Sandwiches feature milanesa with a side of chimichurri. Options include avocado toast alongside a full coffee menu.

People are saying

"I thought the empanadas here were the best I've ever had."

"The pastries here are baked fresh and not overly sweet."

"I thought the cookies here were amazing."

Good to know

1

Empanadas can sell out on weekends and busy days.

2

They are only open a few days a week with limited hours.

3

Online hours do not match actual hours.

10
Woodbine Food Hall image 1

Food hall combines upscale food court with large outdoor patio and live music, creating a laid-back, lively atmosphere. Graffiti art and outdoor seating add to the open, inviting vibe. Variety of cuisines and an adjacent bar offer diverse options for groups and families.

Chunky cookies stand out with variety of flavors and a chunky texture that offers a unique experience. The s'mores cookie impresses with rich, bold taste.

Sandwiches feature bold spices and medium heat, especially in the lamb and beef chopped cheese. Bread stays crispy outside and soft inside. Options like the Schnitzel and BLOT sandwiches include standout ingredients like pickled tomato.

People are saying

"I loved the variety of food, from ramen to pizza to burgers."

"I thought the cookies here were amazing and super good."

"I had the best sandwich and soup ever."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample and convenient for visitors.

2

Expect a minimum spend of $20 at most food vendors.

3

The food hall features a rooftop bar with QR code ordering.

11
Tulie Bakery image 1

Small bakery with bright minimal design and friendly atmosphere. Offers outdoor patio seating and draws a steady morning crowd. Known for exceptional pastries and a cozy spot to catch up with friends.

Shortbread cookies stand out with their rich flavor. Sugar cookies bring a Christmas taste, and duck-shaped cookies add a fun twist to the tasty selection.

Sandwiches feature phenomenal bread and are made to order with a 10-12 minute wait. Options like the cream cheese and avocado and grilled cheese tomato basil stand out for their flavor and perfectly melted cheese.

People are saying

"I found the olive oil cake to be amazing and to die for."

"I will dream about this sandwich when I return."

"I found the cookies here to be tasty and some of the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Parking can be tricky; consider street parking or spots behind the building.

2

The bakery has limited seating, so be prepared for a wait during busy hours.

3

Expect a quick-moving line, but it can get long during peak times.

Discover more

Salt Lake City, Utah

Area guide
Loading Map...