Dominique A

Google review

The young lady at the front was sweet, had a smile on her face & the seating area outside was cute! As for the food, not so cute… Everything we ordered is something we would normally order from any spot that serves breakfast. For ~$37 we got 1 iced chai, 1 Arnold Palmer, 1 French toast muffin & 2 bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches on ciabatta rolls. One had extra bacon, one subbed for scrambled egg at no extra cost. 1. The chai latte looks & tastes like it’s almost entirely oat milk with cinnamon… disappointing. 2. The Arnold Palmer tastes like unsweetened lemon water?? Like *barely* brewed tea, lots of lemon and water… 3. The breakfast sandwich starts at $6 and ended up $9.75 & $12.75 (+$3 for extra bacon) We opted for ciabatta’s bc the bagels on display look like grocery store bagels. The “ciabatta” was very dry and I’m wondering if it was gluten free bread. There was SO MUCH black pepper on the bacon?? The scrambled egg tasted like premixed carton/rehydrated eggs. 4. The muffin was not bad, but idk if it was made in-house

Elizabeth Wroten

Google review

Sweet Melissa's is always an absolute delight. Staff is kind, patient and accommodating (Shout-out to Gianluca, Annie and Sydney!). As someone with Celiac's it's also really nice to have a bakery to go to that is so careful and considerate of a wide variety of dietary needs and restrictions. I've gotten several pastries and other items over the years since I discovered this gem in the heart of Middletown and I have never once had a cross-contamination reaction. My husband and I have occasionally stopped in to have dates here and I could easily spend the day writing here. There are games available for kids too, so it's really a family-friendly spot. Anyone who needs (or wants) a bakery absolutely can and should patronize Sweet Melissa's!

John Chaski

Google review

I discovered this place in the context of being diagnosed with type 2 diabetes and searching for restaurants that will cater to the new diet/lifestyle I was embarking on. The low carb lunch and sugar free/gluten free dessert options are awesome - I’ve made plenty of t2d friendly baked goods at home but they are on another level. I am so glad this place and these people exist, it’s hard to explain what it means to be able to walk into a bakery and order something without any guilt or anxiety but as cringe as it might sound it’s been a kind of powerful experience for me.

Ryan Riley

Google review

A hot coffee and delicious bagel sandwich was exactly what I needed. Gluten free options as well which was important for our crew! Next time I’m in Bethany will be popping by for sure

Bernadette Thomas

Google review

Love this market! I have Celiac Dx and both of my kids. We have to eat gluten-free. ShopRite has the best selection of gluten-free foods. It is my go-to supermarket.