Marion Brown

Google review

We had our son's rehearsal dinner here on 5/30/25. Fabulous service for Mikayla and Lilly, as well as a side of humor from Jimmy.. The food and service five star. Bride is gluten free and they easily accommodated her dietary restrictions. We can't wait to go back!

Ana Carmona

Google review

This is a special little place that my family talked about the whole trip. We visited on our first day in Lake Geneva and loved it. The staff are friendly and the food is so good. We really liked the omelets, French toast, and steak and eggs. They even offered us gluten free toast as a toast option! Delicious. Worth the stop.

Kylie

Google review

Very quaint and cute! Extensive wine, beer, and alcohol list. The flights are definitely worth the price and the way to go! Our charcuterie board was good, with an option to add gluten free crackers. The space is definitely more intimate, so expect a wait time if you're going during high volume.

Pam Conley

Google review

I had my first order with them and I'm gluten free and had there glu free pizza OMG best pizza ever since I had the allergy ..I would recommend this to everyone that has the gluten free allergy

Cheryl Frager

Google review

I went in for a gluten free pie and they had one! We were going to our cousins for Thanksgiving in Illinois and stumbled across Lake Geneva Pie Company. We were too late to order a pie, so the kind last behind the counter helped us find one! Thank you! We have a lot of gluten free people in the family! The pie was a hit and I’m sure they will be driving up from Illinois to get them from now on! Thanks you!