Stephanie T

Google review

Had a great experience here. I came on a Saturday afternoon, it wasn’t too busy or loud, experienced great customer service and had some lovely cocktails. Would definitely return. The guac and salsa were so good! I came here with someone who is gluten free and they had a great selection of options too.

Krista Seibert

Google review

The Waterman Grille is a great place for a quality meal. The atmosphere is elegant, but a little crammed. The food was very delicious. The fennel and chestnut soup was incredible! What an interesting flavor combination. The fall panzanella salad is excellent also. All of the flavors really compliment each other. My girlfriend got the burger, which was cooked perfectly and delicious. Gluten free is a must for her and the burger bun was great. They also offered gluten free dinner rolls, which were delicious too! They offered great portions. Our server was attentive but not smothering.

Melissa Lancellotta

Google review

NOT GLUTEN FREE. The food is delicious but not gluten free. I have Celiac disease and specifically ordered gluten free steak and fries. I asked if the fries were cooked in a separate fryer and the waiter assured me they were. However, I got VERY sick that night.

Alyssa Aligata

Google review

I have celiac disease and need to be very strict gluten free. The restaurant website has GF dishes marked (although there is a mistake where it says a dish that has farro is gf, but farro is not gf). They also say they take allergens seriously and can make accommodations. However, the server I had was really mean to me and was dismissing my concerns and she did not want to ask the chefs my questions. I pleaded for her to ask the chef if the gf pasta is made in the same water as the regular pasta because I know sometimes it cannot be made separately even though she was telling me not to worry. She came back and it turns out they cannot do the gf pasta in separate water so I would have gotten really sick. She was constantly rolling her eyes at me and making me feel bad about asking questions to keep myself safe. I had never had a server be so rude to me. It seemed like other servers were helpful and friendly so I really hope they at least re-train this employee. We were a party of 5 and had a reservation for Thursday 7/18 at 6pm and we sat at the fire table on the left deck.