Caragiulo's Italian American

My first time here. The perfect choice and a great evening. The food was delicious. I’m celiac as well as having a dairy allergy. My waitress Julia couldn’t have been more accommodating. She made sure my meal was perfect. Very friendly and professional. Top notch service! Brian the manager was excellent. He too made sure I had the best service as well as making me feel like family while there. I was celebrating my birthday and he went out of his way to make the evening a great one for me. Great restaurant and great staff. Highly recommended :)

Although we've lived in Sarasota for quite awhile, we were latecomers to the Caragiulo's experience, but once we tried it, we loved it! Everything is home-made, even the mozzarella and the gluten-free options on the menu are a plus! We pop into the bar section during downtown events and have eaten in the restaurant section ... both great experiences and great food and service!